Motion of Defendant Noxubee County School District to Modify Order of November 7, 1969
Public Court Documents
December 23, 1969

14 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Alexander v. Holmes Hardbacks. Motion of Defendant Noxubee County School District to Modify Order of November 7, 1969, 1969. 6e90554e-cf67-f011-bec2-6045bdffa665. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/45b9df24-e007-4b7a-9b9b-9352e380fc57/motion-of-defendant-noxubee-county-school-district-to-modify-order-of-november-7-1969. Accessed October 05, 2025.
Copied!
i ® bas H ERNEST LL. BROWN ATTORNEY AT LAW AREA CODE 601 726-4276 MACON, Miss. 39341 December 23, 1969 Jack Greenberg, Esquire Norman J. Chachkin, Esquire Melvyn Zarr, Esquire Suite 2030, 10 Columbus Circle New York, New York 10019 Re: United States of America, et al, Appellant VS. Noxubee County School District, et al, Appellee Nos. 28030 and 28042 Gentlemen: I enclose herewith a copy of Motion of Defendant Appellee, Noxubee County School District, to Modify Order of November 7, 1969, together with copy of proposed order. With best wishes, I am Yours very truly, > oo rnest L. Brown ELB:cr Encls. y —7 Sy 7 a - V CA 3 ra JE & . WL 4 A App wr” UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al Appellant VS. NOS. 28030 & 28042 | | | NOXUBEE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT, et al Appellee MOTION OF DEFENDANT APPELLEE NOXUBEE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT TO MODIFY ORDER OF NOVEMBER 7, 1969 & COMES NOW Defendants A, R. Koon, Superintendent of Education, and James C, Avery, W. E. Hummer, P. E. Moore, Joe R., Miller, and Sam Featherston, Members of the County Board of Education of Noxubee County, Mississippi, acting herein by and through their counsel of record, and move the Court for a modification of the Order of this Court entered on November 7, 1969, insofar as said Order applies to Noxubee County School District, Noxubee County, Mississippi, by adding an additional paragraph numbered (8), immed- jately following paragraph number (7) in said order, as follows: (8) As to the Noxubee County School System, the Recommended Plan for Student Desegregation 1969-1970 and Thereafter, filed by the Office of Education, Department of Health, Education and Welfare, is unworkable and impos- sible of implementation, IT 1S THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Noxubee County School System be desegregated in the following manner: (A) B. F., Liddell High School and Noxubee County High School shall hereafter constitute one high school consist- ing of grades nine through twelve, Ninth Grade Mississippi History, Ninth Grade Civics, Physical Science, Secretarial Procedure, Vocational Agriculture II, and Vocational Agri- culture III will only be offered at the former B. F. Liddell High School, and all students in the former Noxubee County High School plant taking the above mentioned subjects shall be transported daily, by bus, from the former Noxubee County High School to the former B, F., Liddell High School for such classes, and all such classes shall be fully integrated. Twelfth Grade Government and Vocational Agriculture I will only be offered at the former Noxubee County High School, and all students in the former B. F. Liddell High School taking the above mentioned subjects shall be transported daily, by bus, from the former B. F. Liddell High School to the former Noxubee County High School for classes in the said subjects, all of which classes shall be fully integrated. Additionally, a suf- fieient number of students now in attendance at the former B. F. Liddell High School will be assigned to the former Noxubee County High School to produce a student body ratio of three white to two Negro at the former Noxubee County High School. (B) The Brooksville Attendance Center and Wilson Attendance Center at Brooksville, Mississippi, shall become one attendance center known as Brooksville Attendance Center, and shall encom- pass grades one through eight. History, Geography, and Civics in Grades Six and Seven will only be offered at the former Brooks- ville Attendance Center, and all students at the former Wilson Attendance Center in Grades Six and Seven taking the said sub- jects shall be transported daily, by bus, from the former Wilson Attendance Center to the former Brooksville Attendance Center for said classes. Likewise, English and Spelling in Grades Five and Eight will only be offered at the former Wilson Attendance Center, and all students at the former Brooksville Attendance Center taking English and Spelling in Grades Five and Eight shall be transported daily, by bus, from the former Brooksville Atten- dance Center to the former Wilson Attendance Center for the said classes. All of the above mentioned classes at the for- mer Brooksville Atterdence Center and at the former Wilson Attendance Center shall be fully integrated. Additionally, a number of Negro students now in attendance at the former Wilson Attendance Center shall be assigned to the former Brooksville Attendance Center sufficient to make the composition of the student body at the former Brooksville Attendance Center three white to two Negro. (C) Macon Elementary Attendance Center and B. F. Liddell Elementary Attendance Center shall become one attendance center known as Macon Elementary Attendance Center, and shall encompass grades one through eight. History, Geography and Mississippi History in Grade Five will only be offered at the former Macon Elementary Attendance Center, and all students at the former B. F. Liddell Elementary Attendance Center in Grade Five taking History, Geography, and Mississippi History will be transported daily, by bus, from the former B. F. Liddell Elementary Atten- dance Center to the former Macon Elementary Attendance Center for said classes. Science and Health in Grade Six, and History in Grade Seven shall only be offered at the former B. F. Liddell Elementary Attendance Center, and all students at the former Macon Elementary Attendance Center taking the said subjects in Grades Six and Seven shall be transported daily, by bus, from the former Macon Elementary Attendance Center to the former B. F. Liddell Elementary Attendance Center for the classes in the said subjects. All of the above mentioned classes shall be fully integrated. Additionally, a number of Negro students now in attendance at the former B. F. Liddell Elementary Atten- dance Center shall be assigned to the former Macon Elementary Attendance Center to make the ratio of the student body three white to two Negro. (D) Shuqualak Attendance Center and Reed Attendance Center shall become one attendance center shall become one attendance center under the name of Shuqualak Attendance Center. Science and Health in Grades Five and Seven will only be offered at the former Shuqualak Attendance Center, and all students at the former Reed Attendance Center taking Science and Health in Grades Five and Seven will be transported by bus, dally, from the for- mer Reed Attendance Center to the former Shuqualak Attendance Center for classes in the said subjects, History and Geography in Grades Six and Eight will only be offered at the former Reed Attendance Center and all students at the former Shuqualak Atten- dance Center taking History and Geography in Grades Six and Eight will be transported daily,by bus, from the former Shuqualak Atten- dance Center to the former Reed Attendance Center for classes in said subjects. All of the above mentioned classes shall be fully integrated. Additionally, there shall be transferred and assigned from the former Reed Attendance Center to the former Shuqualak Attendance Center a number of Negro students sufficient to make the racial composition of the student body at the former Shuqualak Attendance Center three white to two Negro. (E) For the remainder of the 1969-70 school year, the defen- dants shall assign the teachers and staff so that the ratio of Negro and white teachers in each school and the ratio of other staff members in each school are substantially the same as each such ratio is to the teachers and other staff members, respectively, in the entire school system. (F) The defendants shall permit a student attending a school in which his race is in the majority to choose to attend another school, where space is available, and where his race is in the minority. Upon the implementation of the above outlined Plan of desegregation, the school system of Noxubee County, Mississippi, will be a non-racial, unitary school system. I In support of said Motion, the defendants would show that the suggested Plan of Integration heretofore filed by the Office of Edu- cation, Department of Health, Education and Welfare, and which was, by : r . Ld . . the Court, ordered to be implemented in said Order dated November 7, 1969, envisions the closing of Brooksville Attendance Center and the transfer of the entire student body from that Attendance Center to Wilson Attendance Center; that the Brooksville Attendance Center has an enrollment of 143 students, and that Wilson Attendance Center has an enrollment of 949 students; that at Wilson Attendance Center there are 21 standard classrooms and 15 sub-standard classrooms; therefore, basing the standard classroom capacity of 27 students, and the sub- standard classroom capacity of 15 students, the total capacity of Wilson Attendance Center is 792 students. There are now enrolled at Wilson Attendance Center 949 students. There are presently enrolled in Brooksville Attendance Center 143 students; thus it would be totally impossible to transfer the 143 students at Brooksville Attendance Cen- ter to Wilson Attendance Center, which would have the effect of placing 1092 students in an attendance center the capacity of which is 792. 11 The said suggested Plan of Desegregation heretofore filed by the Office of Education, Department of Health, Education and Welfare, envisioned the transfer of all students in Grades Nine through Twelve from B. F. Liddell High School to the Noxubee County High School, and the transfer of all students in Grades One through Eight at Macon El- ementary School to B. F. Liddell High School, thus converting the Macon Elementary School and Noxubee County High School into a single high school, and the B. F. Liddell High School and Elementary School into a single elementary school. Defendants would further show that Noxubee County High School was constructed for a capacity of 250 students; that the present enrollment in Grades Nine through Twelve is 300; that the school plant consists of 6 standard size classrooms; 2 sub-standard classrooms; a combination Physics and Chemistry room, having a capacity of 18 students per period; a combination Biology and General Science room, having a capacity of 20 students per period; one Home Economics Department, including one classroom with a capacity of 20 students per period; one Vocational Agriculture Department, including one class- room with a capacity of 18 students per period; one Language Labora- tory, consisting of a sub-standard size classroom with a capacity of 15 students per period; one Commercial Department Room, having a capacity of 25 students per period; one Library with a capacity of 40 students per period; one Gymnasium, with a capacity of 500 students per period; one Band Hall, with a capacity of 40 students; one Industrial Arts room with a capacity of 15 students per period; that Macon Elementary School, which is situated on the Satie campus with Noxubee County High School consists of fifteen standard size classrooms; one Library with a capacity of 25 elementary students per period; one portable classroom, for Special Education, with a capacity of 12 students per period. That the present enrollment in Grades nine through twelve at B. F. Liddell High School is 900, and that it would be physically impossible to place these 900 high school students from B. F. Liddell High School in the facility at Noxubee County High School and Macon Elementary School; that in order to accommodate the extra 900 students from B. F. Liddell High School, it would be necessary to convert four classrooms for instruction in Physics, Chemistry, ‘Biology and General Science; to convert three classrooms into Home Economics rooms; to convert two classrooms into Industrial Arts rooms; to convert one classroom into a Foreign Language room; to convert the cafeteria, which now has a capacity of 600, to a capa- city of 1200; to construct a new Vocational Agriculture Building to accommodate two full-time Vocational Agriculture teachers; to convert the present gymnasium, with a present capacity of 500, to a gymnasium with a capacity of 1200, and to renovate the library, which presently has a capacity of 40 students, to one having a capacity of 150 students. When the above outlined renovation is completed, there would remain only five classrooms to accommodate the 900 high school stu- dents from B. F. Liddell High School, which means that it would be necessary to construct an additional 25 classrooms, a complete new Vocational Agriculture Building, renovate the gymnasium, lunchroom, library, band hall, and all bathrooms at Macon Elementary School, which are presently built for elementary students and are minature in size and equipment; that the cost of such program 1s estimated by a competent architect to be $946,950.00. Further, upon comple- tion of the renovation and the construction of the additional 25 classrooms, almost all, if not all, the available playground would # § i bs t hn 3 — A T O N E 1 | { { { } 4 [| A, be occupied by such additional classrooms. That a bond issue would be required in order to finance such renovation and con- struction, and that same could not be accomplished by December 31, 1969, and probably not in time for the beginning of the school ses- sion in the year 1970. Because of the ultra-crowded condition that would exist upon the construction of the 25 additional classrooms, and the limita- tion thereby placed upon'the playground space for the students, it would be desirable to construct a complete new Aisi school, relocated on a larger tract of land; that the cost of such new high school, relocated on a larger tract of land, is estimated by a competent architect t6 be $§1,504,000.00. Defendants would further show unto the Court that the defendants are wholly without funds with which to make such renovation and construction, and that it is highly doubtful that any bond issue would be approved by the citizens of the County for said purpose. 111 Defendants further show that the recommended plan of desegrega- tion of the schools of defendant District heretofore filed by the Office of Education, Department of Health, Education and Welfare, envisions the closing of Shuqualak Attendance Center and trans- ferring the students from that attendance center to Reed Attendance Center; that Reed Attendance Center consists of twelve standard classrooms and four portable classrooms, and that, using 27 students as the capacity of a standard classroom and 15 students as the capa- city of a sub-standard classroom, Reed Attendance Center has a present capacity of 384 students; that the present enrollment of Reed Attendance Center is 448 students; that the present enrollment at Shuqualak Attendance Center is 122 students, and that the transfer of the 122 students from Shuqualak Attendance Center to Reed Atten- dance Center would increase the enrollment at Reed Attendance Center to 570 students in a facility, the capacity of which is 384 students, and that thus an impossible situation would be created. RY Defendants submit herewith, in support of this motion, the following exhibits: l. A tabulation of the number of students of each race per- manently assigned to each school building in the district, marked "Exhibit 1." 2. A tabulation showing the number of students of each race transported to each school building in the district for classes only offered at such building, marked "Exhibit 2." 3. Affidavit of a Bi-Racial Committee, composed of Bennie Sanders, John Roland, and Rev. W. M. Harper, three leaders of the Negro community in Noxubee County, Mississippi, and V. M. Geno, Carl W. Craig, Jr., and Dr. W. C. Anderson, three leaders of the white community of Noxubee County, Mississippi, endorsing this proposed modification of the order of the Court dated November 7, 1969, marked "Ex- hibit 3." Defendants incorporate by reference Exhibits Nos. 1 through 16 filed in this cause with defendants' former Motion of Defendant Appellee, Noxubee County School District, to Modify Order of November 7, 1969, which motion was mailed to the Clerk of this Court for fil- ing on November 12, 1969. Vv The plan of desegregation hereinabove outlined and proposed by defendants would result in placing an additional 228 Negro students in the former Noxubee County High School for classes, and 200 more on a permanent assignment basis, and placing 183 white students in former B. F. Liddell High School for classes; it would likewise place an additional 143 Negro students in former Macon Elementary Attendance Center for classes, and 180 Negro students on permanent assignment, and 80 white students in the former B. F. Liddell Ele- mentary Attendance Center for classes. The effect at the former Brooksville Attendance Center would be to place an additional 244 Negro students therein for classes, and 98 on permanent assignment, with 39 white students to be placed in the former Wilson Attendance Center for classes. At Shuqualak, an additional 100 Negro students would be placed in the former Shuqualak Attendance Center for classes, and 80 on permanent assignment, and 21 white students will be placed in former Reed Attendance Center for classes. There is situated in the City of Macon, Mississippi, Central Academy, a non-sectarian private school which currently has an enrollment of 276 white students, grades One through Nine. The administration of said private school anticipates an enrollment of 336 during the next semester, and anticipates adding Grades Ten, Eleven and Twelve next semester, which would increase its enrollment considerably. Vi Defendants aver that the recommended plan of desegregation heretofore filed in this cause by the Office of Education, De- partment of Health, Education and Welfare, 1s not only unrealistic, but impossible of implementation, and that the proposed plan of de-segregation outlined above by the defendants will realistically desegregate all of the schools of the defendant school district, and convert the school system of defendant school district into a unitary, non-discriminatory school system. Respectfully submitted, er Sy » i Ernest L. Brown, Attorney at Law Macon, Mississippi 39341 COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANTS CERTIFICATE OF MAILING I, Ernest L. Brown, Attorney of record for Defendant, Noxubee County School District, do hereby certify that 1 have this day mailed, by United States Mall, postage prepaid, a true and correct copy of the foregoing Motion of Defendant Appellee, Noxubee County School District, to Modify Order of November 7, 1969, and Exhibits, to the following: Honorable Griffin B. Bell, Judge United States Court of Appeals for the Pifth Circuit P. O. Box 845 Atlanta, Georgia 30301 Honorable Lewis R. Morgan, Judge United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit P. O. Box 759 Newnan, Georgia 30263 Honorable Homer Thornberry, Judge United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit 200 West Eighth Street Austin, Texas 7/8701 Honorable Jerris Leonard Assistant Attorney General Civil Rights Division United States Department of Justice Washinzton, D.C. 20330 Honorable Ben Krage, Attorney Civil Rights Division United States Department of Justice 906 Milner Building Jackson, Mississippi 39201 Honorable A. F. Summer Attorney General of Mississippi New Capitol Building Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Honorable Melvyn R. Leventhal, Attorney Honorable Reuben Anderson, Attorney Honorable Fred l.. Banks, Jr., Attorney 538% North Farish Street Jackson, Mississippi 39202 Honorable Jack Greenberg, Attorney Honorable Norman J. Chachkin, Attorney Honorable Melvyn Zarr, Attorney Suite 2030, 10 Columbus Circle New York, New York 10019 WITNESS MY SIGNATURE, this the 23rd day of Pscombers 1969, Zz onli le <=— ERNEST L. [= 3 E e — 5, (0) Ql 0 oO ON +L Tq) LO) @) O \O Q O oO Ql (e0) SS) \O QJ MN Tg! \O IS Oo &~ i QO Oo 0 oO Oo 53 a) © LO (¢®) O O O < oO ’ O 0) (0) eo) i \O eo] MN (QV \O < d 3 b = 5 — ry aa ¥ ~ u > ; Mm HH wn P R D ! @® == = lh) B A P $2 © oO Ql oO A or = = QJ OO HD E+ 4 el OC QV] O — O NY Oo ~ = r = n M Fo Fry <d ry «T 5 [@) = ri Sa = ali ea £4 M y 4 n M 0 - e H + S es — O <q 4) ei -| 1 9 0 O) 42 ®) ~~ a a" O 4 > < (o) (0) By O w 4 © si 0 O n ® 42 ® OO gy [3 <3 9) <i +d ® nN (9) = id od 4) je [0] 42? wn O B « 0 i) oO po! < HH <4 3 2 <4 0) a < E+ HM je) 0) 0) @® 0 of 80 <d [0] O > I 3 He or +1 = 43 [v) Sy |G = ® 0 O O fl = 1 fa} SQ ® oO ™ Mm <td ie) +2 ri i <i +3 =. . <x ol o rl + cl r . = 0) [0] » © <4 ge’ 3 QO i 2 £1 T od o 3 ~~ 2 0) 3 M ® oO 3 Foi od <q ~~ od a +2 od > £3 +1 r + © = > 0 | [ay] < 3 1) LY Oo < » ~ Ke) . Oo 0 o Fes eo) {oe ” I= oO 4 O ~~ [0] £d ~ or [ay . st (0) oO . m = ~~ as wn (a= p= Mm H ~ &~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ oO D (0) ® Q D 6) 0) £ & = E 5 E =| =| ~ pa IS 4 4 ~ pS ~ Oo 0 oO Oo Oo Oo Oo oO Fry Fry Fee Foy Fy Fey Fey Fry <4 =< MM Oo MN ¢8) = O\ = O = rl <> (69 (QV) o MN Ql QO r— QJ rl 1 (QV) Oo 6 + 1 > = O 0 Fl <¥ <¥ oO Ql a o O Q J O Q — O O 3 o O (QV 4 : dp] 2a Ea ca | I MN by Ie | - : 4 2 j 4 4 3 3 © vi : 3 v 0 rE O oO Ql O 4 oO . a by £3 ® c- n o £ 4 = te £3 4 A H ll = — < q Q V A EH C T ~ ~ a C o 6} (¢)] + x x 4 & : a8 pe br = cf 0) ® {4 — Kd £3 <3 [¢)) : o» 42 +2 oO —f ri O ES) [ a w Ty iiidy 10 EY = is ol £ 1 0 OQ ey Eh L I 9 3 9 SI D 4 o H o f i o HBS Dail 4 9 S | oy Majd io jo S g 0 Z C O < < 0 2 | vo lp ) O 3 <3} < © ® <t js od ® {2 <1 ® nN wn fe FA tit a oD © D D O < ® 0 Ke < oO 3 e y £ {8 S 0 8 . (0 a ley oe)3jS nN) — , o O $e 6 @ ju 4) aD [ay] O O ay] o r af) a d o r t= ed D oO 0) ® > rd fed > js QQ ir} wd Jed rd OQ 4 < gq § 3 I 63 &4 ju! ® O pe! 4 J fe F r +2 ® Ay] +2 a fay © O < © > a E+ <q "3 ie) <q 2 (on +2 +2 fe] a +2 + 4 vi 2 «t EA <3 < < I. ri <l +42 [ay] 3 + < 1 Si - y H o od O e a D i o Jo O l e o l d o z to Teo is i I O - P P AH lg « w £1 o lo Oo. B i o TO mM oy ~ Pp +4 = (1)) 3 fo! @ |X qa +3 29 > fo] Le os : <4 1) vi < d e l Jd wd ld et JE l s wd |e EH = ~ a 152 H H BA [Hd + J rf ® HH 1 ® t td 0] < < [0] fy] <q fay] ( 4) [A x 4 O o o O X x c t ° \ <3 3 O C > = » ° P L £4 a i O 10 By (Fy O i l To lo i o l s vey Jee wo j © a4 jri oo lo 6 }j53" 9 leo = 5k Bs | H o g pb B 1 8 S i r s SH aqme sl J O E iO i J ha MN (= MN Mm = (0n ae ‘ mn ~ SSE «+ WEE © SE —4 4 Hy ~ ~ SR = YH ~ 4 S 0) ~ ~ 4 H HH I) i) 0) 0) ® ® (6h) 0) 0) © £1 ® 0) ® a ® B 8 1H. B 4 8 gS i=" £2 15 "85 {&4 € 5 8a 18 # ~~ pS ~ | & ps 4 1 ~ “ oO 4 8 £4 < ¥ © 0 [o! Oo o oO [o) oO lo) oO (Fu lo} oO Oo Oo o me Fra cI = [ m e ey ry {Py = [A K | 1 : [ i [ [ ! [ I : i [ i ! £ o} = Oo = Oo & oO IS Q = Oo =| Oo 8 lo} Oo wv JS Oo HE oO Hi Oo Ef Oo oO = Oo ~ pn ~ 4 ~ & “ Fey fy = Fry Foy Fry = Fry fh -@ 5 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS & FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al Appellant VS. Nos. 28030 & 28042 NOXUBEE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT, et al Appellee AFFIDAVIT OF BI-RACIAL COMMITTEE PERSONALLY APPEARED BEFORE ME the undersigned authority in and for Noxubee County, Mississippi, Bennie Sanders, John Roland,, and the Reverend W. M. Harper, three leaders of the Negro community of Noxubee County, Mississippi, and V, M. Geno, Carl W, Craig, Jr., and Dr. W. C, Anderson, three leaders of the white community of Noxubee County, Mississippi, each of whom, being by me first duly sworn, on oath, depose and say: That they compose a Bi-Racial Committee of Citizens of Noxubee County, Mississippi; that the proposed Modification of the Plan of Desegregation of the Schools of Noxubee County, Mississippi, as shown by a motion, which motion is to be filed in the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit by the Noxubee County Board of Education and the Superin- tendent of Education, has been this day presented to, and lucidly explained to us, and we thoroughly understand the same. Affiants further depose and say that they do heartily agree with and endorse the said Proposed Modification of the Plan of Desegrega- tion of the Schools of Noxubee County, Mississippi, as reflected by the above mentioned motion. la 7 IT YE BENNIE SANDERS JOHN ROLAND ; Ly : : Fiihine 4, Pe I, SN 1 fr +7 { Vz vd { A : 12 et a RS We. pga V. M. GENO i & Gh J i nd Loo Ke AAO 2d CARL W. SniTi DR. W. C. ANDERSON a TO AND SUESCRIBED BEFORE ME, this the 4 = day of December, 196 (Seal) (Yc s. POL ae Bla tw Nosh Sr J “) My commission expires 727:..-4//¥ [77> ; WEXHIBIT 37