SCOTUS, No. 89-7024 - Oral Argument Notes and Outline

124 pages
Document text

The following text has been generated automatically during the document scanning process. It may contain errors, omissions, or incorrect formatting. Please refer to the PDF document if this text is not usable.
Download
By downloading, publishing, or reusing the Materials outside of the Website, you hereby confirm and attest that you have read and agree to the LDF Archival Collection Terms of Use linked below. We draw your attention to the following:
For those Materials owned by LDF, your use of the Material outside the Site is solely for one or more of the following (the “Permitted Purposes”):
Non-commercial research and private study;
Teaching, scholarship and instruction (including distance learning);
Non-commercial print and non-commercial online use;
Criticism, comment or news reporting; or
For people with visual disabilities (See Section 121 of the Copyright Act).
For those Materials not owned by LDF you understand that:
- It is your responsibility to determine whether the way you plan to use the materials falls within the copyright exception of Fair Use.
- For any use outside of Fair Use, it is your responsibility to seek and obtain all required permissions from any existing rights holders.
LDF hereby grants you the right to use LDF owned Materials for the Permitted Purposes without seeking further permission from LDF.
If you publish or redistribute any Materials (including excerpts and quotes), you must include a credit line and/or proper citation to the source of the Material. However, you may not use the name of LDF in any manner which creates any false association between you and LDF or that incorrectly implies any sponsorship or endorsement of you by LDF.
NOTICE: Uses that do not comply with these Terms or that do not fall under Fair Use (or another exception) may make you liable for copyright infringement.
Read the full LDF Archival Collection Terms of Use Here.
I agree to the terms and conditions for use of this content.
If you would like to use this content in other ways, contact us at
Contains McCleskey v. Zant Outline of Oral Argument; Jack Boger's Notes on Oral Argument.
Impact area
- Criminal Justice
Topic
- Capital Punishment
LDF Attorneys
Cooperating Attorney
- Robert Stroup
Notable Person
- Warren McCleskey
Organizations
Matter
- McCleskey v. Kemp
Case
- McCleskey v. Zant – U.S. Supreme Court (No. 89-7024)
U.S. state
- Georgia
Collection
- Case Files
Taxonomy
Identifier
- 5c9a41d6-62a7-ef11-8a69-7c1e5266b018
Cite this item

Case Files, McCleskey Background Materials. SCOTUS, No. 89-7024 - Oral Argument Notes and Outline, 1990. 5c9a41d6-62a7-ef11-8a69-7c1e5266b018. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/492bf5b7-f3c9-40c3-9058-d639748d1ece/scotus-no-89-7024-oral-argument-notes-and-outline. Accessed May 14, 2025.

Copied!
    Case LOSS. | > | ; ave Files: McCleskey  (03](-613): Bact J} : 1 Fai fg: ) | K { 

   



  

WARREN McCLESKEY V. WALTER D. ZANT 

Outline of Oral Argument =-- Supreme Court of the United States 

October 31, 1990 
  

I. INTRODUCTION: 

A. Case about: 1. State misconduct and 

2. How it came to light 

B. Presents Three Legal Issues: 

First, Whether Petitioner Should Be Entitled To 

Assert The Hidden Claim, Or Whether He Has 

#Abused The Writ;” 

Second, Whether The State’s Exploitation Of The 

Misconduct At Petitioner’s Trial Was Somehow 

#Harmless” Error That Did Not Contribute to 
  

the Jury’s Verdict of Guilty or Its Sentence 

of Death: 

Third, An Overarching Issue: Who, Within the 

Federal System, Ought Normally Answer These 

Questions. 

 



  

Il. 

To Evaluate the Issue of Abuse, It is Useful To. Lay Some 

Foundation Concerning the Underlying Claim Itself. 

THE DISTRICT COURT =- Which Heard the Evidence =-- Found: 

A. That One or more Atlanta Police Officers Assigned to 

Investigate the Murder of a Fellow Police Officer, 

B. Met At the Fulton County Jail with an Informant -- 

Offie Evans --Previously Known to one of the Officers 

Ce Successfully Recruited Evans To begin an Undercover 
    

Interrogation of Petitioner Warren McCleskey, A Suspect 
  

in the shooting, Who Was Being Held in the Fulton 

County Jail 

D. Arranged to Move Evans From Elsewhere In the Fulton 
  

County Jail To A Cell Next To McCleskey 

E. That Once There, Evans Began An Active and Aggressive 
  

Campaign To Obtain Relevant Information 
  

F. That Armed with this Information, Evans Reported Back 
  

to State Officials, including Some who may not have 

 



  

known about the prior agreement with the Police 

Officers 

G. That the State Prosecutor Later Used Offie Evans as A 
  

Witness At McCleskey’s Trial, Featuring McCleskey’s 

Ostensible Admission to Evans That He Had Shot Officer 
  

Schlatt 

The District Court, Having Found These Facts, Concluded That 

They Established A Violation of Massiah v. United States, 
  

United states v. Henry, and Other Six Amendment Cases 
  

III. THE ISSUE OF ABUSE 

The Issue that has Dominated This Appeal is not the Massiah 

violation Itself, But Whether Petitioner Was At Fault For 

Failing to Uncover Evidence of It Sooner. 
  

A. Sanders v. United States and Rule 9(b) indicate that 
  

the Question Of Abuse is Normally Committed To the 

Discretion of the District Court. 
  

1. As the State Has Conceded in its Brief, the 

District Court in this case: 

 



  

(a) was WELL AWARE of this Issue and Devoted 
  

Significant Attention To It During the Second 

Federal Hearing; 

(b) indeed, was Initially HIGHLY SKEPTICAL of 
  

petitioner’s failure to have raised the claim 

earlier. 

As it listened to Petitioner’s Answers To Its 

Questions, The District Court Was Won Over. 
  

What Evidence Did The District Court Hear? 

i. that petitioner’s counsel had suspected a 

Massiah violation: 

ii. that they had included the claim in their 

initial state habeas corpus pleadings; 

ii. that they had undertaken a four-part 
  

investigation of the claim, including: 
  

  

a. A Field investigation to locate 
  

witnessess who might have observed the 

Massiah violation 

 



  

iii. 

A request for State documents that might 
  

bear on the claim; 

direct examination under oath of 
  

informant Offie Evans; and 

a deposition of the state Prosecutor, 
  

Russell Parker. 

This four-fold Investigation Revealed 

Nothing of Use: 

The field investigation led ultimately 

to the Fulton County Classification 

Officer -- Bobby Edwards -- Who Had Been 

Responsible For all cell assignments: 

he remembered nothing about Evans’ cell 

assignment, or anything suggesting a 

relationship with Atlanta police; 

No documents 

Evans was asked a host of questions 

about his cell assignment and his 

relationship with Atlanta police -- 

 



  

iv. 

nothing pointing toward Massiah -- [see 

Questions in fnte on page 10 of Pet. 

Br.] 

d. Prosecutor Parker testified: 

#T don’t know of any instance that Offie 

Evans had worked for the Atlanta Police 

Department as an informant prior to his 

overhearing conversations at the Fulton 

County Jail [in McCleskey’s case.] . . 

[(J.A. 28) 

Q. ARe you today aware of any understanding 

between any Atlanta police department 

detectives and Offie Evans? 

A. No, sir, I’m not aware of any. . . . 

[3.A. 26]. 

It is Undisputed that at the Conclusion of 
    

His Investigation, Robert Stroup had found 

neither of the two principal items of 

evidence that later established the Massiah 

claim: 

(a) Evans’ 21-page statement to police, or 

 



  

(b) Ulysses Worthy, the Fulton County jailor 

who later proved to have overheard the 

police enter into the Massiah agreement 

with informant Evans. 

4. Having heard THIS Evidence on the issue of abuse, 

The District Court Found: 

(a) 

(b) 

That Stroup’s investigation Had Been 

Reasonably Competent, and 

That, even had Stroup directly questioned the 

two Atlanta detectives most involved with 

Evans, he would not have found the evidence 

of a Massiah violation any sooner. 

5. The District Court CONCLUDED, on this evidence: 

(a) That even though Stroup had not CARRIED THE 

Massiah CLAIM FORWARD into federal District 

Court, his failure to bring the Massiah claim 

forward into federal court had been neither 

(1) a deliberate bypass, nor 

 



  

faith 

(ii) inexcusable neglect. 

THE COURT OF APPEALS’ TREATMENT 

1. The Court Of Appeals’ opinion on the Abuse Issue 

is PUZZLING -- since 

a. It purports to accept the District Court’s 

Factfindings but does not. 

b. It states that the District Court has 

misinterpreted the law on Deliberate 

Abandonment, and Then Proceeds to Restate 

that Law in a Form NEVER SEEN BEFORE, one 

which would VIRTUALLY END the right to bring 

a successive petition -- one which would hold 

counsel 

not to a subjective standard of good 
  

not to an objective, “reasonable 
  

counsel” standard 

 



  

but to a standard of #strict liability” 
  

in the investigation and presentation of 

habeas claims. 

On each of these two points, the Court of Appeals 

erred. 

In ignoring the allocation of factfinding 
  

  

responsibility to the DISTRICT COURT, it 

violated Rule 52. 

in framing ITS OWN NEW LEGAL STANDARD for 

#deliberate abandonment, the Court of Appeals 

ignored the role of Congress. 

The Allocation of Responsibility Under Rule 52 

Rule 52 Allocates Responsibility for 

Decision-making withing the Federal Judicial 

System. 

i. To the District Courts =-- factfinding. 

ii. To the Court of Appeals =-- review of 

legal issues . . . so long as, on any 

reasonable view of the record, the facts 
  

 



  

could have been found as did the 

District Court. 

b. Here, as in Amadeo v. Kemp, the Court of 
  

Appeals Usurped the Proper Role of the 

District Court and Refound the Facts: 

i. on whether Ulysses Worthy could have 

been found; 

ii. on whether interviewing the police and 

jailor Hamilton would have been useful; 

iii. on the value of Evans’ 21-page 

statement. 

[CF. ISSUES IN AMADEO: whether jury list was 

reasonably available, and whether the 

lawyers deliberately bypassed the jury 

issues. IF ANYTHING, McCleskey’s 

record is much stronger -- we tried.] 

3. Adoption of a New Standard 

10 

 



  

a. Up to Congress =-- history of 28 U.S.C. § 

2244, § 2244 (Db) and Rule 9(b) 

b. Congress presently considering the scope of 

successive petitions, no lack of 

congressional attention to the issue. 

A THIRD ERROR OF THE 

a. To overlook the 

covering up the 

violation 

1. Failure to 

2. Denials by 

COURT Of APPEALS 

State’s misconduct in 

evidence of a Massiah 

turn over 21-page statement. 

Parker and police. 

[Mention Evans’ FALSE REPORT to PARKER 

before state habeas deposition.] 

b. Equity should forbid the state to profit by 

its own misconduct 

Cc. This Court should not make a SAFE HARBOR for 

those State Officials whose misconduct has 

il 

 



  

gone undiscovered through an initial federal 
  

application. 

EQUITY AND THE NEED FOR DETERRENCE OF STATE 

MISCONDUCT combine to insist that -- as in 

Amadeo -- the State not be permitted to 

profit from its own mischief. 

12 

 



the newly discevandt evidmen les 

ReADILy AVAILABLE | & Hu SETS 

psig blameless, The ha booo dpp icant 

fa boars hull responsitnlhy Av Ais 

failue b pogut No clam earlien 

But whee, a in Fico v. Jewsay, 

{ho Shr ray have achively Cracsatod 
ih sw Miscondud £) Ta Lapin must 

  

  

  

  

hath. be hao (Foare iS ton Tree od | 
IN fd ender crdd 

novefhabs hae bam discrvenwd 

  

   



 



(3 £ VW (LK A (ECP JON A Ap y GX SPA) 

Es Ari ale 
(1) whale: counsels in yeshgaker 

5 Gmt clhe achm 
demoihals. * inetwsable nogldl, 

(2) Whothon Coumsel has dolibeintel 
fen showdmed ov Gypes-d 

dam , ¢ 

(3) Whatton Yow is smo ofr 
INEqwilat emdud attributrlte 

fo Ho Potiftrmgy fod Malis 
F agpreprick 4 damzs Hu 

Clam - 

  

  

  
   



Jot md dddnse the <u d] dhruna Frst. In Wi. Gre 

Devich Judy Owen Tovrecle, 0% Glousuie 
en fad rssue wh 3) fo Sums 4 (9€7; 

Pp ArtetIPT Rb 

  

  
  

  

  
  

            

  

= Oud he delowin Mist pk fails 

| Was nah am aliuwee SE cronth hin 
| Ad ensidraton J) Io muons 4) Po Massidl clam, 

Te lng apo Commie Hy 

Judges ike am Fovieectar a 

ty ark dader mvs ~ 

(12tifians es Glusshon bos 

ud i their $130d scat 

Tondhormne, both Cones and tls Cond - 

thn bdo 52 bo fedo d Bots, 4 Cul 

fs — hut be Ha Princip] ros ms Ib 

  
  

  
  

  

      fr AU ia idig on Olise 2 ot Oy



Rae Mn fhe hard 4 Dreux Judges (He 

Du bvieslar, 

Our stdomigim EN 

Ei [yt au No 

@ [led rid rot” abuse (k broad denen , 

| md that — — cnoquomtly — IT wag, 

ov tov Oo Cond ah 

Jubpmad. 

 



  

  

  

amd THIROZ An ovedbluny Guosha 

Whettan tho Cound § Apprels rune 
popu defooucs b tho faci 
0] the Rehict Crit ia resolu 
Yoo | Sat. 

le I Bae 
this Comt faced rosy iit fence w 
  

3 Yod to 

dP aye 
IM Sucesshe Cia 

  

J a 4 UTNE arr A LkA\a A Z\ ri\ [Ad 
v8 PAE DRL 7 MANNY / \J7UKPN 

To resol 

( ddut you Presa fit You 
ih ro challouge eaddio” ” 

  

m——  



QO) Jar ome "objective Back aplerna (has Hols cefonsc '— em 
af 22) Mierfernomco by ptAaals " wu 

| iMpodod Counsel's 06 <lity 1 
outhy to vilitin 

(2) pu] HF Waa. 20douco J theo 
vielatern Was net "ppasemably 
discovealil,” edge dospie 

  

tho oF cial jnedosuc | ra 

(3) feat Heo defaamtad oepman 

tachicad consi doh,’ 
Td bo Hu decisum not fo asset 

  

  
  

  

   



Tho poncigel deffewe (etivess fio tuts canes iS HE oF LIU UE: 
nsdn, as 2% Llu   

  

  

is iY petite te IN scondud 

Camu. + ligt oly GEER. He mia 

ud haloes procure had bo ony bled] 
A= CA Tt 

Whe 775 analyte | apparatus 4 Suerssie 
em (au) ENE abraded “Uf : 

bls bel by pes bela 

— Inéxcasabhb hop 

— or Qf vevaciow caudud 
by Pobitines 

   



  

  

1) (Was Hie shilp oncoefusit 4 asm” 

2) Hae trike J Bolin 
bx pa = Jy ret 

beame 4) | ov; instead, 
dep (5 ne i dogovdent 

fo ASE J 

 



  

The Br shid Judy mn Th Ca Se =A 

LZ A ate 
7. 

~~ Was fooudy 

q fo use , Neal 

Aadf fl dy 
dus oy Apumod 

3 

bd 1 Jesh ney Shou 2rd 

Fidos. 1%. bi < 

ov the 

  

  

The Pas EL 
Hot po 4 ar oe 

( i: % a Tt = 
= wi gr 4h 

0tmc] = : { Hoh flinne 5 AD boa 
3) Sade” Coucoal mod 

lay. 

  

  

  

| ol cleo Lis 
- ala 2 el  



dune Wo found Afest pititonert ME band moh 

Ho Massaly claim, — ler alo habees 

Po c@odiuys — (secamac ft ug, 0b Viguo 7 

cold. no) Sued yivem ta fou trom 
fac," 

  

  

    

  
; / 
H J 

3 J 

§ / + . 
; / iz 

AGA——THT NIT ANGoo 

i | 
5 -



Led 
4 Yi Caw is or 

dscsunly or dsnsss lf Tselho; 

fo 1b 4 Shiz Contodmst in impoduing 
Coughs Jer % 

  

  

  

ir: I. ul 

§ QO Ceqmnt Lu 6l30og0y 

| {ilg b & 

er at tn bs wu mg Dr.    



Calls all Fo tuo" 1 is Te ® 
fates yeas who Lear i i 

  

Conepadp 1B Ysindnsts Tho lav 

Nolundd te hoard, Unless 1% ork 
bean disaaea) i ndgre te, oh ess T° 

6 Ce 

it we pA Te ln ET ts 

Vg Li aan 9 
Thun ¥ Sperm) B evr Nanoarar — youve 

im bop ned) ta Predoz, Tle Conk o Poppe ole 

Fo subs bck & in fue fred jubprad 

fle 

   



@ : 
“This Coit #adhivgc Mm Coli bercte Gud sm ment " 

a. WT pbscuns oy Coffe cive - 

In a (na (ws J) canon - 
(nln daip Weng Doo v. United Shite. 

Pi v. J an 

  

  

  

  

on fuck 0) Tt + 

Usduo Alzulelds 
"qccoscille Al fo Hime 

it) 

He 1966 Compr indi 
in propssd_ 2 aL 03.7 Sol) tua 
Ulan dmg 4ineA. af pelitmens im 
with ig ims Tobvibualy bell Loasin h  



  

Th ind 2 he — Noh © = hol) 

patikven b 4 bigfon Shaded. — loan he 

asked. te not Simply Wheto patifpo 

amd Wo Coumsel [pups A fk — 

  
  

  

  

This Dbjechve md ard. reasons 

(yejent Was Insuificiot bo Sebich, (y. 

| gS spd iubstiahsy , Loud lave suffi 

Cudh A A Shi Qiaka (ih dal | i$ Vl | pnd) 

hall not bey ho Lows, 

   



by Qucussise ptm au to be (amed albopls - 

hd. in padhal effed; ic 1a te Cand 7] Ape 

prpess— Mud” pay ds und came ir. Corgis, 

ot Ho fedond cout 

Mod liao J Need vot umdonlus 

td Cops 8 oc cally Adie] Swap   
 fogihirx 0 by # SUCeoSsiwe ptifins iT 

Fis nil Yet Add adept Hou, 

 



Outing of Ord Frege mount O 
  

  

T, Intvedudion 

A. Case Abouk: a) Sale Misconduct 
©) How Jt Cano iA Light 

B. feces al Jisos 
First (1) Whettes Petitions Shadd Re guckitod 

To Assert The Hidden Claim of Mises 
OR WHETHEE HE ABU) Th WT 

Seto (2) & Whelke Tho States Exploit 
Toe So Miscouducl>— 7 Geodon Tle Artal 

| 72% 
Ja? 

r. S re Toot Dd F Suen 

THREE: OvRpRay SEINE dd of Guilh IF 7 
Qu LS E Suny, )k wh Mma Yi fein dt Todi 

CT aE i [os 
L A Brie fo dati ncevuy The | @ah= 

llyiny | Cason otel) : 24g Sp 

The Poumdatm oF He Hsin 

The Dstie] Cont Which Hond tte Evidpafousd 
iy Tt Owe ov Move PHamk be Ofhins 

wd To Tho dMmuoshaghe OF The 
Bre 4 {elbow a 

a nn. Mer At To Budi Comb Tad 
with qr want — Ove (ups =~ 
Previously) | % Ovo of Th, lie fc. 

   

         

   

  

    

  

      

 



@ 
Q. Suctsidl bondd Sanh lo “ M 
jh sie, Inder Goh borin Werrem 

godin £455 Cpe Cte padi Member 

The Gung — a op er 

D. Beto, Ovi, & ha 
ho Fudtm ad h fo 

eh + ME iy 

E. “had Once Tos, Clans Begin Mn 

ih hdl Spf 

5 A Ho Lipied © i dl on 
b Beoy fue 

© Evans’ ios 2 ore (Ton foo Sty . Cr 

And Tad The Shle RT I at 

b: a A has sc Lbs 

‘Closken's Thal 
i Culls sie 
Tus i tof yo 

H. Sine Thov Hed pik No 

To Th Shoohvg - 

  

oF 

  

Th Bvt Cont Erg Toi a ¢ No 

Crnduded That This tip OF Sado Comet 
Violidsd Wassith v. Usted Sie, & US. Hons 

  
  

   



        

gUE The Jesug OF Abuse - ©, 

# The (UQ lus domed Sed 12 st tho Mascaly 
A, bu satis toi He af full G7 July /isldm A 

2 Fy ZEA A       

    

  

Fire = re ph ) tlh se 

Prt inked, Dahil bound gud bl of 

or ol. it Lidanod 4 tesesem plone 

Prswess Ih Quathin, - Bird. was 
Gm ova, 

  L. had suspocld a Massa videhn 
WU dts plod the clan ou SRE 

hale as Ha p su | 

(0 Undotmk aw ote Zale fh 
Fold ineshigton tb boats co Bose 

A Hh Maes? Ale 
———— 

B, Sout Shits documek 

C Quagned Ofc boar, (lus infvmet, 
wndo. 04h 

@ D. Husted te Stil pros 
leo Undo hh.  



iv. . 4 fg ht fit bd by clos rats < 

Una ipd prioals the 
ctu ot — flu - 

B, M docomad; 

> Aoclir a mt) rs 

func = ret Bi 

Aug Te 

Quwic 

  

oO 4. It 5 Uumdo3patad tral” af Mao lusun 4) fog hes 
ar - Shop hed frmd. LEED 

(n fe Evans or FHloweL 
() flo Jasler Ihe bad gverbanid fre 

(4 po Police a gms 

5. Bad a op : Jn ines 
: soll Crnfele” — 

    

  

~ | 3 
TB He pg Fide vislabin ladle intone 

® Deval ld Bi = 

re Bi “a FI  



    1. Wlbhats any tod nat camicd He 
Passidy casio % Wn ify Ledind habee. 

Proces dui — bo crmdud dled his 
ils B dh 9 wh noisy 4 

dl poopy infos Ney 

       
     

   

    

B. Mu Godt 1 Appedd’ Trahrad - 

lg a] Ad opjimn & gm Ho lane Kee 

i puadlip = 
fii umprk h deep fe Bcd Gud s 

© 3 odin. cap TF doe tif ems 

BW Sats, By The PF. a ened via 

(R la boro alambumeX, 

ate i di 0 aia fri 

ilyed, a will wy id pit, 
_ Nt JA ¢7 h Qulje chose sdudal) 

Shodod WoT 1.0 

_ bit fo 6 hot litle, Ando



2. Gnflck om Fcthadus, ? ® 
) No Mis hb hao found jeu lov Wnty us 

wa Net jo hog rund [ale Wells 

N-2- chtnsd acne moe an a 
cata Bot bh pursue Lani Myre A grvavsly 

vs. 
9] (ge Stakomnct <5 — SP epider fled 

bins Dak boon put cp $17, £ infirmd {, 

fia 

0) Shregses Gali h 1~levtew Cop- vs. 

wr Cope ctuldd uae ld no hos 

o A. fo 4 lod {onl Hands AL SE. 
[ds 52 Alleah, pospenrs ale; lla: 

Apham 

  

    

 



  

WARREN McCLESKEY V. WALTER D. ZANT 

Outline of Oral Argument =-- Supreme Court of the United States 
BS 

  

      

RO 

October 31, 1990 prpmetee T y; 

az e—" soy Wome) & 
= gre 255% 

[las ches Ey ie 
1 —1% Nassh fh) 0) pies 

Aa. Case about: 1. State act Fa Hon it wits idol 
; n éxxs 

A 2. How it cans 2 drs bre we 1 

  

I. INTRODUCTION: 

    
     

  

  

B. Presents Three Legal Issues: 

First, Whether Petitioner Should Be Entitled To 

Yerl, Nacsich dni er Wachan 
AS Se Te Hidden Clain, ne " 

YAVRYA LC hd Tah # {Le aD q oh fs. (4) 

| Nofead (2 v hy mi . La : pred - a MEV. Pet—— 

  i Tr Tare © Leen vray 
Use of to trails ol te Meg izle 

Sécond, Ww ether The State’s 

(6 
Misconduct At Petitioner’s Trial Was Somehow 

  

Harmless” Error That Did Not Contribute to 

i " 
the Jury’s Verdict of Guilty or Its Sentence 

of Death; 

Bind Hues Hup Gustin — (slalbn Cor A 
Third, An Overarching Issue: mo wisnin the” A 

  

Federal system, Ought Normally Svereneis 

Questions. Sn opto 73 Ofc 

2. [Za 5A 2 Phase [Gua atsept 

3 Sul afta i forse 
You 

 



   A heir 
A at AT (749 

       

lc ho OEE Str hao Coneded in 1k Gri, Hl 
2 Didi ude Who codntumed patton s-cond fedond a 0 ot 

Me 1981 : her Ae (su &) aliinr by had, 

| udad a4 2-wak evden, 
Ilia cm 

Fh Fes Ras pple | Pour Yau, eontie 
(b) indeed, 5 

   

  

  

  

  

  

( ave raise e claim 

aptren dit IOS MG Se fat he J 
: hand | 4 pated rm tle owlact J) 

Conds] TE ne © Ho Techs dp ha kin Lise 
JUS Co 

uA fynadeo Zy Tee Re 

Jah [lel 0 3. What is i The District de Hear? Uy it 

w of  fobeardei? Roind rp, | ugg 
that petitioner’s counsel nad suspected a 

} Cw 
. 

E 

Lindam te Massiah violation; 
| 

A 

. 

: flab god ov Those Suspicions, ho i 

Gv ii. #het=tley had included the claim in 7 v 

initial state habeas corpus pleadings; 

I ii. that tmwey LY on a ml ; 

investigation of the claim, including: 

    

  

  

  

  
  

a. A Field investigation to locate 
  

witnessess who might have observed the 

Massiah violation 

by dives hum 
@& fli HL Th 

i 14 he Bnd ok lr gr? 

  

be V 

 



  

2 b. A request for State documents that might 
  

bear on the claim; 

  

Ce direct examination under oath of ( Gels 

informant Offie Evans; and 

d. a deposition of the State Prosecutor, 
  

Russell Parker. 

iii. This four-fold Investigation Revealed 

Nothing of Use: 

Shop dd i rp “ 
® a. The field qT SESEEEIoEtINE Lagyrryinarety 

tl 
vo Bi Hi county Classification 

Thos Qf 
al rT ioeN -- Bobby—FEdwards LUT oo) Been 

    

  

Responsible For all cell assignmentss 

Special —— 
: he remembered nothing abo vans’ cell 

She 

Gut © eusigueghy, or anything suggesting a 

    

" relationship with Atlanta police; 

b. Tee sncumentad ios] 6) flo Chit Turd 3 Wo 

 



  

iv. 

nothing pointing toward Massiah -- [see 

Questions in fnte on page 10 of Pet. 

Br.] 

d. Prosecutor Parker testified: 

#I don’t know of any instance that Offie 

Evans had worked for the Atlanta Police 

Department as an informant prior to his 

overhearing conversations at the Fulton 

County Jail [in McCleskey’s case.] . . 

[J.A. 28] 

Q. ARe you today aware of any understanding 

between any Atlanta police department 

detectives and Offie Evans? 

A. No, sir, I’m not aware of any. . . . 

[{J.A. 20]. 

In com 
E=F5-—Undisputed that at the Conclusion of 

  

hot 
His Investigation, Robert Stroup naa sound ivy, 

either of the two principal items of 

evidence that later established the Massiah 

claim: 

(a) Evans’ 21-page statement to police, or 

 



  

@ (b) Ulysses Worthy, the Fulton County jailor 

who lZ%¥ proved to have overheard the 

police enter into the Massiah agreement 

with informant Evans. 

4. Having heard en RR on the issue of abuse, 

§] overs 
nudge fortsey Found: 

(a) That Stroup’s investigation Had Been 

Reasonably Competent, and 

(b) 

  

        

AL. ——— 

5.( The District Court CONCLUDED, on this Sissons 

(a) That even though Stroup had not CARRIED THE 

Massiah CLAIM FORWARD into federal District 

S 
Court, his failure to beiRg Sthe—Maguinn-olain 

forward into —federal—court had been neither 

(i) a deliberate bypass, nor 

 



  

(ii) inexcusable neglect. 

B. THE COURT OF APPEALS’ TREATMENT 

Guonturnd fi (Gbps am gpm; 
3. The Court Of oe! emule ue 

<elf *cm I 
frat is BUZZFHENG -- sin 

a. It purports to accept the District Court’s 
qu, 

Factfindings but does not. 
_— 

fd vs b. It the District Court has 

) 
nizintercretmd the law on Deliberate 

& Abandonment, and Then Preceeds—te RestateS 

that Law in a Form NEVER SEEN BEFORE, -ore 

  

os /} 

ee Boiss wy 

not to a subjective standard of good 
  

faith 

not to an objective, “reasonable 
  

counsel” standard 

 



  

but to a standard of #strict liability” 
  

@ in the investigation and presentation of 

habeas claims. 

2. On each of these two points, the Court of Appeals 

erred. 

a. In ignoring the allocation of factfinding 

responsibility to the DISTRICT COURT, it 

violated Rule 52. 

b. in framing ITS OWN NEW LEGAL STANDARD for 

ndeliberate oa the Court of Appeals 

| ignored ne S005 tls Cn (8 I] Crrgose. 

s The Allocation of Responsibility Under Rule s2 | 

  

  

Se 
<i       

f / 

  

     

4 / L / 4 

w_ of (the r cord’ th 

  

  

4 

 



  

“aia the have b es 

Le #1 

b. Here, as in Amadeo v. Kemp, the Court of 

finet 
Appeals Usurped the—Preper Role of=pire 

bistrict—Court and Refound the Facts iy sel: 

gf ouproscly dusaguanl oth Todge Fovresten on fine 
< 

i. "=n whether Ulysses Worthy could have My 'w 

been found; I agen lis dio We pes 

   
   

  

/ (ii. <» whether interviewing the police and 

jailor Hamilton would have been useful; 

  

wih ene 
&% the e of Evans’ 2l1-page 

statement. 

[CF. ISSUES IN AMADEO: whether jury list was 

reasonably available, and whether the 

lawyers deliberately bypassed the jury 

issues. IF ANYTHING, McCleskey’s 

record is much stronger =-- we tried.] 

3. Adoption of a New Standard 

10 

 



  

a. ple Congfess -- history of 28 U.s.c.§ 

& 4244, 27 Ab) /and Rale 9(b ~~ 
or 

~~ 

< / or 
ra 

  

   

  

   
céngressignal atteition t& the issue. 

4. A THIRD ERROR OF THE COURT Of APPEALS 

t Ld Signlfiance 8 
a. To overlook the State’s misconduct in 

covering up the evidence of a Massiah 

violation 

4 3. Failure to turn over 21-page statement. 

2. Denials by Parker and police. 

[Mention Evans’ FALSE REPORT to PARKER 

before state habeas deposition.] 

b. Equity should forbid the State to profit by 

its own misconduct 

Ce. This Court should not make a SAFE HARBOR for 

those State Officials whose misconduct has 

@ Ee 

 



  

gone undiscovered through an initial federal 
  

application. 

EQUITY AND THE NEED FOR DETERRENCE OF STATE 

MISCONDUCT combine to insist that -- as in 

Amadeo -- the State not be permitted to 

profit from its own mischief. 

12 

 



  

WARREN McCLESKEY V. WALTER D. ZANT 

Outline of Oral Argument -- Supreme Court of the United States 
October 31, 1990 
  

I. INTRODUCTION: 

A. Case about: 1. State misconduct and 
2. How it came to light 

B. Presents Three Legal Issues: 

First, Whether Petitioner Should Be Entitled To 
Assert The Hidden Claim, Or Whether He Has 
#Abused The Writ:” 

Second, Whether The State’s Exploitation Of The 
Misconduct At Petitioner’s Trial Was Somehow 
#Harmless” Error That Did Not Contribute to 
the Jury’s Verdict of Guilty or Its Sentence 
  

of Death; 

Third, An Overarching Issue: Who, Within the 
Federal System, Ought Normally Answer These 
Questions. 

To Evaluate the Issue of Abuse, It is Useful To Lay Some 
Foundation Concerning the Underlying Claim Itself. 

II. THE DISTRICT COURT =-- Which Heard the Evidence -- Found: 

A. That One or more Atlanta Police Officers Assigned to 
Investigate the Murder of a Fellow Police Officer, 

B. Met At the Fulton County Jail with an Informant -- 
Offie Evans --Previously Known to one of the Officers 

C. Successfully Recruited Evans To begin an Undercover 
Interrogation of Petitioner Warren McCleskey, A Suspect 
in the Shooting, Who Was Being Held in the Fulton 
County Jail 

    

  

D. Arranged to Move Evans From Elsewhere In the Fulton 

County Jail To A Cell Next To McCleskey 
  

E. That Once There, Evans Began An Active and Aggressive 
Campaign To Obtain Relevant Information 

  

  

P. That Armed with this Information, Evans Reported Back 
  

to state Officials, including Some who may not have 
known about the prior agreement with the Police 
Officers 

 



  

G. That the State Prosecutor Later Used Offie Evans as A 

Witness At McCleskey’s Trial, Featuring McCleskey’s 
Ostensible Admission to Evans That He Had Shot Officer 
Schlatt 

  

  

The District Court, Having Found These Facts, Concluded That 
They Established A Violation of Massiah v. United States, 
United States v. Henry, and Other Six Amendment Cases 

  

  

III. THE ISSUE OF ABUSE 

The Issue that has Dominated This Appeal is not the Massiah 
violation Itself, But Whether Petitioner Was At Fault For 
Failing to Uncover Evidence of It Sooner. 

  

  

A, Sanders v. United States and Rule 9(b) indicate that 

the Question Of Abuse is Normally Committed To the 
Discretion of the District Court. 

  

  

1. As the State Has Conceded in its Brief, the 
District Court in this case: 

(a) was WELL AWARE of this Issue and Devoted 
Significant Attention To It During the Second 
Federal Hearing; 

  

(b) indeed, was Initially HIGHLY SKEPTICAL of 
petitioner’s failure to have raised the claim 
earlier. 

  

v3 As it listened to Petitioner’s Answers To Its 

Questions, The District Court Was Won Over.   

3. What Evidence Did The District Court Hear? 

i. that petitioner’s counsel had suspected a 
Massiah violation; 

ii. that they had included the claim in their 
initial state habeas corpus pleadings: 

ii. that they had undertaken a four-part 
investigation of the claim, including: 

  

    

a. A Field investigation to locate 
  

witnessess who might have observed the 
Massiah violation 

 



  

iid. 

iv. 

b. A request for State documents that might 
bear on the claim; 
  

Ce direct examination under oath of 

informant Offie Evans; and 
  

4a. a deposition of the State Prosecutor, 

Russell Parker. 
  

This four-fold Investigation Revealed 
Nothing of Use: 

a. The field investigation led ultimately 
to the Fulton County Classification 
Officer -- Bobby Edwards -- Who Had Been 
Responsible For all cell assignments: 
he remembered nothing about Evans’ cell 
assignment, or anything suggesting a 
relationship with Atlanta police; 

De. No documents 

Ce. Evans was asked a host of questions 
about his cell assignment and his 
relationship with Atlanta police -- 
nothing pointing toward Massiah =-- [see 
Questions in fnte on page 10 of Pet. 
Br. ] 

qa. Prosecutor Parker testified: 

#TI don’t know of any instance that Offie 
Evans had worked for the Atlanta Police 
Department as an informant prior to his 
overhearing conversations at the Fulton 
County Jail [in McCleskey’s case.] . . . 
{T.A. 28] 

Q. ARe you today aware of any understanding 
between any Atlanta police department 
detectives and Offie Evans? 
A. No, sir, I’m not aware of any. . . . 
{7.A. 26]. 

It is Undisputed that at the Conclusion of 
His Investigation, Robert Stroup had found 
neither of the two principal items of 
evidence that later established the Massiah 
claim: 

    

(a) Evans’ 2l1-page statement to police, or 

 



  

faith 

Be 

(b) Ulysses Worthy, the Fulton County jailor 
who later proved to have overheard the 
police enter into the Massiah agreement 
with informant Evans. 

Having heard THIS Evidence on the issue of abuse, 
The District Court Found: 

(a) 

(b) 

That Stroup’s investigation Had Been 
Reasonably Competent, and 

That, even had Stroup directly questioned the 
two Atlanta detectives most involved with 
Evans, he would not have found the evidence 

of a Massiah violation any sooner. 

The District Court CONCLUDED, on this evidence: 

(a) That even though Stroup had not CARRIED THE 
Massiah CLAIM FORWARD into federal District 
Court, his failure to bring the Massiah claim 
forward into federal court had been neither 

(i) a deliberate bypass, nor 

(ii) inexcusable neglect. 

B. THE COURT OF APPEALS’ TREATMENT 

1. The Court Of Appeals’ opinion on the Abuse Issue 
is PUZZLING -- since 

a. 

b. 

It purports to accept the District Court’s 
Factfindings but does not. 

It states that the District Court has 
misinterpreted the law on Deliberate 
Abandonment, and Then Proceeds to Restate 

that Law in a Form NEVER SEEN BEFORE, one 

which would VIRTUALLY END the right to bring 
a successive petition -- one which would hold 
counsel 

  

not to a subjective standard of good 

not to an objective, “reasonable 
  

counsel” standard 

 



  

but to a standard of #strict liability” 
in the investigation and presentation of 
habeas claims. 

  

2. On each of these two points, the Court of Appeals 
erred. 

a. 

[CF. 

In ignoring the allocation of factfinding 
responsibility to the DISTRICT COURT, it 
violated Rule 52. 

  

  

in framing ITS OWN NEW LEGAL STANDARD for 
n#deliberate abandonment, the Court of Appeals 
ignored the role of Congress. 

Allocation of Responsibility Under Rule 52 

Rule 52 Allocates Responsibility for 
Decision-making withing the Federal Judicial 
System. 

i. To the District Courts -- factfinding. 

ii. To the Court of Appeals -- review of 
legal issues . . . sO long as, on any 
reasonable view of the record, the facts 

could have been found as did the 
District Court. 

  

Here, as in Amadeo v. Kemp, the Court of 

Appeals Usurped the Proper Role of the 
District Court and Refound the Facts: 

  

i. on whether Ulysses Worthy could have 
been found; 

ii. on whether interviewing the police and 
jailor Hamilton would have been useful; 

iii. on the value of Evans’ 21-page 
statement. 

ISSUES IN AMADEO: whether jury list was 
reasonably available, and whether the 
lawyers deliberately bypassed the jury 
issues. IF ANYTHING, McCleskey’s 
record is much stronger -- we tried.] 

3. Adoption of a New Standard 

 



  

Up to Congress -- history of 28 U.S.C. § 
2244, § 2244 (b) and Rule 9(b) 

Congress presently considering the scope of 
successive petitions, no lack of 
congressional attention to the issue. 

A THIRD ERROR OF THE COURT Of APPEALS 

ae. To overlook the State’s misconduct in 
covering up the evidence of a Massiah 
violation 

l. Failure to turn over 2l1-page statement. 

2. Denials by Parker and police. 

[Mention Evans’ FALSE REPORT to PARKER 

before state habeas deposition.] 

Equity should forbid the State to profit by 
its own misconduct 

This Court should not make a SAFE HARBOR for 

those State Officials whose misconduct has 
gone undiscovered through an initial federal 
application. 
  

EQUITY AND THE NEED FOR DETERRENCE OF STATE 

MISCONDUCT combine to insist that =-- as in 
Amadeo -- the State not be permitted to 
profit from its own mischief. 

 



NavYk Mest (019) 
  

7 Cie 2 arlene” gfe rms. 
Reduce I occasims on vl 

No pietum. © profes vs. Hammbosc sven — No Pritfom . 
@ dye rach Conch hac] uirlahems , A Just 

gulp MUeu 

Thy did whl nde istmlvgim 

| = Th odoh scbshy a precaduald 
7 ut Le ww ar Spd 

  M1 ~ Aof an ¢ (ndopondod Shits grand iF [le 
| sab hoch. fas 
| — Lod at mmedmay 

Hee fat ts, bon lane th front 
Sts blr iowa. 

EE ~ [IRCocyct mo. 

~g, fo Bont Jus 1 Pruselily i in Bred 
os Soy thao 1& Prods.” Zudpse oz mb 

  

   



utp 

Jos te SHG Gud. 

(Sit) Ths Who 1 Nebo om Massnly jif aro feat ssfpedr 

fo cud | he rls 44 
bo th duo ng 

Ru to Salnl ic a Baty Litton Fat 
Gola By funn Fovveddew anvund. 
Dowt treat eit awa alone as “le toy. 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  
    

  

    Lindh be required [1 prec He clin.



Sndd Ge tot shandd) fe requped fo fuse lium ec — 

| Pst inti iobat py foie b fide ont ot, 
On sl vase it, A Dfedey Vib red. Son 
EE 15 the way tas come dl 

mable | Te clits chants), 

1 oe op fine. eo ng h om (ho SALf pce 
Ahdivp Fowstdined] pins. 

! aM 

oer 

= iy t REE 

tL 

as lt rd 
| Gla Jes He As 9 Ag CONT 

#r anil thei diy nate Bt Bong 
bit dua fon Hoot — trated) People af tha jad 

. Be Rossing fe witiesr— ap of uy te 

Thor to ft Hijiouo tes Titre up wo rg ngs nets.  



| 4 2 anid WRT Bindi, 42, tha 

La fries Cie msds ~ we win on mired apg. 
Me bie ad -~ pixel laws a. fat Bulut yo 

HE lg Ylals Oo dud J 0 

ihn fee corpo 24 swipe, lo owl 
® byplicais oi the usmaloo § clans — nfs ok. 

—= (Chuck « law. 
re oy Aa ty crud lane gol yn rive long 

Wanda |, avon # nt Mili vendo 228, 
y he gla dowdy 2Hgress pu 

Mo conshiwbinal (an — Bh @thre A <= 
a (dw 

me a amr til) dilfewuc, — 

ov not— 1 wld have affelled « Googie 

  

  

  

  

  

   



 



  

JHE MET DOZER) (or 2) 

. fe to vi delilercls bps © (notcusct afc 
Glusshinn, J) pt, N bof mood asd fad. 

SR 

  

a Wy 2 Se? 

Pain Sve 7 Catumerd ae Te : 
i \ = Ag ENT ae 

3. did gu gp tooclarn 7 dos] tat 12 

boil,” 2bambonnad 7 

4. i ths yocod) «3 Hed 4 flat Mdbske, cae 
frail b moet No plba? 

c. EBL Mec, Hedfified os reli citlle 
Ho Si ( ve gn 

+ Rus Sale placals Cf Hi Sans 

AR bol Sl os Adu go 

  

Ee Jolt Tn pl np” 

  
  

  

  

  

  

  

  

§. ¢ refs, tens Cas’ Genob Ly 

i #45) Sly ee 
ef eile doa Mee pecad cupat (le (ll 

(FG Ton that So yt pubicll availed 

9. Wien Uy Upper Wr ly ih hackle grec 

tn lo - 0: ont His oy 2 hrc cil y Yetto fe 

  

  

  

  

    

    

  

il Af had Tc. is avn 

 



  

2. Dvdut om Adele i shade this Contin” 

V3. Way sionddot we df gas & pure sh Lg" 

14, awe ye avel held fut am appellels card pst 

FPmoy seus Subsiitey fadprdices ma Herm 

b. (oak 2 fra Ade for (1005 

 



Nos 

  

1, Tho Sabo Nakao dagoibin melts, late at coho lasts. prffead. ca. 
the blo ads asauley eounad) at brad - 

2. Po syn pod as Coan. 17D lo fH. By. 

3. i we lve Lsclid Ulysess Lt, ? Ko toro 2 lpi] perio 
tb loot for. 

—>d What is a Cutan Jo Uh? Hp boon Pa hierar 7? 

sy (oats liad bud dis vam Ko cuca. Have o 

dfn Spit 1a hic 124] us Secemiol] — 

1 cyldl lave wsvel, Zane? 

bl poly i. Doond is ad 4aitd to ran ada w [quests 
a 

1. Shvirup fried b feats &gLoshin Com poor b fret haloes, 

htossp, nf bs lad Pde fivdiisp hui i 2a prs 
vm. 

oh Shap di duitdaet guuashiny Hes ¢ boviey direct, / 

he did have (anid Fhe af Pict. 
F. Tn) Jeshimng Tg ot 2-83, 20p.872-873,15 Veal 

Ae firs} ra uf hie, efter Convarschor of Maske ir. 
ové 

[o. Nie hak in lo U-p . Shilpa Bam Sup he pollo 
0) Be Urigld ¢ 0) har tho other Or -Ds WTI ln 
put le Nosh M Fim —— Gut a] In- ho freckled ha hedet- 

: La aly Bea Lng (esos 5/13 2 M4 cook. 

Eh tn 
44 2 RA nT sued Ul 

7%, ed Aa) alnX, 

Bly nts 
bs Heom aM cle Jol. 

Bi  



  

Moles 
  

| To bin 4 Tet Tames St, @ atl Lbs reli » te ae; 
oO ald hss skews, 5 © Shiewa dL, & Suman 2 fo ay 

dams onfresnadt wn @) all Showa dt: wv Summenie qd A's sala 

ils Shlewedt. | 'DPY 1A — 62 Wd 
Supt — - in flo abloruatiie =< 740 0 uars i socteia tv 

Bey toy ied | & praluches Sel wikss's Slaten SH 
Arent 2xeuin bon br Hind Lae on Css xan uctin 

9. Je Tarnsiclehasior at Th [6-18 5s exauplosy - ho watssa 
act vend. vi Gssarip lf Ds stewed — aval av orth, — 

  

9. Dante 43h heal dunicy a habeas poceodiip— pecndsy b BoC oe 

Put be Be pus ha fl wig = es 

put in Selilecy copfmenad. (TA 4) 

4 Judy foweslens sttlomad ed Sweossive pd omlar om pp. 66-67 
3 a modo]. 

5. Bua reason wo diduiast @v wands and a cdl wane ¢ Hed Sans 
Jechiel at ech Heh hs vrs Pd in Bu adj tap call S Bright Fra tha 

shedt.! pn ingonsekl veh. 
YH ¢ fareskie Nall — fiak af wht Br hed; isle <t ohet recsmatly 

aphid” cone would laa bed —— ¥ raitis. ele fg Cndewes 

uta discared ———np jnoxcuscll nl]. 

7, Tn United Ou. v. Hamu | fo (feat dllifersle dy Fusshon=el 

nry In eo labm Sweibe SHly shud tods ms ure than 

In — hell ee ¢ Opnst violas, 
8. Tuomif Sud i a "Foil stranded — Hs vf £oxith Gi. Ke ay 

flo Stet ups. 9 Gua 1 aun b Helos “rae gu alte * avdect- 
at foray was poruidhd | mols 25 Ho Godt sum Judgesh 

bout Mo dosineln iy © pr halbess rowdy Chang. Sully, If vas 

Arise cone albp— rit aankis, doamsd §) — fuss § pruenb olan; 
fom. Binge ia Quidco 4 pois. (WE erdadd lis bello is. 
rol Suds Mis condo. 

9. The Sil; prem tha we tty 0.1) i Mss ‘chim’ ta 

wala slughtd) Saud. Ou li Hal cud ghia exislf) ue 
nes st J tse Nid Zbl hoist d gue cadB. Slain wef. (od ge ditt be 

  

dae  



  

— Loont Sade. i Uoxllo stthdacd — it 15 Sp Hondli vi Me 

Yo SIG Doe. JF Gives No cowand Fo Conclamu 
ETE ahuse it Ft Bonet woo peru fled]. — 

ody bb Gah Yuet ut 

— What & Ho cove emduct condomued. fo, tor blbosts 
bypest Sham tpl — 

— faulims ho frp rund, abuse ¢ flats 

~ AaSlalty — 
~  obUguly Lue] burn 

The Pitnict Coat expanded flo Gudipidl Sandee rele 
f veadh endumes had Sladd lease leon 2a tlio 

av 68uTly well en 

b ramet, Logoloct Carve /— 

he fued. Mellott Ih] Fr 

Clio, awd Lon't Supe By 4 Dladuip of alos. 

  

  

  

tr 

ae 

 



  

[opel Shodod - Wistiat, - lndod, 
  

0 peat stu home 
A ial 

 



  

— Pug 
— Hanmbss Siow Too geen 
Ji The Co Whitt 

"Rony 
wim fa Qo hay 

) To DEEN Caud WW Bok hu facts . 
2) To ld, Apress — bo reves ofl ggg Gs Tre 
>) 2 5 Camps — hy clange Hu lope), strand fr % W 

% dt 

& MS & nich (nd) 

 



  

Nod Bb Jus 
(1) Eady ofa dd Ga. bial cond fucbuct on weley Merde, ¢ 

  

ney neanden? | 

(2) Wht is Hy Goya lu Comartig foo [FAUX of Co-4ic 

br ack J) 672 durin q ony. 

19) Way (Bt le Card aud 2 de tn delet: Strdonecit 

tier @ veasoucll inyestiphin Stbazyonty bax 4. ard) politi. 

Looper ~ s 
20d SAnbad - 

0 Deliberate ft 

is “Llibeats” 
ot “nani — no wed b cult a large 

& Howmbss Cyn “or 

g il HB on Lew 
©) Pig Dioske poe 0 ee 

by &4y Bw 
3 a a puis obciie 2 

y 

Kitk 
antl, on Shti 
Reason the Df ihbold Stim  



  

" Delite gto Pamdormat” Levy - 

Note: Bost. 4. /a. Fes Cac. 

x Woo “deliberah” pitt angi ICAL 

¢ Cases Codimuig [\c— Mog lo readily &asible 
2446) obvivnsly welltsm 

£ At last aon J6G hae Widow eidenc. - 
| ( parallel b 110 sdoppete 4indpl. Fo 20-9) 
F Mandy (nustget 

* Bl) Wir a ane hiss a litre, bps est- 

x uee] | 

¥ (pide t wif tacks on ele ~ Shrick=tebsit, 
Dorit Be llins — vm i€ 116 curds Qucoos 

2 Dishif Cond foun donit “delibente® 

  

  

 



  

Hanmltsc Sve © GLa tt 

2 prong. b liz ds - 

— OFse Evans Sictaned tally, 
Ts Ho wo, bie loll 

ue oy e? # 

    

Lamudl [Thus 2. jn Pat — Si [eer 
alee | In bade — fen 

Maw Ilr; Mat | if Pad 
Mitbdey “holga © 

Charge sm Indie Mud yd 6. les 
nt hes herds % 

Hips 
Frias Thu Lo Luang? # deshonmy that MS oclt, Ls 

 



  

    

Cry eolgis — oly fheg0 
5 «ck 

Fane b 
! i Cini iP dir 2 3 

i: es gs / jaf 

” 
* 

ld 

 



  

  

  

wy Thc 4 Tupr tt. 
mb bn Vhgao Srl - A 

on Aptdlsh 
wv Willy HSE in frenpt'c. 

Mo vequamcse 1) am exzar wa (To Soufeutn ay sit We WR 
fis cst Sr FAR. Iter to 

  

oA wipatl (ho death s=ittns Lvs. Shad. age 
Lg wkoktiar, tho State lice proved 
unr tb Mad? ghisnylinstsy 

> wt rbisite Po vodid slticnad. © Gitloyal,. 
(Olupw)3-) 

Crisps frend ¢ wnog ui vocal, festrimany, 

 



  

Pixed_fad « baw   

Js ff flu oF HE/A 
= 5 Rupe 2 nd, ued Leh 

8 Side 00s, Eloy Gta 

 



  

4 fortress Une Woy Onda dl 7 
  

  

No 
On Pwehgahin —( Mérenstd 

AE uN efi wd 

Cpwplo-J 

2 keacle A (Soluce sudo condh) lae lean, 

$B | Gumd (oulmo best) dint um, J ackiy and Sit: 
pigodust, 4 0” ud et pis) TT Aiea 6 
fred (Vis 2A Uislatvn. 

 



      

  

bon Dd Seto Lec ve? 

Pati Li tonight fon - 
lo as 

bh Jn Tomer tehhad ted Op apreed ir gare all rhe 

Pomond- Dadrunitnssg leshipd —4 aoue.d 
(rely W] op Ta 

g Whoa tndl jode nd “9 dod bun Rye ell 
dot au, wy Hdomat © DF Poker shod] 
Souls Ty 

P On = lui > pAT Lg hrdrod] 

nil ahi 

» Wha Maso) lating Shy WZ ranged — 

net AC nda 48 ae alld > Cory wird wb veland 

Wn fn Meet pind. 

2 [or Nida Prmidh wide = Complies ap 1 
Dnseatns Al — Wished, 

*  Dh< fomndl ald Shedowad~- : 
ConhluH frsd G Splt pmsl t 

  

x Diy lamb finkey 

Ex Sh «a kl — Pdr strjpunt 
Gigs Bel) sup all) Lhaged k Sits 

(3. 

Yi Fiduags” — 
(n JA &) a complicated <thgua tp lee g lies wed 

2 JIB 9b = slefpsd od 4 (ine 

G) NB 09-116 - Gasp Wplly ores Uso 
yw femdd 4 Wn}



Hore 4, Techumial Abts ~ Neuf. 

  

  

  

Mass) r= % 

% Nytawed, hvieJesl or — 
2 os <h: Lad ims fo recoutl Alsi 

  

 



  

(A ih Luly Poco This Cane” 

D Plenty Lub 52 find; 
2) By far Bb 2 dg based on 8 

wm de ymscondud] yy nding tho gosis the cl ein. 
Smith v. Mamay 

Metra. Canwiae ~ “Ula fiun Aro pr<ma Com <mme 
  

> Slyechee ach Otlevved Hla defouse tmpedod Comsdls 

= Got 4 compl [vale fe Gad < padund ng] --- 
"£m Aten feronce Cy of pial Made Conspliuet 

imprachcalio Y 

Rech v. boty ~ lla itine. §) comme) 
c— 
  

 



  

2) 
~ Tuy nwa razed (lava - A hel suse belle. pga fi ro 

dolileets ettmtrimed nfs fan us dblbact AR o BGA ©) anseunod § 1 
= md chant adn flo Wo so jury Shane’ armas rude 

— Fvnadeo ages 13 b hold flat SED daaphon x Mertens 

\S (Une — 
= [ it really infos 

EEE bypass, or vn Mis cae, 

      

    

  
  

I hao 2 pak— if Db(Hs x 
ri hin TE it 

Hh toon fad Ji (4 { Appedd- Sty #. Bl. 5 

Bugis Mn pot 4 

Gat os. inetasak@ nog2d 

Spr iw. doled slpmdmest 

S 5 cobellior- Rel Tg, 

Pull fs 1 pune Mm tl = 
  

  

  

  

ETI eh PgR 

 



  

Nittimo — Lib 52 

A Nive Naw aro (3 flor mss: views 4 [lo dvds Ho font 

tole beh thou come] be land, orvews” Proc uv. 
4b 4 BC bu Us.d 54 Ta 

“1 the Shik wd Guat fo ouidente it Law Bh in 
to redo vicued in fo feck, a 

  

Mere Oudm flesuyW Confined (hol bod if Leen, sth as (Ge 
ea I) pd, iF und hase Goigusd fa Qudina Sifeially. 
AL 5713-51¢ Si 

 



  

  

      

    

 



  

0. Tack — that S did; ass Uboln & adage 

I. The Shtrs buef hi with, hind 
ue v. Jolms on 2. Nobo Hut tho huge ciicas Judie 7 

ald lak Cuan b ye L Hie fon lune by sso the 

lain csp rntibge 4 Noo och, Cam bo ecuced. 

3. tet Brion ~ pre 19-0) kin bref « hat to C epTest™ 

SAT baaed fc procodual] ella — Got the aad fou finaly of 

   
   

   

~ Jadymaal3., 

Bd vi Git fy read fet Go pu § Fr vpesles in (of). hetao— 

Jaty Losi ee I 
be an — lo duct ing 4a, op. 

A Vad hed esto jf ict Hold suid tua Exess camae bain, 
Landed gb Tl ple oat he lod Gand, otz. 

(0. H qm wat Deputy Hamill a FR thal he Gad 

oy fi prio fo Judy ((E — & Meat Mee yiersm ales augit 

yw wn Mo Clicb' cabo Ofc Bilt, Zlua do. 

fa ads well bole dnd Sho 

lh Vety foram Le old (ast fre fo bo indopeudoitly! 

7: Mak fo Vind Jenos lat fr Bich Cnt dh — presse 
flip 2 Sing on abe, Ove dove — IE sua. 

> fri reste reves hog ~ Male Her 5 cap abot judria] 
Admungiation — nol Puli sz, 

5, Handa doseides ta Judy 128 medias i “a rz daca 

he i pl ws sod 4 9. he 1918 WS Sahay pe Lurenp shoyed om Lwe 29 (5). 

= 5 (2. Heb. oh of Rls 2. : 

Po. 29 Dove, —b Quen aya, 

dnl indivecky b prompt bron Fi a La fran UZlos 

EA Dosey nd Hei, Loli Hr allpd by fussed arta. paced 

allen i tno Su ub compas — & Uo 4d he ddu-gd 
Cooly Yo 

> 1. a bd Gil ar i] i 
23. os Wil, M 

Nn. f f. rie Jury hc in i  



  

ay pled op by pollo an. 4/8, cdo Taruse BUA prdion by Sevens 
ofr phn 
Git uss, aus, Aang inditve3- Get XK sdlitand. wihes 

puns on Yl. 
2% Jam Torna in nat he dd Taxis ints ann apearmact ot 

Vo poset | word) Guo Tuma cop, 4] Ha Witpas 

hd i Sg the titirss &; 7. fil lo 
thar pro lf Pl Bist ly tat Porky. & tpt Ilona 

ast No ached) Flows. £7 pupenn J) Oosc- eammeion (f 

(SN) [LOA filo Euans wholtuy he ug. asted hr sowe as am 

ANlpmodan My’ ter. Ho sls thot Edin to pad fy Reiky om 
lashing 0 bh + amdlon Russ Pally cme — Padus 

Lo On oy dpdaicd 87 TPS, J weedy that ol Shug 
Habe Ke had Safi  Detehie Brey dump Sit hes 

va pceding withnd sweet 

I Mo Licking back 00 3alenads — on PS b dart. 

CoM DOV, anes 
I LI 3-5 fic 1 63 Tams docs on 

jut Unidoubli prot wpe rr 
[} 

26. domflick hotuweon Palen rs Dap ) af ko Lelat porsoubar 
Ruvisie le, 1 Poros stain Cui Hob, fd Frodon badd calls, im 

in 5 3 hat. hocasipt ack iu abonct Gaus” Sid 

A tak haa sonaltie wlll vey (od (put 16 Gre — the 
Unser, Hho Boorick Rdg apt bo it ~the ! cpa it wo. 

| That's the J0b Nols assed to Brdveyf Juolp.. ards AleS?. 
IbH (ust some teduuod Weve ican Fahd) . Ysa. 
llpcabin § vsponily Bo Re elon syd 

wp if ep wilh the huss, Lo foes bade 2s 
bn, dicks — ha domoassr, Ho Loabeha, 4 Io wie. 

[ha FRC, 

2. 

  

  

  

3, 

 



  

vk EEL a a dnt ave Lita C 2 
: ¥ rw dds lit =f ply 5 

He hee a leflan chong pint: 
on 

 folons Dorsey ~ flo sks hala, bk 4g. 

Vids om ~ 

all Lotion on fori] bud silver ges. d stead 

tigen 1p] anlivy 77 abo” vise trey emo. Dols 17-2 
25 volte Who came m1 frm lo bird. Hakan deo 
bf ohon 2 had, on aa Juin Occasinr. 
im Tors wd fam ord had] 5i ls prstl. DA 

TW bom raf 4 a pay “buggy. Sho cledut id (14 
Bt prsbin hes — (nda, Shy fled af sin & ud. iF msi huss 

Sho tid Go bend 4unshsk pom the (ct, 
ar ¢ nut shih. 

wer My) — Ball dun 1m od fo fui =a pomk - hand lodgm 

Mow who cue it flo foul had — 4 
am - A alt S 

Dusk trucos, (omy slams Silk 0) broumen. ld shor 

Os ALL - Dawe Salosman ~ SAS Cond (instgs Gack Adis “oh 

0: Chrowe gum — a big lume gua — § Swe, 

  

  

  

  

Jou - liked og We tosly om flay 22. 
Mss Sl Shlwait — Sot nora, vod B fit, sun off 
hd wid, bed, Aoand coh Pom (he beok 

Enilige, Su NE ostty, Was Co ing Wf gun — Moy have bed c 

pei, 

lo 680 bosiy- Mo chive on fig policomsn. dus cw — on ta Loft, 

bys Sp fet from the clo  



  

I Lesay Sain bo so camygs bandied pond lu a lad tnd. 
Ih Clesy lpg dro 20a Pont Weight ail Sills elusomo flit 
Nouole 

p LE Towser ¢ (hoy Pwieled Mtlsglon p Duin Bias, bout Re 
” | Same fue on Ser ho 

#1 ~ ss Mws 1poRen A. Joy "Kopf it wader hain hf: 

pL Hid om Mwy Jenks 4 Bork Bo, went puble fond. 

Topas Gos ads Wi ha, D1Chly eid, Tose ry 
pit mw = pdyprla indd hase 6 in.” 

UE). edly sid. Vow com tpt Mot no, Jaa, vp find. 
On tho flo uwdn Seo. 

st Tnwtns — Gu) 1 unos al Tle fons hide amis 
Pityy Tolls - in busied 35; Boma 4 bo sled. 22; 
  

[30m Wank - Wim n 36 ) Dupes ’ 25) Burnsy « 38 gnu nese. 
  

= Whig, ha Lon 

Na clr ~ inf) (UL 4 (ise Couey inf [od bad 4 (9 thant 

sum. Tr. 5S 

| ot Th wt ola tl [ Me pore § fud ot Ho Milita mecca 8 

ee ahs ma td [Me Llatey pocondly 

AL Quad the calle ff th tid — 1p Bits vewks dtuonplie LiL) 

 



  

(ite boswt ied Pcsily Arm Ha baginnep —lcsant i Hast, 
i Kony 10 ind aot when Fed pramn [ Jim wl forbi, cul away Af 

infoymaad nul. 
  

Ness ue. atl Bs of 4-pocnn,(ulhicy 6. Gos o. bl. Tl — 
| po 10 cushy a a pliv. Hes a umeptitin tips 

Mat in Cuslods, 

4. an tambo ator print — US. Hore, ( amdtra. umata, fad 

a wipsssin — (nd st HE b une $ Nidues.) 

uj. 4 Pare digas 

  

  

Massialn Tien Mad iz [Colman 

ouis | Owgsmuglosy  Bonkiobley Guo he) Mundo 

  
  

    
      
  

  

          

  

| | PW), Sy | Oubdfuend | ud | prlusss 3 

sunveilloeg die tapuitl Pax | bug Can : 

na : dnt qy chim 

| ] | GE cl RO 
Of {Owked | 
Pehcipabin 

Sted Yop NA Salou | ou 
fats, (n Sp 5 crab ged VE i 34 £7. pas i lat - 

fia cpasisdi fo nt vies Jo) ¢ Sety cam hae 
Many wads rad 4 litle P st 

  

   



  

. y/ we od fGgt Magia, asim ix — wed fe a uo Sucascive hittin 
wd have B shad "eded] poise? 8 Pihlran 4 bogus S—gackd 

[ Nhotencr. 

  

Mawes v Clie — Miaudas_custly + coven Mt 
OIC fpr wistiscon opt bh 4.8 Justis + dlp. 
Din cusledy Vs Momd ¢ 
QA Wai. 

Me 6% Mat Sue aud Me, tues no craps (red ban fod 

péusg fans. 
52. Leolt baud ot felleisn vo Jus HTUc2%5 (993) 

(Sfuls — Shrdaia. Bor arnt obalen C Emil sts — 

Samy as 5% pdf — Mivzsda Wa rai, auang.. ; 

Cults Suwd- |, 4 haa didut insole bin UKs olin wen asd 4 

thou Juoshwad.) : 

A did acento a witon badse, fle arivgn — Lurch. 

gl, Rally mil v. Win by ue 

5 is Vo rd (icrmalon 022 0s rly Miowoheedd, fmol, (nf 
Ys we LA oT th Quoshn = i 
2 Cogs dort lile it fon tan. cheng 

Catiao fr procestusnel. dofruntt wrll  aotamaidy un on, ottes 
tw isin, O44 dung ful cong 6 bje Awe 2k oplorual hb Re ddefeene 

impedod cele os by cougly wilh tro Sn} proxadied ids ! 
Maroy v.Gavne | ¥T70.5. YI HE (159). 

Qeshla, - ineduoicce . Undone crmaed B) lost tet cui 
ic dolslecats yi fhe soo of li. (xd fit — fos “nuasiip 7 

Lum t Supe. 

ss A Jed i Sticke] v. lleclunrton 

  

  

  

  

  

  

" Thors oe Corunllose Bb pids effechin Se 
PU ETI Ovi, Hoe vz dd put 
efor A a poahiedan of oF an ho sana ui,” 

 



  

  

Mixed tad law 

O Mospr v eds (197) (pn Cunzan) 
—Culfrd/Gudly 5) muda i la. «1972. 

Dero mm habee- — tS20 Ef] to Shovel brid wu (572. 

Momwsg) tia) ~ comel) mrgval fr uation ~ <form [or 
inion ie Wf local pychabist. Welf-ovietsd vu bo 2 pies, boil ui 

noid dedusims, 

BG docod velig); ST Gi veyersd¢ clined ant bid. 
fpuasnlly pected hel Sts Cat dodeuminon congetiy ume nt 
“Gly Sufpnted by fe econ, ’ 0 hin, Suma v. Mah. 

2 per cup, by hd Jods. Ho wto Griendid hwo d<pac; yon 

Pliny £ Gora of Cad ts dolly ic bie). 

he lowers Judqusd Yor covgloves, Ra Mixed 

Quoshn A) laws & (ed. May be reviewed wave indgpondo tl 
M decid such qUoshmng, lhe fedora coud nes) Go d feet 

encasim tn lip I Lopd chaudod Summa v. 

Mik | #5505. <0, i 

® Milnv. Fd - 4740.5. 10% (98) - 
I¢ Uumbn ino=¢ & fees im a mixed Quoshe 3) Qu £ fat, 

Or & Gusshm I pd’ Tie udbinado seu a dbs Sa 
i$4 UL Ngquiniy ft de lenvncten. 

  

( 50) Rk alms a Ler ihn. sph te Shondeds 4) Trumaend 

$n} Cores Hum pppoe)  



  

1. Tho peste 4) til), Tn Tannoy petled fuscesl) nti sub « room € aslad 
"Wit vas i hat or pucts app licatn” Ad bio rseves cas, Im nat 

ne ho EY You. IH yon, 11 credit de oy prilp, 

(22 [erm sayy “J was hw fren dtm indication Hal Sactia 

hlansad outa. 
13 Dont led Hom D Ko proseadnn We've not sup Mott ibe 

pret: une maloaluit- — rly fal ce mado = rexcovb4 

 



       

To Po - NEtluctoy Ogpayshs. 6 
  

  

Geta vead Qodedhon  Shiddacd ©, Uedoogh 
aT-su 1. Do read J buiefs ln Oil 

  

  

    

    

  

  

    
  

    

  

  

  

Tugs Pas on Quswe- KR. 

ee £ Povezd cod) J) Rood Habeas 
3 0 ’ Shs Halvas 

Adgony 4 on! 

Tes 4 dil confinuir vib lik 

oo s Succoge pattem law) 
con Drecend includ, billed Copoce 

past — Commun (g) 
Cre (a 

stabs, 

aslo his 
i 4 Hrmliss awry Sond s, Moy 

wena M 7 Ca) 

Lose. Clark : el > 

Stlercdide © || |. Tdoutiby — 
- 0 op 10 ussbims 

SM. 7. Noort am 0c taproot ve Loop Epa diSels 

Sef — 

Ew fo Ds 
(lotr i= 
Tha ~SttsbeTre floes Tic] 
fi.—  Casos —| Herrmbsos—Lyre ye I(t Dros 

| fret mn |= . 

Cat, Toe 
Kea (a=) 

Sum. Pradice Raspes) Rous Eom 
Dov. [Ay ~ Mat 4 Lapis 2s SE. 

Toss. Visit Cad | Fuad up. — WV : 

ig Ed onl Pry by) hop Jt Ri a 
olebadk Briefs



  

fads of Grime 
  

; (e322) 
J Haw into did 8 fre Cua, fectly in fic can, — ECs ~Rupro? Bung,” 
1. pig i is Lin Ce ? ER, ip 

Cane slicks 3 Inddpoudtty ) Magy ir did! sone) ths oly asters Guy that 
Queer nl. amid Fy pretel 7 Uh? 38 lose 7 4 
Tid 4 Hog inte Shak wee bred? bho wns Fomk iatf-tt 

5 Rat Molo ict tit ho cane bo tho Bord ff Hea stove 2 
ag hidisp 2s co Selltt cams pad Moy” Jesu t ud bor 

Appia b ple? Lye H34s7 
GiRbd Gfeol. But Pe admit Caving 4, tho Aonldeey” Ordut a whe 

Gi Dau W[® a] Lthosua ft by No Pi door camied Hosilugpe > © 
Ind. IR 9 ud due te hick mn ibe ta Aw. “Yh To co ndetter hdd coven 

S Hewiy sink lao in be lik § Me Set, Ko Cotitinn 0tyin Bond.” (Log 65) Tar £2 
Bn dsj QU 3 Coivdidth fim od to ak. TorF7 bam boy amived 1 He can, 

(hi dydin Jali Hot fo hed shit tho polis ohio. (T- 658-55) Tor F 2 

| sdnt lassie Bmw] say sto aw alter coma iin frond olla 

S$ ZT TL 263) Raat Manze Thomas sey Ho Sse | 

(TT,. 26901) food boedted sb Gam tp. 78) 
Or ustie Lisunst] Gd She tecmmizel 1oo yan form bess Ws Str 

phy aul, & ART do in Wo Gn dire. £2) 
v Times — MC) ve OW como Gn Crk. 2H5-%. 

& 

Chis buona Gy arnple, alld 2lpd 2 be me Him 
| el) in how can — ot “ania lo gy odo (ogT 

Fshens alpnt- diag He tons Ls Rensith (4% (re) 

 



    

fack & Invesco 
  

Why iat ou Coit bo asoit tho Missy cain or mun iit) eds 
idm Wow! 11 san Het thors was fala wp. db bedomo 7 

2 (bat poss te onaute R thao Av Net falls wit Ho jnoccpyetop ofr” 

Goon if) Moy had not revealid Hoo Cito | puseaih Vinlater, cvmddt 
Hoy ot fast have wevecdsd debi shout elo Give ws hint Miewibual’ 

3 Wad wrote Geog las) veqposhng dcelosun A witwose slafewaats > Did 

tha. Supoucn Cun Judge violate hod lw” nat, boked’s yn Geof 7 
4 Gant lo 0d) Cad GiaTod 1 tum prea leo Blas shkemot nly if’ 

it cntainod Bedy mati ia? And it Supslly hast Netlusisp Pxedpalny b Mh 
5. Whal iF auytiup bd Notre judy do wonp duns fo llega al 

Tint Mpouslic 16=19] 
¢. Bit Tl Turns adut tat ba bnao ke badlit gt Neo Couples 

Pogecitans plo —he tugs bo didut gt 2 Heats — Rauck Fay wi, ¢ 
Mo sof shew ? 

0 Did? Luscedd ali Net Me. Soup (at TA. 25-2) phat. 
Jrs, Hovis & C.K. Hunton poag in odoed i chvelipiap tle fest 
q J SAMS | Why di dat yeu dor vic Hom? Puauip {1h 

had Hose ray foods, why dldityou Cavtinug tha Nasal) cle 

17 Pow hates? 

¢. Didnd leel Puta tll Bob Srp diveckty Had “Offic Sonus 
Jue hs Sdenasdt. .. dat # was nat inbradiged <t fa tid... 
IH wis psd) fle Milly that ans made M cmue inguin” 
tow) tnuch wave ditty 4 clo endl he hana seid of? 

9. Why didnt” Yu Shoup ask Hal” Shlonsd 7 Gru nana 44, 

did yeu? Did cua ib pap & JLo cbpesi tim aud asl fy 
tho q beforsel b thas 7 

lo, The Dawid Gly promod k aonplith copy §) Ho frocctn's 
AL. FE Ut Tet Tova Said at Baka WE (Th 24) 

—
 

fla ono ha fling Tal went Jhcliclod i, Ho £1, 
i Ha) Nes us wosss ded Shay infernes thie ties S:/ 
7... Nay lute In hz affdoit His) at ns fue Jung ho 

habecs did be Lown of @ trtien Stews fy Offic Zins — 
haw wgwskd it hed it como b he atleast (TA 33), But d 
did Come b he alleachon, Lido 3. af bai he ust passed (F, didt 77



  

B. Yok ts bog Lo cade Act wen btn used — prior § Mapper ~b obi acs 4 
wind, pls” Abe dd us ope 4 6 fd’ 

My wt (elituo Mr. Sg ctidpuach Theta nae, talizal Koons co gunithe 

Salemp! (1.0.38) 
5 Did gon Chand file Runa conc i you tet an inFormaud” relation 

“ wan) nol Ge SUnpricing"” ww (TA 44) Cuty din 4-1 Quy Strougm? 

to. Shop ndiclad on is bead Ketiman CF 4K) Hod he cos iecached 

m “how dan Come b bess, puad fue coll naa MCh” ded? 

Ju puss Boul sped bolt (hoy hae Yherm aretha ko 
23%) ‘ 

7 Why oid Sp hay fro ftacsily lawn” (Th 55). 
€. Lolcat Th SC -59 — Soup dunk he save pac b Haris ov Dos, 2 

pst hb Naaniltm. 
[9 Doesnt fo Sats ad the pin! dum — Bol, Zaue & Beton pon kdb 

Ditwhss Nims, Troon , t borseg — yet Soup ahoamdnadl fle clas 
wilhad over chockiia With Hom. 

ont Wyse Gilly Cp flr a Udon? Woe be 52 bad b 60d” He 
Ost just ony dbo julor” 

A 9 Moone ary Jjpace btimem the Dist. bt. hldniy rit Ho Stats did rdf 
once i n bubiy. RR Aout vercise de 

dilisgue in wT cops? Js pitility am svasenst py 
% stink ont Heat bout Did. ct. luatd apmat ho uilire 
hin police: 

tC — Ap erovs Wado Iv fo Ged eh. 

What Bes ded t dis oe (2 125) ok : 

22. Jent Ho (ud § Appeal, nghd ul How 5 no shourip Naf add ( 

vy, Rrst Ct says Satp bas mado uy Shain why MS dbste dnc] 

bos Lin 1 iulguiad Wovtuy (T*25) a dey Saye hetlosta, 

8 puseulad Up Wor yon boty walle fo enibidt (nfl, Does 

bo Guid § Popa hase ho Dd pasty (TT) wits ee 
(svadin / pry Z27 

x5. Hid Shp lauast Ho "couple proseache <b wu fe Cone a 

oh Deo Oe. Hang ig A fol tle 2Epre Glens Worlly t gp-2, wv fied 
(5235 te Toby 12 meaty cov. Gills: ofr. Ye Gly =o nid haveget Io 

     



tac 4 tlio Couns 
  

  

1. Ud Unf sid Loan, pao Moved — if rug i tet ough br 4 Mesci 
de Je a quoi Pet bo izlen? Pied Wye Wertlly, 2uet 0 tonlloy — 

Clim Watt Hoo Delechive, acad Evan bh ivvhok Tuschorwp? 
[See TD - Samo wo asked hosit seme infoimation rm cla, 

oi X to Sits ight Hot Yo file. turned yuan b Sng ly Dumich woe "Hos A Wes 

vias veady cwmlalde lack at pu-tisl aud died 2 (Co St Br. 7 Fuckin Oped 5) 

[Lott ct F081 ~ Joy indie but § lie te rssh, uri, 
IT aoed 4 big spicy | 

 



  

  

f roced ind) Hilo 

1 hal coco te Rady Yom raised nos; ape]? DA land bom.” 
2, a te Gut, have gud tho Sly + lade GoCt) neotean? 

Wadd aS hase Mado au ipo difaca a Meo T1tions hoce? 
3. HQ 0. to chun d 1 Clty ibaoclinony retin fox « nas ral aff 
inet sapped? 

4. On oon dd ta TG helty Copus Aremic Medak, suceesip pln? 
Js thou ¢, proacdund pl” 

S, bo Ggse vin you, Mi. Bogen laddnt we vomed Hos ceo b 

(r 4) Apes 1 msde, whole, a Musial Vislihon hao beou 

proves” (Se Th 13). 

¢. he" dlileat, shadmmed’ 2 “Maceusable ngfloct “fuostins of 
Jad lack, or ana toy whied_ 4 peste ? 

 



  

Myssizh 
  

“ 

7. nt toe Staty S27 Sed Vad f insite price infomein? 
pat id Grae dh — om the recs) — Bo patticll, 
vain? [ 573. i bande hdt=NTL ols 2o-Ds hed 
oA police tat Eo baht om the bri sermon. | 

2. Opesiit the Dist. A. hinge Leng fing [) He hinting (ho Mave. Flos co the 

Ofer olopmgats lie inflexied Fora th? 
2. Desnt (te Brind Cod rest fay foo munch an eulduca tht tha Ems 

Sheet pravos ‘om gh uhy velaasiiy wal poli’ " Dees Ho Gadus 
Sopp Hinveadiog”” 

f los rt pan prone fle pecire [Renn do seaded] ui. Kuhlman v. 

Wir. Dat lf. frvad. prociateb fo conbrany (JI 4.8753) 
1@ Cans’ Ar Linfirms Ha. | 

L. sthaddud toe srernda Mesily ARP: devo So in the Fh awal- 

hots Content in Hiv v. 1rlbns td) 4 

6. Dw to Ost Cac vmalte a pi uss hs J) ptt b ready ik 
Massish comdus ams? g se, Ldn EEE tor ord Tom 

I. kul Awws awae od — Yau Pp pussusl Neo ciel dlrenimschin 

claim | 2 ¢ oly Whom iA Aird po, tun db nd vbud srier? 

£. Under He SELLS Voir, ae lo Wolo Srp, aloif He Jed, (2% 

rbaclich 2 bins Up Ma, vo pre; Uosty ~pesn?). 
gq. Evass ran pissy bam oan. info vad he Od Bree, | a nel? Sut 

suigpds lo hdl ben( at Dat, B + wihoss.) 
lo. (Nast it Pom Se wl asked Wat have Ofte Emr” A 

Gidutt It cpu Afr. a Folly 12% tavtrsy ik Dh funn” 
I. Qidit tua Bind Crust sil maki op to nshar Nei Ole bins had] 

n nt] el (rn Hh iy wor lun Oy Pe pfic. ” 

(2. Cousdsa fhe conboay haus 4 Ly c Che — 

fad 5 po, G. Sh No nny wlobe lolly tat? Jsut Fa 
wid ® 

3. Em Lind fst be hod Lied fo 
Uuovon WE costly 7 52, Acts He spoerd Jel abn cc 
fo Tew documed = tag Cllr Shovel 

  

  

  

  

Boeont [+ judt covprim eConel Aid art 3 prodl 
Lun 

 



  

4. Dont lho Sify = Ym kage ns idsute. gm load $0 price oll have 
; LA Yam — ecanse vpn. woven ashid, 

/5,  Mageraby Juin 12k Wyss 1 Yd vepdicli 

WM a6 a Wks — So does He Slo. ER 5 £0 
Cad’ find — on 1s vecod so & uk. hoy effoneso, 

b: Doesn't Two Stes bri) have dono v. Cy J] Bossomunn Gly sit 7 

  

  

Wasut Willy "so internally jycsusisind on it in lass SiH 

odds folds it yy pd id 

n. How can Tudpe Awests resslue to Maced Clovis an Pract 
hosp Ore Evens? Why ent-Fau evan fo clay Ale & 4) 
velizf 27 

 



  

Sucexsive Eoin law 
  

h 0 gon clan tat petit ua endd wast on’ ods. A jushe” test how? 

Und Snail y Muay 7 Undo, Bugger v Qdasws? odin cmt Digs 

2. deta a “alpalie a 4 imscgue “hae? J) utd? Wiloch, < 

lasly pty mud Int At but ony Madar? 

ART Debt Cus die 4 os m pag §€ 4) TA 
covecl ? J it & “roa, cho ype los. 7 

4. J A ule caucd doce infers a critical wits ( (46 te 
polio ) int td omg in jketd f Shans InKaually Vale d - lrrespochie 

wholls, He tnterviecss wendd le wade 4 Atledua” 
Cds" inexcu ald wgfret a pop hifache redo 7? 

b. Wet te Dict Crud ight — "Sh Pet Mead, valuho “dsl” 

te Jo Massidy ¢Lasom orgrually Vaid in bu prst S12 patton’ J 

). Brecnt Codd J Fppoads itl that umasarenss d) facial frotodf 

Aim 3 # ouesy,  § jush hy mile 4 peat ta aim’ 

Jan't ashandad bauseld M Desudy ech ur Orotlechs err. 

f. gl Melt 4 Diet Chotcs Pot  ledotle Mags ialy laa 

  

  

  

fnibal Lolo) pot 

Adenia SL he A estan tovy efits roe wm succea/rf 

pn on ade ni Etat 

Ho lbw 7 

b. Loumsel | dont Gow Groot Praggenalg tno Cnt trl gu 2s 

Heo Sd 4 a, « (6— SBP Con 22 

1. Slew gpl Lop, Saudi Hd direct hes 
“de lbesdo abdmmoct' hb Fo Tohuse u. abst Sbrudond. 
Buss, W's nol Ho reo | 

12 Co yuu dak Oat fo Batic Gudi fambuiys on fc 
ua counsels inves; + tho gecose ii Wa 

pet 770s SR OV La Jct 1 A 

mip {$i eH my 

  

  

8. i fo § in neh 3m gr Ir are a Le a mi Le nin 
q boshns 4 (ad. 2 

 



  

Or Couns) swt uk aoe cyersited = te coflan 
A Counsel a sh Tho Magsly Sha 
a : affv wetivell, Supporsed andacce cud (red in 

am offoit to Wide fain Wiscanducd. (Pd Sz. 9-55). Who fd 7 
hos 

fs? huge yan diced! ak Ha? 
P. 77 maxim * M (fa. br. %) /< fala lly of pid 

isnt of ° 

J. Odwt Sug adewslicly o. cons Cus theis Gr b ap Ho Massa olain” 

(ay 16] #ld doliots Bhudonsmss? 
22. Hawi we wplaced a dolled sbamdmucd dandand tn must oft 

CORE wilh a Coun & prajudies” Fmdard” oly chadlat-or dss low” 
= 90 Qu iF Mah fox Tb tse Mola shite habs ¢ thon Seda? 

%. Pidnt loss in Ley He) Swplsy inet Neo ands ahting of de ih” 
find go a telus 8 Mardely bo Ho lbs lel ap gd 7 

| Sho sledor poi is prope md 7 
2%. hal iy sei. IT) a 5 

ppetly a Compress 7 Prost it Skavo hal taps fan ase Lacie 

Supe Gov Succeccit fa patel dom sau Javan?” 
n.. &) op Tad To cedibs a fe Fu toe” 
2%. 4 we fost Gndaxs chliterdde byes shrdad ra Seva bllass | 

Aime vi Qovkst ds You loge 7 (Wy wel? 

2. Lh, didnt bom pst cay tie Massisdy lian ito fedoad count. 
Np endwme/ & ono crac Sv [ tnthiy Fle bom 3) 

Jo. dy ru debingeush Bolan -7 wlisboan TT \omas 4 fle pessinll 

oii) 4 th or he beltoed Who laisy, ted or marilovione. ” 
St. ér, 23). [ule not Glan fr & Swbjoctie Shincloud. 

3. oo Te SI, Nighh — ov ypu Asgeivp Br @ Subjective Stchud d) 
"Jost" in oda 6%: do with "cle, Geely Sadun 

27. Dont it paccuudh BH State Wat too lit Appecds bund bat Be 

Duin Goat bad usd Ue Ling fod strdad, 2 Mus sot 7 foffonlie 
agile. Is Mel evn” 

  

  

  

2% abuse f] Mo wit 3, mitch Guo J bu 3 f20) or = quostn § yy 

K finch 6] [4d] : « 

34 I: He 405m wl atbar Camsd)'s Inginy b2 reasmdrl “x bute k 

 



  

(og Juostom Js fhe ATL ole frrkbioy [1quiny werd 

howe (ocalad « upbrose frobal o 

%. Od Ho Bripick Cat reall say ltt Git Lic om p. ZY ie fois” 
(nd did it Fiod, TT Pras ) $B Ofic Cuan’ Shlenact 7 (£49) (RT) 

2. lp diduT naw whoo b (ol Hravideace 8) am informant relat ith 

"ie (oly st Meoce prsons wth Aoal lad contacts Tie e Sues. 

Dow, Havrs, Homa. 

31. Wasnt te comma lao nda fomifip SucCcossurt pins eLeselly 

[ied to Hho limited porpasas § tuo anit 2 Lost F a toll defforg writ” 
%.  Puwont fx pute Guldy cut Ar te Sul 7 Dot mat gocup Cans & it” 

he, oo buds" LaclnfPrigdet have (eos proceuded 
2 = wnt 4ccopouce pes den freliar 

celui agin fob Lote) Wiad se A ~1 efor 

pig 
4, Waldo you male df the ligase §) Pre Hat” Ha privacy punpos 

halts 1 to ull contain tata mia ic t= va she jprs mal] 

dl. Int Smdins puro dicta on Sed] petits of haw Lasiae” Hino 
Cam. #t le bindn binduiy procedout’ 

fa. Jon't dios hilt — the considaiatne Cu pocadund0d fo It ¢ seca] 

[2m Ch cums tore idabeal — Samo idlaasls 

B. Kan slaadd we (alana toe niassts woke §) ua sttesmed the ial, 
Sty —hawiup larin laid Aste 5 A, in banning Sani head at ad. 

4, Wels way OE OE Say feo baton J cotad Hy, 
naan he belay iu nic rmuding 

45. WHat des $2240) —" doliberatly rithnlatd fis oes, agald geod or 
ofuse adrvae d Wo wsit'— yuan, ? Byesn't it shay Vat doll. abandoait 

  

  

is tly me ff sovend ode § ale? 
4. SL dpentt Bb TI Lekio hishre, reflocta 

bed bo Cano: (p)- cae 
a fas PE ny Loglaboe ph ‘ahd bo wal!” 

¥ 2 woe pif if lave Savas a cba 

in las oot ucts (oA 1 Es ) (han if pre Rind. 
Ro Ham pears Poors cas as fach 2b Soppot 

 



  

Honma Evy 

1, Uneds, Ocogic lass, Lindl Bow Writ Hestimncy hase beau adiusshb 

a. 

2 

4. 

on tho Muds 30 alias Summ’ Covrabonahim - (Cor TAH — 
Fonestar dowto t — OCEA § 24-4 R)(vmcarolmaTsd fectiuncy of am 

acomplia tat sulbtioat fy sotadrtok a fod) ( Budzes MC y. K 753 F 2Jatee<) 
(Nst nocsany 4x tomate. b ited 1 hy 0 bo!) 
Whats te Srrdacd wud HE ES 

|enardid val contnbuls bbe vedict? 

Sndotfla Oshic Cad have hooded fe pry ypuont 4 
to ou banc coud] 

(Shot inlining pe achelly made on herds 

eqn? Law fay ash Mixed quoshins 4 fad 2 lan. 2 
Js HErar ar nd 8, 1f 

Evans’ sSElbad fe Expl PG ap 

chasm 4 ag put Spa kh, Sindy 

ic Ae fae 

lew) oud) BStods loge fo Taio] 

Madey about py bu | ho wa the ggmen” | Und the 
Malice Mundlon h Ha | juny — na. LE 

(Ws 2 bovis, on bsha malic munden 4 felons 

Wiidon® les ha coaricled a tH? 

, Desnt Nav. Buggers contd on hatte Hoos HE in Tay Cans? 

Js ft yr wr Poy dan td luke 32 Pbids a oud] Appoct Bom Loker of 

ho transept 1b Wako ou ind vine J) fuoby net Focud— on sm or I 
is ar oh 

06S on bane Lu) ML hse Qn We +2 1 

Dystnd Crd lowe a TR et A Sr festimom, 

bt wid”? 

nly incense Shiemed instar Zo 11 cloars wp 

/ & mis idan hatin ostom 
Rr {6 Ole ondino)| "malice SuRest bs vale harbe., 

Apy Cibment Soul” tu [2 paephe-policomsn 

 



Nofes Delle v- Polls - (16 SHES 
Henry - Massial, elit 

  

  

Nossal. v. WSlod Sets, . 37705, 201 (15¢4) 

Sel br 1 
Wile Uak, Hann disodt 

  

  

Satmen - in ip that bad Shp Nance bcs gn Guta Mani. Socrded skip, 
fund 25 pedis (32 16s.) 1] cocaine. (oA Colon decider b <sopencte 
Lt Argo-t Magph indald 4 vadis Damennity under frond sect of eax. NM Jigs 

Convtrsahin, in can—aH cverhand Lo, Mung, 
2 tosh. oles ~(@ (fuck Dill ® 58 — post-indimad) £ 

sfsat-trun in Hoe alone f rehined coed” Cf. deosn't rods pod 
a. 4 judhicas in asso ved Co HE hull- toll, ei cvnmchuoo cons) 
Sid ~ alow, eunsy, fod 4 prstandichued ded. icited plea Fthornondl brat 

ath. Tl nos) Sementz0 neat / Dea floust coviloup (ce, Ho inditand 
on Gay had in am weeds A. «« Judes. Novi cnnih Since Spare 

hawt hold that any seae Seandt ivlevioghen, post-indidwed offs Cowerce | violets 

rig bo counsel. Lite fod) v Yabame 2 Fim inkichmend fp trial), compli, 
Preseason 4 Prop. dno (@. 

Méssialy (dod) prosecdim - LE Adt appliec deck, 

HotoING = # vitlehim 8) 6% Audt une at tied A% Lands, 
€) Coliboumfoly aise ol iciled tum han 
(2) by Glu agen 

5) Mien indichmot 
(4) abst coun. 

Quay Sfieant fom Spine = not ipl thin. Yot © rdomest 
apply buh Places Fb be plheacisug RIC db Sone IHET + MEre Serious ines hn 

Sino. Gumphtious. Cen agugo « els 4) Fig], ave a clfy, 4 
confaue_ in veshgchies, allen \ndichnad. Q lg Oauq tonsprmey vo~ biel 

[ales conficmsd. 4" bd puoblms aside — Pmt “We db ast 

Jesh Woda Mis cone... iF ue enhidly pen fo contuse am Muegads, 

Lhd wt hdd — wp rigid b we re iowa against Mi seal. 

  

  

WHITE = Cored abo vilehinc 4 comin, Coed (to) & Wage 

a Host Ha, Disslisbrdin, of puosied allbridbis shndli fi 
A aaliy] doe'ohy from lech, ¢ fhppns cows, Trleubius cha, 4 

ova}, lamier creded b elove tis relma], doe ¢ Luytd 
 



  
v” 

    

(ahve. Seraucha, st Ay ttl, OK who, exclu 

i Polizia re ol Howe | urido semmpbpppl atin , 
Moveqer, how vio Siag on cans) ¢ died ov i nler|erna wf vight b mdf clond. 

Indeed umlie. 5% Pct — prectudss oll Gola pretrid aduicione. Astondy thase Congellyf 
3 Coareal . Zspecielly ngppupricla hao — A mit on exclady, bd m be! 

No plfiial torn. Head Hose beans wa prior craomussl by Colson b Coguct 
of pic — pe Violen —Uad No maamin Akhnctesy 

Ciigens sthanld repos] andes | ents ind Gore ull uss be feu € 
Savioh, will be Me Lager 
b Connnd? unig 13 LD — Joghacy D) inhi Hhada, ovine) any 

ns 
thle ol s hndd Wrest ht es a Vln wer infu —le the 

oho, 5) tans) masally oa 4) to eluant ctor 

United Sito toon, , ws. 24 (138s) 
 -PB Bvemunan Stead Mashall Pret d Slovene 

2 Bi wok disco 

| - Rebumguih, Leced 

 NachliC 
Bak neg MaskdGanmmin. | hy. Lit. con pind. Rud recap fiv te 
tanh M R. Nuvi) res Sb tenn. tebe. Jolidd - 

lncanealed, Deed. puhcipatin, 
F8I entitled Nichols Gin 1awdle dl NoAlk ch jad Ci) premisus 

ped bo unds enmbidodil inpy 2) as a pul fond, Nidols s2id bo coe a 
11 Hens calllod(. HBT ud be aloid 6 din'f (nitride convrahin A Goch 

Moun (Merry alll aks ve hell Nidislc— hb embed a When 

in Vo. Bcd by act laiiplond handeuff ay, fo aid aseep)) 
Nicely teshihed oft the — Homa esd doscrilie dobaitk 4 dey 

& Qual insiaty - Tos. Sls — alow Estibief) 1d Moms cots 
Pe jal, Sot vant an infrimssd 

Hou on piteanickm a eged Gy cbeonand Nit Wicd ue 
a anf 2 hat bau pfu a cell of Michal dole, 

fp < 1 Gleopled relapimiip | (nf said ho Nl wao i 
 ihals ~ ust hs (isle 

  

   

nat Cont 53 condifhile Hmm



 Pabngutt reqodl to reasidu k, 

Codd wv Plo spoilt wap villi Mase ich ingun, 
3 Rotors on auswaring Govt aged "doll badely Qlicitel 
[hum showed, 

C1) a pad Govt informant | ach wads indict 
) oslous Fler el 

A (ih) wd UR in cushby 4 undo mdidmet 

Con fea velabimslGp — Ndi gf afeq of he praducot 

EEE Loon lf age is tet hilt ™ must Kave bugery 
fd sud t 0pm oh Led, worndd Ged H Ht res. : 

<= Massech hse < * bensdely elidel Fat. Contash ui $6 9- 
fle [idlening pos“ 4) Am 2lodvmmicde vite, Hedy "hac ®) cape [S 

Qa Mo coravsitin ino Gay padivdan silied |" or an inbrmat 
placed im hae Prim Se" malts vo fot Go Shwnlads converse’ 

ddd nd O in Massidh , o va tive achid | &® hf < 

hd h be etmanp fl Cotnee un bony, dhs eo. alhosdy a 

<ile. 
XZ hepuals, Gore. wt Ch eas suspakd . OK fn wae 

aii Sat Hoffa v. US bsnl rT Sh bt puollom, 

Kucsing & hassby Wits dotort gpl, — Henny dit brut 
fhe 0 Coll nls Wigan iNBvnink .Co 

FwzLd)- Wa ago Nace, vo Brower v. haus Sone 

dete we pun psfully walled « 4 fon Danger. & weed skh 
| ATR n A iat [0 (ody remake, 

OC To have a jtalhoes infrnand iritrudled A avorhasn [) 
Aofise in ste Conungebions — isu is ods inh ments aches 

costitins)  delibeals ¢ sumophbius intemegch: 4 (Mul “srgag, 
Covduck that em s1diny J 8) fa Ciirewmshuas, i tne 

fpwchinal gquived §) jitenagatio” 
BLaaemnl WIZE] Hl oy pupusa &) Tic Creo, 100 nad bo 

dSS1aly ae Clrae_ 90°s od Messed, ; 3 vie bi 

(@ Ae Prin oles J Messisly 2. (B Ho fack iflo.ta, . 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

" Dubey elicled danses iT? = & Mes 2 rages cu 
led hy Liat 6¢ Maan foil respmse. How, 81 apt said be 

dd nat inkud have statah Sicikd. Toa Mafjonty | udte rebrins 
oe 0)" doblodely dick) cctodly adapt a. vegligaco-tye 

 



  

Tues wailing Wome § (Masih aes dabei , hago purged 

3 Qoliv, liechis . OW broaden, 1 poh Hist tmanashomall, Locos 
del, io Undence. CD pit g accomodate vals 
J), unde, work. © Ysee shred xo umgead. Uoluarbay (BAB 

Conluet vast culpldo. 
Miamdla, & an chiedhre tet Pusunac Conor aloe] « couse df 

(ebavor Wasisg bocusrs a Ho dolilesdvy §/ Ali bebavio, 
Bladiusn guachin wfgher Cotinge.d fea. amare] mlfer 

3 vas fest "Ulli indus © is Red) Mkapplied | InPhole Jeaed 
v. Jk, wt ondonnd 2 iif police ach “reasmdld, bedly Frckae. aie] 24 

ImMihahey heme . 

—=7 Ser hon “Te Us of 300 0% dthepide Manda ¢ Messinh 

Conbagy of MEUsckey — We bow naling bo] vais 4) cmornati 
poifede ds, holla Nokes beused a mk robles. Leak be foun 

an have ached Ss pevBnsassly 

(Pbieart) Fh Wekssintin J) Maceinhy . ONo poveto 

8) conslhbin Pry mache, uf camsd ditiabed or spied apn BD nn ikea, 

aselance hb D> va ding (ho Guy ¢ lapis tothe Criminal) prado; a 

@ fh minimize thy imtbalouce jv (lo pdversersy schon. Tho thaovebics 

trwodshin, €) b* Porft ight Haig Ho hae a Soph cept § Shipst 
A th Wadd due deesut Noguine Lope & Wage anata 
fe dived ty~clod welch — 

J will lose veceved Wicaudn infashian on dix neflk, d ten 
ull tue fem mrad ry A cons d nel bp aC. 

A choad Maasrsly veliues a, Pose Bellas "chitiet 
0% " omelys is Cnisvesdiug — [Bret] wa lind lain reo bey z. 

sucha cituater) & Pon Gams v. Na Ynls - a CoCread cprffaricn Fe. 
Pome Dh St o£ pd ano wehaled a cova B eb, pn 

adveaiic] — redo Tau a jnquiitoid — Sot... Yt vate 
Suqgesh a vigid chcholony ow Yoho ach it, 
clini fle Sani a [rie - veliadt hfs 

Ss Jet aun He 10p i Uplumtand gives, 
hn bs Indjonitys J Yat Got how 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

"ol; brad" ino Frm secu). ® UWndneaes pile, work 

 



  

   
5 and, Lo hineelo ones ome cromind Voteodun 

oe — ip NEL wet fer wii. ' i ra 

fv Pad A 1.4 lee tne Nos bras red hing ha Feces ‘Aypncarial 

doesut gon bs Mutu 2 anbiKod b conned. (As platy ‘Le; Glad 
hasabistling seuss). War duee it pace, Govt invoshscon shadl Camo. 

py" Hpiemedoo Sp, bh ‘dua fue accurad bi red vow. fev 

Mast v. Woolton | 474 0.5. 159 (1985) 
£ ( Prenwin Minsiald Blackinun, losels Sevens 
7 Buyer ide. lohuuist  Oonmpr ( fs. Te.70) 

ifs | belleot Wai (0 1osprre h bo al) pan ath deloslip. Seo 
umn, show, Hoel - Scored Gilding im doalintip form, Jocsed 
Moulin 4 Colson . Fond loans §) vecont aud tislte . Indickd for Hof 
by rewinn mm 44/3) 

Ch 14/82, Colom atled prlice 9b, bo FLL. 
: 1681, Cots & Modton TAlled — Moelfon susp ed Klip ss Sali 

ns. 

nf4fez - Gltme Aisess cane of Clic) 4 Defebue, sd 

h Haff by receiiop, ip @ dof mE 
Feshied gpant Mattme coopuchd . Colon hod a bp puto 
Pov — wiel eudl Mul. 3 ll, — fu § which , (ladbr 

beep Nit sud Woe rosie h wad om 
i Celoon apasd 5 le a Ft LETTE 

(an BV Doken’s sefeh,.) Groom WA, esleuall inshuds) nth Hop! 

Bn: Moulin vejech) hog deaninedin, eid (Yné ~ vejech enhog ‘Mn ehon ‘dad on 

elle TR Ha Color prifessed tama lapacs ve J 
tho rion € Mouwlbom wade Numorsss inorim. Sowa. Colter also 

aa Tosl ct doused D Come) maed Bs . Indl cf oe) — cd] “res 

wo Ho © ded will i ns hls lsm C 1 pa 

Golem ® jnvest gale Zttomap) m fee Life J) Catoc cnn 

oy - Judi Cuil df Mis - peutnrded) for a ves 1D. Cow hdd 

Hit tho puaposes 9! wre tens gtinets, (nd hits 4] 
5s adwiSliy Guild! be wad). (OChae relih sy 

  

Miu 
(feo Wott lol + © propoie J mis uo dru 

- 

 



  

dog Surges) @ Cole ca ahi 4 bea bos: Bio 
oben cud! ip wire] Hol thay unas ov 
snd bau Shor 5 big Ay rea tt cu Me dows alin 19 0imwakp 

toned nl MM umn indied #inoc ; nef on foe 

Jodided ones. —5 xx 
Rialit b coum] athdss a sadn, “Ofical < " protatriad. 

0a at 4 Cran altace, Tue Saty oud honor 4° Sty & 08 hao an 
alficndhie digzhmpst Bad b cicomved to patidi.s 

Spr - eal si rer, cuchdicd Infemagi q A peo cand 

b se bic ups. In ulundan Cop sei (5%) + 4 TJadosy, a 
CE bd vidshi.  Messid, ‘ Hom — Zonfhsrized Phdng: (OO Md 

tus Ba pilin frtanaaid uf ine Bo pndss Got 10 cdlisorm 
Hamu | ® cmfired on jd (thle pssivan) | Wot sthend bv FBT 

tpt ho indmd Ndids it bo qushin, Shee TEL “putt bape thpan ” fut 

Te “ob fs W tad (Go Sat e AA fle cial, ¢ Ho Ul Lh Ey cg whe 
We rejod Hu pict — who wimg yn MN /H ov da, (21 Cun! dm 

revered ( Beatty v. US) whoo  requbd tha wachee. ( Tndasd, 
SE so aged fsa ~ bu anal, & SE arguad i Horry todd 
0 [premabion n (sadn , Hcend vauve. wan rasds fo madt 

Wiseioh .) I 
Ye ifr tee cradled flor indidnad, Cored io nad som’ 

lehoeom self ¢ STAD, Jnidude. SIs alficm aldgbn nit # 
Ss 5 PIs. (hn advent hiss disclososs decsit 

1b 55 BE LN lopitatn Ho Sh 4) am appara 

fo erupt Gecuned Ws 1s as tes RU : 

afficmhus bliin o5 is am indochionsd Suahon 4) sucpm. 

  

  

  

  

  

  

bppoimmhy vo Viihha “lnsulossly Th trast aenad § 

OR! Bs tonsesnd pPresed. 

nnplo SUsgpdled Topi cell & weeping 

yor LL to [uve J /he wgobrp, Ps lo deus hel 

ie ; 

 



  

Tha ley Compr ise — Police com coh ane wnidlncarss wok afl Mdjihy 

olan [2 bo tesa cies 00 (D fi thovagl. nuestyehon o) Te prom] cute 
J anelu dba, Hhind. 

| Rush) ~ Clijeds th Section d) Yatkomans tecodsd a3 put f 
I fort ihtstigeio ff whirely spurts amc.” Bek wd dSg 0 ted 

wihistes — acid w bce,,,, Madiv dd incsint rl 1 24 +54 elope 
(lls. Sonpaed] ody wie b puatief Glen & Qopun atnd toast fo 34 
Puabes 

J cdf hua (re, dorelidt ast fo have dems oda pole dd. 
Hol v. US BSUs293(1%6) Oks tae I) postindichroct clean 1elTedts 

Dhar ffomss, Top | The prlice did peti ang sn wiviny. Gili; Heo shew, 
re 3) erimor & conpviay hha witwess ae gdimits ile alt du la mid. 
Vay bo game @idos be admsitd Lior’) Worry tov one podl] (od 
tol volta. 

Tow punk be mare bo gun crtl foo. "eblbnct alli? 1h 
Sis Wao nat Medio h 4 ewduer fic this io, the blasat 

IMAG, in J). 

His Wy, Uckido ¢ipduce oly Fiabe «ced in bd {ath & on « 

i Hux shad be tus Sis rdf vids, 1 sss the oxclinine 

de hs lo wand in tice carn each — loss 8 Portus the rat 
rele, Frethaod,y evdauco.  - ew fon. Po cds 

ale & to defen pale oot PEN A yn 
ho dokrene. ( Cle Loan), 

Ku Humany v. WILSOA] | y77 0s. ¥36 (1986) 
foie -T IV ~ (Hew) Burger lle Bluckmun oh nsustt Osan 
Het TIL - Busser bhnguust tOlsusv 

Prem pon , Manche dl ER 

Yevew. diceufin 

  

  

  

v/N] - (J Kon 4 2 le] Sha Tanieh barge. Cot ru 

spar. Whos a Wilam, a former ¢fee, 01 promses tales, vill 
Lotus, 1 [luting uth fuse monty, 4 day Cet, fo Fuvuch hid 
in, Sid br po Preset uf yof ynuplsed 1 a mundy, 

faced tv fron Vous of Lofetio yf Bonpy kee (4m rma), Ws 

Mado Stlowond> © Beans loo —uned aginst hum at tial) 

 



    

Lee agpa0d prey h Gilems anniv), tb [icka } rapa J (Son's ve madd. 

{orpose §) police achen~ to dodowmine ids f) code. Bomt-ack 77s, 
>ihply llaop 20s span. Wks <hrdd fae convarcatin Al Les lle 

stom fo had piven pilivs. Log répliold Hd aR ston ‘dodont sand loge” 

Bahar vided A (ater 2 suid aml ano ped tect A news bane 
Lille] Aapudd. Ellorands, 2 adunited Bo Lao hd ba lsd commited 
Yoo Ls {0 id Co-Ls). = lot La 

ne lo was (Yshu fo bite, 4 of 
Hoe a ule No hac ale) sy ile. Fred a 

Semel Ure Spanos "5 “tmstliald 

Covided q prand { weapuposcession, Lh pret (ad. hodiedoon 
Wassialy — ho jms sabi AY) bpp, Plt —evem unde 
Brewers ov. W. Wine | pve & vequiced-tiaam fo sw ‘Solibecckls 
2h" Him incnim Sadevadhs edend cushdy, 

Ja Homey 0 and hades. best 50s cant gn 0 rebhoactiv 
and §) Horn” fel ditinchins. Boch Of. eld of Viaadut each. 
tztaachnh, waa 2s ‘wel vulo of las" ) Since Honry did 
ed Cadi prior rs — the ilu J) Lee to make any mais 
re He petilia, Cout 4) Appedds 

: - Henm nit fos bw CS cadils. forte wee 

TEL brom Togs 4 Tg olay 
ik ¥ Fuchs loved). Pel Birr, Oem ; 

Clee previdse (Ha guidauce om Mod §) Juste feet. hity C— 

Succesur (24) polit & abso lo anit “hae Lishnd 
rtapitgo Mee is frosdsd om ho oqeiteli padre) HC." 

Witney { HC pont T8T — i tals Lund 22C 
Nawaieg ‘in Se v- fou). In doses 7 2 clocads. | Cond Us 

lp vied fhe £9 Tl uohes ff wat. Nob J) 20 pag ad 13 nif 

po) awe fit. "4 shiv we Shu, J be inka intplia- 
fd. See 4 — a altucsip of fi Cpe ITT. 

4 Lubs 4 yuehte Pa Soumd ham hrm $224Y 40 wi) ty ou 1943. 

Did (Me wows gud Wb Sarpy By 1, Ho ovd gag, 
Loaner gud "ud iushio" Jan o-[ Hs induded jn His $2248 

uilodt he feds prow « Logs. hdd, odd Gy « 
dogop pak Hoary, bude beans d, Appleapa 

Dring"! \ Jordhaal) bo tiene assaded Wn (novos, flicakin of 

predicald) re grpud- “slips, well buoys hous 

    

  

  

 



  

Pood) re jed handy vieq — allo 1966 | ne 9 aud J push. To 
lapuo C pAMAKS AP not mandate, gi (> a "Nad nd! 

Mee 6s & gomaes 

Divahn +. G. ado guidance — we'll wag “Und J) ust” 
{ Swndiss . + Damdad fon Sp tmudt weigh infeanfs 

Priseraa os o "proeshd ¢ laghmdde last" IF he « janocad. 
Not tha fv Prana “udpose Gud & conceded ov plan! ke copdote 
do) usta requis leduval coud b uber suck patton ‘a 
Le tho prism Supplements his Corgtiftend Lawn wilh 4 colo 
shouting J] jackie) inane, !' Prle 17- (kT Friendly Nokd = vt 

2a © Show "ud Le mgd Nel, ov avon paddl mt, have bea 
emacs inte oluce op unas. tnd | but alla | fhatenon 

pilh Ho aed endive | Wilh dus regard bo ary Lreliab, Uk qt 
fha tier qf {acts wand awe 2ulertringd a veasmably doubt of gett. 

pple ing Yo Yee) — Quid lems gif who rudy orm-se 

  

( qushin §) info waa Tt ufo um, p lied 
e loss Pe fd Mada vie offort fo hmulsts conuersehanr Cot 

Pegs. Moulton — mjovmamt os "ident fosk pn 

; parkicipudr inochi coneacatin dred venugt” petits vaplay 
Massied ¢depled comeumanct rn Sr , MCoudl mack 

Yl (fran Vd it ue Comearnad ih nero godin av inuchir 

dehniquie Bnd went eguivalst inden tages.” | 
| yw = wWormaud hdd 2ugegsel Ow Corvesetins 2 had 

Lelopd a velehimslisy § vs And compass, .. infra dal; less 

lely und postors tb Secuns Unni. info, eeu haul" hael uit 
Hsin) A. Infoumasd “hd ied comvstabing iu ada to 

robuat" Jab. 
SRA Lie Misyiak 

  

  

  

  

Yo Hopi coveamn § to Magids Lig ... is Sanat vemos: 
veh Jechuiqus, dio up e quivelet o dived police 

lnorecptin Not euguh vou a pusr Araspesd, 
bv infsenad singly b report shiamads Rall He 
L mut dowan. fhe Mo pelice ¢ Had inforsect FOUL Some 4 chew, 

 



  

ond mares \s Tema (ht wes dosrgnad, dal 10 hc incnemineg 

hye roms. Hong Ke ord 'h L Sdomra v. Mebz 
Stall Curd bold — Lon inhuctid Sl hy (Whew 1 Ho followed gp rmshecinr 
His male — Whlsmi ary Widat sound fogs aged [pps 

for ot thal ovement & gout a Joc phe, I) op 49 A Stak 

Cou 
VRGEH CORNY. eck 4 (IP bebvsaan placing Hn Youn" in Wo 

Suse & Plagng” 2 ito /n Ihe cell ty emarrasye Converefein. 

oe oF ute Sigasas h ho snd dscrntn { [dat $4 
0. ¢ doinasl Po we COTuch. To , Y Fechus oF 

lit Jou) ot (nnotoue, Tf Van's “ys helrea, vg 

etl fo An atovce 1s uN Concern. Uo, Studs HA not 

"64ye gun Jie ouds 4 justice 22 in Sune MS Rh ts’ rouse 7 
boll eg £0T must be cane A) cae; plunddik wank. bo ubehbd, m sve, 

Gand ud — We Guts, 
Caitany bh msionl— unless suf doled uf by weiglsy compet, 

los 4 Fre by Ao ore dah 
MM v-fonodlf feo been, limikd 
Wo" + naugn imide HE onde bo acum - ou hans, Masi, o 

inom clums, Salil fos b de wane ahd vislat= K. 
Conhbbon.” Frama Wall. puss hin, ho go fT, tras, vindieahs 
Lolidikond) practi. Welhang m bp ) bio mM iomocencs” 

Look af Go §atur Widerny = fHisop to 136 o JIT poisiito Vid 

1. On Ho nat disagar uf ledowiny pod” atalipic, 
acePled flv 9A ddl pin davect Sed 4 
Me A. hd Hest dolilberate plicibahin tan Ocun Hong move 

subie forme J] shwmlsion . (Pt A uw @J4 ovrenledtiy Saye; laa 

Said Iz ails did conned hoe 2) 

Henry obidut inveloe on | formset (Ae iecks, Gucthane Fou, 
Movin, 5 fo dissin. An Uilsa, , nee, Grofesss nid wre 

The jomidyaly cctelyys}. OQkaghte bratty delivescd) cop do jue , re 
Sry 4 vewadlC hop ig 
{ur ) bovsancs # a selbst | bud wit Ek May, 

EW fay 

  

  

  

  

  

  

  

 



  

TLuwoLsv. PERUNS - ¢fofr 
  

  

WY - viundin oi Gact & Lous, In Ft, Dvictd Charlton BU poli a 
lin) 

Contsers eines befusaom sued, 4 undorcasey Cops do nol inpliatl Mivand; 

Ie concern ws jnhow-tl Sh resunsy d] 6 Polite -dmasuated 

sdmosplns. Who sued trinks boi he he Mules <P 
Ptwise (ivan, - digo Foal. fm, infandiic] Cushdin + ofkiel infoteyds 

Aaa wo rejet Cush dy + cmvaghn of on hoffewe 5 be a Fp. 

(rub Corncim st mato shades ’c docphes . “(lay RE pa cueptoy bf 
fm tc elas Souse]) sea that deni fie bb Nee Loved Nerepulo or 

Ceram hy spall ars net mle Miranda « Conan. 

Mascidh ic Liiopealdds. My diane, hed (etn $14 has gm tle nulyed 
ts iviBviogehin 

rei ten ow Hu peend 
0 toda af Tus Sag, on Mionds. Bud if 4 dnokod bi pd 

Stee sy hy cancel, a dest care. No E4Andt piatbon cnt indetes 
On In cha. But or Merah oo dan const act — polio cmdud 
haw may vielety Due Foose Closer — Rick probit inguiciric 
(vs. aman ) pele to ha. Oaut leven cont mm fowand h cveds 

frat | 
[ Mansktd ” Clushdiak (rakes ™ k Polka affican dards 

Vvrarda La UW ge — fanied. Hog S¢ agus A vasut custody Stheo 

NOGan Ws Fans Vo og joJ Aan prity rrupyR meet . Nimo ua 

Sant NC yo dvd inferno fata — infrrwan astal fe b, 

bws. 

? Issue uu Miauda vZswt coercion = it Lac amy alice Tach 

(taln bo cone a BD #8 male (neni. Sirfuonts “fo full comouose 
Is righ. Trickeny by peice i fun Mauda’ 4s & dled 

doo, Hae | polite concoced a Sum 2922p plat, & ldo 

  

  

  

{) Perkin b cot Oy prbiey bis slings b anges: vido fo 
Lar 

 



  

  

  

Miclig v. Haney _ US, Mog 117 (195) 

$7)- (Ake 0Gnnay Scalia bauvady 

A fs coda, Milan v. Tocom 475 05.0240) Jo 

  [ ottindichuod™ quochimsy requis a valortacy, (aug & «dell; 
La wen — [tam v. Wives rs Or re 

Ww agh a. CL holt vis — Mv. T bance pn Whee 2 (6 

Prop | ake <pndsad. Sduard. Dpiznge Ta 2d lager ff prophole 
6% — 4 D Ber way Jin mis (Ppa h bast cowed presed ) 
Yio vad wasve: 2 Shorr Just A vegas 0 fonths, Tush; 

Midge, o 5am sap 6 All rid prs) -indichus dco ~ © 
Wig ZX vel i2Ahl 2 Pnlahie 2d me dy il [wa lumbaz 

0 angus- a d faand TeClusdnaen ado shadd gas, FA 

gah — since edumsanicd ocoding begom, & Postirdictmad 

fnferna godin naplaates 6 md Gruasaidas eat Bt A Ney 
Ae UR Seba And id, & ay <b St we] out Speck, wnt con) 

To be swe, Ho andlup: 4) wave omde. isso Ciresms men io rare 
Stay — Shee am appara conftd (ubiseny 2 cuss Cased. é pre cand, 

wed Wine. Bed, Bllocos y JUnns hath Hetavaue. 
Presille. ave wt guing fo AiG dian O's fone ill caren iF wise. 

JAN Agus Hat sce the police pear howe afp rmdir vini'S 

int (020d Br. (ayn Site Lg ents! lrg? i Siena 
od, Sloaddut fails gt shiewet Cy i 

No udtbbe, LN win misdl 
ou ge oy 20 4 Inga) bona fax o Wadi oA 

=> Wawes, A Mo Police \awe Wigs 57d in eed) 0 couae 4 conduct 

| Luh wad] rude; Ha wives joniolim Me bapdo JU it Ge 

hispid. We Jeserrs de quash Yhe Aulus bled) if ~ 

  

  

  

  

  

    

  

Dunttny Slowed” Made uibod o pany & dsl, 
Wiles : 
BE dr Wars bd ekwsn — Tov w, No ISSUL 

N Odle Woy Covduet & raves loves fe. 6 Bdt   

 



  

inbatowt 5) cans). Bresw) mila. (hatte. fv evidduco 
Jj i] tial sha dex 6 impea chine : 4 

E higan v. Je elbon 's EF Adt ads 

2. Rd Ae bpd am S* Add Dumdabe 

s. Sthmdt pullte allay inbol. <) Mauda vids 4 
Sakwad, for Wtse cat 

on Pi Er Aledo 
T% ued on ANA — Meloy iz based a, AY | radensast oi 

Wp 0 Dé hoice hb par Couns Ashe modium wn Jit, kyidy ) 
Lx 1- pt a pve | Compudl] inntanineha oa da tet pls 

hd &ppgag ry wv hand va i Summed. in 

fin ka Inco O) HT crus Jado 6 an | rrebuhidle 

prscsnplion uid Oe waiven is nat Vs bub out of scp init 
fer confi] & Lav hs rol, 1s complain & yu 5° bret] alia 

Llmdt - NAA Mich Weve fr Vasiw, £1. Sedy's 1A iv fnddin- 

Seeing 8 Compwad wih Ns nT] in come { (Ho fifed bis wats) 
2, Hoo Stats bee for accunsd a 44 Nine = coped is nocossery 

suns am spout drial, t+ socnad nid «1 No police precinds. o 

Jodo, is eked Ast end Gan Sttondt edupuds conanrs fl 

Ve poed / cmused o¢ "madkium  Coutarms — Sex Mains © Moll 

(gu: Ronny. Of # Stilt jwihates commmuncchi of repuselid dak, 
tle roseuce 4 Cosel, the stoma af 4 ano wt dasady “pgcunad. 

paid — Hoy aug inal, Towpe undes Exile. Sauilh | a (® 

Pdt vicahon pon | to S2Andt prolom - - must have ud bs 

Come Prin h encode. Bucliawon v. Moitadl, has sTondsd Suit 
Z wae 4) such eindoner 54 re [nd (by ho SAT) <t sutton Nastcap 81 

Cout sldschy GEA} viotabin - ale oly 1 viclcbin 4) a prope 
fuged rude — P alla dea ancleyy bh es , Meme v. NY ofr. 
flo 

  

  

  

  

  

o lies tole | $ PS eve xy we rtd gids 

code. HEL" wg conplated J — 3 

Sly detrodt Ghd! 0K b pati ond OK bs 
hago surveillaue, 4] jal 4. MN, hot Good ad trial 13 fo 

4 viehon.( Dusich - OIC Lyd jes tpn, wid wut Fo use 

(dome of tied) 

 



    

Eloi v. Jinad $87 05285 (588) 
wt Olona, Scalia [Co nnady 

in 2 gay fiptds — vim Usd ialha2d. Upm sum, 
lille ald fet, dewie (caddy f Ho Lond. Affe 10dchuad | Coir ¢ 
RActhAe mbrvies tun dng 2A F: jf Fin ovaful Mivavds cave, 
d sewing wiles cai | 

D ape, Dll haadds, hiv nkewtisy shnld Genial, 57 
wile. edwards | IN didut i10oke ghd fo oomid brs. If ho hed 4 tho 
infervics had conhmad | iV uptdd bac vislibd Widiigen v. Tuck. Bd a 
cn wit. © ape sultbsticllly | O apps he duit wie GE hud 
\iks. Swe he fof wapnunp ! ead cyniben WAire, lo voll ire 

Whalhor tray ve (nai ¢ rite). 

A oF {or audabion — 
nse v. Levlst _ jnfenhnd veliag richuna Tv bd, _ 

92 tei Ps nH iil — past (ota wtbed” 
he i choinp Sh of Moice ir VA WHE se pa, 
Maanis v- OS en vel. MSlnn 3qus23 27 (1542) 

    

  

  

  

   

  

| Ugun — wr to A made sulci, duos of lot right 

i=l ¢ f ho cySequoucse() i fleets 

Hag — Miranda, bainivgs eal. Warn, AL be Wis 7 

Quid usr au lowed WS edly reds te ont seid -. 
Not acescany oy A To har a Al g. complsfe afppeoatin of 
al) Vm Com Seguamtor floran Fro ky adm. 

I Poshikichuant giodbonurs, White asp, tn (2b of Cota] 
tata [ile] — Los imdimmsnd. Letan moe imporhud d J 

rf. 
desu all 2d Ui f 7 eam 7 

A wtdd Clip ‘ve lf Mimunde C4 12] =. 
when 8 wasn] fall het hs Tausio. wn 755g fo suds hon. 
Muli 8 nt 6% bind). @ (oie nd SE 

 



  

(nguiw) | even if Utlumbuy) dfler 19dsepuad. Hon 
ob ed 1dsa cubes, of hols nat < Gp Bom SP ALLY 

Vigd| ave i "fuentes Than fos ofan @ bretd regi A quik Wier 

(Wg we sled bf conse) ngs prapuehedd, — wha do 
am a lam sae (oat lmels J) Ua FA Rp, dq 4] ite given 2. 

a Ge chr — Ns hed by lunes of postin huss pls iid ut 

haart hinged uanmng- 4 rm odura, fre wai acum ed lina 

Yr rs 4 ped indi ned) gucennut ht cowed] hal wit it 

wn rN od. Qerddut le duu uostioning undass OD indbute, Ho 
CU Coupy 

Beers] Brena, Missal. Cou skadlt condso urd 
rial pap. by Preecdinn or Mag in vech gates. Zio cond et hao veld de 

Jnpropes Ga & Uhl Caterd” 

Swaly ten fv DA to Condi an nfervied J A Jus ied 
fo ath wate ave i Mirawd,, WBN ings Loo givem, 

[ Mossad, fowry 3 Maul WL Mr delat bean 

May Aoshi the Shop hec “anmaffivmaie 4 latin + 

respec oud pesave the accused's chaics h S2ofC af ass thud 
Fey Meno cave ¢ wil waive (reno prgiito siico Ne ll banc] 

Ind wholer Sate dali elias) 
Gy 3 Mim Hoe 4 ussha — Whom does 1 econ gms re Ror ee 

ond ale (Her News JIA - (gu ad versvss, pucaadups Commenss, 

Pizona v Kobus ~ gb St. (1985) 
Stwtuia for bb —  Houmsde € Lehngus disse Xt ~ Olianor nif pusbipe 

  

  

  

  

  

Fir 
oy J) invplso nat h taumsed, in Casitas | Eland Sys no 

funthoon Guoshiovin. How 3 day Who am phan wd J He 

Ns request, Yunis sloy) LUIS (VB RR 

Shlewad sn Thich Wdwudod I JA Nfs Sibneo, os 

ed amo lack la rewar | { gust | 2 valid Wale 

  

X Fodd Sh zc £ uth —impls, Brows of Piz fen 
p GET ln bie 0 Coparadin bb < Ni 4 4 
Lf Gigio Sus /se, 1H (1972) 

 



  

69- Nake, + Coax Simi chauduad > 4n dE 
Ham INcugalyds nogtsdl 

| th hedit rode B dow (ic 
oi htyls fi + 
dat vm flo may 

(lio - Llonadate ft. - 
2¢9 IY Wag Pro ~ eT 
Yo ven 8 vepurad bo ua orusety 

Lh eat gpd id ie 0 tn 

Wg Moe Wo dod (lle Lo-0 ho] on pelohymds) Ds Geared 

X id nfs from ois DA bo liad tasked of Ph lis oct) 
= Duk glo sune © beats as hat 

A wm) ke. Onan bes fathhijmy 
2 Soul bho 

  

Tonto - TO dydh en. mid ~ ip bosced, abnitd of 
Jury fred bo ind in udunsdea A, Bn. dot hinsin dda, anole d. Held] al 

fsstus) bo A. re, Given i "™ yd i) subs baue — ne ethSeron © 

, A cles). Cons dural daguchs ow turns pe Lice 9 puthoncy 

os plrrmocalogice] witves do barbed ofp) bps civ du kp ol 

: as \D hyoscine uf of osama 4g Fuaend pares freehand 

TT collusin of uf ocr b (re Coufesc 

& a confer died 8 sk 10d con py om 
Leu dnd) 4 | volte, wlio vichm he ibd puollear, 

Towed - Jr 9) ohn vol atlikdtls h to idKoucelle 
Jr, 07 0) Mei y3 - andonce crucify waewt 

2 Pl och fo Gut 
Lis} Ho ih gl win ER] 

by Mri on = arg 

  

  

  

rs ball Sum. i oncuntt pl)” fod b bg Ys ak, 

nite dk aD ho dot BL LED WE A lel, 
cd. Tho dussic 

 



   > 

U0 Tdssen V. 20bst. (Mudtte ds choo - ©) 
Whigs daie_tath ppaal wae « “ich choi 

Saduign Vv. foals 

Newell No Yeg niala, a) o. do fume ace 

Cian : han vio appellee rede judge wo independ]. 

ld Saito dont lay dana Spee be lb. 

TER vove dame A) Liochoy B didi and 
ke fray’, A ALi rakhett —Seo Abramson wus !! 

Wop Dro ~ ad 241 ~ 
“TT hd (© Cull qo ov huss 1 Je pref 

@ gy) Mascon BY UT (Msc Xs 

(3) it ud, aceessdts af bpd 2d 

  

  

Url Swite. BUG Bw Us 2 i) - Waa 14s 
ag just ome Bf; Cl, Aaa. | Ts] 2c 

poyckiatsy we. foe it Sr os EAR by 
Fam pba — "in coud §) epics an difesed &) m heft 

  

Hay usa 4 the hms J) Po disposer, ¢ 1d HC. 5 cordaindy 4 be 

eee ei 
1 

Ra, eer , 303.193, 202 (C4. 7. Menketd Y Ca trescns, 
Trak mM s) | 

b3 Symon Thowpeen, " Muga) he Wnt § Haken: Corp * 18 fom. Lo 
1 1s80)( rals Yash |%7 actos see info Elona (2d. Be pret 
view) lo docs ob Soe Crk “— clive Banc § Chine 

    

  

A a a omsely” 5 po Bullman $Ocad B94, 5g 
Ipods wi BF [53 

Clu bevy Godutan “Uae & Hise 110 dil of HC 7 F703 13 
( (978) boy od pettuio Wm Weatez wee driving Neen Lag y. 

Cosmet Coo ali Yoseyy GU WSE24 357 512 

  

  
  

    (0e.cl. 1946)( prisms ALS S024 2 22 L 2p pte sn Siw. 

 



  

2 pts Lodoquab jnveshis. & 
2 Pain igh — gion] 

No bao judicch— 33. hixtng. Goetdad, AN mt C5 
LR Vey 30, 2 (p49) 

6nd adit Lew ves jud. + dod weo nl 
bo kt re - 
blo Apple cations f) r= jeud. h dail 4 relef by AC .c shill 

Condes rp is 1, Hoe toma los ib Ue pravel s, Impey «4% 

Vib (to Sop OF so frond 171 tacszeey h prond Sao props f foals 

LY fag fell suet 8) aay dpb ta. 

Earl ) s ures planes 

UJuito bypons 21a nyted uk fo grok i § 1 

Fd P. im Re. 33 — Reopen a ju blowa.S By Newky oLxeov. end. — 

Sith v- haflec ve quod on dalled, sbhesdouns3 

Tr ott Cuddy — A | demic] oy D3t- Ul — aged. dh Used. 
oats od [ack Mw, —— lf No vec judith, 

  

  

  

wv US - 19% Pre Bazelon — Give ws sod us hfadda 

wWCAn , hn 

Gannison v - Ils mo 4-0. —fack sbvisely buan 

Sesion v. Jhon 

  

  

  

Meinl — helugus newedl be bras & fic) . 
Dred 2 Ai. pt hE te on rr §. 

TE Presuuiphin doops 7 hak Cnpunn 
> a n —=1 

Gk Gut — satus How AH Cd | eve. dosed of 1&4. 

Mk v Ok __— oA 

 



  

Equi al Docbna, 

Faseph 
Fa tal, Jodo Sen OFmp va Tyuily adi, ora Correia Pv Mac y 

Jamo, (oi ac Quamedler Co Naini. veably mall Ate luo asl). 

Oiafon, Coma vi uit, vf Clan onde “4T Moki Lo 577945) 

ally # Gosdr doctrine J) moc widoqraad, ditse, 4 voids nats. 

 



  

  

  

ey whi ry 1+ abmnd mua d 

    
    

3 fais 8 1 TG [odd] 
~  Doant nthe. vy hdres ia 

    
  

Lok J #8 babe (x plhnck) 
2 Wovdand v- 
  Le. 

 



  

AGA sec 

4 The quash = 1S abmdmmest alow 2 
Dr - shadd we dig Tip case aguminp aor. 

Cobat ant dd He Covad Colas held 7 Pose 
(luat i$ Altune 

Hic fivwied b dolil. aboed. ¢ 
I Exens, nyled- 

Ones. ead d) Mose Forme 

What olse di 44 aps rely m1. ( Hx) 

pn lg. bride Frond in ud. fo 8 Rood ic bf 
The alleen use &. fres. we pred 

ha Hours ty. 

Ul Mink pn ma “dlelilensls.’ — dee Fh bo 

  

  

  

  

  
  |   

Woe got by cddiosc flo Cou Juste 5 
we Maeh HE - 

hse (vn a A Douce — 

dif 3 vs. CF Appesd- - 

I “foo mud § pee ease © 
(9 we'se Dg, — 

Fs —delile.dp 

We noe fbi =i * cdl bare sutton 
ful. CY EE = 

[Bult Bail Povadle Teaching 
a i eves proto 
Ding Sukie i 

ow usd bare fra, Rvady 01 uncle an fle 

  

  

  

  

   



  

bowald, nod 

a a 
oo : . Er vo 

i a 
: 

: re ful 

ule sy 
Tum 

: vochine 

fn 

  

  

  

Cv 

. Cn Eh 
W N. 

ny 
   



     
  

  

Ul lod fh god Ugpams — tena fort sla wig # 

  

adhe aise 1. Mo. 

The, maion locas foe wo in. : 
() Nétlosieys ngs wee vidal] 
G) £ we & swakip ads in IAs 

O 
SU willy 5, Cour £65 ud Veiithon 

ie Cpa 404 

 



  

   
©. 

The Si all f] qua srewgfn op fait = Has onchans 2 
Wig. — ; 

bib «1g 
shit & judi - 

By the fine he def ons fis ase | oe ve im 
  

  

Keun it 0 dl Tir ange — ti (Me tt - 

ka on Nol oy i gE 
a mali, poh 

- hal be ak a aly brvpusc desu? Ui 1 
a Can, hy | 

Bult contd ds SMUsS 25 npr GHeunfed. 

[1 Thsy eld DIB it, Rio. Cy. ik 
  
  

  

Yeti] 1 

  

  

 



  

   AOA A DBuy lar 
ama   

Tadicd guastion an discussion re Congaess. od) Hail 94 rikoon leald 
on reunankls wu. eo apeuming brief. Mayle Too Samctimeniou Tha potil hea 

Sp, dest iequito nud aidhounby. Well be Aho b Sag it ix tho reply €nif or 
ott or gunna. Cones — Laas. tbo Gruss (Lets hatd gf vi tha fbiat 
wud] Fic, rallied Me came ic bod 

Dbom— vshallon or wf shal hagponad hore vally dhovted Hoa fotth Rides 
ain, tide ie Fo ied. re) ushieq  Issg > 

wr Shaddit § fonthar Tham Shan fat Evans vung awe 

ga Sr NCloskay degizte) tho ack. % fc Sup 

7s go hs char — Lite it veally is qechuedd vidgpon . Tra nave J 
iy Evans’ motie Rv lying, flo ave Ah urrndunad wall it uns 
?) ; 

We nad) fo uy (Close, cid} 6-7 
Y, Hoos dm aus lisp — Mua vetom Hiv 5 pt hurmbbus 

that Eins’ covnladdd 4 cae toad cod pendily hare bern do lias]. 
Stcks fut (MS Qoslsy csgpnand vith Blane — A "Swearing eiitas) 
Dros wrt ARTS soanding Gb a Jedamicd) nant. 

Havades eae validion — “Le cam disauss it tn had veachip 
discassin 8 fhe Ba. A dowpn Med thoy trad 1) (le Strvp v. feed) 
Si ufifindin fmchon . No fan amis on Teh and-suid, 

ne The 2 
Tee. 

  

tino Cass’ Shas that troy divit d 36 Suieluas, 
HE pro Huaugh Shagid | (it be dosighis ald br G4 

Eves is. Lex He Sty ov ho Cond” dome lace 8 vouch Av Evans, 

We Shedd Lmdnad hum indirect . Should nst do am quia 
en Hus. 

oA Spat — 7 yale H. brody Gelaie The VAL My 

a ill td wbbnids HE f R ou 
balck Gui gob. Ou Sbiidicy Je — {go hare emits fas 
Gavidis spin 

Ile Forcestr _ shaythe Soppiabd i the keod Fraunlel, 

didn? bower a factfinding & Hho vewed. Dit wbipily 

7 

 



  

A Sumner v. Mata dlefouns Lio"re sbadt fe iscom whic) 

hs Shade Guil FB ence er, Tha Version we 
peed. Shonllit elo PF act § estar. 4 a Spront 

tins recies fo fd of tha aict — 1h in Ho anteit d) tho Sk 
Anode a 

Forrester iaode to le vecrfed 2 supped. (TAppacslive te Bow trl 

May Sonkins:) Ginphusye fooresten's finding, Pale 52 ke . to Sced dead 

On fio 108 - Eveutrapucll do wo Yosh of. Send make ais 
Massialy Viole aut bth fuctdly pleded Malco 
Hw cnihatim elomait Cuthlmann - alate i 

Lo a 2 fu Pucks — fhom Vs. Bit 

eae psy Sr ta 8 men 

rota DAS ahs ov Liz Hokpma, 

Bay Licbuan by Dick of lgg=7 

  

  

  

  

  

  

A dvesn] bad 
Eh deer nt Viewed 2 Rll. Spiker 

Tom Steger! | 
Coddntine DR age 

Wo be Wap po rok En Suto bore 5 
Sanders ~ pry Cir i Bt ' Shudad 
(FR strand distor — Hos 22 2] hase gov off roxeasabls 

A i 
  

Fa Nota hos Tyo JE. wi Dolowsse on OC.  



  

FATS To STOLE 
  

  

— TF the Stati hud hurmod sen too 21 “Page setowad—~ all wndd have 

com ak 

— Tf Wu stats had admitfed if ehansr gt ndl or jn Skis hades — 
— Shas tnd Ms oa info wre doderitals luted. 
~ Lops acted Claus tb tattle 
= An informed ols di pImusted Sows ip - Speak a and. 

-LU as Comrahan ve. “Fuuctod 24 wivadn) Méerregch 

   



  

® Our caubal fous mug nit be on to cndabyp police 
Misconduct (ry Detechoe Dovsey (Fhaals 4 moh issu) but mn OL 
piseandud J) Ve I-4oaq Coper up,
Copyright notice

This collection and the tools to navigate it (the “Collection”) are available to the public for general educational and research purposes, as well as to preserve and contextualize the history of the content and materials it contains (the “Materials”). Like other archival collections, such as those found in libraries, LDF owns the physical source Materials that have been digitized for the Collection; however, LDF does not own the underlying copyright or other rights in all items and there are limits on how you can use the Materials. By accessing and using the Material, you acknowledge your agreement to the Terms. If you do not agree, please do not use the Materials.
Additional info

To the extent that LDF includes information about the Materials’ origins or ownership or provides summaries or transcripts of original source Materials, LDF does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of such information, transcripts or summaries, and shall not be responsible for any inaccuracies.
SCOTUS, No. 89-7024 - Oral Argument Notes and Outline

Impact area

Topic

LDF Attorneys

Cooperating Attorney

Notable Person

Organizations

Matter

Case

U.S. state

Collection

Taxonomy

Identifier

Cite this item

Copyright notice

Additional info

You may also be interested in
