Akbar Fund 1978 (Folder)
Administrative
September 8, 1978

21 pages
Cite this item
-
Division of Legal Information and Community Service, Fundraising. Akbar Fund 1978 (Folder), 1978. 193c7a55-719b-ef11-8a69-6045bddc2d97. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/2dfd7604-6341-4677-a7a2-5d7b68ccacc4/akbar-fund-1978-folder. Accessed June 18, 2025.
Copied!
AKBAR FUND THE AKBAR FUND, INC. 514 CAMINO CABRA SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO 87501 505-982-9805 f^ ' 18 September 1978 Jean Fairfax, Director Division of Legal Information and Conmunity Service NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc. 10 Colus^s Circle New York, NY 10019 Dear Ms. Fairfax: I regret that the Akbar Fund will not be able to provide assistance for the educational and technical assistance program for minority women lawyers described in your recent proposal. The Akbar Fund is a small foundation of tenqwrary life that is now approaching the conclusion of its current grant program. Because of substantial reductions in our budget, we are able to assist only a few of the ma^y significant projects subinitted for consideration. Our primary emphasis for the next two years will be to provide one-time grants for American Indian projects dealing with a few critical issues relating to the exercise of sovereign powers by tribal governments. We are no longer able to make grants for the wide range of other types of organizations and issues we were formerly able to consider. We do hope that you will be able to attract funds from other sources for youT work. Sincerely, John A. Folk-Williams Program Consultant JAJV/pJg \Jjl egal efense N A A C P LEGAL D E F E N S E A N D E D U C A T I O N A L F U N D , INC . U n d l 10 Columbus Circle, New York, N.Y. 10019 • (212) 586 -8397 September 8, 1978 Mr. Robert A. Levin President AKBAR FUND 514 Camino Cabra Sante Fe, New Mexico 87501 Dear Mr. Levin: Would the AKBAR FUND be willing to consider a grant to the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund (LDF) for partial support of our new Western Regional Minority Women Lawyers' Training and Technical Assistance Program (MWLTTP)? If so, we would like to submit a proposal for consideration at your fall board meeting. We are seeking $20,000 a year for two years to enable this program to reach Asian, Chicana and Native American women more effectively. MWLTTP is a continuing education and technical assistance program which has been designed to assist minority women lawyers in their professional and personal development. Our constituents are about 200 Black, Chicana, Asian and Native American lawyers in the West, The pilot phase of this pro gram was launched in 1976 out of our concern about the serious economic plight of minority women, an increasing number of whom are heads of households and poor. Convinced that mino rity women lawyers can play a significant role in enhancing the economic status of minority women, we set out to determine whether we could identify a constituency with whom we could fashion a program and test out some project ideas. Our goals have been to help our constituents broaden their understanding of the dimensions of the economic problems faced by minority women, to increase their knowledge of the laws that provide tools for addressing these problems and to sharpen their skills as lawyers. Knowing that many of our constituents are pioneers in positions that have historically not been open to minority women, we have had a special concern to help them develop survival skills. Contributions are deductible for U.S. income tax purposes - 2 - Since 1976 we have sponsored a variety of projects on an experimental basis. Two regional seminars were held. The agenda for the 1978 seminar, which drew multi-ethnic parti cipants from seven states, is attached. We co-sponsored with the University of New Mexico Law School an institute on employment discrimination. We have held smaller workshops and consultations and have arranged special training assign ments for individual women. We engaged in extensive con sultations and conducted a survey to ascertain the special needs of minority women lawyers in the West. The findings of this survey are presented in "The Sisters - In - Law" which is also attached. We have now moved beyond the experimental phase and have designed a three-year program that would have the following components: 1. Continuing education in an academic setting, drawing on the rich and varied resources of a major university. We are currently involved in discussions which we hope will result in scheduling our annual seminars at the Stanford University Law School and in developing cooperative relationships with other schools and centers at Stanford. These 3-4 day seminars for intellectual stimulation and professional development would cover a range of topics: analyses of the economic sta tus of minority women in the West; briefings on the state of the law and on developments in Federal and State courts, legislatures and administrative agencies on issues relating to race and sex discrimination; substantive presentations on such issues as credit, consumer fraud, and discrimination in employment, housing, and vocational, apprenticeship and professional training programs. There would also be sessions on practical matters: preparing cases for trial, administra tive hearings, negotiating settlements, the management of a law office, etc. Stanford's Center for Research on Women, which is currently studying problems of stress experienced by women in nontradi- tional jobs, has expressed interest in working with us as new multi-ethnic approaches are incorporated into its research agenda. If Stanford's African and Afro American Studies Pro gram succeeds in expanding its research capability, it would be eager to provide resources that could help us assess prob lems faced by minority women in the West. The increased - 4 - 4. Dissemination of materials. Key decisions of Federal courts and administrative agencies; analyses of regulations; information about special assign ments# etc. 5. Vocational counseling. Although we do not desire to become a placement agency# we do wish to respond to requests from our constituents for help in getting information about and evaluating job possibilities This is a very mobile group of women who appear to need this kind of counseling when they are four or five years out of law school# as well as the year they graduate. We have observed that# among our constituents# the Asian and Native American women lawyers are more likely to experience stress in their new roles and especially welcome counseling and support from other Third World women. 6, A litigation backup center to provide legal# technical and financial assistance to women lawyers in private practice who are engaged in race and sex discrimination cases. LDF has successfully developed a network of cooperating attor neys# most of whom are Black and in the South. We would like to replicate this model in the West# but on a more modest scale and redesign it to meet the needs of minority women lawyers. We are currently seeking funds from several foundations for MWLTTP's basic budget. What we would like you to consider is a grant that would enable us to ensure that our program# as we move into this new phase# will be genuinely multi-ethnic. Seventy-five percent of our present constituency is Black. Non-Black minority women lawyers are urging us to make this program more representative and inclusive# to be more sensitive to the differing needs of Asian# Chicana and Native American women and to find ways to address these needs programmatically. Grants of $20#000 a year for 1978 and 1979 from AKBAR would be used for: 1. Active recruitment of Asian# Chicana and Native American women as participants and resource per sons for the projects. J t - 5 - 2. Visits to, and consultations with, individuals and organizations of the above groups to ascer tain their needs and to get specific program ideas. We have already initiated consultations with MALDEF's Chicana Rights Project, the American Indian Lawyer Training Program and the Native American Rights Fund, as well as with several of the tribal based legal agencies. 5. Peer support. As we launch MWLTTP's new phase, we plan to use women who are already in the program as outreach persons. A grant from AKBAR could help us finance a multi-ethnic team of part-time program asociates. Travel subsidies to enable Third World women lawyers to participate in our programs. Resource materials and technical assistance from the backup center which are especially designed for a multi-ethnic constituency. This program will be based in LDF's San Francisco Office. Please let us know whether you can consider this request at your fall meeting and, if so, whether you would like detailed infor mation about our plans and the budget. We look forward to hear ing from you. Sincerely, / rrm end. Jean Fairfax Director Division of Legal Information and Community Service egal efense N A A C P LEGA L D E F E N S E A N D E D U C A T I O N A L F U N D , INC. illlld 10 Columbus Circle, New York, N.Y. 10019 • (212) 586 -8397 THE SISTERS-IN-LAW In 1976 the Division of Legal Information and Community Service of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund (LDF) launched the Western Regional Minority Women Lawyers' Training and Technical Assistance Program. Our objectives during the initial phase of this pilot project were to understand the special problems encountered by minority women lawyers because of their ethnicity and conceptualize programs that might address their needs. By 1978 we had developed a constituency of about 200 Black, Chicana, Asian and Native American women lawyers in the West. In the spring of 1978, we sent a questionnaire (see appendix) to the participants in LDF's Second Western Regional Seminar for Minority Women Lawyers, which had been held in San Diego in February. The observations that follow are a preliminary report of that survey — we have received about 25 very thoughtful returns to date — and also reflect the sessions on "Surviving as a Minority Woman Lawyer" during the San Diego Seminar, a consultation held in November 1977, and letters from individuals. Contributions are deductible for U.S. income tax purposes - 2 - A. How Minority Women Lawyers in the West Perceive Themselves and Their Needs "We are the first generation of black women doing a masculine thing." Of course, there have been minority women who have suc ceeded individually as lawyers in the past, but now that their ranks are increasing, minority women lawyers are beginning to see themselves as a group whose problems need to be addressed collectively. As the "first generation," they communicate their sense of exhilaration as pioneers, but also the strain and in security of persons who are paying a heavy price for charting a new course. Although they believe that higher and more rigorous standards of performance are being demanded of them, they do not perceive themselves as inadequately trained or professionally incompetent. With the exception of a few who have had trouble passing their bar examinations, these are women who are confident that their basic legal training has equipped them for their professional responsibilities. Whether their sex or their ethnicity is the greater barrier to acceptance and success as a professional is an academic issue to these women. It is the experience of the more than double disadvantage resulting from the compounding of sex with race discrimination, exacerbated by the handicap of modest socio-economic origins, which makes life a daily and constant hassle. As one black woman poignantly wrote: - 3 - "The stresses and pressures of practicing law are compounded with the fact that as a black woman I am behind to start with socially and economically speaking; all of my needs are compounded in this male anglesized society in which I live and work," Constantly confronting stereotypes, while attempting to resolve difficult professional relationships, achieve financial security, contribute to their communities and lead a rewarding personal life, they risk getting burned out. Therefore, they identify coping and survival skills and support mechanisms as major needs. "Black women attorneys must cope with the problems of the 'Sapphire' image, that is, too aggressive, pushy and loud— but that's how attorneys succeed." "As an Asian woman, I have to overcome the biases of my own ethnic group towards women in professions. Furthermore, my culture imposes certain responsibi lities towards my family that result in a heavier burden than other women might encounter." "Minority women lawyers, like Anglo women "will be seen as radicals. It is assumed that your politics are different, that you will be involved with left- wing issues. This gives a weird twist to your back ground. You are not trusted on political grounds." "I must be careful about my dress in court so that the judge and other court personnel don't take me for a defendant." We Native Americans "feel more pressures from the community we come from because we are friends, as well as lawyers, to our clients. It can't be any other way because we are so few. Few other attorneys understand our particular needs or care what we do within the Native American community." - 4 - Many problems in the workplace were identified as creating special needs, "Minority women lawyers are so rare that people have problems relating to them. The women need to define themselves as professionals rather than to work within definitions imposed externally." Women have shared with us their problems in developing sound professional relationships with colleagues. Women in large private firms or in corporations spoke of their sense of iso lation, of being a rarity in their workplace. "I am in a corporate law firm. My colleagues are 15 years older, male, white. In the office, things are okay, but not outside in social situations. Then, they fall into the old boy syndrome." "The black woman in a corporation has, more so than any other woman, the problem of identifying with her white male co-workers. Generally, the black woman has the least in common with her co-workers. She cannot relate to the white male in areas, such as sports, as a black man could and she cannot relate in areas of community as could a nonblack woman." A woman in a state agency spoke of her problems of relating to her colleagues who were predominantly white, male and Jewish. Another, in a legal services office reported that male colleagues resented her being out of the office even when she was doing intake work in prisons. Some described secretaries as "being on the warpath" while others felt that their relationships with secretaries and para- professionals were mutually supportive. - 5 - Problems with clients were reported. "I am overworked, underpaid and often times taken advantage of. My own clients refuse to pay after services have been rendered satisfactorily. (Black women in private practice.) "Latinos don't want to take advice from a woman." "I'm in the corporate sector. I have no problems with small businessmen? I do little extra things and quicker. I deliver the goods. My problem is with the vice-presidents of larger corporations from whom I get a lot of resistance. They are not used to women giving advice." "My problem is that women lean on me. I'm getting out of domestic relations!" Some reported that they have no problems with clients. Two black women who are criminal lawyers— one whose clients are in jail and the other who has established a reputation for defending persons charged with illegal gun possession— said that their clients are only interested in the competence and not the sex or race of the lawyer. The women described their "survival" needs differently. Some, particularly sole practitioners, voiced very practical survival problems: "Attracting a clientele of paying clients, small businesses, private entrepreneurs, etc., is a major problem for me as a sole practitioner. A special need is the availability of a more experienced, learned practitioner from whom I can ask advice and seek assistance." - 6 - Others, in large private firms, corporations and academia, are concerned to survive as committed persons— that is, to keep the faith: "How to cope, learn what I can, keep myself together until I can rejoin the struggle more openly— not feel co-opted.,." "In academia, I need to keep in close touch with the relevant issues and problems of minorities so that I can keep myself apprised of them." "I need to be kept aware of the attitudes and develop ments in areas affecting black people that are outside the scope of my practice. Need help in developing strategies to bring more minority related work into the larger law firms as pro bono work or at a reduced rate." While some, like the Asian-American with EEOC, appeared to be very satisfied with their professional life, still others reported that they are totally fed up, such as the Native American woman who is planning to resign and take six months off to rest. Perhaps the majority are basically happy with what they are doing and learning at this point in their careers but want to add another component: "I'm satisfied with what I do but want to do outside things also." (Black woman in a large private firm who is currently not involved in her community); or, to move into work which would be more relevant "I am satisfied insofar as I am involved in the only available outlet for my concerns. However, I am frustrated professionally by the lack of social change that attorneys are able to effectuate...! would like to see a group of women obtain the - 7 - financial resources to establish a minority women's law office especially designed to focus on women's issues. If I were able to work directly with a group sharing a common perspective, I feel my work would be less frustrating." Many want to build on valuable accumulated experiences and de velop the special skills which they believe minority women can bring to the struggle for justice. "I would like to be involved in some type of ongoing forum to assist in continuing my preparation and edu cation as an advocate for poor women. I am a legal services attorney, and while both male and female attorneys of all races do function in the same capacity, I feel that the additional background and perspective that minority women bring into this role can and should be developed in an organized approach." To our question concerning the needs which minority women lawyers share in common, the women responded as follows; In-service training and continuing education were favored by the majority. "Because the present support mechanisms are inadequate, minority women need to be competent, current and well- versed in the fields of law in which we practice. Because we are easily recognized and remembered, it is important that the impression we leave with all those with whom we come in contact, judges, lawyers, clients, and the public in general be impressive and' competent. The in-service training and continuing education enables us to do that; with competence also we can develop self-support mechanisms." Support mechanisms were overwhelmingly advocated. "Support mechanisms and coping skills are a must. After two years in poverty law programs and pre paration for a fourth bar exam, I am 'topped out' and need help." - 8 - "There are plenty of law-oriented courses available. It is the psychological, human side, we need help with." "Black women need to be a resource for each other. That's what this is all about." "I need someone to call on when the need arises." Help in developing management skills was identified only by half of the respondents as a need, but for this group— especially the private practitioners or those planning to shift from agency work to private practice— it is a serious survival issue. Career counseling and personal counseling which one-haIf and one-third, respectively, of the respondents indicated would be helpful may, therefore, have a lower overall priority. It is our observation, however, that for a significant minority of women lawyers, the availability of counseling is critical if they are to develop coping skills. B. The Current Interests and Involvements of Minority Women Lawyers In our survey we tried to ascertain not only whether this group of minority women lawyers regards certain issues as important but whether they are personally involved either as professionals or as citizen volunteers in addressing them. ISSUE - 9 - NR. LAWYERS RATING ISSUE IMPORTANT LAWYER'S INVOLVEMENT Citizen Volunteer Professional Job Discrimination 15 2 7 Credit Discrim. 14 3 4 Housing Discrim. 14 0 4 Discrim, in Prof. Education 14 3 4 Minority Women Prisoners 13 4 4 Min. Girls in Juv. Justice 13 1 2 Discr. in Public Schools 13 2 3 Discr. in Higher Educ. 13 1 2 Discr. in Train ing Prog. 13 1 1 Welfare Benefits 13 0 2Consumer Fraud Equal Opportunity for 11 0 0 Minority Business women 11 3 3 Battered Women 10 2 1Discr. in Health Services 10 0 0 Occup. Health Hazards 9 0 0 Minority Women in Military Battered Husbands 6 1 0 0 We were not surprised to discover that strong majorities identified most of the issues as important. Only "Minority Women in the Military" and "Occupational Health Hazards" received less than half the votes, probably because our respondents had not thought of these issues of concern to minority women as ones which lawyers could address. - 10 - What did surprise us— and we hesitate to generalize from a small sample— was the low level overall of current involvement with issues in which the women stated a strong interest, al though some of the women reported that they have been actively engaged in litigating in these areas and in addressing them through volunteer work in their communities or by service on boards of agencies. In response to our question concerning whether they desire more involvement, those who are already litigating, for example lawyers handling Title VII cases either as EEOC staff members or private practitioners, indicated satisfaction with what they are doing in a particular area. A few, such as a professor, want to become better informed about the issues but do not anticipate becoming actively involved in litigation. A lawyer who works with a bank expressed interest in the issues but stated that she has "neither time, intellect nor emotion to do anything other than have a theoretical knowledge" of development. The Native American woman who has been handling students' rights, landlord-tenant, welfare and prisoner's rights cases wrote that she seeks withdrawal from involvement for a while. Most of the respondents indicated their desire to become more involved in areas where they are not currently active. For example, a lawyer who is tackling employment discrimination in a university-based program wants to become involved in 11 - credit, housing and health issues. Private attorneys who are active as citizens as well as professionally want more involvement with issues. Some want to move into new areas such as those affecting prisoners and businesswomen. Others are eager to litigate in areas where they have worked primarily as citizen volunteers. One member of a large firm, who has performed pro-bono service and worked as a community volun teer, wants to become involved in housing discrimination cases; another, to find ways to get her firm to take pro-bono cases of concern to minority women. A corporation lawyer, interested in most of the issues but not involved in any, expressed a desire to become active in jobs, housing, welfare and especially public school issues. :P Legal Defense & Educational Fund 12 Geary Street San Francisco, California 94108 WESTERN REGIONAL MINORITY WOMEN LAWYERS TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PROGRAM TO: FROM RE Participants SECOND WESTERN REGIONAL SEMINAR FOR MINORITY WOMEN LAWYERS Elaine Jones Jean Fairfax Allen Black QUESTIONNAIRE As we have consulted together concerning the survey to follow up the seminar, the list of questions has grown. Perhaps you will forgive us if we assure you that we are not just inquisitive; we are trying to design a program to fit your needs I Please send your comments to LDF's San Francisco Office by April 1. We promise to report the results soon. NAME (First) (Middle) (Last) AGENCY MAILING ADDRESS GRADUATED FROM TELEPHONE LAW SCHOOL (Area Code) (Number) YEAR MEMBER OF BAR(S) I. YOUR PERCEPIION OF THE NEEDS OF MINORITY WOMEN LAWYERS A. What needs do minority women lawyers share in common? (Check) __ In-service training and continuing education __ Support mechanisms __ Help in developing management skills __ Career counseling and assistance with job changes __ Personal counseling; help in developing copying skills Elaborate on any of the above. Describe other needs: ______ B. How do differences among minority women lawyers, e.g. related to their ethnicity or workplace, indicate special needs? 1. How do you define your unique needs because you are a Chicana, Black, Asian or Native American woman? 2. What special needs do you have because of your current workplace (cor poration; large private firm; legal services; public interest or govern ment agency; sm.all private firm; solo practice)? II. SCOPE OF TOUR CURRENT INTERESTS AND INVOLVEMENTS A- YOUR INVOLVEMENT IN PROBLEMS FACING MINORITY WOMEN DO YOU PERCEIVE THIS ISSUE AS A MAJOR PROBLEM? Consumer Fraud YES NO YOUR None INVOLVEMENT Citizen Volunteer WITH IT Professionally WOULD YOU LIKE MORE INVOLVEMENT? COMMENTS Describe present or desired involvement Minority Women Prisoners — Minority Girls in Juvenile Justice System Minority Women and Military Service Job Discrimination Credit Discrimination ----------- . Housing Discrimination Discrimination in Education & Trng. Prog, as students and/or staff Public Schools Higher Education Vocational Education & Apprenticeships Professional Schools (Law, Med., Eng., etc.) - — - Occupational Health Hazards - Battered Women Welfare Benefits Equal Opportunities for Businesswomen Discrimination in Health Services B. Describe the range of cases which you handle. Are you satisfied with your professional life? V III. KINDS OF PROGRAMS LDF SHOULD SPONSOR TO ADDRESS NEEDS YOU IDENTIFIED A. Inclusiveness; Should LDF try to reach all Third World women lawyers or just black women? Should programs include men and Anglo women lawyers interested in civil rights and economic issues? Comment. B. Projects; Would any of the following meet'your needs? 1. Miniconsultations; One-day sessions in varying locations around the West for intensive, single issue focus, with LDF providing speakers but not travel costs. Suggest subjects that would interest you. 2. Regular groups: LDF might provide staff assistance and consultants for groups that would meet regularly on a geographic basis or around an issue; e.g. a par ticipant expressed interest in a task force on occupational health in the Bay Area. Would you be willing to be the nucleus around whom 6-12 others might cluster or is there a group in your community to which LDF might send resources? 3. Regional conferences; On the reverse side, give your evaluation of San Diego: range of topics covered, format, quality of presentations, mix of participants, location, length. When funds are scarce, what priority should be given to large conferences? Could money be used more effectively in other activities? Since travel is the major cost, would you be willing to cover your travel expenses if LDF paid other costs? 4. Technical assistance on your legal work: What would be most helpful? a. Individualized help on specific cases from a backup center: Specify. b. Workshops on practical matters: E.g. litigating specific kinds of cases; dis covery in a Title VII case; exhausting administrative relief in public employ ment cases. 5. Training assignments: Would you be interested in working with experienced LDF lawyers on a Title VII case; for example, joining a team for a week during trial preparation or being a Title VII intern for several months in our San Francisco office (if funds are available)? 6. Lawyers in the corporate world: What kinds of LDF-sponsored programs would meet your needs? C. What kinds of materials would be useful to you? IV. LIST NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF MINORITY WOMEN LAWYERS WHOM LDF SHOULD CONTACT RE PARTICIPATION IN OUR PROGRAMS. { M E M O R A N D U M September 8, 1978 TOt Jack G reenberg B e tty Stebman Anne D ow ling FBOMs Je2m Fairfax REt AKBAR Fund Attached is a copy of the letter which I am sending today to Robert A* Levin# who is the President of the AKBAR Fund. As you know# I wrote to Kenneth Cuthbertson# Administrative Vice President of the Jeunes Irvine Foundation# last w e ^ rcsquesting permission to submit a proposal for basic support of the next phase of our Minority Women Lawyer's Training Program. 1 have asked Irvine to consider a grmnt of $50#000 a year for three years. My strategy is to get a basic grant for at least one year and then to seek similar grants for specific projects within the total progreun. For example# I think we should return to Columbia with a proposal for a backup center in San Francisco that would enable us to develop a regional cooperating attorney's network on a modest basis in the West. I want to approach Texas foundations to support some activities which we y/ould like to develop to provide assistance to a very energetic group of black women lawyers who are concentrated in Houston. Following Barbara Wells Anderson's advice# I am asking AKBAR to help us ensure that this program will be genuinely multi ethnic. I gathered that AKBAR has a special interest in Native American 2Uid Chicano affairs. Our seminars have in cluded non-blacks# but Asian# Chicana and Native Ainericem women have been underrepresented emd it will take special efforts to reach them effectively. AKBAR may be suspending its grant program at the end of 1979. I wish we could get two grants from them# <me in 1978 2Uid the other in 1979. Since this fund has finauiced litkgaticm# we should not hesi tate to seek financial assist2uice. Hence# my inclusion of the backup center in Sem Francisco aunong the itema which would be financed by an AKBAR gremt. Lets get together early next %̂ eek to discuss whether a direct approach to some of the board menbers would be appropriate. /rrm att.