Opposition and Objections to the Revised 1998 Redistricting Plan

Public Court Documents
May 27, 1998

Opposition and Objections to the Revised 1998 Redistricting Plan preview

22 pages

Cite this item

  • Case Files, Cromartie Hardbacks. Opposition and Objections to the Revised 1998 Redistricting Plan, 1998. 4f7b2dbc-e00e-f011-9989-0022482c18b0. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/1a31bc9e-6df4-49bd-bf13-6a4d6c8270fd/opposition-and-objections-to-the-revised-1998-redistricting-plan. Accessed October 05, 2025.

    Copied!

    '] 
$e 

ded 
I: 

My 
wt 

+o 
1. 

p 
Fy) 

= 
or 

w
r
 

x
=
 

d
n
 

boi 
5 

nt 
oe 

~
 

= 
5 

Or. 
i
 

* 
Bae 

Ny 
i 

ga 
es! 

C 
Fo: 

: 
; 

Go 
Ios 

c 
ied 

wl 
5 

0 
fp 

. 
: 

i 
: 

3 
£ 

! 
as 

por 
-~ 

i 
“~ 

k 
. 

. 
LE] 

t=d 
pen 

« 
: 

od 
wa 

: 
* 

Pe 
—
 

: 
”
 

F 
dl 

E 
vad 

A
 

.. 
:
 

5 
. 

“ew 
ic 

| 
o
h
 

P
T
 

- 
: 

p 
Ww 

i
a
 

=
 

»
 

x 
ao 

£ 
8 

ig 
p
h
 

“er 
a
 

re 
= 

ad 
f 

. 
; 

Cali 
%
 

£
:
 

Er 
- 

" 
tJ 

A 
fre] 

ey 
| 

J 
pled 

lois 
B
l
 

. 

3 
r 

« 
v 

Bs 
- 

" 
oe 

SLE 
+ 

¥ 
i 

if 
> 

5 
-¥ 

iy 
<q, 

2; 
= 

w 
2
 

Nn, 
4 

Ss 
o 

- 
Hy 

t 
“ 

3 
fa. 

. 
» 

A 
R 

”, 
. 

Lb 

Si 
: 

=
 

[A 
| : 

F 
bi 

-
 

PY 
-
 

Tout 
4 

. 

vol 
=
 

oa 
£ 

Res 
is 

we 
5 

if 
i
f
 

ps 
“= 

i
 

5 
o 

¥ 
* 

i
 

| 
L 

of 
a 

fio 
pe 

3
 

be 
we 

| 
gm. 

5, 
ox 

& 
hen 

{ 
ge 

- 
wi 
L
E
 

Fs 
= 

3 
- 

o 
xi, 

C1 
B
E
D
 

A 
pe 

3 
jo 

s: 
Lo 

[a 
Le 

oy 
- 

id 
8 

U 
Pa 

. 
¥ 

he 
wd 

a 
c: 

o
l
d
 

i
"
 

Ly 
da 

0
 

fr 
- 

- 
En 

c 
. 

5 
t 

£ 
© 

«< 
£: 

L) 
3 

tid 
J 

i 
~, 

4 
4 

Ea 
Sd 

Apt 
= 

hs 

\ 
CofE 

ho 
ol 

hy 
Ee 

1: 
. 

e
r
 

I 
A 

I 
SR 

= 
= 

5
 

pov 
HS 

“1 
’ 

er 
"- 

c 
1. 

‘ 
R 

£
:
 

hoo 
) 

J
 

&
 

0
 

Ea 
{. 

<
 

Ww 
Th 

bi 
. 

e
h
 

; 
© 

g
i
o
 

lod 
a 

bly 
4 

a 
{ 

"i 
y 

EH 
[+ 

v
p
 

« 
§4 

2 
© 

3 
5. 

oo 
4 

<! 
pu 

3 
9 

3 
= 

LB 
. 

it 
I 

. 
Le 

” 
pr 

i 
*: 

foe 
P
u
 

ot 
iL» 

> 
7 

p 
i 

O
L
 

- 
¢ 

aie 
iy 

: 
[ 

=
 

-r 

C
 

i= 
{ 

’ 
=
 

[os 
a“ 

mp 
je 

—
 

a 
A 

2
 

oy 
ie 

pn 
Tos 

£. 
H. 

>. 
po 

ua 
bY; 

. 
ie 

pe” 
“ls 

hi 
i 

LL 
9 

of 
r= 

: 
Ek 

£ 
bo 

I: 
~] 

& 
% 

oF 
i 

op 
“ 

153 
" 

) 
= 

nl, 
i 

gor 
bt 

on 
ah 

0 
i 

——e 
- 

Go 
: 

wo! 
Be 

«| 
it 

Fa 
>
 

on} 
fem 

‘i 

C 
a=i 

“i 
ok 

is 
bi 

4 
45 

: 
«| 

Ri 
"3 

3 
00T 

E
o
 

8 
: 

del 
R
e
 

3 
- 

+
 

par 
drei 

L
T
 

kt 
2 

i 
- 

: 
# 

or 
pi 

wt 
3 

<a’ 
3 

RY 
LO 

tL) 
w 

w 
i 

> 
1 

a 
TER 

[
v
f
 

ao: 
“or 

vs 
de 

| 
wl 

i 
or 

i
n
e
 

a
?
 

- 
3 

Ch 
ar 

on 
T 

pry 
doe 

5. 

£ 
1 

eg 
Bd 

: 
3 

od 
2 

we 
a 

, 
i 

£ 
{w) 

in 
y. 

pos 
wk 

) 
3 

= 
3 

i 
Rug 

fous 
{ 

: 
’ 

. 
—
 

3
 

{oe 
Th 

(4) 
hw 

J 
%, 

fr 
a) 

- 
ME 

Lu 
ry 

by ¥ 
3 

P 
th 

at 
= 

- 
th 

4 
x: 

= 
C 

 £ 
2 

J 
1. 

~ 
pd 

~ 
v 

vad 
fre 

. 
oil 

” 
re 

wa 
r— 

5 
. 

ve 
i
 

in 
£1] 

— 
ts 

i 
td 

* 
peut 

ie 
| 

oO 
o 

¢ 
2] 

ort 
¢.t 

La 
: 

's 
g 

i
n
 

ty 
- 

: 
. 

H 
oJ 

C 
478 

e
d
 

[Ih] 
Jd 

Fl 
4 

L
F
.
 

1 
H 

3
 

S00 
c 

s 
C
h
 

iF, 
‘ 

dt 
{ 

fo 
£
 

A. 
w
h
 

o
l
 

ty 

ik 
| 

bet 
i. 

1 
roa 

,
 

1g 

 
 

 
  
 

 
 

( d a J a x. 

      

 



  
 
 

S
E
 | -, 

- Ch 

2. Raroivand 

t h 

 
 

 
 

 
 

   

FR Pa fandanie u 
Fig 

tha Tia nat t 
PY 

Aer and t tai TAYTUTTY an winnnatifniianal rans 
© 

alon an nsanotifiiang LA 
——. 

mifth Diigtrint ic i semi FEI tha 

 
 
 

 
 

Mma xas sa   

£3 

si vrw tae 
YY Wwhabik MFaRshdvWh i 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

POF in tha [= ot hanos whatcasues 
3 . 

i TMaa rim» 

[3 

- 
10% ABTANTE 3 

- \ 
tT me 

. - 
Fig Aer 3 SEPP As FN PEED 

 
 

Tastes Janel m En LY bh 2 Fi mwnamyisasmitles 

". 4 “ t 

 
 

-~ 

¢ 

  

risa a hPL asia moar lant lah TW 1 visa dan srriniadh © 

  

 
 
 

 
 

> T zara vor . 

 
 

 
 

 
 

faze 

5 
in thie rannantian 
He cs . . 

| vamvasmas S¥si ane iG 

    

« sa 
AT tha aol 

sa ie a 
he “taint 

x x hat the “taint 
HNRTOM al-Ial Dak] 

  

4 4 Er 
PETAR AR Wh et 

 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

rR Aarisias   fa Iman] sadimaad as   

. SLT « s P 
hilar IM SANTTINASTIARN IER 

ne wn 
ave mitran tha rasan 
warm mr or waa meee . > > wn 

SATIYE S37 

 
 

  

 



 
 

 
 
 

 
 

 
 
 

 
 

  
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 

   

  

  

- 
oi 

" 
3 

—
 

iy 
5 

fd 
3 

Ji 
” 

Lt 
[8 

wy 
ie 

Lo 
A 

1 
- 

i 
ism 

k3: 
os 

> 
ir 

H 
2 

& 
Sod 

TL 
ob 

oi 
pe 

. 
3 

- 
B
h
 

+
 

b
 

E
u
 

a 
3) 

NR 
! 

i 
|
 

1” 
LI 

J
f
 

rT 
34 

ins 
- 

|] 
>] 

i: 
i) 

qi 
iy 

Fu 
or 

Ew 
‘ 

ih 
3 

2 
vx} 

- 
of. 

[2 
Ly 

a 
e 

ii 
1 

ty 
23 

b> 
i 

Ci 
fat 

ai 
“Ww 

= 
ai 

th 
i 

“3 
E 

bu 
ey 

03 
oi 

i
 

whe 
4! 

hE 
- 

: 
e: 

wed 
. 

bt 
ai 

3
 

i} 
oof 

[I 
ks 

"3 
od 

"| 
=e 

rl 
oe 

do 
< 

[EN 
a
 

— 
fel 

Le 
5) 

dod 
ow 

{ 
es 

: 
os 

= 
Oo 

; 
2
 

XL! 
[ey 

. 
| 

¥ 
8 

B
B
 

S
E
 

i 
5 

coi 
yt 

L 
Xl 

—
 

—
 

i 
ho 

a
 

[= 
t! 

20 
. 

~~ 
re 

Q 
al 

Pr 
es. 

pe 
i 

Vom 
€- 

od 
4 

po. 3 
- 

+ 
<! 

2 
iE 

g 
35 

yi 
ET 

! 
Re 

‘i 
Bh. 

ze 
3
 

Sia 
] 

ci 
ua 

Be 
| 

o. 
‘13 

Pa 
3 

c! 
"a 

Hl 
uk 

0 
Tl 

Hue 
i 

3 
&! 

=
 

3 
& 

f= 
£3 

on 
ot 

i 
i
 

be 
3 

£ 
= 

hs 
: 

Ci 
Ly 

Gl 
- 

3 
Of 

| 
1 

& 
2 

¢ 
© 

a 
3 

3 
A 

© 
= 

vi 
hig 

® 
E
E
R
 

i
:
 

TIN 
ih 

SE 
o
n
g
 

Tz 
= 

nd 
: 

: 
Uy 

wd 
dud 

; 
3
 

wv 
.” 

a 
£: 

> 
\£ 

A 
; 

| 
nt 

Ar 
Et: 

pe 
& 

EE 
: 

o€ 
od 

C 
Ly 

+3 
oA 

oF 
34 

C. 
3
.
5
 

A: 
; 

Ke 2 
+
 

tH 
ik 

+ 
n 

beer 
"3 

2
 

fe 
-
.
 
=
 

4. 
i's 

fl 
~
 

gt 
y 

J 
; 
iy] 

1
 

2] 
Po 

- 
i 

3 
A 

LET 
on 

oy 
& 

3, 
E 

2 
! 

a 
; 

Li 
13 

at 
2 

fat 
sir 

i 
x 

= 
oq 

: 
: 

1d 
ri 

> 
in 

[) 
] 

en 
& 

2
 

ny 
EREEE 

B
R
E
 

Ba 
2a 

a 
- 

t 
——y 

Oo 
—
 

L
E
 

3 
oe 

PP" 
Fie 

“19 
S
T
 

he 
« 

te 
8 

att 
Sig! 

2 
iF 

G
o
 

= 
Ps 

+ 
8 

=F 
N
L
 

£ 
2 

8 
w 

y 
0 

1; 
i= 

¥ 
8 

at 
B
e
.
 

oie 
o> 

$y 
1, 

= 
of 

= 
3 

w 
fu! 

- 
ond 

of 
¥ 

or 
Es 

5 
> 

Is 
=
n
 

\ 
{ 

- 
£0 

do 
i 

« 
te 

Ly 
» 

: 
rR 

3
.
"
 

P 
oy 

* 
|
 

o
e
 

[hon 
. 

M
a
 

: 
Te 

ht] 
e
b
 

E
a
 

Lin 
[Yh 

jot 
Ce 

n
d
 

t
i
 

F
E
 

-~ 
: 

¢ 
i 

p11} 
ik 

ol 
ar 

|) 
14] 

» 
1 

ol 
ton 

, 
" 

f 
i 

i$ 
e
l
 

ke 
i
 

[ 
= 

—
 

o
r
 

bo 
2 

§ 
“= 

[r 
A 

H
y
 

HS 
jou 

Bol} 
Cr 

2
 

13 
ot 

— 
pe 

has 
=! 

“t 
= 

ha 
£: 

hu 
o
i
 

on 
vont 

- 
os 

p
o
 

3] 
~
 

pre 
’ 

ad 
- 

ed 
t
 

oy 
Se 

2 
oo 

" 
e 

. 
r= 

. 
o- 

1 
3% 

o
t
 

ith 
Lt 

to 
oi 

ds 
- 

5 
a 

2 
wp 

A 
ia 

vy 
£ 

a 
W
h
 

om 
g
d
 

; 
z 

5 
4 

5 
op 

pe; 
op 

= 
oh 

y 
3 

Fi 
oo 

: 
Ad 

& 
on 

el 
: 

c 
3s 

: 
i, 

wt 
I~ 

15] 
~ 

3 
p> 

os 
a 

: 
(i 

-—t 
G 

an 
ii 

= 
fa 

i. 
oy 

ef 
a 

: 
x
 

ia 
c 

5
 

tou 
> 

" 
. 
—
 

%
 

2
 

f
o
 

i 
1
s
 

-
 

i» 
| 

=
 

i 
-
 

4" 
‘. 

ft 
(= 

x 
boi 

ol 
i 

po 
£
£
 

[<) 
] 

" 
: 

r
 

a
 

; 
* 

£3 
» 

3 
i 

i 
os 

dnt 
Lov 

I 
H 

Jol 
j- 

i 
por 

pre 
Ky 

[o 
3
 

y 
vt 

iP 
—
 

na 
i
h
 

» 
i 

od 
]
 

A 
id 

— 
-t 

01% 
4 

an 
; 

3 
[a 

int 
E
e
 

B
m
 

a
D
.
 

2 
Ae 

< 
rs 

£ 
& 

Ft 
2. 

~~ 
ht 

* 
buts 

h 
ar 

ts 
} 

por | 
Lo 

os 
ri 

3 
14" 

& 
Lt 

i 
fag 

rT 
1
 

EY 
. 

3 
" 

<r 
3 

ro 
ps 

a
 

L. 
“ 

ide 
~ 

o
y
’
 

gs 
. 

MJ 
u
d
 

"~ 
[} 

A) 
—
 

-~ 
Ye 

H 
m
y
 

i} 
oe) 

- 
- 

[4 
|
 

- 
2 

J 
A 

£u 
if 

i 
oe 

- 
0 

ok: 
hy 

hoe 
- 

ed 
a 

i 
La 

oy 
g
i
 

Ms. 
a: 

a
 

Rv] 
% 

fx 
A 

or 
: It 

i 
PE 

ee 
Kol 

= 
font 

: 
0
 

“© 
i
 

: 
[nd 

3
,
 

* 
3 

8 
ft 

Ei 
L, 

z 
A 

eo 
Ee 

i 
i 

EY 
k 

Ch 
- 

T 
4 

= 
ded 

1 
2 

of 
h 

13 
= 

i 
3 

i 
14} 

~ 
Ew 

| 
: 

he 
ER 

' 
wn 

? 
—
 

joie 
- 

he 
«fF 

fq 
a
g
 

" 
¥) 

i" 
on 

pes 
o 

rel 
113 

5. 
i. 

2
 

te 
3] 

i
 

Fn 
tie 

igh 
“
 

i. 
d 

£1, 
©. 

loot 

 
 
 

 



 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 
 
  
 
 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

  

 
 
 

 
 

 
 

    

 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

  
 
 

  

 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

op 
w) 

i: 
ce. 

qr 
i 

£2 
' 

ri) 
EY 

Re 
3 

do 
-, 

vd 
oe 

uly 
4) 

; oa 
. 

A
 

'y 
ge] 

Lr 
WW 

ps 
«, 

ier 
- 

Xf 
#5 

& 

pL 
. 

E 
| 

pa 
¢ 

3 
H
X
 

.S 
5 

us 
[ 

I) 
|
 

) 
1S 

fut 
LL 

te 
N 

“if 

Ka 
ks 

= 
” do 

- 
fi 

"h 
4d 

Se 
i 

c
h
i
 

nt 
us 

wont 
“3 

4 
ne 

i 
~~ 

i 
‘ 

: 
& 

~ 
13 

a 
ve 

45 
ont 

2 
EB 

fo 
1
0
 

i 
— 

«ios 
i 

<i 
[ 

} 
dk 

Nd 
= 

I~ 
EA 

8 

x 
= 

wo 
fl 

4: 
A 

i 
1
 

IY 
: 

a 
EY 

3 
— 

ut 
ed 

b= 
-
 

i 
Ww 

$ 
? 

0
 
I
 

TI 
TR 

"es 
3
 

[mg 
~i 

~
 

i 
0¥ 

-. 
Hy 

- 
n
e
 

7
 

gs 
> 

wo 
ob 

io 
= 

; 
i
 

ol 
= 

] 
W
A
L
 

KE 
=" 

o 
= 

3 
. 

0 
1 

$e 
i 

1; 
es 

G
o
f
 

WI 
a 

» 
8 

5 
©
 

. 
“eh 

yr 
= 

pi 
( 

«] 
! 

+ 

i" 
ur 

ten} 
An 

W
h
 

. 
: 

2) 
“ 

1
 

1 
l
w
 

"oR 
0 

(I 
wi 

bo 
ved 

: 
ir 

0 
HY 

o
t
,
 

a
 

2 
: 

4 
£ 

(af 
Gl 

id 
J
o
 

: 
: 

h
o
a
 

K
o
.
 

a
 

I 
: 

tami 
Shy: 

43 
b 

fp 
B
h
 

a 
“ 

4 
i
 

e
c
 

whet 
ode 

4 
thes » 

p 
3
 

wi 
3 

- 
a
l
 

J
y
 

£, 
a 

4 
b 

I 
4 

i’ 
2 

= 
: 

7. 
P
s
 

gy 
oo! 

0, 
-— 

ai 
it 

ed 
: 

¢ 
oe 

3 
vr 

fe' 
> 

4 
Cr. 

=
 

tu 
C 

ae 
QQ 

y 
ut 

L 
YB 

: 
oy 

er 
§ 

a: 
ha 

it 
e 

oh 
i 

[3s 
© 

:: 
: 

id 
mi 

& 
iL. 

- 
u os 

: 
; 

i. 
w
a
 

a
e
 

o
s
 

£3 
gh 

<3 
: 

: 
2 

1 
Eo 

ts 
Ld 

i 
J 

2% 
co 

fon} 
Co 

Te 
ft! 

Fo 
ae 

[7] 
y 

- 
Ir 

i 
$4 

veri 
RY 

Wa 
et 

- 
iy 

7 
Lx 

3
 

F
l
 

vf 
a
 

. 
Q
 

wea 
8 ¥ 

oF 
= 

Jon 
i
 

ars 
Pn) 

wh 
on 

Lo 
4) 

=
 

a 
“ 

ol] 
oF 

: 
4
 

“ 
¥ 

oF 
A 

=
 

bE 

a
 

3 
i" 

" 
“= 

i 
pL 

ch 
q 

a 
Ct 

i 
I 

»
 

a 
: 

T
e
 

wl 
[3] 

: 
eid 

{3 
’ 

) 
Goi 

cil 
wt 

o
e
 

<
=
 

“Bi 
rs 

: 
=3 

; 
oh 

or 
Lr 

g
w
 

=
 

Bi. 
; 

; 
- 

Th 
Ly 

; 
or 

Fo 
0 

EI 
c 

on 
=
F
 

Ci 
an 

ry 
é 

£! 
2] 

) 
obo 

of 
3 

a 
4 

=, 
a 

-
 

ny 
£4 

mon 
! 

reed 
i 

& 
pb 

yrs 
wh 

R
I
 

id 
al 

: 
rh 

B 
. 

®: 
3 

3 
od 

a) 
> 

oo 
o
o
 

1 
"3 

ti 
p 

0d 
bi 

33 
La 

td 
3
 

i: 
=y 

* 
Sei 

wl 
>
 

ou 
b: 

—
 

a 
mv 

; 
we 

Wl 
SC dE 

» 
1 

~
r
 

a
 

Ppey 
oi 

be 
| 

ol 
Lr 

gn 
hee 

LG 
mas} 

E
 

A 
B
i
 

| 
fo 

wo 
F
y
 

h 
os 

o] 
5
 

r
R
 

|X 
: 

i
q
 

“op 
~i 

4
 

“ pot 
£
1
 

“req 
n
e
d
 

hed 
-
 

3
 

EVE 
] 

h
d
 

- 
P) 

oy 
2
 

6 
a
 

“Be 
iL 

13 
3 

a 
“1 

wn 
a 

ph 
G
o
 

ba 
i
 

he 
£1 

5 
oe’ 

ns, 
Ra 

recy 
gr 

Eh 
cr 

ok 
wd 

vi 
o
g
,
 

a 
XA 

om 
uo: 

oon 
3 

. 
aud 

4 
; 

we 

i” 
= 

a 
ta 

& 
L 

i 
v
u
]
 

3) 
oe 

E: 
B
R
E
 

o 
oot 

1 
~
 

4
 

boyy? 
TR 

dnt 
Po 

i
y
 

23 
3
 

p
e
 

o£ 

: 
SI 

ve 
of 

£ 
o
o
 

: 
gu 

9 
8 

3 
“ 

i 
; 

; 
[3 

rh 
ia 

= 
bE 

Kou 
Jo 

JEP 
S
 

smn 
a 

od 
od 

fo 
2, 

fos 
£3 

Fi 
km 

io 
£. 

pre 
Ye: 

Aa 

a
 

ne 
' 

poet 
ed 

! 
oi 

3 
» 

[) 
s
x
 

3
 

Ta 

a 
1 

3 
£u 

) 
3 

n 
£ 

i 
ho 

ti 
1a 

£ 
c
B
 

i
 

Er 
a 

a 
i 3 

Cc. 
« 

42 
#1 

|
 

i 
3 

es 
a 

A 

ys 
4 

4 
{fF 

Lu 
i 

4 
o
y
 

yl 
ry 

ea. 
jo 

or 

e
y
 

EN 
I 

.“ 
L- 

EH 
oh 

rH 
= 

? 
2% 

ot 
K: 

; 
i 

5 
3
 

Mo 
od 

[i] ! 
oh 

Ki 
qt 

E
S
 

3 
Ubot 

[3 
, +3 

J
 

T
p
 

=
 

ivy 
3
 

Cy. 
53 

< 
Q 

( 
: 

¥ 
ns 

f
o
 

ek 
= 

{ 
— 

4 
: 

: 
you 

=~ 
Ph 

+
E
 

LE 
pe 

3
 

r 
A
 

CR 
PE: 

R 
iF 

LY 
Re 

3 
H
n
 

er 
of 

i 
og 

I 
> 

£! 
OR 

E 
W
E
 

RE 
. SE 

7 
a
:
 

is 
"le 

I 
uf 

wy 
e
y
 

a
 

4h 
" 

=] 
w
e
 

i
g
 

"pa 
"
.
 

« 

we 
a: 

E 
3 

C 
iF 

43 
re 

| 
: 

h
n
,
 

3 

pi 
Us 

: 
i
o
n
 

., 
[| 

~y 
u
e
 

ur 
(
|
 

Yen 
| 

"y 

ol 
[aH 

ee 
¢ 

Da 
tu 

£
 

“ih 
3 

lu 
i) 

0
 

C. 
Bose 

Wh 
al 

bie 
te 

§ 
L 

£1 
» 

Lr 
=] 

J 
vr 

[= 
4
 

“Ei 
= 

¥ Hi 
wd 

XL 
123 

i 
AL 

Lr, 
i 

1 
goad 

Ep 
wl 

i 
oe 

~ 
13 

wy 
Co 

i
 

vf 
i 

w
o
w
 

og, 
Lr 

; 
iy 

- 
ER 

bof 
L&! 

E
v
e
 

J 
; 

of 

ki 
: 

adi 
1
 

oh 
- 

b
d
 

ts. 
: 

sey 
B
 

*= 
e
y
 

=
,
 

D
Y
 

P
a
 

"
d
s
 

—
 

iy 
RY 

o
y
 

ce 
113 

Bm 
rH 

ny 
"i 

4 
M
e
 

oo 
th 

ee 
nb 

i 
+: 

RA 
t 

vy 
he 

Wd 
Be 

PR 
gd 

o
f
 

+ 
i 

+ 
wh 

: 
ied 

2
 

y 
“0 

iS 
a 

£: 
bd 

H 
el] 

[8 
Ti 

>) 
o
£
 

~ 
4 

a
 

EEF 
i 

«8 
a
 

q
i
 

ai 
pHi 

ns 
. 

2 
ind 

a 
11 

5 
ol 

3 
o 

= 
I 

4
m
 

. 

-~ 
El 

“
a
i
 

o
l
 

Ss 
- 

a: 
i
 

a
k
 

A 
SO 

S
R
 

E
i
 

NY 
+i 

E 
1: 

[= 
k 

re] 
£3 

’ 
EY 

by 
4 
£
5
1
 

IF 
: 

HE 
CRE 

> 
= 

gl 
LL 

gi 
L
A
 

Lo 
La. 

ri 
oto 

bt 
- 

5
 

3 
2
 

Li 
2s 

£4 
wed 

Ey 
, 

pl 

S
o
 

ile 
I
 

{. 
I 

| 
L
L
 

® 
et 

E
 

o
h
 

* 
Ch 

By 
oo 

L 
an 

=
f
 

nt 
2 

BE 
i 

TYRE 
zp 

ts] 
3s 

@ 
5 
L
E
 

0
 

IL 
[73] 

"jo 
J
 

% 
or 

P
o
 

pd 
Jy 

wie 
be 

h 
Ha 

[0 
FRA 

ai 
[7 

y 
ne 

E 
N 

it] 
¥ 

=
 

Ls 
[
A
 

rt 
H 

1
 

Ral 
5 

“i 
=. 

Pe 
- 

© 
wi 

g
o
p
 

" 
Sh 

iF 
i 

Tos 
A
 

£: 
bo 

orl 
" 

gl 
a 

bE 
o
r
:
 

4} 
ud 

2
 

i. 
wa 

£i 
of 

oh 
£0 

ay 
~
 

i 
. 

» 
= 

yi 
x
 

he} 
o 

o
b
 

Te 
= 

li 
L 

# 
Ft 

in 
- 

“<. 

 



With racnant 

—— 
SRI ery pyem ys mers 
TY WAL YY IMA UY 

110 ihe 3 ei Ty ee iPrd ar eifieesy 
bn AR dw oF A | didi Sobre Pew isn 

rexnectiveiv have stressed that the sxishine “a 

3 : 4 4 Lo. - . 4 x a Ann ausanianal RaTamarinm maicld na cmaiemtnimad 7 Thess Swill om wn mands man blade wll WIR ALT I TAME REA SEIT? ARMIN RALANATE FP RIIAIWA RAtd 1TIPCITITAITINN eG T tEm.w Pegi ERE TARE .f Fry triers ra 

redietristing nrincinlac At the came time the sien “hisanha 

  

a 

in its eaninian this Court stated that “the lagiclature mav congider readis 
a id . EY *5 4 - - . 

kj AMFaria (SAITTAIRS TRA 119 FRA MAYS Amma Tames bee PS A. : te dh gy LRA Ne fg Be Alt gh 30. 0 jo 
ben Fre Saint Peon Ai trdhganwd anced dle ont osrdin we 

THCY Wars msex THISRIGAWIYRS, SP UPIE LEVEE RL 

ponstitutisnal detente” (A “, 81 TT swambeacin 1, Plaintiff anloels sloas 2 
Ponlfl, T¥iciime In : : : : . 

hi or — em — —- 

ers mer wean wr 

 



nen Tha state connie 

CART 

Leak 

Sera eh or Rie sess 
LAIR UL T AREA. 

rnd 

dd al ite 

srtione 

g 

Werks md 

uy 
- 

on 

1 

Haining 

TX 

Yili; 

from = 

" 1. CO 

la 

LDCS $8 + XE IHE {we 4 

1 

ES 
 g 

Germ non oy 

t resnd 

¢ Ana intant Adm 

ER 

Ta 

5 
WRPAY Ve wh Ay 

wale ale a a wu.Van 

on 
v $11 

3 

4 

Fy Spa Se 
PERT) 

< 

if i 

ZR 

a 1007 mn 

of hin 

& 

3 

sf 
rs 

De ! 

IRf™ 

il are 

ArmA bm san 

PTAA RITAII EI 

hurndan 

| mrasinste in 

Be vu ai Wn 

wa dn. 

rata 

manr tha 
= 

x 1 

rate metrovolits 

ine (if a 3 

TPL PRTEPRA SAS AS 

fendamis 
, 
i 

3 
i cormdoe 

! 0
 $v) 

e i: 3 
2 

<> 
. 

1 i: {x 

mantles blaine msealbl moon ot 

. THITR 

far tha sman 

iTminatinn the 
r 

EY 

| J CW 

x 

p SE VLA I, 

= 
« 

LE TY 
+ 

igor Y 1 

$ 

Are 

3 

Po w—— 

or A 

Dredomin: 

Fa) 
£33 

sfiope™ fuel 

Fnvrr Ialathiatil 34 

didn A masts daa 

Tate aba PANE nea wat rea bas od 

. 

Briss 
—— rm wg 

  
wwiana AN massnat me wm sea bela als 

ra 

ei 

iz 

Rn 

37 

fen of 

Neos —1 Rocoived 

 



 
 
 

 
 
 
 

             

 
 

  

 
 

 
 

 
 
 
  
 

   

 
 
 
 

 
 
 

c- 

oh 
<
s
 

P 
pn 

= 
‘ 

5. 
7 

I
L
 

EF: 
: 

£
 

i
 

Q
 

3 
C! 

S
 

L 
H 

A 
bo 

rt 

dee 
! 

i, 
iQ 

“ge 

e
l
 

ih 

- 
-
 

: 
Te 

i. 
a 

3 
pet 

2
 

x
 

i: 
Fy 

4; 
or. 

; 
4
 

+ 
A 

: 
ot 

i 
: 

x 
bH 

u 
3 

£ 
R; 

: 
B 

Ba 
of 

[= 
¢ 

['R 
J 

i 
bd 

we 
e
s
 

C
 

- 
oF 

4; 

Py 
r
y
 

ox 
u 

LC: 
£ 

=; 
a 

ak 
KE 

i 
Q 

"
 

[~. 
1" 

i
 

5
 

~ 
i 

ot 
xt 

or 
We 

oa 

os 
E
i
n
 

a. 
i 

ww 
? 

KS 
ci 

z 
t 

5 

a 
£: 

top 
3 

: 

Ho 

c 
ia 

sg 
rr" 

3: 
Wo 

pelt 

pi 
v
e
d
 

. 
 ¥ 

fro 
» 

o
f
 

2
 

~~ 
0h 

no 
QO 

h
y
 

I
 

feu 

0... 
kr 

¢ 
t: 

3 
et 

otk 

= 
ti 

bi 
; 

£ 
24 

F 

=
 

Eb 
5 

*. 
@ 

Hy 
Hi 

ro 

1’ 
pr 

h
a
 

i 
fe 

£3 
4
 

i 
J
 

s
e
 

om 
|
 

3
 

1 
[ 

I 
: 

i 
| 

ot 

p
r
e
t
 

s 
- 

gd 
3
 

G1 
E 

i 
3
 

H 

At 

H 
L 

| 
id 

Qu 

=
 

hk 
PE) 

: 
“ 

: 
5 

wp 
4 

a
 

a: 
— 

r- 
] 

i 

1 
=
 

: 
po 

.. 
4 

Q
 

KS 
o
k
 

| 
po 

ot 

. 
e
t
 

o
w
 

e
y
 

ut 

3
 

. 

oo 
ai 

% 
< 

fod 
ne? 

1 
=} 

Hy 

I 

“ 

J 

: 
<i 

"ge 
$i 

“3 
3 

& 
3 

< 

. 
- 

o 
E41 

4 
+ 

ee 
d 

N 

9 
on 

v
d
 

i 

dod 
£ 

¥ 

e
d
 

1
3
 

3 
£4 

LJ 

Ei 
fe] 

cy 
o 

-— 
Roe 

_ 

1 

1} 
- 

Da 
| 

id 
ed 

t 
i 

gh 
~ 

e
d
 

io 
=
 

O
r
 

3
 

i
 

RY 
wb 

of 
L
l
 

~~ 

—
4
 

A 

al 
iJ 

Fr 
+ 

ey 
3
 

et 
Sh 

EL 
4 

+ 
g 

i 
i 

v 

Ly 
: 

HH 
a
 

Ee 
dd 

gd 
o
b
 

al 

So 
A 

i$ 
“
S
T
 

w
y
 

5 
L
I
 

"5 
nail 

o
e
 

. 
y 

, 
J 

fn) 
wen 

4 
Eo 

£) 
ge 

=
 

& 
5: 

12 
: 
£
0
 

Ei 
Ye 

" 
L, 

we 

L¥ 
1 

pe] 
2
 

pds 
bs 

: 

3 
we 

J 
Ses 

oH 
B
d
 

g 
L
I
B
 

i 
= 

ht 
>] 

(31 
Q 

23 
ro 

put 
h
y
 

2 
a 

€ 
pon | 

: 
i 

Lo 
oh 

a 
dR 

oh 

‘ 
-, 

vp 
r 

of 
y 

» hf 
S 

~
 

n
e
 

4
 

wl 
[4 

ri 

fet 
oo 

of 
on? 

mn 
ey 

3 
2 

> 
= 

| 
: 

te 
ia 

pb 
E
R
 

=
 

“pei 
oe 

f
e
 

pe 
i
 

'¥ 
po 

fue 
wnt 

Xi 
aan 

Py 
- 

Ted 

S
 

Pd 

d 
n
y
 

lh 
I
d
 

3 

iT 
E: 

) 
8 

o
H
 

TO 
« 

I 
4 

LL 
Ct 

a
 

p= 
a
 

{ 
1 

; 
Pha 

.
 

"
 

ARE 

or 
H 

A 

3 
£! 

»
 

3
 

|
 

In 
w
r
 

wl 
i 

5 
Zl 

FS 
3, 

ey 
6. 

8 

5 
e
l
 

2
.
9
 

B
a
 

SE 

= 

Hi 

Vol 
C1 

fl 
A 

- 
po 

my, 
®
F
 

c
u
 

yo 
fod 

£1 

hat 
- 

Ia 
Nit 

a, 

E. 
H
F
 

E
n
 

i 
w, 

4 
1 

E
L
 

x
 

a
 

A
t
 

>
 

T 
; 

2
 

L. 
: 

1 
i 

Ld 
a; 

a 
a 

i 
nw 

e
n
;
 

3 

v 

t 

tov] 
ql 

- 
t 

a
s
d
 

dard 
by 

Ly 
i
 

ond 
fo 

j
o
 

5
 

v' 

Gi 
cr 

5 
i 

= 
I$ 

A
R
R
 

aR 
Me 

2 

Zz 
Z
k
 

B
o
p
 

ow 
Brey 

5 
3
H
 

Z 
£ 

gE 
wv 

3 
a 

in 
ot 

orgy 

Ht 
fue 

Sia 
i 

3 
! 

bet 
“el 

b 
R
T
L
 

Ci 

J
 

r~- 
oo 

£
1
4
 

2
 

3
 

3
)
 

”™ 
4
1
 

re 

ton 
Lr 

a 
> 

0 
3 

/ 
G 

a 
A 

“1 
3) 

Ql 
3 

A
E
S
 

he 
. 

i 
S
T
R
 

gH 

| N] 
we 

Cy 
i 

. 
» 

B 
bo 

gi 
iv 

25.51 
i. 

Bi 
ae 

a
 

4 
on 

a 
va 

%) 
S
e
p
 

x! 
7 

a 
“ad 

— 
a 

id 
3 

E
h
,
 

on 
Bd 

i 
a] 

ee 
© 

£: 
pL] 

RR 
pel 

£! 
i 

g: 
dig 

Jronet 
'T 

a
 

gli 
ng 

" 
¢ 

: 
an 

&: 
. 

oo 
% 

W
o
l
o
 

S
h
:
 

& 
L
T
 

1 

: 
bt 

& 
1 

y 
4 

£ 
oi: 

Cl 
2A 

aut 
Hi 

i 
| 
£
4
 

[ 
Cg 

G+ 
5 

bt 
9
 

: 
For 

BT 

Be 
= 

as 
¥ 

3 
3 

oi 
8
 

x 

LA 
eo 

4 
ul 

(of 

1
g
 

£3: 
WF 

i 
4
 

wa 
IH 

b> 
cl 

to 
| 

qi 

B
0
5
 

o 
£! 

] 
itog 

| 
£
h
  



nane 

 
 

 
  
 
 
 

                     

 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

  

 
 

i 
3 

2 
- 

o
n
 

3 
i 

1 
M 

oe 

ht 
{ 

Ly 
i
a
 

a
 

"4 
od! 

4
 

i: 

. 
{ 

“ 
oy 

er} 
Fl 

oe 
1.1 

Ql 

LL. 
i 

i
 

1 
- 

’ 
r 

<i 
1 

" 
R
o
 

bis 
E 

8 
a
d
 

RS 
F
o
g
 

+ 
pe 

tr 
= 

H 
3 

al 
£1 

= 
yu 

3 
& 

{0 
L
o
]
 

Eo 
E
x
e
 

t 
fh 

¢ 

oc 
£5 

‘ 
H 

4 
T 

i 
Hf 

= 

IN 
Hi 

. 
PE 

Le 
- 

H 
1 

2
 

: 
. 

>
 

1 
¢ 

14 
t 

foe 
-
r
 

2 
i 

hoff 
fad 

x 
k 

x 
4 

El 
gi 

g
w
 

hi 
ba 

Lo 
Art 

L 
3
 

>
 

1. 
© 

Gi 
21 

-~ 
ai 

on 
8
 

PR 
an 

q 
L 

H 
re 

+
 

p
L
 

I
E
 

": 
T
R
S
 

& 
= 

cl 
n
a
 

n 
3: 

3 
4 

oo 
= 

£ 
Tr 

= 
fo 

qt 
i 

i 
; 

. 
6 

r
l
 

of) 
gs 

h 
3
 

I 
h
i
d
 

p
e
p
)
 

m
m
 

oF 
I. 

! 
EF! 

Eo 
: 

- 

on. 
fim 

| 
pt 

Rg 
T) 

P= 

LA] 
: 

i
 

Me 
A 

wd 
Ki 

cord 

«
l
n
 

“¥ 
Ci 

Cc 
5 

5
 

wl 
$i 

aN 

oc. JO 
Be 

ai 
© 

: 
¥4 

—
 

LIN 
HY 

2. 
2 

I
 

ei 
1 

g 
+: 

C: 
i 

{ha 

'™ 
re 

¥ 
s
d
 

. 
pi 

> 

0 
5 

“ 
A 

ul 
x 

3 
oh 

=! 
GQ 

ih 

C 
45% 

we 
rc 

4 
«J 

; 
w 

i: 
2 

or 
3 

Juet 
ed 

} 
Ce] 

¥ 
& 

at 
AS 

1 

A 
4 

a
y
 

i 
od 

LL 
Sie 

at 
C: 

rR 
Ie) 

X
X
 

o
f
 

- 
oS 

&
 

! 
Lad 

8
 

. 
. 
Ei 

o
a
 

1: 
ha 

by 
: 

(3 
{) 

=i 
QC 

2 
7 

r= 
i 

re 
BE 

; 
#4 

B
B
E
 

£ 
B
n
 

£ 
9 

< 
i 

3 
2 

§ 
: 

g 
3 

$
v
 

8 
3 

PT) 
hee 

a 
[3 

= 
& 

A
 

4% 
| 

io 
&h 

EE 

I~. 
FH 

- 
amt 

Ht 
om 

x 
rs 

rv 
of 

H 
x
r
 

oF 
ale 

3 
= 

2 
* 

t 
- 

ho 
: 

LJ 

. 
wha 

i
,
 

qi 
C 

da 
4
 

om 
A
 

Tr 
i 

£ 
4 

ye 
i 

=! 
fe 

or 
Q
 

ad 
Le 

3 
i 

S
r
l
:
 

chi 
1
 

-
 

a, 
, 

wr} 
=
 

$i 
‘
=
 

We 
r
e
 

4 
“ 

oe 
hr 

Do 
3 

W
w
 

CF] 

[a 
4) 

rt 
[=] 

of 
fea 

/ 
B
R
 

qi 
= 

ef 
wd 

; 
he 

=
 

bog 
i) 

nt 
= 

™
 

Ee! 
el 

# 

N
G
 

g: 
ry 

: 
UL 

3) 
! 

34 
I] 

g
C
 

b 
pa 

pot 
wi 

ig] 
B
h
 

- 
i 

ph 

= 
leh 

4 
r
d
 

read 
Pu 

" 
nem 

1 
1
 

EL 
bi 

+ ay 
po. 

A 
a 

pil 
3) 

P
b
 

ob 

ry 
4 

bar 
gL! 

1, 
N 

u 
~ 

+
 

= 

> 
¢ 

= 
SR 

fs 
> 

2 
5 

3 
: 

5 

ps 
2 

i 
0
 

. 
’- 

- 
Fe 

—~ 
«i 

oO 
£4 

a 
or] 

if 
3 

TO 
Lah 

B
o
s
 

| 
bt 

aE 
a 

or 
Bl 

As 
oy 

a 
5) 

2? 
: 

- 
qi 

> 
“ 

a 
be 

io 
2 

[ 
es 

Ge 
2 

Cl 
or 

Su 
“= 

— 

7 
3 

nid 
bor 

jo 
oho 

(2 
TT! 

= 
ay 

ry 
a] 

2 
ti 

rod 
3 

£ 
on 

To 
3 

it 
* 

30 
ht 

5 

T 
sh 

L> 
p
o
 

Be 
| 

Le 
& 

i 
0d 

peal 
pt 

4 
» 

le 
& 

B
a
g
 

m
l
 

C
o
k
 

Me 
TB 

= 
E
H
R
 

T= 

£ 
G3 

2] 
re 

~ 
fo 

4] 
pd 

£u 
££ 

| SLY 
J 

3 

§ 
“t 

2 
3 

0) 
i: 

st 
C: 

= 
¢i 

Lk 
= 

2. 

Ei 
L$ 

@ 
jo 

A 
He 

wy 
4) 

pe 
: 

i 
i» 

' 
1 

be 
od 

Pa 
f 
mE 

9 
J 

M 
- 

oy 

& 
B
o
w
e
 

od 
ae 

2 
u 

- 
T
R
U
 

vy 
i 

od 
a: 

i 
R] 

1] 
0; 

Wok 
Tid 

Bh 
gn 

. 
b= 

” 
2) 

2 
oe 

: 
La 

¥) 
oH 

= 
h
e
r
 

ra 

a1 
ho: 

hel 
4! 

Ea 
. 

eq 
(7 

ES 
= 

3 
bo 

-'} 
L¥ 

J
n
 

c 
! 

; 
oid 

[4 
] 

e
d
 

’ 
2
 

Fig 
»: 

R
A
 

ui 
. 

" 
j 

: 
1 

oh 
“4 

g 
- 

of 
1: 

32 

iT 
4 

tL» 
g 

«
 

"es 
For 

&. 
Yd 

wi 
4] 

r 

Si 
—
 

We 
T 

0
 

4. 
1
 

ip 
o 

£3 
i 

£3 

i 
Bw 

c 
v 

: 
- 

5 
$i 

2 
ot 

dont 
ix 

7 
Bh 

an 
E 1 

Ta 
€ 

Ly 
er 

AL 
nd 

Ch 
wc; 

EY SR 
S
E
.
 

R
R
 

Bl 
Er 

¢) 
= 

- 
ge 

(#] 
73 

po 
5) 

5 
Tr 

ic! 
A 

¢ 
ua 

EH 
wel 

i
 

o: 
2
 

bY 
. 

= 
wil 

4 
L
Y
 

if 

gies 
: 

es 
a 

EE 
83 

i 
3 

be 
qi 

cl 
ie 

od 

: 
f
t
 

**n 
por 

| 
or 

bow 
q: 

hor 
‘ 

a
 

H 
1 

: 
Uo 

hy 
BL 

5 
E
E
 

Ee 
£
5
 

3 

up 
8 

- 
= 

5 
on 

ah 
i 

wo 
5
 

fy 
<2] 

1 
iy 

| 
: 

ra 
: 

€ 
(i 

er 
5 

3 
x
 

pot A
 

he 

x 
fain 

ney 
oe 

og’ 
(me 

V
o
 

i
 

bole 

= 
a5 

¥ 
35 

re 
oe] 

Cs 
on 

he 
zh 

i 
| 

[of 
"hy 

1
 

o 
Wo 

: 
3 

4. 
wed 

fy 

sv 
i 

lg 
«© 

ft 
Lt 

74 
a 

ed 
45 

Zz 
ot 

I~ 
ot 

et 
vas 

ot 
£
3
8
 

v* 
E: 

fig 
[4 

- 
b
d
 

¢) 
¥ 

3 
=
i
 

& 
het 

Wn 
§ 

y
y
 

a
 

 



TF ahd 

 
 

bur 

. 

Lend 

tated raters 

5 

Did Tntal 

5 

» 

nite A 

£ IUTSET i iin , HAETL LT 

C 

3 
i 

fo ——— 

—- exam 

 
 
 
 

3 
AF TRS HaAMY 

 
 

al 

ANIONS in {har irs 

{4% 
SN 

eo The avictan~e Afr 

enfr « 

T 2; - ps - - A ~ 

1i¢ BISCINCIS in vie 

Xe 

i A: 1; 

{ in 

FY 
noarintts 

At rz 

I mative 

» 

 
 

e in 

\ 

Seger on 

- 

iv racia i 

WMA hb hw Ll baSRkie i 

i 

fi 

tire that Arran kim 

| ie { i » t, 
+e 
3: 

Anas hihaa 3 

HAN 1 Bey 

he new nian 

 
 

3 + 

hi 

in 

{Pa Arora 

hotline mn diabm 

ene 

 
 

» 

 
 

. oni 

. 

- 
- RAT 

Astana 

= 

¢ 
a 

NE Aslee YW 
Le mttims 

we mm —— 

Bon dn mw aa 

Wingian 

ToWY as 

3 

- od 

in 

v 

re arit svrmas 
pS Sed 

& dan 
12a k 

l 

Countie 

yreensharn an 

  

CELE PY 

 
 

 
 

a) 

Ps SO | PR 

{ 

 
 

AAde vw md bom thao Therm ibiln TY 

 
 

a bidianl A 3% 
ru wr ma K 

FICE 

i d a 4 a x. 

  

nvthine Hea ite 

x 

 
 

Fis Seigiin 

Los 
A Cire 

jaf 

TTawsl 

 
 

: tas 

la VEToss - 

Wf tha A 

  

Tmrham 

vlad wm be 

Tn, 

wero Fivis RA Fale 

I Man = 3p an mmm ——— 

a= 

rE An tt Lr 

a 

nd twisting shane o 
inn 

-an 

nent ramrac 
“ 

+ 
THA vars afsisnnta 

JAILR TARR 

ITCH 
+ 

if [T&. 

refient Ad 

assure that 

€ Tenn 1 

gtied to 

rh 

ig f had not been des 

Fh TY 

 
 
 
 

bral kal 

if i 

RLS RAIKDRILT 
FT EY a 

- Ld 

PATH A Tar 

. 

mem mem me oe Waa 

15 
a 

  
four 

& 
-ie 

E
I
 

X
x
 

: 
-
¥
 

I 
LE 

W
l
 
a
 

ny 
C
e
l
 

ny 

c
 

et 
TH 

h
e
r
e
 

hei} 
§ 
3 

i
 

i 
4% 

x
 

3 
5 

3 
Lab 

* 
w= 

Gy 
AD 

-
 

R
I
E
 

A Fd 

             

i 
in 

w
f
 

kp 
fy 

-
 

. 
L) 

== 

- heheh ih. bi 

 
 
 

slam Ales. -d al 
+ 

btm thea meacand 
= ans wrinr se:eorunaria. 

~ 1040 
-» 

etre nt Fray 

4 Pah 

Tara 

 



  
their near mation for SNMMaty mdome t tha Nafandsnte ranaatadiy arouad that tha 1009 

- a Bre fm¥oen dt. 
2 2% .n p tt om 

  

rw mam rh Tre seen. cid 2 2D 

    

— e 1008 ni A vesrtwar oot ETL i CONCCITINE Wie 1YY5 bilan. A review of the changes made to the 'V'weitrth diefrint in Farsvth 

Craving bauraver - 

      

f
a
 

p
h
 

ion — (he sha DU OF [NS QISUICE antears wo b 

County inchidad in the new Twaelfrh Diietrict ie almnat rastanm LL, 
= 

  

Winston-Salem is stiil I harflv divided hv raca in tha naw slaw TA a 

  

  

p
r
     

     



    

Rorcaoivard Nov —1Q- 

pL. Hin 
9% 00: 20am > NAACP iDF nana otal Ty iT 

fms 2 4 3 » 5 Ty w wel iE OT Ms 1H ; }      

" imnrova tha aasthetics of tha district — not remedy tha canctimtional vialatiane af ths ald nian 

    

“a win. tard 

  

me sam wm www sews 

     APPR LIT IT 

    

{ih sia0c = ds Wi seid 

  

© — are predominately D tf
 

0 INGCTalic in rms of 

registration hit they nrimarily perform ss Remnhlinan nrecinets ananrding ra infarmation 

   Bsn crn ole ee Bn cman - 
tha: Tiras Tia sim x         a Fe 

        

anes { ammimify {Centar 

mtater ta vlan wines ad ale oo 
BISRIT Z THE REIL. WED BE 4 Ra Ar 

  

twalve ; w “Hemacratic island in a Rammiblican sess” or to aracaria tha £-& marinas amlis in 

mmmms manna Batemans we TIL 
2 RLEMEA TP AARE AIG usec AEt SY PIE : = 
   

      

2333 T Ef xs 3a 
WWEAW WA waAwW 

    

custnl ala 

- The CUnort’s Memaorandnm Oininion made garna    

  

Tod 4 bm wmun md   

             = = EE TTR Ho 1 SE : TL FRI. A eer at Ty may, zie sr rare yuri vses: ve Sede TS FA BL pe 3 WAAR MEST alae 

   



 
 
 
 

 
  
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 

 
 

 
 
   

 
 

 
 
 
 

pe 
i 

% 
» 

- 
$s 

: 

“id 
"Ld 

“ 
(i 

s. 
0 

1 
3 

i
 

ba 
i 

3 
4
 

E
 

¢ 
"” 

. 

a 
he 

4 
’ 

F
y
 

ng 

g 
ok 

‘ 
H; 

out 
on 

veh 
3 

_
—
 

go 
a 

CRE 
A 

3: 
< 

o 
i: 

i 
"i 

ww 
fi 

rae 
; 

: 
" 

£; 
yu 

13 
9 

3
 

bi 
§ 

5 
: 

N 
Qa. 

; 
oy 

+ 
eo 

Ee 
L 

I's 

ES 
{: 

v 
er 

tl 
v 

ij 
wt 

al 
ES 

<5 

- 
p 

® 
or 

Zh 
i 

£3 
oy 

E! 
¢ 

: 
i 

§ 
& 

& 
i 

og 
id 

E
s
 

k 
I 

€) 
«Be 

Shae 
aE 

E
W
 

{: 
i 

eo 
= 

» 
p 

Ei 
a 

3 
Ei 

: 
E 

4 
£] 

o 
. 

R 
o 

of 

-. 

a
)
 

- 

o 

L, 
s 

H 
- 

LL 
if 

& 
oH 

ei 
3 

ai 
1 

oe 
if 

= 
: 

~ 
i: 

i 
— 

£] 
a; 

ue 
i 

4 
{ 

i] 
'}] 

i: 
=
 

i; 
“ 

£ 

re 
bi 

~ 
oh 

Cl 
ke 

7 
gl 

Qo 
oF 

ot 
oh 

_e 
4 

of 
! 

e 
¢| 

2. 
1 

4 
0 

30 
$ 

: 

£o 
AL 

Fm 
d 

=! 
» 

a 
bo 

1
’
 

red 
I 

w
h
 

ef 
bod 

Hl 
iH 

[XR 

1’ 
~ 

+
 

bo 
i 

ed 
H 

“3 
ai 

o
F
 

¢d 
- 

L: 
ai 

i 
As 

#* 
H 

oe 
3 

p= 
.e 

4] 
it 

34 
[) 

fi 

FS 
v 

Sod 
ko 

he 
3 

Hr 
x 

LR 
W
i
 

L's 

Y 
| 

XL 
T) 

ly 
£ 

- 
br 

K: 
u
e
 

$4 
qk 

I, 

5 
: 

oh 

on 
5 

tet 
Ay 

iE 
or 

bt: 
a 

i 

Cc) 
5
 

B
y
 

el 
ie 

T 
. 

2
 

0
 

~~. 
+4 

oe 
\ 

po 
J 

= 
i) 

i
 

tL 

« 
i! 

5 
Th 

tt 
3 

5 
a 

(
 

a
 

be) 
£i 

rt 
de 

4: 
Fos 

a
 

i.) 
= 

3 
a 

td 
: 

: 

J 
wo 

t 
1; 

; 
ns 

9 
: 

¢ 
i 

5 
Z 

8 

3 
B
q
 

P
r
k
 

S
0
5
4
 

d 
5 

3 
=] 

: 
3 

: 
= 

1 
5
 

Si 
LJ 

= 
rel 

Al 
Ie 

ton 4 
= 

rH 
aE 

| 
& 

pe 
0 

- 

£ 
Re) 

=f 
#4 

yh 
. 

» 
£3 

vo) 
= 

3 

[4 
Ch 

pot 
&
.
 

of 
b
=
 

ol 
hv 

fon 
pon 

© 

ry 
to) 

en 

Ec 

C
p
 

; 
ing 

hey 
i 

3 
3 

g 
[3 

0 
pi 

ht 
3 

f= 
0 

& 

8 
| 

P
o
a
 

R
Y
 

Ei 
H 

8.5 

& 

. 
wet 

x 
; 

M
o
e
n
 

i 
3} 

8 
£ 

aty 
= 

4
2
°
F
 

oF 
Ti 

¢ 
£ 

E: 
35 

pi 
£ 

= 
|
 

x 
& 

o
h
 

hy Gl 
o
H
 

: 
3 

5
5
 

i 
ul 

to 
gi 

/ 
4
 

ht 
Li 

bh 
a
 

— 
n
w
 

—
 

' 

ud 

i 

+ 
“
7
 

a) 

le 
J 

vid 
- 

8 
Le) 

Fi 

i 
fq 

H 
» 

ad 
i. 

! 
=
 

th 
Po 

| 
gl 9
 

Ld 
BB 

we 
BRS 

ol 
LY 

Tr 
oh 

|
 

i 
EI 

LY 
be] 

y 
i 

oY 
' 

' 
‘ 

LE 
Ge 

.ey 
in 

o
i
 

ee 
£ 

[a 
| 4 

o 
I
 

oY 
"oa 

a} 
z 

%: 
E 

H 
: 

; 
bod 

of 
+3 

E! 
x 

i 
5 

Ry 

Ly 
go 

al 
hs 

HE 
= 

5 
. 

‘ 

gil 
BE 

& 
g
o
 

= 
Ak 

2 

34 
0 

> 
- 

&: 
Ss 

d, 
a 

x 

£i 
aq! 

a
p
 

ed 
Bias 

ry 
of 

[T 
gui 

= 
H 

1 
w
y
 

£1 

=| 

rot 
F
d
 

£3 
of] 

Hd 
’: 

5 
: 

#
3
 

a 

-
 

e
 

or] 
nn, 

: 
dod 

I~) 

Zi 
h
a
 

Wow 
ne 

it 
p
e
 

=
 

§ 
i“ p 

S
e
s
 

ole 
b 

‘oud 
3 

{ 
2 Jes 

x
 

5] 
B
y
 

i
y
 

i 
a
 

i 
zl 

= 
a 

E 
2 

5 
cE 

oO 
Ch 

EH) 
5
 

r! 
& 

~S 
; 

Hd! 
os 

Try 
pe 

Gy 
if 

=i 
a 

& 
“ 

< 
= 

2h 
a 

"ad 
[#9 

Ly 
! 

ho 
» 

ny: 
oo 

Fi 
a] 

Jed 
© 

Po 
150 

al 
fe 

L 
- 

Ll 
4 

'H 
i 

por 
ow) 

os 
Vode 

oh} 
&
 

3
 

“a 
>
 

al 
i
 

=
 

. 
Sa 

het 

=
 

RA 

M
o
 

ht 

i
i
 

zl 
5. 

= 
1: 

i 
3 

g: 
NE BE 

oD 

i 
3 

x
 

7 
4 

4 
3 

x; 
i 

£2 

=" 
Si 

Ei 
£ 

h
E
 

ry 
ir 

of 
vied 

[=] 

; 
= 

ef" 
elf 

ial 
- 

SY 
E 

= 

(a 
3 

“ft 
rd 

fa 
Ci 

Ls 
od 

r
e
g
 

+N 
| 

U5 
4
3
 

[= 
in 

bor 

3 
¥ 

 



nana 

H.14 

TIE pe 
LE = Le     

    

  

Phase smu mide sinae Se Boo doo sate as wiv PAIVALLST WAL IL 0a0 0 create a maioritv=hiack 

be 

ait ui North (arnlina m nrdar thn ahtain Kantian 8 neanlanmnme an we EES 

fo
rm
 

po
 

Po
ut
 

r
e
 —_
t 

COmDLY Wilh the Voting Rights Art and if the lacinintaun shaw 

viniatine AF traditinmal sem Alo bed idan 
—serssgen reste tu. Tre 

  

- 
Bhed to PInintiffe he the Yanisiation 

    

DARI if rare Far avamnis tase Pasd $a Alaa 2a 
23 x 

: ETT rn HY S pUilivas iE 

    

woblialon of 1U7.¥24 — of whom 34 O71 122 206) ama = Blan. AS 25 2 

  

FTalrinee i 
= wer 

al     

    

   

  

ie Delendanis. When in Hahmram: 1067 
if risa. yy gill il - ge esr Y ENE J J NOS WY 

- -- 
- 

PE LE ra 
A842 A: aq POLILICE] 

acked as a political gerrvmander 
d by the Civil Righre 

    

    

  

     

   
   

4 by the Voting hi 
ubiect to strict SOTNHNY and remanded tha smn oo 

4] nat ; wat ranlly nar a wosial mason d 

ai he same time = claimed thar if if wake a ragie 

Stinremea Avie raimntad 

a m—d 
satis anal 

astra dra ler . 
v.12 1s [3] 

fm mn Ceeliias iL          

  

AIT TE Evie 
Hhadled SUL 

         

  

    

   

        

| otetia fmm sto - 

100% . “ian laa Sais L.. 

   Bortitles 851 i837 af which 

RBEISCIIS were Diane in The Fires Thioteinme nf 

fame TAR AAMAS An Asam. aos 

  

~ aes “oy 

poe rear Benn, 1 

  

3 

 



PA " 
AT 

0 ¢ihies and fourm ench as Rasam..i 

-e 
Ee eT 

- 
Feannat he craated in Nash (aati. 

sd distric 

¥F ha LEELA an md mien sa 

ERE HpPRIcs is 23 

Therefore no nian w 

Seal dri © Considered io have eliminated tha rsmaima aft 

 



  

   

   

Noman ASR TIE 217 A 100Au8 wy 

  

3
 [a - I
 

f
o
o
 

Fa
d You
 

ot
 

po
i 

ew
s 

© 

P
p
,
 

L
e
 Bg O fev
] a 

tnbinmal "ML. TAMAR      
unconsututional becanse it FONTAINE sn Alarmina 

  

hased and which hove thaie me 

    

»e 1 
g
t
 

{1
 

wh
 

in
 

Cx
 Cr i oh
 

or
 

pe
 

ow
} 

Es
 

“4
 

So
rt
 

[)
 

tial DECause hey digraoard 

  

or 22 w-e sums pease xr 
VARESE RIEL aramass 

& 

CONAITION that muct ha coticfiad berlioume nm en 4s yy 

  

  pe uvier result. THO Concern is only that tone siit : sade nanny WAL CONSHIutional requir réimenis he followed § In mesmo. 

Fadil. DCHUSS ine data no Ww hefars tha © F_fAnwt md 

  

=P hrs 

  

id GOT commiv 1 With eenetittinmai PEA mann 

   
    

   

nl Li chruvid ne raianved i5 my ~~ 
a a 

  

iaiily Ol (ne First Distriar or the Thuralfih 
iy {OD obtain dise avery af tha Thad fam Anim 

- 

    

peti ir vmmivrs oz. i 

from Q1Q 718 A7RA > NAACP | DF nana 
Fax i9i9=71h=A hd Ms 19 midi F.iR 

king the Court tor ¢ disannrave a 

     

 



17 nane 

                  
         

 
 

  
 
 

    

   
 
 
 
 
 

             

  

   
 

|
e
 

% 
E
i
 

he 
f 

— 
3 

IN 
i
 

iN 
: 

af 
J 

2) 

2 op a 
A 

Fa 
£ 

decd 
§ 

en 
i
r
 

oe 

LL 
in 

h
 

} 
¢ 

i 
:
 

f
o
b
s
 

“i 
\ 

£ 
; 

a 
¢ 

3
 

k 
/
 

" 
iw 

ds 

a 
i 

f 
x 

3
 

%
 

= 
Ad 

9
,
 

45 
C
h
 

oe 
De 

| 
® 

Hs 

da 
ah 

B
l
 

i 
a 

eh 

cl 
Bo 

“
v
m
 

Wy 
og 

- 
jo 

-— 
B
 

~
 

" 
O
t
h
 

9 
% 

ht 

iy 
—
 

{ 
"x 

I
 

P-L 
£r 

oF 
be 

\
 

Ing 
’ 

vor 

at 
So 

il 
© 

4
 

3 
5 

o: 
al 

“J 
M
m
.
 

C
f
 

#; 
Ua 

~ 
SE 

; 
HEgEL 

& 
’ 

5 
: 

_
.
 

ig 
Juv 

ud 
M
a
y
 

my 
a 

: 
; 

*) 

’ 
[he 

| 
7
)
 

be 
i) 

or 
i, 

‘edt 
2 

* 
we 

w
h
 

(Th 
i
)
 

ff 
; 

‘3 

o
m
e
 

Er 
ol 

9 
a 
E
h
 

Bookie 
o
u
l
 

(hs) 
oe) 

< 
. 

} 
wn 

BY 
ot 

4-4 
: 

T 

“< 
fo, 

TH 
I
 

‘
 
w
p
 

3 
=f 

| 
fi 

I~. 
t x
 

ot 
joa 

4
3
 

I'S 
i
 

¢ 

fe 
: 

Sean 
H
B
 

EA 
5 

é 
Ye 

Fld 
Dr} 

E
o
 

2% 
- 

= 
Neu 

|B 
R
L
 
Z
C
 

= 
: 

c 
~~ 

3 
REY 

BN 
2 I
C
A
 

SP 
i 

& 
<u 

4 
Jn 

ey 

of 
ne 

he 
- 

(ol 
T
a
 

I
 

: 
E
L
 

’ 
C
r
i
g
 

: 

Ton 
Lia 

ba» 
lu? 

a
 

-. 
1.3 

# 
wrt 

yi 
5 

( 
oi 

A 
o
r
 

: 
od 

Rak 
: 

£
 

&- 

'¥ 
3
 

t 
£3 
gu 
ia 

 
 
 
 
 
  

 

Pel 

b] 

PE 

  

TREAT ae Law ilo 79 ore 

 
 

q ¢ 
 « | 

.
 

4} 
= 

LY 
> 

a1 
>, 

J 
4 

tye 
) 

- 

2
 

| 
a 

2d 
heed 

L 
E
o
n
 

1 

Eg 
g
d
 

: 
on 

oy 
x 

S
t
 

yon 
| 

p
o
 

phon 
= 

i
 

- 
L
f
 

i 

og 
i  



1 

. 4 's wl TE 9 

BE CWS nem ow 

 
 
 
 

 
 

TEL: (#13) Adina 

| 
2 

pen 
t 

| 
p
H
 

w
l
 

E
r
 

h 
= 

X 
| 

o
d
 

v 
LK 

dos 
a 

2 
a 

oes 
-~ 

os 
p) 

: 

ded 
T
T
 

He 
n 

y 
3
 

2
 

'
S
 

a
.
 

by: 
a 

0 
3
 

ow 
B
E
R
 

=
 

a= 
| 

h 
4
 

i
 

dad 
oe 

h
m
 

ow 
#&: 

| 
Fe 

cb? 
5 

i 
th 

iL, 
5 "
n
o
 

i
 

br. 
Len 

Fuarait 

= 

%) 

y, 

1.3 

[ 

arn § 

0 

ai monde & 

p 

  

1a 

H 

rors fa 

hi 

 
 
 

= Bre Swamy 

¥ fi 

Rol 

 
 

ih ARKignad 10 

 
 

TLE ¥ = 5 

pe- 

LORY 

oo 

aa Af 

Tr 
B 

oes 
LL rR eu 

i7 

: 
nel 

A 

On Dade e1gnt. s 

£ 
i 

du 
C
r
 

RR -
 

ie 
w 

i 
ol 

— 
H
e
]
 

w
d
 

> 

ford 
9 

3 
Je 

<. 
2 

She 
ig aT i 

auld ha A19, 

 
 

  

 
 

r
e
 

a
 

e
d
 

F
d
 

x
 

e
s
 

wt 
=
P
e
 

” 
¥ 

0 
C
h
 

WE 
-
 
3
 

a
y
 

i 
T
E
E
 

3
 

Bow 
3
.
 

©
 

3
G
 

€li. 
=
}
 

be 
8
 
x
 

fo 
A 

| 
WwW 

2 
2: 

€F 
qo 

fa 
2 

we 
dh 

LH 
: 

R
B
 

ig 
t: 

i 
3 

ai 
=
F
)
 

=
 

[ 
P
a
 

y
d
 

[| 

H; 
mt 

I
 

u
h
,
 

he 
ot 

+
}
 

H
o
 

[o 
3
 

Bart 
B
O
E
 

eed 
nia 

Ha 
pif 

=
 

{ot 
3
 

v
d
 

jor 
af 

| 
 B2 
$: 

; 
E
r
 

wi 
M
a
y
 

in 

 
 



le I RT PF a. REPT ah gi lipid 

Re ru BL 

Wii Asso 

  Fase dimen 

Fat ant A aT uN. WY 

eb lOS De, 

=m Ea 
CrWY Freel J 

TELESLCING *oas ttt ed 

S8. 284 

A BPRAADE ain - 

TegMad M, GRADY 

  
  

Tural f+ 2 5. wa) frh 
ed OV rhe Carissa’ 

aSBisrtance 

  

 



  

UA . BOQER, JR 

     

    

  
  

  

    
  

    

   

TRAVIS, OL 

x = =m Ld MARTIN §, MeatE # =i 
NS — Ez amas SF SLES te Rae Fon RUN J PT, =a ol Tete eee TN, TSLIET  OCARDLINGD Soe mm | oma JOHN MIEN WNT 1A® dee vm y's BORE SEQ Ri — 

LH 
Fi tne 

AMI AD m. m 
EE Lt Pru Fu ap PE 

1988 

wav pd ww ge no - 
EATS EE EE Tf em = i 
AL SAA Ned» AF prize § ob   

     

1 
Rediarwyi 

= a EE iY 

nerers 
Fa} = 

  

Ir, Heotrr 4 wn ‘ 

- - EF $ : 
ATR . .     

  

  TT wd mind B=, 
EE Rc Br 
Pi h hole 2 4 ks 

SE eh 

  

1 read 8 DEW me. er 

Yeoact F111... 
tos 

1 i 

NV AMAA mar laa 

  

 



  

First: J 

Jey 

Ben [gat 

Craven 

Corral» 

J pax 

I. en ai 

Fevsan 

li! 

Wasisingron 

apace 

im 

Toad 

  

KITS ek = Diwighe dd 

fom Fop 

eli h LI 

hE A 

Appendix fo Plaintif;? 

I Corie: 

42733 E1104 (3].245) 

E1615 E116 (5 3091) 

33345 45 (5 8.0995) 

0414 3677 (31,) 9) 

57214 12530 (39.2 95) 

ENFER! HIG 3 2 

(49:4 AO (350%) 

13 4366 45 455) 

1) 28 Tp L263 (33.24%) 

aL 20 per 8 \ ARE R %e] 

24806 (37 355) 

Told ier ty 

Opposition 

[O02 {4.3.19 

101-06 (4.3.06 

Ait) 140.50) 

18154 {1} tir) 

13007 { 34.895) 

23373151 1:5) 

hh RE LES 401) 

131243 148 5 

flock ter I'v x Foca fo Othe - 

18559 (3rd) 

54314 4 (3nd) 

1653 2m) 

26.253 {314i} 

GIT (eh) 

SEH Cp 

247 (ha 

C8347 +d) 

22544 (2d) 
24 'F.. fa Py l end, ri i itd, 

4 Non 1s Mh 1 rere vane 

—— ay 

Mirch 15 Orbe 
DETR RET 2 

Aon Eg ] 

JBO3 {270 0%) 

216(23% 

1330 (13.649) 

700 { 19.655) 

POSE (13%) 

HESS (15.1495) 

LEC 02090) 

LEAR TA PALS, 

S34: ELT HY 

Ad
 
H
I
N
 

  

P
o
n
i
 
o
l
o
N
 

L
—
A
U
N
 

-
B



. 

tt 

OWING adrirecaan. 

5 
= 

’ 
4 

¢   
LE 
— 

doe 
" 

J
 

™
 

de 
8 

= 
= 

ag: 
1d 

4 
PER 

- 
B
o
m
 

“ 
f
A
 

bo? 
ta 

nee 
Poe 

at 
net 

ony 
| 

b
e
l
 

X 
= 

n
L
 

-
 

w
—
-
 

y 

: 
2
.
 

: 
Ee 

Ply 

§ 

o 

3 
1 

far jo 3 

> 

er 

  
1m “ 

- ret 
ot 
5
 

. 

4
 

| 
- 

Pr 
  

 
 

TE 
i 

1 
1 i 

we 

$ 

eners 

Jd Tivobe ma 

diins, G 

3 

 
 

 
 
 
 
 

  
 
 

Len 
Ld a
 

ry 
£ 

£
 

w 
4 

J 
b
o
 

[| 

p= 
B' 

i 
3 

E 
: 

[= 
x: 

+H 
2 

£ 
; 

5 
I
 

os 
or 

i
 

: 
oft 

f
e
 

q
.
 

Es 
« 

o
H
.
 

I 

oy 
am 

g
E
 
g
r
 

h
y
,
 

vf 
or 

Bund 
S
t
 

BD 
he 

. 
S
e
 

ig 
4 

3 
iS 

54 
Hi 

pb 
JC 

, 
a
a
 

5 
b
e
,
 

ST 
B
I
 

fom 
ry 

£1 
2
 

: 
24 

g
o
 

S54 
Sg 

+
I
 

of 
ven 

ot 
ao 

£
1
 

3 
1: 

ci 
= 

IY 
—
 

a
y
 

S
F
 

q
o
 

R
a
]
 

he] 
» 

Phar 
A
 

be 
Ii 

y 
It 

g
n
 

S
e
 

ol B
n
 

3
 

K
n
 

Jang 
Ihe 

4 
is 

3 
ots 

Kip) 
e
g
 

Joly 
{
x
 

p= 
hn 
£
5
 

vy 
ut ¥ 

Q 
T 

CERT 

| = JP 

4 

raivan 

     

Rao 

  



from 

  

2 5 NAACP | NF nana i 
FAY 19197 IRR? En LE = +. {1     

   ; 2 0 ROY R208 Ci pgbed iredil teddeidinge 
        

  

RAL russ Sarr : 
ALEIGH IMAM 8&8 Dom 

2 or our—acirieus 

276020638 iR78 716.8783 (fax) 

  

TAR A TRAE NYTRY 
Tw wm rx oom 

— cn wo a 
EE SATE Thea TIRA 

= @ rs m= = iw    
~ we 34 = zene ns sozzase - & 3 

a 

Aine swith 4a navmandinneg (F ladébans at # 
Zrterezit ve pmme zeny wes TReresir Taw sermews or mer 

  

ype 
- com 

3 
& -

Copyright notice

© NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.

This collection and the tools to navigate it (the “Collection”) are available to the public for general educational and research purposes, as well as to preserve and contextualize the history of the content and materials it contains (the “Materials”). Like other archival collections, such as those found in libraries, LDF owns the physical source Materials that have been digitized for the Collection; however, LDF does not own the underlying copyright or other rights in all items and there are limits on how you can use the Materials. By accessing and using the Material, you acknowledge your agreement to the Terms. If you do not agree, please do not use the Materials.


Additional info

To the extent that LDF includes information about the Materials’ origins or ownership or provides summaries or transcripts of original source Materials, LDF does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of such information, transcripts or summaries, and shall not be responsible for any inaccuracies.