Transcript of August 15, 1967 Hearing
Working File
September 28, 1967
51 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Furman v. Georgia Hardbacks. Transcript of August 15, 1967 Hearing, 1967. 00c22e29-b225-f011-8c4e-002248226c06. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/33a2eb2a-566c-4be5-a1fe-548f9891e8af/transcript-of-august-15-1967-hearing. Accessed November 23, 2025.
Copied!
PD
«
Q
o
o
r
r
.
L]
Ul
»~
[LD
©
vl
-H
CS
o
n
o
l
e
Y
)
~
ay
~~.
08
0
O
8)
th}
nN
a
Dyth
!
™
~
~
0
r
~
U4
om
", 1
-
~
3
35
I
o
i
a
3
i
—
oN
)
~
-
~
N
T
j
o
pty
(A)
y
~~
—~
ON
-
Z
C
dy
~
1
™
\
o
y
i
C
e
T
—
~~
N
I
N
Vb
—
Ul
Vd
a
—
—
B
R
O
L
E
S
o
A
Rd
oi?
e
S
t
e
A
eS (
S
e
fn oh TE
Copy iT 1 vou 1se find C
-
recoro ~he +
u
-
&,
3
h
i
oN
“ri
i
Q
11
i}
+
gy
.
i
0)
QO
y
d
P
e
l
{ i
,
g
y
ed
"
i
Ul
tat |
Pr
i
Ul
o
WA
H
A
¢
7
3
ot
A
~
ht
"Aad
m
}
f
a
|
o
y
”~r
[6]
Ui
re
gy
(
rr
WF |
r
s
~{
N
y
e
y
—-q
\.
0c
as
iy
ee
B
O
S
k
A
S
h
i
b
M
A
AM A
,
bi
e lax pury 1) [A incom S.
y
/ U jor
,
eductible
r
1 is are «¢
.
Win
Pare
=
-= ~ W
-~ ~
Q
Ca
~~’
ak
H
A
A
set
M
A
N
8
0
S
:
-
3
a
a
CR
LEE
S
a
2
Ww ,
§
3
3
§ i
=
i
i
a
ibid
oe
a
—
_
,
_
_
—
-
o
-
"
com
RE
—
E
E
—
.
ETCH
—
—
—
—
—
_
a
wen
B
p
a
uc
=
ws
c
E
A
A
i
A
as
wee
-
:
»
-
A
S
O
N
E
¥
Y
:
.
3
.
»
i
e
d
a
v
w
J
'
'
s
§
a
Wy
-
E
E
a
a
n
a
e
—
—
—
—
—
—
E
y
—
—
«
A
A
R
G
I
A
IIE
a
E
E
E
B
T
I
E
R
C
E
E
I
E
N
,
ts
f
.
x
P
3
Te
i
e
r
3
’
e
y
-
:
5
¢
.
3
3
:
po.
i
.
4
“
»
ar
4
»
3
:
y
r
he
a
13
A
r
w
>
a
d
oq
d
‘
ob
¢
pil
pie
;
A
="
§*
¥
b
”»
*,
-
«
p
”~
3
%
.
3
$F.
3
!
h
3
#
i”.
3
Mi
i
2
be
.
¢
{
>
A
eg
i
l
:
»
-
N
’
3
¢
C
4
i
9
y
¢
=
"
“
!
£
-
§
:
2
L
a
wl
.
§
:
¥
:
<
k
“E%
2
a
(
al
:
pr
S
.
L
’
¢
»
%
A
x
&
a
N
5
f
ir
N
J
‘
*
4
¥
vig
f
:
{
&
.
.
gy
ys
-
:
2
:
*
4
|
3
.
>
"
i
:
®
]
.
’
®
§
2
Po
}
%
1
M
y
J
.
a:
r
o
y
-
%
:
.
4
a
~
"
“
.
t
!
.
1
}
LB
,
hd
:
13
:
\
*
é
_~
a
8
3
#7
NF
sor
wi
1
¢
g
u
Is
>
x
:
k
:
x
w
s
%
~
oy
{
{
1
:
y
Ww
¥
"
q
‘
:
"
3
4
3
£2
:
2;
s
oP
A
;
%,
a
b
hog
¥
'
:
i
:
WIN
Fh
i
n
3
1
ot
e)
4
i
g
3
h
F
y
¢
H
‘
Sa
d
3
A
1
E
¥
"
"
Le
|
ad
of
ji
wr
:
¥
4
3
Hj
}
A
i
3
t
3
o
u
t
he
F-
P
w
a
n
g
.
§
Ww
5
#
%
A
y
y
a»
5
x
-
{
PA
4
£
9
i
we
:
i
%
3
d
oF
a]
:
}
Lad
-
i
1
N
¥
”
-
i
2
%
']
-
"J
4
d
"
A
"
w
3
”
oud
4
N
.
}
a
«
r
e
HR
4
4
‘
b
ge
§
"3%
4
:
.?
2
w
.
2
'
’
*
é
H
#
Gren
3
'e]
-
#
2
.
pa
Fy
%
A;
”
x
5
4
;
p
‘
5
s
8,7
i
H
“ps?
%
LF
¥
>
.
{
Lg
5
4
i
§
:
i
Fh
4
1
.
3
?
-»
v
d
y
§
3
s
i
¥
.
¥
*
.
i.
'
a
?
:
x
m
r
sth
Ce
a
—
—
A
I
Fi
OV
1 HB RSH
BRE
:
S
a
a
l
M
a
e
L
a
:
=
a
R
.
aa
A
R
N
p
R
A
S
a
a
i
m
,
a
Ea
—
-
—
i
A
k
!
—
a
sore
S—
we
ms:
i
3
3
;
e
¢
]
;
5
i
]
:
¢
&
i
=
‘ o
S
y
>
a
we
ES
&
S
T
O
L
E
_-
e
e
.
EE
B
N
e
e
,....
«
BE
a
a
B
L
.,.,.
x
¥
b.
x
v
os
f
re
i
»
i
3
5
pr
[
N
3
e
3
wo
A
i
-
.
3
=
*
f |
_
¥
y
a
———————
a
wn
”
~
-
—
os
n
a
“
E
r
-
a
un
-
-
a
o
t
a
RR
T
E
pe
.
T
R
a
.
-
m
e
m
o
s
a
a.
A
R
=
R
c
c
a
EE
E
s
E
E
a
a
A
3
&
¥
b)
!
;
iq
wa
:
4
] ¥
{
4
J
»
«
%
o
n
®
Be
—
A
S
E
A
S
E
a
A
I
A
A
A
A
S
L
a
A
ESM
IAN
I
rane
a
L
L
R
.
A
a
t
a
—
De
I
Ci
A
-
T
a
ann
aa
S
E
A
a
e
e
A
,
a
eM
\
’
4
§
§
je
“
A
Lig
|
3
f
¥
aT
¢
t
Wy
“
t
wing
3
t
"
&
a
3
¥
v
k
¥
K
L
-
$
H
A
3
=
{
.
’
¥
=
-
a
-
-
-
-
-
a
C
e
.
.
.
e
l
S
S
nc
e
e
B
E
a
en
I
Ei
a
a
a
h
ee
—
w
s
“
-
¥
%
st
3
ww
R
¥
¥
:
§
'
4
¥
%
5
§
.
»
3
>
@
3
»
3
4
¥
¥
4
%
t
{
v
.
-;
L
I
-
—
—
—_
A
R
T
A
—
c
r
a
s
s
a
w
m
ac
.
y
po
4
.
:
p
i
5
#
6
§
$
.
d
>
2
wl
¢
"
;
Kr
"
‘
«
&
4
or
hy
5
pi
§
¥
%
'
a
o%
v
#
a
t
E
R
A
S
i
,
AM
m
e
n
a
a
by
e
a
a
—
B
y
.
.
.
.
oF
"
e
d
3
o
>
‘
w
a
a
a
%
a
a
a
i
a
e
B
.
A
v
:
®
¢
™
'
i i H
;
>
wa
Ch
>
a
id
a
A
a A B
O
A
R
S
Co
aol
A
TE
AR
RS
lr
0
SMT
ARTE
T
A
Hl
|
,
.
»
=
.
D
y
E
E
S
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
S
E
E
RE
i
.
.
.
|
e
R
a
—
.
E
E
~
x
wa
a
EE
S
O
A
A
A
A
N
Wl N
E
oo
1
A
N
B
a
a
a
a
O
T
R
O
a
Ey
—
Ra
=
“
¥
o
'
s
i
Me
a
d
¢
3
%
%
&
a
d
;
.
.
id
-
y
RE
y
2a]
3
=;
:
§
¢
E
%
Ve
2d
@
\
a
i
3
»
i
g
vir
v
o
y
pied
5
!
>
V
9
;
’
.
tod
Bt
-
y
»
£
wy
:
:
«
3
“4
o
e
"
go
©
A
f
T
o
S
:
.
p
oy
¢t
3
3
peg
4
“3
]
v
3
wb
5
i
n
!
p
n
»
3
3
;
:
v
.
»
i
EE
:
:
i
br
i
¥
[
3d
A
B
‘
.
§
%
$
i
¥
:
,.3
}
¥
u
*
4
>
od
i
.
o%
“
p
#
3
As
b
:
4
’
ra
.
2
P
v
wd
i
"
;
-
ag
on
;
5
i
¢
53
og
Ja
$
d
.
5
o
+
3
b.
-
*
:
"
d
v
¥
"
v
i
J
y
r
5
,
3
:
y
]
N
v
$
i
3
.
P
g
‘
i
Ns
i
#
:
t
1
’
#3
of
L
a
i
d
g
y
"
.
&
>
P:
5
P
e
i
:
hd
2
"wy
%
#
A
.
Nl
"
.
’
;
»
‘
A
t
e
\
v
*
3
4
:
,
g
:
LY
A
R
Ww
_
-
-
.
;
;
3
y
4
R
,
»
”
@
pol
x
A
os
ry
v
y
’
:
1
&
a
r
A
w/
oo
%
5
F
y
p:
ring
wi
#
iv
wipe?
»
A
*
“
-
.
b;
bo
¢
3
4
.
w
y
-~
£
:
§
a2
.
x
$
¥
y
‘
.
t
‘
y
a
/
:
-
~
‘
.
i
t
8
.
&
rs
Fa
2
§
4
M
%
"
n
¢
hb
3
3
#
3
g
h
.
A
¥
*
Ww
.
#
3
“
wt,
¥
i
py
y
&
7
>
g
;
E
R
A
SA
I
Ea
T
E
A
A
3
T
N
5
]
%
%
1
bog
a
4
x
“
£
%
-
*
n
¥
:
,
%
y
o
i
¥
:
wd
H
5
he
3
“,
5
“
bh
iad
ot
@
¥
¥
w
%
wa
*
>
“g
{
» or
"
E
E
a i
I
I
.
.
.
L
£3
LY
.
os £3
:
apd
.
¢
v
N
L
y
4
" pe
ye
§ a
SC
—
—
—
—
—
—
i
SENT
a
i
3
Soda
h
k
A
NA
R
N
R
Ci F
R
LS
T
E
p
T
e
y
T
S
A
r
hk
SB
RL
ra
EL
il
on
AE
Aine
G
a
h
pe.
a
T
T
TE
I
T
Z
e
-
_
E
e
E
E
.
—
=
-
—
—
—
U
.
S
BE
A
E
E
—
—
T
E
—
U
N
U
S
E
E—
a
.
.
,
.
.
i
A
.
Py
.
‘
§
«
f
w
a
’
!
a
#
5
‘
&
La
J
g
:
§
a
b>
ol
e
l
“
x
L
»
:
=
‘
9
»
h
3
o
w
w
p
a
v
5
§
1
¥
a
¥
9
:
£2
’
¥
+
3
v
»
-
¥
.
ik
:
d
2
3
p
p
3
d
<
¥
&
"
‘
@
*
>
'
#
he
WW
5
J
H
A
:
Es
5
R
&
4
4
B
§
a
L
o
#
od
v
’
.
“
y
g
-
¢
-
>
a
.
F.
8
4
nl
4
fd
;
if
3
4
¥
!
h
?
8
¥
i
a
4
#
—
:
3
H
%
4
&
Fe
o
¥
A
"
3
G
.
'
Pr
"
3
on
©
4]
”
w
o
£*
#
v
e
%
A
®
*
i
wg
5
4
.
.
&
uw
B
ve
iS
.
;
¥
§
-
:
N
—
w
v
£
Ga
i
¥
4
i
¥
»
.
i
A
|
J
g
p
v
3
‘S|
%
:
4
i
8
f
]
x
§
K
i
44
‘
f
>
a“
-
-
a
a
.
-
“
Be
a
a
,
R
E
—
—
—
—
—
—
R
S
.
=
A
-
—
a
e
EE
——.
B
E
E
e
R
—
a —
=
i
c
F
y
v3
§
3
]
:
3
¥
;
:
\,
x
#
2
-
:
§
i
;
:
A
i
T
e
4
w
i
»
.
y
o
n
:
§
ud
v
3
4
-
»
&
i
3
.
¥
:
:
“iy
.
;
)
LSE
é
go
5
:
p
2
v
v
5
Y
:
»
"
:
3
:
wb
7%
.
3
/
5
]
;
:
:
-
-
h
.
.
v
”
i
4
a!
|
3
.
a,
5
4
b
{
a
aie
G
i
r
4
”
R
he
-
i
poy
E
S
.
i
&%
;
y
w
e
2%
¥
3
A
¥
-
>
F
Va
:
y
Po
"
H
:
>
wf
A
&
hd
¥
N
=
-
J
Lh
wae
b
»
a
oa
A
:
-
-
9»
.
¢
i
)
4
’
.
.
0
)
:
:
"
:
J
-
>
a
]
4
#
t
S
f
e
:
4
A
:
*
6
4
N
ol
A
:
“
3
3
ax
bs
epvd
4
ed
*
4
i
.
2
oil
:
-
ee
&
:
Ly
~
a
h
o
ih
2
G
:
:
J
)
‘
io
fled
§
A
i
’
-
.
“5
¥
e
y
v
A
¥
.
;
2
}
™
%
ov
&
:
"
oh
:
;
}
OE
)
2
oo
g
»
.
;
rx
»
3
!
3
go
wy
4
;
:
4
¥-
“as
|
*
”
:
£
-
J
A
_
i:
o
“
I
%
B
S
p
i"
*
&
g
3
W
¥
.
¥
'
W
a
r
%
3
an
|
h
»
v
ba
5
“
i
§
5
i
o
:
¥
g
:
|
:
d
ee
pi
|
;
5
.
4
:
pes
:
v
e
b,
N
f
w
’
"
4
3
3
4
v
MN
)
:
;
;
b
2
N
}
a
m
8
5
a
4
.
Ta
&
§
§
§
b
4
:
d
.
¥
3
A
.
:
—
¥
>
"
,
i
:
;
¢
A
4
:
i
ny
al
|
5
wlth
|
he
»
.
.
4
3
.
-
ro
‘
OE
£
5
pn
:
:
0
,
;
:
&
4
y
fia
2
g
g
4d
wr
§
5
i
was
—
—
E
E
a
.
e
e
a
a
T
R
—
—
.
D
E
o
o
E
M
E
A
S
H
O
BE
a
,
E
a
"
—
—
h
i
I
a
A
R
CREE
NEE
R
S
C
A
T
S
E
A
T
I
P
s
a
d
¥
-
.
e
e
e
e
e
a
a
.
e
e
a
e
t
5
E
T
A
5
A
A
E
S
PR
AS
A
SE
S
R
E
:
:
iNeg
,
=
2
i"
2
‘
gad
{
.
3
=
-
¢
[|
“Te
“
AEP
i
P
’
th
§
!
8
;
.
*
3
2
“
%
PS
.
y
|
,
.
A
y
wy
.
.
oil
=
&
3
i
d
_
—
@
3
“
r
q
A
!
4
»
gz
Gb
&
¢
:
a1
3
Pe
:
3
v
.
3
3
4
i
”
‘
Ton.
¥
3
¥
Ld
5
v
t
§
}
2;
i
gv
b
W
e
o
g
x
Ld
8
5
:
w
bE
3
K
XY
i
:
.
“*
«©
4
»
x
¥
»
%
R
of
a
N
W
b
+
3
é
F
]
i
%
{
<
¥
w
e
§
¥;
b
wy
¢
!
§
!
+
3
&
¥
;
$
3
;
3
x
¥
pai
§
He
§
*
pl
5
*
i
§
&
3}
”
g
2
{
t
&
$
4
4
3
$
H
“
¥
§
¢
‘
"
;
J)
#
¥
£
FB
s
3
$
2
.
“
"
%
4
ry
Eo
-
i
x
3
:
H
:
“
-
1
Fh
-
t
?
4
3
.
4
;
«3
i
"
3
:
vik,
,
-
.
pers
.
a
Rik
-
—
—
C
—
ec
—
—
u
n
—
a
S
S
S
—
—
a
—
I
—
E
T
N
—
—
—
—
S
S
———
E
S
Y
e
5
‘
k
d
;
V
i
¥
3
g
.
a)
|
:
4
»
3
?
§
]
b
Hii
&
:
:
:
x
@
}
¥
.
’
3
i
:
a
5
‘
3
:
‘
ES
i
g
£
5
"
Py
‘
‘
.
-l
¥
¥5
{
Z|
i
4
5
&
y
’
!
¥
2
!
h
e
3
»
-
[A
3
.
“
#
o
y
:
:
.
%
.
§
|
R,
G
a
*
4
{
:
>
“
ud
.
§
:
:
»
1
A
o
%
é
§
-
2
&
5
IN
a
a
w
i
g
y
ke
|
t
v
’
H
“
a
*
teh
>
"
3
%
-
3
i
«
i
,
§
"
‘
-
.
¢
.
Gag
-
}
-
SL
“a
M
:
[
f
.
S
w
i
h
w
o
B
o
H
a
o
F
d
¥
i
i
§5
4
§
:
Fa
«
"
3d
:
:
FF
:
"
4
’
i
=
3
:
§
bid
A
.
L
Ld
|
:
-
Li
a
2
:
4%
-~
3
;
’
8
-
~
£
f
¥
:
i
.
;
;
’
®
&
:
‘
¢
>,
i"
x
#
¥
Pian
d
.
N
»y
§
1
3
boi
§
&
&
v
wd
¢
ii
5
3
i
;
;
:
IY
»
avd
»
“
’
“
’
¢
‘
§
#
a
=
:
8
»
}
:
;
;
4
¢
0
a
ila
ol
“pi
wy]
»)
t
g
a
wpe
£3
4
§
"
§
=
“
3
i
beg
id
3
¥
™~
©
a
&
»
y
s
~
cat
:
d
Pig
Sow
_
«
R
E
C
C
R
c
o
r
e
r
E
e
,
5
a
A
E
E
S
B
R
S
0
A
CO
S
A
a
m
i
—
a
E
E
A
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
§
V
3
§
¥
-
x
He)
%
.
yd
§
&
#5
vi
:
4
.
f
3
os
4
i
i
>
y
:
=
J
A
n
¥
3
$
F
¥
3
”
4
3
»
#
a
3
g
i
¢
.
:
ou
;
5
Pe
;
‘
3
+
a
i
tl
&
\l
¢
&
e
"
he
:
p
{
3
’
a
a.
a
a
d
&
*
$
3
a
A
3
\
m
ayrd
¥
f
:
3
¢
_
{
w
pod
8
-
-
¥
Fy
g
:
rR
J
.
%
p
$
.
§
Fl
ay
)
¥
od
&
4
»g
£
‘
$
i
:
y
5
3
§
§
i
P
.
.
i.5
oN
4 y
a
’
y
4
e
e
3
i
,
3
%
M
oo
#
apt
]
oe
:
hs
2
¥
od
y
¥
\
!
So
;
i
¥
i
¥
#
:
5
§
oh
2
’
}
A
po.
»
¥
a
i
t
v
e
:
a
wn
§
@
ky
$
LL
.
a
M
M
e
a
T
T
;
E
E
Ey
EO
TEE
E
R
E
E
E
TRB
i
“
I
e
n
a
a
«
a
~
a
a
a
o
s
seta
E
e
—
—
E
E
—
essan
E
E
E
E
a
—
—
—
—
—
—
a
LL
I
.
aid
«
J
y
il
p
el
¥
“
5
S
S
A
A
E
S
A
S
S53
>
a
I
E
S
,
L
D
a
,
i
P
—”iiE
'
§
4
}
Wr
:
ho
¢
w
>
€
b:
ud
:
:
.
]
Si
$
}
‘
@
’
§
é
.
:
‘
g
y
y
n
:
“
:
3
:
‘
5
:
j
.
4
i
i
y
A
3
&
w
i
hd
a
¢
’
.
5
MN
g
:
!
:
¥
5
a
f
’
.
i
¥
i
i,
]
¥
§
[1]
w
h
-
J
*
b
$
3
Wl
»
#
’
a»
“
;
P
|
J
»
.
*
a
%
§
Peep
5
F
y
¥
@
&
é
¢
$
R
{
¢
*
I
.
-
Fag
-
.
-
a
m
a
.
a
.
BE
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
.
e
.
-
B
e
S
Sy
e
e
.
.
.
i
.
I
.
.
.
A
.
C
e
0
A
A
A
I
EA
A
S
N
S
S
WF ¥
3
nn
»
:
:
e
{3
i
P
*
§
&
F
&
"
pr
] i
i
,
—
I
.
U
U
BE
.
.
.
i
E
E
E
—
—
—
—
a
.
E
E
a
E
E
E
a
a
.
.
.
RT
-
.
.
A
————
—
—
—
E
E
a
i
t
8
)
ws
.
»
i
:
ht
v
-
M
4
\
4
f
§
8
“
i]
w
3
é
p
n
H
y
w
&
i:
hs
3
£5
g
whine
1
r
©
:
=
§
3
4
o
%
Ww
3
3
s
*
w
l
\
g”'%
p
+
p
o
"
:
i
.
i
i
A
i
S
A
x
-
se
cae
sans
J
N
e
L
h
.
.
.
R
E
a
A
:
.
A
3
/
:
:
:
y
§
2
Fey
4
i
‘
$
©“
:
|
*
yy
;
x
3
i
Pi
IR
.
jue
§:
N:
4
:
La
G
o
;
:
@
G
e
i
i
:
:
3
pe
[4
]
3
.
i
re
;
}]
2
:
FE)
3
wi
§
}
;
o
:
Bis
]
|
x
F
;
:
eg
"
Brig
a
:
a
r
s
i
n
e
n
a
r
S
s
>
-
ws
A
A
R
S
0
N
O
SE
DAE
A
A
wi
-
I
OID
BE
—
—
@
"
-
-
-
-
"
RE
i.
TE
—
]
5
;
;
y
0
|
pop
:
Fe
+4
a
:
§
S
4
¢
2
wo
;
”
e
S
w
ip
9
hs
a
:
4
;
]
|
:
-
\d
:
Lo
:
i
¢
,
=
]
e
b
#
5
3
ds
-
§
2
%
y
Bs
:
;
|
:
3
”
x
.
:
o
w
L
#
¥
2
x
-
Ca
’
»
wi
§
-
=
-
<%
.
a
>
A
A
A
N
S
BON
5
H
A
E
E
A
.
A
O
30
5
A
LATA
D
E
A
N
A
a
.
By
ax
a
——
.
’
wv
.
.
¢
;
4
bp
“
ss
2
}
.
§
of
:
—
.
§
2
Sry
:
~g
H
ID.
.
;
9
3
7
%
i
v
Ci
¢
h
x
:
oi
-
>
J
i
¢
¥
3
H
§
v
§
‘
3
G
p
:
.
5
g
:
3
“
;
p
n
g
K
py
.
ras
carer
5
ses
BE
i
—
a
..~*_.
.
E
T
a
e
e
a
m
e
nam
ws
E
Y
<
«
,
EE
i
.
S
L
.
E
soucas
2
:
$
‘
2
{
%
pro
3
=
=
-
a
8
3
5
.
“
2
w
.
:
5
§
.
©
a
-
(edd
:
#
war
pra’
:
4
:
ta
we
N
a
]
:
A
a
/
g
8
&
J
¢
j
t
§
%
AY
N
&
5
3
*
.
-
4
\
t
§
.
§
v
:
5
y
¥
g
:
|
a
;
4
.
2
o
»
Ls
¥
3
B
w
g
é
k
i
£
ey
gid
p
'
>
:
-
4
und
"8
3
§
os
;
i
3
x
ound
P
3
%
4
J
3
#
:
“
2
¢
3
}
.
"
.
4
‘
.
"
rod
}
or
a
3
B
%
:
.
:
;
¢
;
a
e
h
l
§
.
3
&
»
¥
a)
i
A
L
¥
.
$
FS
4
3
p
d
£
A
-
P
e
§
.
J
;
4
a
on
Po
!
»
4
“
&
!
k
Png
“
o
e
‘
s
e
l
’
h
i
.
%
¥
¥
hed
¥
®
.
fg
}
hd
.
.
i;
i
N
7
9
§
we
"
£
‘x
b
i
8
:
i
»
w
a
i
¥
ol
i
¢
>
¥ 2
5
i
¥
"
_—
F
S
C
S
SE S
—
—
—
5
cam
T
R
E
U
—
—
—
—
xn
a
T
E
—
—
—
—
5
'
]
!
]
-
i"
d
r
y
;
tow
»
&
~e
:
:
)
#
x
.
:
|
8
0
L
a
r
4
.
¥
4
3
»
W
i
4
.;
n
4 :
i
5
iy
;
»
ul
~
2
¥
s
.
3
3
s
-
:
C
.
Fry
v
£
4
:
g
3
&
d
i
‘
#
-
:
#
;
"
§
3
:
s
“i
'
¥
w
v
“
V
3
i
V
y
w
r
e
£
3
d
E
e
.
s
i
E
C
L
WES
E
t
a
R
E
I
A
C
A
C
S
A
S
A
A
O
A
R
N
a
a
f
i
m
.
L
A
wodiuag
E
o
a ER EE
rtm ACER ds RSA Sesion SRA EF SA RE IR
® SY
in my hand and 1 pulled him « «
Q ¥ou reached under and helpad him to come out from
|
under the house?
A Yes, sir,
| GQ Now, aZtor he was out from under the house, was
| he searchad in Your presence? :
A Yez, sir; he wag.
Q And was any weapon found on him?
A Yes, sir,
Q Wheres was the weapon loc: tad?
A it was in his left pear pockat,
Q Left pants pocket?
A Yes, sir, : :
Le! Rear = did you say? i
:
i A Yas, sir,
|
CAPTATN HALIVANM: Thank you, Questions,
Mayfield?
FR. MAYTITID: Yes, sir, Captain,
EXBRMTINADTON OF CTITORR BALL RY Mn, MAVYE TEILD:
CARTADN SALIMAN: Oh - wait, Excuse ma one |
BRECON 4
|
COTTIINIED TYANTIATION OF CIoICTR ALY, BY CAPTAIN BALIMVANG
Q Aftar tha man was oul from under the house, were
you able to observa his condition az to the TON
dition of his clothes?
A Y@s, gir: he was very dixty and wei,
0 Yow, €id the man at that tims have tha game type
37
”
cmbuscn
a
oe
I
a
a
.
a
a
a
—
—
.
i
.
B
.
2
5
B
4
S
T
PI
55
KO M
A
C
H
SE
E
T
M
0
.
-
,
>
l
a
a
—
—
.
.
.
a
-
-
4
B
i
d
id
[Y
§
po
y
o
v
n
A
>
.
3
3
;
[
3
ng
“
Pe
Fee
F
h
>
a
.
gis
Gy
¥
y
5
AW
sad
&
*
a
¢
&
y
a
g
3
y
3
a’
d
w
wig
.
»
7%
3
&
3
+
.
&
b
HY
w*
’
i
3
*
y
o
J
Lae
¥
-
#1
#
yt
e
8
pe
From
n
i
~~
~
$
3
k
¢
:
y
5
®
4
3
N
a
>
by
"
n
¥
+
”
3
hy
A
¥
4
#
:
-
Fam
1
§
:
r
¥
w
m
"
dia
§
wpnd
-
-
_
"*
’
g
g
1
i
‘
b
a
.
poo
W
3
:
aan!
!
4
“
h:
i
8
w
i
t
Y
e
H
:
>
‘
¥
3
s
e
{
4
<
}
¢
.
y
.
i
a
]
a]
"
i.
,
’
2
>
-
»
a
Eo
je
»
2
§
-
‘
v
i
:
"ris
*
a
FR
:
5
bi
’
6
:
!
|
+3
4
M
#
#
;
;
La
b
&
3
§
=
:
ig
i
i
¥
LB
Ni
ft
Ge
aw
}
7
%
}
:
¢
¢
i
3
Ny
f
Hog
.
n
x
,
@
§
2
"
5
&
"
§
4
.
{
h
AF
x
-
i
£
weet
N
oid
¢
3
a
y
:
E
oy
&
&
§
4
a
,
‘
i
y
»
A
-
‘
i"
.
a;
3
&r
£3
:
F
y
pl
'
4
b
gh
5
Yo
‘ud
v
;
&
,
3.4
¥
«
5
“
“
x
H
3
.
“
e
t
3
»
$
M
%
i
.
w
e
L
J
2
wo
"
#5:
1
*
.
-
ol
d
:
we
wid
v
uw
.
.
8
4
4
i
5
pss
i
2
:
.
3
4
i
#
.
W
8
3
=
%
¥
§
:
-
”
»
fb
=
N
re
§
-
~
.
i
—
A
e
I
et
5
:
a
i
*
.
.
ped
2
5
+
y
lt
»
a
2
& A
:
BR
EC
—
—
I
I
T
—
—
—
—
—
S
S
f
a
a
i
A
S
A
V
E
E
O
A
T
S
N
A
S
LS
i
#2
a
a
a
a
Py
{
3
:
§
i
y
Lo
$
5
RN
—.
A
N
T
A
L
x
Be
—
-
N
L
N
E
i
A
E
e
R
S
Y
3
“
%
3
[
#
t
,
Val
1
*
'
eyed
:
¢
pe
)
ie
8
9
>
*
:
$+
"
~
.
.
Fl
|
we
"
{
N.
b
&
%
g
aod
.
<
9
}
a
i
.
pid
*
;
-
gong
§
€
w
h
a
*
)
£9
_
1
3
a’
X
\
¢
v
)
-
’
3 $
$
po
:
‘
:
.
.
r
te
%
:
3
:
Ra
bk
}
-
]
n
.
&
a9
Wo
:
»
3
¢
3
wi
nd
”
,
+
y
ad
5
p
.
{
’
¢
J
a
h
X
"
we?
i
"
o
.
+“
"
P
§
:
5
hg
ad
Ul
;
>
i
“yo
.
+
5
s
5
:
5
#5
‘
F
s
&
Be
%
3
;
y
«
¢
.
IN
{
"
i
‘
{
§
&
s
-
.
-
-
a
i
i
a
—
.
a
m
s
.
E
T
n
m
E
m
m
n
a
m
a
m
o
n
e
e
,
n
pa
”
—
—
_
e
t
A
A
G
S
A
A
N
E
T
3
0
E
E
A
1
A
A
A
A
.
A
E
S
a
i
8
|
5
5
&
F
¥
2
4
A
oof
w
§
s
2
i i
.
’
¥
R
5
v
§
y
;
i
—
.
I!
i
:
A
‘
5
A
"
y
:
i
g
g
oy
"
»
“
—.
‘
§
i
ce
v
id
hy
¥
a
e
¥
.
v
i
n
d
R
a
i
%
£
.
vo
5
nl
i
3
¢
$
i
%
po
v3
’
-
:
>
&
v
8
:
-
i
‘
i
Y
‘
¢
:
h
-
~
:
pond
-
4
»
£3
{
|
3
¥
4
§
\
J
HW,
|
i
-
’
H
.
“uf
f
i
3
4
.
§
3
2
3
>
5
-
;
:
and
a
*
:
3
4
bh
ow.
’
i
4
§
ei
y
us
:
h
»
3
¥
a
i
¥
¥
f
d
ai
|
4
X
¥
\
tow
.
wo
3
;
.
3
,
a
y
i]
-
;
%
d
:
5
y
3
od
i
a
i
"]
2
%
’
{
-
{
3
hod
r
o
d
4
b
3
i
»
v
4
>
;
3
3
a
»
:
L
W
i
:
E
l
y
§
#
v
y
--
3
Pe
-
l
y
:
on
S
A
RT
RY
ANTI
cu
>
F
R
E
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
S
I
L
E
I
a
d
.
I
er
T
E
A
S
AT
M
T
R
1
;
2
pity
x
J
Wy
£3
y.
s
Hy
he
"
¢
Sp
'
§
L&
]
Fo
4
W
o
3
Wa
{
L
I
%
#
8
i
o
i
a
¢
5
:
:
.
y
*
3
4
-~
pr
po—
—
—
—
-
-
-
-
—
—
—
ze
E
N
it
sr
5
S
E
E
N
B
R
A
E
A
S
T
E
N
T
R
S
.
sin
ced
came
A
A
OE
AALS
AR
A
G
T
EE
—
we
-
E
E
e
.
,
t
-
a
r
a
m
s
-
B
E
—
—
—
e
e
.
n
i
§
1
"
“dd
o
ws
5
]
a
»
or
wy
‘
,
To
¢
$
}
{
5
olay
#98
p
:
b
4
t
E
YN]
#
3
¢
re
a
Ww
.
§
§
“
5
i=
¥
5
.
$
.
%
.
¥%
i
y
3
broth
i
.
roy
:
§
-
nt
$
p
[|
P
S
i
i
.
:
2
%
E
|
+
4
Ww
:
yor
x
oy
5
1
“@
.
ah
;
4
”
1
]
3
pe
wy
ie
h
e
2
é
-
n
”
o
;
3
-
g
*
.
2
fs?
H
4
Bo
¥
o
i
-
i
3
®
3
)
w
5
J
¢
oe?
§
R
uy
ob
A
i
4
‘
=
"
th
1
E
E
E
A
A
PES
A
on
ass
"
a
A
A
A
S
m
a
i
LY
:
A
rd
+
RS
»
a]
=
1
Z
Ns
3
A
ww
.
4
»
«
io
0
-
4
-
i
"
$
5
v
e
‘
%
.
i
Hl
La
1
S
a
"
+
»
?
Py
.
*
doy
3
&
i
3
A
tol
4
+
;
#1
7
¥
W
o
W
.
.
ho
|
J
$
4
:
“
4
£
;
”
y
f
4
p
"
od
n
R
18
N
Par
?
od
i
»
“ol
®
%
8
bil?
:
5
b
o
4
%
p
¥
3
i
1]
.
3
-
¥
ow
»
n
»
wv
’
‘
*
-
T
a
d
¥
wt
i
p
H
‘
:
¢
vr
§
J
ve
a
e
e
—
x
a
n
t
l
A
5
Ey
a
ca
a
I
e
E
h
.
.
.
E
e
i
e
,
a
s
.
.
.
.
.
S
i
,
S
A
”
n
Y
5
:
o
A
y
¢
ie
X
i
’
Ww
a
a
n
Si
J
§
I
,
i
%
:
Pb
“4
'
ho
%
¥
p
@
i
¢
3
:
8
3
i
.
‘
5
g
“
¥
*
v
3
+
3:
4
bi
a
’
.
K
Re
%
f
;
hy
%
y
go
4
R
3
H
A
Ri
.
®
3
¥
.
yu
a
u
’
J
\
}
5
F
hod
7
a
¥
J
[
A
é
{
y
©
}
i
&
J
¥
$
3
”
-
"
3
i
x
bg
h
g
5
4
i
"
#
»
Ww
wid
M
!
bo
.
.
|
$
x
%
9
%
~
-
"
4
y
i
$
,
Li
%,
;
:
“5
a
Po
#
!
ay
*
o
&
Hy
p!
s
N
«
-
4
g
s
3
:
i
i]
A
;
5
3
3
3
3
el
5
{
gi
3
"
H
Sag
i
ot
,
Ey
—
A
A
A
RST
TROT
SR RNG?
A
A
5
a
—
—
—
a
w
r
y
A
AH
F
A
I
2
¥
‘
£
®
n
ia
:
wid
L
E
)
i
L
S
4
anil
%
.
§
x
a
ao
»
Rs
’
x
B
E
Ba
E
E
—
—
—
a
T
E
—
e
T
x
,
x
e
C
r
P
l
.
L
sch
R
I
a
A
a
N
a
a
l
E
R
Fa
|
g
é
s
‘e
"
=
:
2
:
&
i
:
’
i
p
»*
¢
.
v
;
w
|
‘
C
d
§
y
F
o
n
a
“
Pag
«
4
.
x
¥
tag
Fog
su:
i
I
a
L
a
a
i
a
a
.
E
E
I
.
,
.
5
4
4
5
<
E
a
#
1
4
»
"i
kK
of
%
c
y
§
%
3
L
i
v
h:
J
3.5
x
n
>
>
din
i
E
ape
'
ud
&
]
.
_
:
b
a
;
J
i
4
i
i
.
.
4
»
d
4
#
»
¢
h
y
4
%
‘
»
¥
“
4
font
»
*
$
wr
:
+
¢
.
:
¥
¥
é
3
.
’
¥
i
>
;
i
he
2%
‘
oh
w
5
:
a”
eg
;
.
)
Lo
%
i
ul
er
¢
&
$
.
od
¥
2
i
-
-
-
.
aver
“
R
N
.
e
.
a
A
K
E
T
sce
s
u
s
I
m
r
a
,
.
E
U
l
e
]
kL
Bo.
F
ffs
*
F
3
P
e
3
9
.
i
kot
wie
‘
gobs
wi
*
4
]
a”
F
e
g
s%
a
*
~
-
ol
h
b
A
-
y
5
!
:
*
pd
”
“
=
e
&
&
3
]
3
2
#
1
-
»
ty
3
x
g
:
*
"
-
cin
.
4
’
.
Grid
3
?
*
»
”
¥
bid
v
’
*
Fo
»
Lo
¥
B
,
:
a
:
©
¥
%
v
¢
3
3
.
y
§
:
N
Y
ed
‘
F
a
2
:
4
.
ng
y
E
e
>
wh
ooh
4
V
.
}
&
”
»
:
p38
¥
4
’
d
&
Ew»
&
oo
v
n
R
®
¢
w
A
o
d
¥
lb
L
R
|
i
po.
i
3
.
'
i
v
3
]
wp
$4
«
%
-
*
J
3
»
=
¢
3
]
&
p
5
-
a
/
;
J
3
i]
Pend
]
&
"g
i
ig
\
3
¥
i
p
i
2
A
¥
»
:
3
2
®
|
/
i
.
nd
rod
v
E
;
bs
Ww
y
:
:
a
»
g
5
gre
i
.
I
I
a
T
S
A
A
A
R
Y
S
T
T
N
WF
2
Ee
a
a
_—
—
ers
_—
a
sot
.
B
E
.
.
.
.
me
.
-
EY
1)
¢
a &
i
i
g
3
a
i
&
whe
a
»
2
)
:
3
~
y
wl
MN
rd
"
4
¥
&
v
v
:
3
.
:
$
s
v
>
E
T
Ya
y
¥
y
ws
i
?
}
¢
i
¢
E
i
4
7
{
!
4
¢ i
&
3
:
§
Ee
.
i%
{ b
*
a
@
¥