Memphis Police Incident Report
Working File
1974
-
Case Files, Garner Working Files. Memphis Police Incident Report, 1974. 4f5d3a96-33a8-f011-bbd3-000d3a53d084. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/5b299c95-8474-4e9b-b161-529cd5f1c567/memphis-police-incident-report. Accessed November 11, 2026.
Copied!
Ni.'
i
EITOM R. ■ V a X A c Z m a n
D U T Y S T A T U S
^ O N D U T Y □ O F F D U T Y
2‘}41 I Ca/L n 2 s ! 25
S U S P E C T ’S P R IO R R E C O R D
U n k n o i ^ n
SER Y IC E
V . U
CounCiL'.'.
F o / j £
~h’)rroi4^ocz0i
I
t y p e o f I N C I D E N T - S U C H A S B U R G L A R Y IN P R O G R E S S , F A M I L Y F I G H T , E T C .
? A O l ‘J Z s / i - b l ^ ^ d z .
S E X R A C h / ’
m f ’ l
RS.I N U M B E R
g i v e VVOROIHG^O^f” M E S S A G E ^ T T ^ K N S M r r ^ ^ ^ ■ r a d i o A S S I G N M E N T . O N - V l E W E T C . IF tT T r O U G H R A D I O A S S IG n M ^ ' .
Rcuii.0 ZnbZac. cciLZ.
i , i C H ' i <NC; C O N D IT IO N 'S
□ d a y l i g h t
d u s k
13', N I G H T
□ G O O D A R T I F I C I A L
P O O R A R T I F I C I A L
F u A S H L I G H T
I N C I D E N T O C C U R R E D
□ IN D O O R S
V ^ T I I E R C O N D I T I O N S
C L E A R
□ C L O U D Y
□ R A I N
□ F O G
□ O T H E R
L O C A T I O N O F I N C I D E N T
759 'JoZX.LitA.nz
Li*- O U T D O O R S
I W [E A P O N S D E S C R IP T IO N
I □ C O L T S M I T H & W E S S O N
□ S H O T G U N □ O O B K □ S L U G
, ° “ t h e r □ M P n o o ? >
T Y P E O F P R E M IS E S
'Jack ijojid 0-5 •'Toi-odc.ncc
n u m b e r o f O P P O N E N T S , W H A T W E A P O N S D I D T H E Y U S E
T . . .
! i V o R C
I n u m b e r O F S H O T S F I R E D A T y o u "
done.
l a :. I /vN C E F R O M SUSPF.C F W H E N F I R S T S H O T W A S F I R E D
' S U l jP E C r W H E N L A S T S H O T W A S F I R E D
u . i i C . : k ’S P O S IT IO N :
3 H IP Q S T A N D I N G
2 J f e e t
2 0 f e e t
n u m b e r o f s h o t s F I R E D B Y Y O U ;
i ' 'U C
— ------□ S I T T I N G □ p r o n e □ K N E E l . I N G □ O T H E R - S P E C IF Y
D I D Y O U H A V E W E A P O N D R A W N A N D R E A D Y F O R U S E B E F O R E Y O U N E E D E D i f ;-------------- y 'E S --------------------- D ~ 7 7 5 --------------------
A R E Y O U
□ R IG i- IT H A N I 3 E D [ j ' L E F T H A N D E D
r e m a r k s o r R E C O M M E N D A T I O N S , F O R W E A P O N S O R t ' ^ T n i N g '
I done.
D ID Y O U H A V E T O R E L O A D ?
3 y e s O ' N O
D I D Y O U C O U N T Y O U R S H O T S A S Y O U F l R E D ?
3 y e s Q,' |\j o
I F y e s , H O W m a n y W E R E Y O U A B L E T O R E LO A D ? "
! H O W L O N G D I D IT T A K E S E C O N D S ?
D ID Y o u H A V E T I M E T O S I G H T A N D A I M ?
a Y E S □ N O
̂ D I D Y O U R W E A P O N W O R K P R O P E R L Y ? ----------------------------- ---------
•Q y e s lJ i g p IF N O T , E X P L A I N O N R E V E R S E S ID E
I N J U R I E S ; S U S P E C T W A S ~
O f f i c e ,T i' n C v e d w a s ^ s u p e r f i c i a l l y w o u n d e d
□ N O T w o u n d e d □ S U P E R F I C I A L L Y W O U N D E D
j n u m b e r O F S H O T S FI R E D :
I 3 SI N C .LE A C T I O N □ ' D O U B L E A C T I O N
□ C R I T I C A L L Y V J O U N D E D 3 K I L L E D
□ C R I T I C A L L Y W O U N D E D □ K I L L E D---------------------------------------------- -- -------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------- ' - r . i I W O U N D E D l_j
d e s c r i b e P R O T E C T I V E C O V E R W H IC H Y O U U S E D - S u r H ~ A r i:T 3 n T - p ~ c3 ^,D O O R W A Y S ’, C ^ ^ K T ^ R ^
K O i : e
•V HY OJO Y O U USE Y O U R W t lA P O N ? ~ ̂ "" ---------------------------------------------------- - ----------------— — _______ ______
3 P R O T E C T S E L F □ P R O T E C T C I T I Z E N □ P R E V ^ ^ N T F E L O N Y 3 ' d
□ S U S P E C T W A N T E D F O R . R P R ^ V . N T F E L O N Y 0 PR E V E N T ESC A P E O R F L I G H T O F A F E . .O N
LJ O T H E R - SPECI F Y
• - 2 1 0 0 . ] 4 9 / I• - 2 1 0 0 .3 4 9
■ : " C .
WRIG.-rr, LfSL'/G B. PcU/io Oran
J . . . , «l ..
I UF8, iVoA^ut I
9 2 7 3 ! C a / L < ^ J 2 S I 2 6
P H IO K O C C U ' ■
u t
S E R V IC E
I l̂ Vi.
D U T Y S T A T U S
□ ( O N D U T Y □ O F F D U T Y
S U S P E C T ’S P R IO R R F C O R D
U n k n o u t n
T Y P E O F I N C I D E N T • S U C H A S B U R G L A R Y IN P R O G R E S S . F A M I L Y F I G H T . E T C .
M i 6 p ' ^ . c ^ ^ i e ( U n g .
R & l N U M B E R
0570
D E S C R IB E M A N N E R IN W H IC H Y O U B E C A M E I N V O L V E D - S U C H A S R A D I O A S S I G N M E N T . O N - V I E W E T C . IF T H R O U G H R A D I O A S S I C n W i^R i '
G I V E W O R D IN G O F M E S S A G E T R A N S M I T T E R .
Raxiio ai^^giwiant, P.'LCioiz.'L J,n.ildc..
L iG i iT l iV : C O N D IT IO N S 1 W E A T H E R C O N D IT IO N S L O C A T I O N O F I N C I D E N T
—
u d a y l i g h t C L E A R 1
D U S K 1
' □ C L O U D Y 7 3 9 l / o c i- O ’u Z o ic .
□ N IG I - IT 1' □ R A I N 1--------------------------------------------
□ G O O D A R T I F I C I A L 11 □ F O G 1
1 □ C O L T
W E A P O N S D E S C R IP T IO N
□ P O O R A R T I F I C I A L 1
1 ^
O T H E R Q S M I T H ii. W E S S O N
□ F L A S I I L I G H T
11 j □ S H O T G U N □ 0 0 B K □ S L U G
— .^ ,„J
1
1 -
* □ O T H E R
1
□ M P O G U .
I N C I D E N T O C C U R R E D ' T Y P E O F P R E M IS E S
□ IN D O O R S iZ l^ ' O U T D O O R S
1
1 d a d I ' O M d 0
i
1
< a e i - c d c . n c e .
N U M B C .R O F O P P O N E N T S j W H A T W E A P O N S D I D T H E Y USE ' N U M U E R O F S H O T S FI R E D A T Y O U
;
1
1
K ' o n c . 1 W o H E
1
U IS T ? \N C E F R O M S U S P E C T W H E N F I R S T S F IOT W A S F I R E D F E E T N U M B E R O F S H O T S FI R E D B Y Y O U ;
D IS T A N C E F R O M S U S P E C T W H E N L A S T S H O T W A S F \R E D F E E T
i l o m
O i ' i T C F R ’i ; I’ O S IT .O N :
□ H IP □ S T A N D I N G □ S I T T I N G □ P R O N E □ K N E E L I N G □ O T H E R • S P E C IF Y
D ID Y O U H A V E W E A P O N D R A W N A N D R E A D Y F O R U S E B E F O R E Y O U N E E D E D IT ? □ Y E S □ N O
A R E Y O U
R I G H T H A N D E D □ L E F T H A N D E D
R E M A R K S O R R E C O M M E N D A T I O N S . F O R W E A P O N S O R T R A I N I N G
i \ ' o n .p .
D ID Y O U H A V E T O R E L O A D ?
□ Y E S N O
j IF Y E S , H O W m a n y W E R E Y O U A B L E T O F iE L O A D ?
I H O W L O N G D I D IT T A K E S E C O N D S ?
D I D Y O U C O U N T Y O U R S H O T S A S Y O U F I R E D ?
□ Y t S □ N O
D ID Y O U H A V E T I IV |^ T O S I G H T A N D AliW?
□ y e s C T '' n o
I N J U R I E S : S U S P E C T W A S
□ N O T W O U N D E D
O F F IC E R I N V O L V E D W A S
Q N O T W O U N D E D
D I D Y O U R W E A P O N V /O R K P R O P E R L Y ?
□ Y E S □ N O IF N O T . E X P L A I N O N R E V E R S E S ID E
N U M B E R O F S H O T S F I R E D :
□ S I N G L E A C T I O N □ D O U B L E A C T I O N
□ S U P E R F I C I A L L Y V J O U N D E D
□ S U P E R F I C I A L L Y W O U N D E D
□ C R I T I C A L L Y W O U N D E D Q K I L L E D
n C R I T I C A L L Y W O U N D E D □ K I L L E D
d e s c r i b e P R O T E C T I V E C O V E R W H IC H Y O U U S E D - S U C H A S L I G H T P O L E S ’. . D O O R W A Y S ’. 'C A R . F U R N ' i T U R E . E T c !"
i V o i i e
W H Y D I D Y O U USE Y O U R W E A P O N ?
□ P R O T E C T S E L F □ P R O T E C T C I T I E E N
□ S U S P E C T W A N T E D F O R ;
□ P R E V E N T F E L O N Y P R E V E N T E S C A P E O R F L I G H T O F A F E l O N
□ O T H E R - S P E C IF Y
B A C K G R O U N D - Y /H A T D I D B U L L E T S S T R I K E IF Y O U M IS S E D
1 uuiZiU. by pa/UiieA, d id no-C vUm .
Sb!. ^ d e t a i l e d n a r r a t i v e A C C O U N T O F T H E I N C I D E N T G I V I N G P A R T I C U L A R A T T E N T I O N T O P R O B L E M s ”
W H IC H Y O U E N C O U N T E R E D 1 H A T C O U L D H A V E B E E N A V O I D E D T H R O U G H M O R E A D E Q U A T E T R A I N I N G , B E T T E R E Q U I P M E N T , E T C ’
F - 2 1 0 0 .1 4 9
KtcQA-vzd a "pfiô -xtcA. -itu^de." zoMi -ti 7 3 7 VoUUiitiyit. Upon <ivU.vci.i, (ce
mzt by a FS, 32, VcU ŷ S - t o t t i , ic/ o -CiJCA cX 131 i/oZLcrXlnz^ Shz
r.iCiZonzd tc'.m/id 139 V oZ iln tim , Z3iz /xn .Jic cUAzcittj t o tb z c z i t of, kzn
home and ita^tzd t f ia t ioinzont' bad cAokai tn t o Hhz iica iz and t h e y ive/iz hu>tdz
139 I'oL tdtttnz i:on\
PtZn:. Jyirvn took h to fZa6lxtghx. and advtazd -to iko'.: u6 on thz ^eznz axxd
iiz tkan pKcczzdzd dcio:i triz ivnAt i t d z . o f 139 \loZJ3in.‘3inz t o th z 4oa-tj'u<;e6-t coxuiaA.
I ir,avcd ouJl ta fi facin th z cZivt&Xi. o f 'JoZdLintA.Kz tn fa cn it o f 137 UcZZiiUt.nz t o
tn(. ^ ou tk itdz o f \JotZtnXLnQ. tn f/LOixt o f 759. At tkz z>ar,'z ttrnz, I adv-uzd
tko. d tipa tek iA -tii'o tA/nzi, t h a t wa k 'g a c on thz icAr.?., bcX)U\ acknoi'jZzdgzd thz
■izcond tir iz .
'[ pnoczc-dzd to tht zazt z>-ide of 129 l̂ o<JUnttne. and 1 nzacJ-.zd tkz nofotk
czuit zoxulzb, I iiza/id thz back <icAC.au doon of -uic hou^c zZoju and Offtazi M
diji-non i.'cZ-C "daZt" to Aomcanc and then aftcA a zhont pau&c, I hc.oAd one A'not.
I th en aan t o the. Aouth&oit conn ea o f 119 ‘doZ iZnttne and AtUned ir.ij flaA hZ lght
t n t o t h e back ijaa.d lohcAc I Acco O f f t c c a I'.tjrr.on. h e AcUd, ''Hc. 'a on th z fen ced '.
I tJien obACAoed t h e MK Aubje.ct Accmped cvza t i i e t o p o f a high c y c t .o n e f e n c e
bZeeding pKofnAety fa on a u’OfO'tri to t h e head.
J aan back -co the Aouad can end eaZ.leJ foa an aiiibuZancc as Office/t 'dijtnon
eXXoepted to Ace to the AexUouAneAA of the Aubjec-t'A leoundA. 1 a.iAo caZied
fca a LietXenant and Catme Scene Ca/i to w.eet at the Aezne. T aeturAed
■\o the Ata/i of the houAe and OfftceA H'jre.on hxid gotXen the AubjecX dcien faom
tJ:e fence.
1 bbAOJaecA the acoa. dooA and'Aevetuai i<t.i:doe:A id'Xch had been attempted. The.
aeoA dooA A*Z(̂ htZij open and a pane of gZaAA aoA bAoken. A acoa (/Xndoio
h{id been Loioken tiXo and a Aide cjindou' AcAeen m u Zijtng on the gAound on
the eaAt Aide.
Z then leent ncK-t dcoA to 737 VoZZintine to obiicXn the infoAnaticn fAom .'die
.■iQXj'ibo'U. atni to adoiAe ther', to AariaXn iriide foA fuAtheA queAtioiXng. I
Aett.Aned to the fAOiX of 739 VoZaUntine in t̂ ime to Aee u't£ .'!C iubject being
u'heeZed otXo the FiAC VepoAtment AmbiXarce by Fiow VepaAtment attendants.
Oidne 5ccne Ccw. H313 made t h e Aeene cuid Aipha CAuiACA, a lon g lo ith Lt. C. K.
Vavis, CaK. made ti-.e A eene.
7 i / r ^ y ^ t v / ' ^
y y _ _ i / o i ! s r J r i r J s . ^ ' / ^ ' 7 ■ ■ _ £ 3 Z L l2 Z J ? Z
" ’. ^ ^ / 'J y d - C L ^ '
'>.-. •• '-‘-v^ • • *■
( '
V
aibort; Presea D. Ch. II. M. Lea'-'jierwood
Lt. j-.D. Music
Capt. J.A. Coletta
Lt. E.G. Bailey
Sgt. J.M. Holt Sgt. B.Qt Cox
Ptlm. L. Clemmer Ptlm. R.T. Archibald
Ptlm. C.D. Cothran
Legal Advisor:
Pocorder fo r the Board;
Mr. Joseph Dailey
Mr. . Sam ‘ Knowlton.- Ptlm. K.E. Crocker
Hearing // ^_~74
Si tua t ion :
Ptlm. E.R. Ilymon (Hatae of o f f i c e r s )
Firing service revolver at fleeing felony suspect (Burglary)
- 2300 hours, 5 October 1974, 739 Vollentine.
Situation Sutamary: Officers responded to a "prowler inside" call at 737
Vollentine and were directed' to 7 39 Vollentine by a complainant on the
scene. As Ptlm. Hymon approached the building he noticed a MB run from
the rear of the building and observed a broken window at tne rear of
the building. The Officer ordered the suspect to halt, and when the
suspect refused, the Officer fired one (1) round at the suspect as the
suspect was going over a fense at the rear of 739 Vollentine. The sus
pect was hit in the head and killed.
Board's Summary Findings:
A. The Board finds that Ptlm. Hymon was justified in the use of deadly
force.
A c tio n : No action necessary.
A p p r o v e
^ (Hcmber)