Memo to Counsel

    atSrcSl o. rStctr
3tlar

}IEHORL\DUI.I TO COUNSEL OR

Nos. 84-1286 MAGGIE
84-7281 JULIA

Ir ! lan 8Er dt\rPut
lrrarrr Ctrutl

oTtlct ot ?r3 CL3rr
50 *ritE S13Gt, S:!. 

-Atlurti, Gorgle 30303-3147

MaY 6, 1985

rt lar!"lia alva rsraaa
, C^al ara rraaa a, t.t?raa

PAIrIIES LISTED BELOW

S. BOZEMAN V. EALON M. LAMBERT, €t AI.
p. - 

Wf LDER v . EALON M ' LAI'IBERT, €t aI '

Encloced is a coPY of thc courtrg

ffi::;ia i;;,,,1"11iT:" i"l: ", Enli
Proccdure. ', "
Rules 39, rl0 end 41, P.R.A.P ' , and Circuit
govern costs, Pctitig?:-f?I-t:k:::?:-t::

dccirion thir daY cntercd in the
day bcen cnccrcd'in accordance
ini r.a.ral Rulce of APPcllatc '

or

Rules 28, 26 end 27
nandatcs, rc3PectivclY.

tion of en banctiruelY, L Petltion tor,r
ration t!qE!

not 3U

clrcuj.t Rulc 27 providCa that, 'A notion lor a stay of the isguanee

:l"ll*fi: il"i. ,"li3i*ii!rlil;^;3irliri1l be denica-or,ii"" it-rlroii-ir,"i'it is nor frivorous, not fllcd
mcrely for dclayr _and shows irr.t a rubstantial guestion is to bc

presented to t[l'S"ptcne Couit,-ot otherrrise 3etss forth good cause

for a staY.'

..
ieetion (e) (4) which provide-: 'In the event of affirrnance or other

a""iiio' advcrse to ti'" p"'I;;:ii:;;3:ttn:t::;l:"t?":::;"}":iili
piomptry advise the Party i:
review by rhe lt1ing o! a. p.tiiio" ior writ of certiorari with the

Suprene Court.--Eouisef snafi-iif" such petition if requested to
a;-so by thc Party in trriting',

Very trulY Yoursr

SPEIICER D. HERCER, Qlerka

Enc. /
!6:' P. M - Johnston iC. Lani Gu:'nlerV

BY



IN TBE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

BO }lOT

PllBTISH
ELEVENTH CIRCUIT

No. 84-7286
Non-Argunent Calendar

UAGGIE S. BOZEMAN,

Peti tioner-Appcllee,

ver sus

EATON I.{. LAMBERT,' JACK C. t

LUFKIN; JOHN f. PORTER, in
their official capacities as
nembers of the Alabama Board of
Pardons and Paroles;'TED BUTLER, a
Probation and Parole Offiper employed
by the Alabama Board of Pardons and
Paroles 

Respondents-Appellants.

No.84-7287
Non-Argument Calendar

JULIA P. WILDER,

Peti tioner-Appellee ,

ver sus

EALON I{. LAMBERT; JACK C. LUFKIN;
JOHN T. PORTER, in their official
capacities as menbers of the
Alabama Board of Pardons and Paroles;
TED BUTLER, a Probation and parole
Officer employed by the Alabama Board
of Pardons and Paroles,

FOR THE

Responde n ts- AppeI I ants .



Appeals from the United States District Court
for'n:-1::1:-3:::::::-::-ilabama

(ttay 6, I985)

Before VANCE, HENDERSON and CLARK, Circuit Judges.

PER CURIA}.I:

Defendants appeal the district courtrs grant of writs

of habeas corpus on plaintiffs' motions for summary

judgment.

Both Maggie S. Bozeman and Julia P. Wilder were

convicted of three counts of vote fraud in stat,e court in

Pickens County, Alabama. Bozeman lras sentenced to four

years imprisonment and Wi1,5er to inprisonment for f ive

years. Both h,ere on parole at the time they f iled their
petitions for federal habeas in district court.

App1y.ing the standard of Jackson v. Virqinia, 443 U.S.

307 (1979), the district court held that the evidence

against Bozeman was insufficient to support her conviction

and therefore issued the writ as to her.

The district court concluded that the evidence against

l{ilder was sufficient to sustain her conviction. The court

also heId, however, that both petitionersr juries were



lnstructed on a crime not .charged in their indictment's.

Bccause of such violation of her aixth amendment rights the

distrlct court also lssued the wrlt as to lfilder conditloned

on her retrial within ninetY daYs.

The district court carefully, and lre conclude

correctly, ruled on the various contentions of the parties.

tle thefore affirn on the basis of the joint Memorandum

opinion of the district court dated April 13, 1984.

AFFIRMED..



C.

ll[l 26. trrrilo[ tol tllElnllc ro El urc @rslEAflor
(r) frjer of CoDi.r

(f) tcrr ccall ol . FSlBlos lor s.lorlnt Purturar co EIAP luk 6O

rtrll tr fllrd;
(2) ttuc..r c!Dt.! ct . tuttr.ctce tor o blac ccoridrs!3loo Daa-

rsur to niu nrrr $ rrru D. tll.d rtrr,Lr tcr Laltlel l.rttj
cr rtorll3.

O) tl- . trtrattou. l FrlricB fos s.brril3-cr . -ru3tstlics cf :ro
Droc corldrrefiAiE6rffi?s3 anlit Dt fll.d t{}}{F 20 &7r cl tlr drtr ot tb
Oidoo. Io ddfdci.l rLr .bif D. rllorrd lcr rililj. Cooal.l rtocld urt s.-
fili .st orioar ol 3Lr .8c.?s tcr tlr -I.t cqrllLoj rurou. Prl*La3 ,Ll.P
iftt eor be corl&trd rdlfifot Jrrtltlcrtlor tcr r*rarlcor. t. lfll ao(b).

(c) 3ruttr'tlo ct .etuttrttlco ct ra beec coctiCatrCloa, aatlar tDca lEIBlrl Daaa:r.ot oa raD.trr^E3' It l!
cr;-norrllartT procrdnn Lglaaad to lrf$ to tL .CBrESlos of t& oCis. courB r

(

ia a8

grrcr{rat-reletij rrror ct ccrptlorl taortlcr ll .s .grj.tl cr ctlrr groc:cdtnj,
ind, ,rtt! rgrcftfc !.t.s.oc. tc I .r|totlC of aa b.8c eao.ri&te!1o-a t4on rrlertt3'
tt'i!3ttd.d'to lrr.{ tD !b e3tcetcq ct tlr.agist Gou.*,-. prarl ogiaioii ttr t It
rllcgrdly tl dlttct cqffi,ct rltl gr*rdac .l $. tqrr Conrr cr of tlir clrclrit.
Ui.t d irro31 ta I grnl'r trtrdutfca of rtat br, cr 1a $, trctr of $r c1e
(friuafq rrdtlciah of ttr rvldrocr)r.r.aaoa ..rertrd ls tL glarl'.r rir'
ipffcrtfio ct cocrci pncrdar to tL trct of tlt cetc, ran ..3!t8t tor rrterrilj
Lilorr tb prorl ht nt lor a Loc corl&naioa.

Cocarl .8. r-irdd tftt tfr try cl cornrl tr ft'lly Cllclrrird rttlout
til,tll . tetlrr3io fcr rrbrsLg o Doc lt tb crr doer loc a.s tlc rijid rtra'
d.rd.-of l:Ili 35(r), .rd lLt tl. t.lrr3 of r jotltioa tot rrLrri.g cs .natrtaio!
fcr rrtdrir3 re b.rc lt DG r grtrqpirlt to tlli"ot . FSlBloa for cr*icrrr{.

(d) lbrt tl Iot Coti&rtd'Es t+c. ldd.drtrr** ."d iat 1L .rGt.rtr
ler rrr?ir. ru@ e14rri, t?ttci!,-ilei cf :a€le-, -etvc
to rgpcei il loirr plprrir, ud love to eipltl_ t-rc_r -s-ti,.ul ordcr, .3! lot
rtd; .sDj.cr to i btrc ca.i&rrtloo ud.s !Il! !l. I! bor ru3Srtioar vlll mt
bc ra:rrtej,id io rul -Ga.sr brrt rill Ee rrfcrrd .. . iE31g1o8 lor rrltrlri.a! co

t!. Jodfr or gelrl ttrc .rt.trd tL ortr looalt lo br rrio:d.
(r) lrocrder.. l .attr.Bi- c! u buc co8 i,d.s.g16 [Doo !.aiti.l lrlrr'lj

os rr!..12 ,t 11-t:i-$iT&r b, .ry 
-.: 

of sr paal or ery jd3r--of- 3!t ccur- rg
.ctl1 ..Fia. - tf ea Uoc tsiar8.tloa 1r jtutrd, uct grrtT rtrll fgr:nirb t tL
cltrl 13 rddltloarl c4io of arrT !1,lel tlr 9rrr7 Lrr jrrrvioorly ftled- .nd 

- 
ll

cogi.t of 6c! rqpl-trl Lriet I rrtlrlli tI D.rE, 17 liL. tec elro 11t!
Cls. l. 27(c).

(f) loil of suE"tti8. l Fsltioa for rri.rrLt3 tbrrld idclu& . c.a-
Litj,c.r. of i.at6rc.fr cr{L trF, ud rbonld b. Dcqld ia e 6itr corrr.
tt p.titi6 or .uttssioo rJbrll tt t oi tb corrr rLt&!' tt trql.ttt rrberi.a3 by
3!G ;.rl or tu3jcitr r.brrftt a l11c or bot!. A tsatertiol for rrireri.l3 ra boc
Irill- rlro bc rrcrccd u e pctitloo lot tt silS leforr -L orlfjrll DurI . !
p.riBloa for rrbreri-ol rill oot Uc ts.rt d u r ru33crt1!9-!or ttt.trin. o brac. l
inrjSraloa of eo blac coati&trgioo .!.U c-t i! t& follori4 ltG i^o t[ir rc-
quttlct:

(l) c.r-tiflcrtr of teterlrred D.tro!. rr rrquird Ly llt! Cir. R.

22G)Q);

(2) rhcrc ttr p.*y .oat rrila ro broc coarider.liou ir rrpmoccd
by cororcl . oor or boc! of tlc folori.of .trt6Gt o( cons{f jj e99J..icrblc:

I rrgrcrt r brllcf, blred oa I rmroord rsd tBldiad
prof:rioarl jud3nt, tbt li. prnrl &clrioa it emt'rrt,
io clc follrinj drcirlo(r) ol tlc 3rprc Cocrt of tlc
Ir8i,gtd Strcr oi tb: prccrdratr of tJlir cirglriB .!d rlrt
cooridclrtr,oo by tb !rll] ccst lt r.!...r, go rccurc rsd
r.i.oG.j-r uai,toiriry of d.citiolt il tlir courB: [crtr
rpecificrlJ.y ltr cuc or crcrl

nl3c.8

(lcv.12/82)



e

t rrynlr r lellrt, loed o r-nuoord e& rtdlrd
grcforlorl Jcitrac, t!.3 !!1. egiorl lsvollm c!' or Da!
lrrrtrrr ct iactgticul tryonrscr: [lrt fottl recl $rett'
tcc La o aalC/EEal

ltlut 0 llc@ lc
(3) trtlr of sEtlltt .!a clt tt6.;
(a) .t 3-E! cf tll lmr(r) mrtrd to rltc .8 b'!c corld'

ereSlcei

(5) .t t-3 of tI Gurar cf procrdLljr .!d {lt?o.lglo of
!t ca..i

(6) at trEG cC tt tlctr rcorrt, 3c .sttnt .t tt trrrr;

(7) .rlrs ud otlotitlrr. a... .uif Gq!G.aa. c'It q!
frio od rlrll ldarfrr. Ortttlcrtly rt ol7 '\'1a -rlB
fes *t tlrT rs. Grc.edd t b. Ettry of l.bloc cc..1d'-
stclo;
ccclula;
c.riltlctt of rsvfcr.

b) .t!94. I rrrpor to I rci3..tiol ct o brcc
ccE id.trCl6 t Et-E-EiEi clerr rrgrcrd ly tb coot?.

IEEG.t

(nF. U/t2)

(.)

(e)

(t) !.erc!. l t.at3.t1o! ot o loc Grrt&sr3lo' drll rt rrcrd
15 prjer, irf if.r,r.1 Joi.ssfi dt! ._Pr?ltle tor srlrrt{.q tlr c-i.rrd docs'
air-rfiU oc scred- fti pfer. Oot otbt gic?irlor ntrtlrf l" &!q'
arti- of ctnru It tL ccrit-ra b.!E ..d prtitll lcr trl.rr&|, la llAP 32'
35, rld aO.)

(1) I! lrlc tr1lefSr !lcbr&!e - b E b!. H.tr.os tcL&L ti.ll b.
aar q, Gr c..ffic! DE irt .a !.8 :t t-zEr- tlI -J
Gorn.- t! t E ltartr, llt ecpl€ ct t.icl .!r stsittdr .a. -. .lt LIr
lrtorc tlr en b.rc ciltld.rrtioo rrd conuel rfll b?. tl^t" l^o lors r'lr to
tttp.lt .!d ..Et tb.. rtrrj.k, u.htt tlr cue 1, e.dt!.d L, tL cgct!.-
ir.rl p.t l Lt tb !1rzl.i tc liL clcrt Lli .ddltianl cogi.. o( re1t7 brlrl
tL 'ritrt prrvicetly tlLd. tr t a brldr .tocld bc prrprrrd i^a t51 r1r
ru.i od -!oo r. oD.a&a brirtr. t . le ry.t.l. ..d Clselt bf. 2. I!
.ddttlc! t! nq$rr;tr oi CtrsCt lEl. 2il, lt ccrrr lor rlf ra br.cc btirfr
rhrll cotril t!. c13I. 't! L.s lr{.f .

'jt !G::: C:--s'- Judl3t' !r#3iD.tio8 laior cltElit jtdjrr of
r.or El:lcate Cr a:.=--' r=! :3:--- --'t rt
ti,t,.a b.!c r.?i.Yilt drcirlor of porle of ri'ic! tl.,t rrr d.at'

(L) Effccr of Greatiar trcbcrrisr ,!a Brac- Ual.rl.otlrrrlre cprcrrly
prorid.d, ti. brac ir to trclCr ttr prarl
ogirioa .!d ro tt t tb ..ett .

Crorr Srfetroc:: EBAP 4, 27, 3:l(b), 35; IOP V C