Attorney Notes; Memorandum from Guinier to Liebman and Boger
Working File
March 18, 1983

Cite this item
-
Case Files, Bozeman & Wilder Working Files. Memorandum from Gibbs to Guinier, 1984. a13d0e4f-ef92-ee11-be37-6045bdeb8873. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/cce136be-b678-43e4-98a0-8100da066764/memorandum-from-gibbs-to-guinier. Accessed April 06, 2025.
Copied!
@ L,t-a; k,M^ Tmrv', V r,^ YlJf* D^P ' 'l*4tt ^,'lru b, f4t4 k . Ms,' lp'llr^'t Cuq fttrf.O Q,rut,", Wr^rr^k a t td\rjful-, fl,@ dJhtilL Or,, -t urll )^ u*,4q a-t lYu. W,[d]" Wa Lowvi't 0 Ou T)/L be-;- ?, tr,^s^5i.,-,*-t. 3l^{ Lfr,*ALA t" & ^fpL-,! 4 {iuJ W *fW'^ZLil^L tiolnco' Pff'd;1 a<W Co*u Lc,?"0,n Wel 0.,.,.wr',t rt J- A4 T/2 1.4r"* (."r^4 P, I & / 44s u. r 301 (lgl r) PA a 4ffL** iA b{,"kJ h /'^l** L,trTut /1,4 4 k i hJ I/"r^* W o^ fr,.e- 1lunl t/.r{/tntz- L/dr.,rrJ a/ .T/tr- k',o! /Yv, wtirnrl .(";v 6 W 6,,4 4rr/ t",,-/ \/1J' 66 % W buyt ct, /1tt-6^il/L d,,l,t lt , 441 U- f . al 3 L(- 7* o.on-tu,alr- -W brutd.9 b Ih* U{"t'fYwrsl h4t, f{ Wror a&-a- t" [l^L yua-a,tL^ T() d ? L6 . ?. Ly'a.a, tL/ tL Brut+L Dg^car^ \t. 9l7nyLu"^L-t 764 € U (^ Lt,B ),' t*Lt^u.: a*,t t/. [lc4/nq , 6S z b(c, (ru c), /tr) lo.zL I bt e. cf, )a t q,6? /. il. zl I u 60r. 4s t L(. r. s1 s Qqn), c-orr+{ rwrrt-s I dd0"^\^4- 9,s ( ffi*- (/,-b ry M w'J rw.t /1/.,t^ 1'< lm L4" 4 0,r.!-'' L;c\ , &rfil^yL in u <1* u,,i ;" Wat4^L$1 fre Aa.)o,,-, Mt+k #t t l-{.An;* s1,r1<- LC^, t' /.Ai^"a/'Jr t W Ct*b, D,r-nr-- u 1uf € 2J t>t? i tz tt/( tl'tt (;. ltu ?b du{<*uvJt b.,l lrJ'l,rGl"r* 44- < GJr'tz{,-t-t I 4arh,wl -Aolxr* curp* 4,*+ P wL{L a'- /wu{d \hlnc,,Q. WrU"} s.^1P,s.{, Wu-,v.q_Vx_.\ aflW iJ{-'4 dr,4 n^* %y,^ ,bu,*r\- W #. (; (,t-d b-eoL6-l y Pttrh G"W ir^ Yuo' ^Tl^' 4w,"*L^, V rr c/rr^r- ., %. 1., 14-k /'taolJl*. " Sul'r*^ '- 413A.c. d 34, ;* .yrv*Sl bL ?.ov4r^ 't4*k IL. ft\( . l,O,U,u- fuo-, Cqu:r*A -{V;t^*;, g n- ?fuil rt y* Lk g h-;dd^^^^ Pt 15 / ,JJ W;b i put^.-+ f*l t htLa Pu' \ tt nt t,u$"o v o k t rwl $,1Q t(,t^ or fupur,ll, ,rrr,- T^a,A oAa- b4!/5+ lnr fu0- sa,** W o-, -4; u*- 'A,* Ur^ l).-o-<f*qt or la',,-'*.fu q{<,^fb h vo&'ur)*-' 4'- ; A.+ !*',14il + bo^so1 rLffi,\w1 k ,A I ,utl.r*Q or ]^at,it,Ja*T **T\, *tf 6.' %wrlt!L^' L'<- y."WL-"^'J h -Ki- P^tL4+;"1 \o' U-- 4(* 1,^/t )tutt .atLo,-.- fu^ b W, d,, fr* dLo'rj)-oc,- 7 la Y1 ' {nr e Ot^rr}tnn t b. obhu*',-^9 urr,4a g t1- 0.J-l z frrLLLUr'-g o^,"fu@ fa*r) { /o# ttttult- (/'-*'' G AnU. W:uLs,,^ v. e{il* /€ 2 +h, )4q/ ?o Z L tt 1t ) ', l/rl fu^ /. g 1*1c, ct6 I gu u / / /sl , LLc> (frlo h;- ftfr,.) , o*t t ' 'l- 4bt fo ,d lbs aru, (%r), ul / -i , L drrfu* cr#t h16*;;, s,uq^*tt4 C^rUdr^L Ar) X ff,* &rJ I"/.6-"/ h Vo, qu |\ns- Wfu*Q*z-- fr,@ at*oun* q t^Jo^r-- ,+1"* hutt^+- tplt-' Cr-e lh [^,* rvW'vvto- q^ Wt* (rt" fu"'rr-/ ffimwYLwbff* prd*l wp rgwrwau-t I4N;-A^L./ b,"..{.o1.' l,tu* + fuL iw).n( hYLuq Vok-.hx&- ?*'yfl\LtgJ,rb, rr pl,* l"*l 'a;* h )Mr*1 a frl'L b4,*<, 0^,-,1 aL u-h L V=-t hrrq +Lre i. u 'l'la; t Q^tl.^r t" Vrr.' ,hA a^;-J.9 fr fi-tL4 co,^L-l lWaDM^,Flz flil t-rfu^l'6 fu^a-a.',."+'d o\uJi U|* uil/t- rr^ tl "1"* [i,Ll /^ (/^- buJkh .l^!^?,).{ wl tu+ YLtuW^ lL ,^l+ 0tl w,y a)dlrwflry dtl Wb $*,-^l*p h^i: +fu)w4 n"{ WTTnV ffi Trnf fi"*fo W qt a@vg fvww ry Vf,*fd u*,)nY W ffi yy-drfi*a mr *p r-f V.*nil o .t\1+su?-) L-r* jw) ,f+ y n-rry| Amvfux \.L )yl'"rl ,,ri4 =trd'rwv hq Wry t"**'1'r1 {4 ?q ?t*,.*"7vt 4-*f,^,r+ty ut f{ryu(J ry ) lw W u,etrrcp tf*--)* f-,,qO \ l*\? %ropdl % dr,avr ri"'r"r,f \^""oa,1';, M 0 b ,yenry ywfl ^fl- ua fniy ?N\d t ''n")lT *-efd +ry o'[?)|-flln x m f:'t?P aL 'b ]a+W a'ry'*?rr'}1l tf 'PT- y*r1/ -)t \.Pnrnyt n a_ fli+ ryv 4Y8 J^d 'J h s l ttlh *r.,f vvoto wn,) ,e"q @)i -tTqul @ U4^AL ?rfr.lL^ta AnA wa) TJ,4 U-fu-ac-t- +1,.4 lqiL Lil^;) h^ Uil/tt)-,^ tn t4^ p"tr{*,ntu\ a^l ,",1* fr,- ,W*lb^k c*in ; fr&, 'v1a*g,,, tls f Sr*fp . kZ Cs-t) l@ 1L &-Fr* ,^,^+ kp* c-o,tr.q 0,,,*9 \!.5{r\1& +;[+L*^e) clir"; dr^r**r) -W fu,1o^J.n^l- t'+\ k"l- a Ar-i\rL**"0 Wr*, \W-1, ci^^1 7L<t- pr( lilL t trt-,r,*ff W (rr4J Mf,nar*f lr),*, + uJ-il**.1"'w TL& ()/6- lid**u- +. y+'h a,n$,^*J &u^ q,wfw ew W"",L a A).-o<o,n-lrls- dt:urtrT. tt 5 tI- f.s4 r of 16+- lb< ck r1.o<qo* Ar*# CD tra,- ${^ 3odrf qM W @**,,^ to to,n1 t^r,V^ .lL C"-t*, M-I,A Wd- y 3o d*{ +1""-^{. l^^ f/f f,Suff, o* lU r . Ll,la,l il^* "-l)-.b+ t r,.*p a,u-l w & -Ur"t-,9 LWL h t4t), \,h" Wt fl^,Q- lufu)-t &-} t^ Lb,nrtdu..1 urlqfl^^ fr M ttu,^r"1 d^/ qfr,,# i,^ b,,, ( fi, MlPo-lt* b{ A4,'i<^o @ur fr* at*,L'^,,.; Ut^ /0f& L hJ ["u^ r-" Lbwr,>k) s, h fi-6?^ir 6juu- il"e W apmarl tld-k' -1, fh** J4 d $u d"ur"**= .' 44* s//^k 'ff"t * a,n/3 &rr^ ; /^j<* uT* f.{,{|u a / fl- ru-*iua ^ d,r,^-; n*./ fr4/'- 'r ,u-V--rf-L muf,'bm. .,V' , ,o , 66 z E e/ zJZz. @ dA / ' /W @ /-o6r-f ccya.t /zore/ fu- \U/ru^*J b1 -f^;! Orq{.JL* A}r*l 1af4' tulAil l^ h"t Q*U u->4r-*t a b,Tl,. Nl;'; W {-- tli,"A'|I hil hr^{lt}+u^,o o' t)occ,-,au*. (J ut v I w fu4 Wr ["a{.na Y,* d;li-* 6*r| ( u. C',/r* ,b6?€il at rr (. , t, pfrl;,^ ,fu tu,*4 I h)lh^ but 'L Wt, k;"* A*4 t' (*, ),L-! 4 aztq*t*/ t M,q gnltua tlrt t-4- "vrr4"/4/ r/a,*t'u-/ a{' fr^L &ak A(lrj. Oqr\+l s*tanor!1 UJ Ca*&rdil flqf 'ilu- qn'/e,^ct- le rv'"1 r' ffi ful'rJl*,l^ tvtl N [4,,ru'AA y /l^ /1.0-*-u.//- 1-,1 p ul/ti f l,ut 4u Lr*rt-L 4hfr, t( f;d4e,^ {^- W CA)n+/ /LilrJ t(ti,a, d^>Gr* b*,+ 6 H'+ rafu--wu laira fi*-Jr*livr-y uL&'- W ttac.tttrch;{*1 etn'ltnc'L (D d4 arl ({1,TU-+b/ Y4 tu'u* tH* oa ( a(ro . ,t-ta *,^t 1qtu:;:; ;, i-;.fu / ii r,--+- - ryr & a (l4u,L;^,-ti W d*(r:,k rn*rl s /t{,lrtyu4+ ,e!. N @ azr,'l /D/4,,11<4 + \dlr+-- U*P* frf++*^ a,l.lrg { pq- wfu,-cz, X A e+ g8? - (r't. 1 klt),Y^/ry tuN, +I'n] *L u,* t 1u* T,,* u,-t krLlP,^Rl d a>ust Y^ru-Ar.u!- W tlr,llrrrfu ,\{s- b";\lA) ch; \) frrr^ W /1r-!^L1 a^-a-{--.- lau-.*, ,}-d4 D t^ r,-6Vr.r;-, 9q ,c, th1 U^d Wt,t,aJtnl"t- h,'!,'4r")r#- f "d* X {l* {c+;^.,*, Atr ffi"rh&,W;W;!r' , Wlt^"L f,u*"-W a W Xt t*f*" W,^A 4d** n.,,1 + W dgla€rr>,^a-1L -.f.1W-r,+4* +<,+i"r^- X p..$,'errro, t^il"o g^4- U^+ L *H'{^"r$ ks fi*+ fl,g b.4.^,}. n-, og L + .!yuJ* 'lAil {*l Wu: }rJ d ",,^'-;^",1"1 )rtn)t',,Lrr-o4itl W F;*4" Vr-*' n/u'<4 {, b d'u"r+. l"tt- UJld'h, +;,1 \nl da^ cr"hl b.&, Pl"* tta& 6,a!^ P.H:,rrn\ Ai^ff<-6 fuA^ry F-xrYv-^,.-!*^ arv,A 'l-t-*+ A,L<- l-.9 cLAa/r,k^g b Nbv \ hw+ /'1^ .W WbJrv,, t>r"r*uT)r*-, W-rl aJ [-Luv- UJ { l't'18 %- Al,ro c,on ca-LA W Arl,a -l-A pru),-J "-ft dla.,'lza- boJJ^+s + wd'rry fr,ad- )^^r* U qY* w@ t\* pn'cl.!,,. .,- T!4b"Vra ^J il,Lr. fu\/tr^'t (n:'J- ,lrlXt^/d- W y 1ot*Dv'L' t\A^M y* wl,tust b*l,ul-r Ur4^L tu/1L6,^fl aJrrl )v* *< 1"""^.,^1 t o-, lr*\ Le^ b Ms, h,ryt A4-tr-i Ltn--l*- ltar. /41* Oluat Urwd [hr, h/,a1 [-;nes.Vol So.Ud]lel-/ez' 'JloOfuY q 1Ur* o..l.{^0" Cp',"l AA; o' e-,'tfun-u{ . frl* rkt< "fldirJ* l,Uv b"+t^ b"Ntu\ il'!,-l b^lMy, A*1, eqwh,r'q a" lnh o t,'L t*o')*a W!r^" ilA).4.+;+'wwo\ wu 4uroJ,u ' -l L,o til. "1,'- fvt^st-uLL trW b". dt-Vfu ,',|il)a il,a/r!- A- upr,t{'*ov t"^ '4fu"^^ fr^r^ T"fue. A; g,.r^* rgrLu ,/rr+/ d;t ;h^P"l { .kL hr 6r6t, fiJ*- ftlsw/ Da,1^r- ( 4.4 +1Q l I q!.---tt)Jr* url,*-@ h - - W;$"'dd- W tuAb,t a* tt^* pttlt, *!* At!, Ue aJ,)'t'r)<& hoJ/"u+'- lhillr- l* /,*rri$ t l,*t^uY- a* fi!- %ru*.hJlr^y 0v-^r6 b(/t rr 01,* We^^n) l^-L- t1** ar) CiLu,> il)*L 1'(qtl^.'cua+^ 0 +BW 6n* A,l,'\Ud 7 ffi Now L MJa^^Gl ( Utl<-, lln,,,,'t- tfLs*+l*A {Ja, 0 Offii^fu ry u- ,"1 +@ W a^l a)t al.L, Ml /llr/J ,aVU,,nh*Ju-, ,n,'.lL Irruh o//-tu. T1". W tt)b',ar*/ c;"j bu '{,"* t CAri-\ h,,;,*0 A'?Tu"Lt 41/,rlf*1 il[..^'f q>UAk\ yrvt dlr^a Ah Lo,nl*'j'^-*t"'-" f-o ?rVL(. t W rlfuA\ Cl,ar^;r, 'U*rl- {tY. a-Aa !-'t*t*o'^l X TL'* % Uf W l,-l t.,u^ b,^,*-p^+/X^*f nia4't u)^ ae|lyt st^^,^*A uc,".* tA^76.,,tjn."f.t: lqz, W WCqil@ & ; p"; | *Ll.*\ sld-,,0 'et lrr- wLlu &;,& ,,,*+ W {ak l.; [ruk LT* Ft,u M tfurtfr^t', erfr,h, fu fYl'n (tmn'u1L'* 0 !*a ,ur. t*tl.L, U*l /; a-.u,rtr^{ Jr,f,bLJ nW 0L lA D,,.. /^a4^,4-4 on ) 0 fl,, dq b-llct uLl* r:v-sl 4"* 4-''N'- U ith'",r t,r,,^@ a^* -t/to- htuf , T, l7(, /f'-1 . . t - l r , fu 11,"^ Cctv^ l^-r^tq ; d,wdap ff orr;-Ar"^,o +l,r^4 Al"s. Ur,l"fu4u€+CLll i{r:. 0rn^,--,dna^'t uk, tn 4w ard* ft,f frl*n"il sk(I t- lU,rT^4,- a t fr;"^f frt*wo'il Sk(r- *'ll {ilr^\ w;,*1",r",1 y,,,,; io^ .