Attorney Notes; Memorandum from Guinier to Liebman and Boger

Working File
March 18, 1983

Attorney Notes; Memorandum from Guinier to Liebman and Boger preview

Cite this item

  • Case Files, Bozeman & Wilder Working Files. Memorandum from Gibbs to Guinier, 1984. a13d0e4f-ef92-ee11-be37-6045bdeb8873. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/cce136be-b678-43e4-98a0-8100da066764/memorandum-from-gibbs-to-guinier. Accessed April 06, 2025.

    Copied!

    @

L,t-a; k,M^
Tmrv', V r,^ YlJf*
D^P ' 'l*4tt ^,'lru b, f4t4

k . Ms,' lp'llr^'t Cuq fttrf.O

Q,rut,", Wr^rr^k a

t td\rjful-, fl,@ dJhtilL Or,, -t urll )^ u*,4q a-t
lYu. W,[d]" Wa Lowvi't 0 Ou T)/L be-;- ?, tr,^s^5i.,-,*-t.

3l^{ Lfr,*ALA t" & 
^fpL-,! 4 {iuJ

W *fW'^ZLil^L tiolnco' Pff'd;1 a<W

Co*u Lc,?"0,n Wel 0.,.,.wr',t rt J- A4 T/2 1.4r"* (."r^4 P,
I

& / 44s u. r 301 (lgl r) PA a 4ffL**

iA b{,"kJ h /'^l** L,trTut /1,4 4 k i hJ

I/"r^* W o^ fr,.e- 1lunl t/.r{/tntz- L/dr.,rrJ a/ .T/tr-

k',o! /Yv, wtirnrl .(";v 
6 W 6,,4 4rr/ t",,-/

\/1J' 
66 % W buyt ct, /1tt-6^il/L d,,l,t lt

, 441 U- f . al 3 L(- 7* o.on-tu,alr-

-W brutd.9 b Ih* U{"t'fYwrsl

h4t, f{ Wror a&-a- t" [l^L yua-a,tL^ T() d ? L6 .



?. Ly'a.a,

tL/
tL Brut+L

Dg^car^ \t. 9l7nyLu"^L-t 764 € U
(^ Lt,B ),' t*Lt^u.: a*,t t/. [lc4/nq , 6S z

b(c, (ru c), /tr)

lo.zL I bt e. cf, )a t q,6? /. il. zl
I u 60r.

4s t L(. r.

s1 s Qqn),

c-orr+{ rwrrt-s I

dd0"^\^4- 9,s

( ffi*- (/,-b ry M w'J rw.t

/1/.,t^ 1'< lm L4" 4 0,r.!-'' L;c\ , &rfil^yL in u

<1* u,,i ;"

Wat4^L$1 fre Aa.)o,,-, Mt+k

#t t l-{.An;* s1,r1<- LC^, t'

/.Ai^"a/'Jr t W Ct*b, D,r-nr-- u

1uf € 2J t>t? i tz tt/( tl'tt (;. ltu ?b

du{<*uvJt b.,l lrJ'l,rGl"r* 44- < GJr'tz{,-t-t
I

4arh,wl 
-Aolxr* curp* 4,*+ P wL{L a'-

/wu{d \hlnc,,Q. WrU"} s.^1P,s.{,

Wu-,v.q_Vx_.\

aflW iJ{-'4 dr,4 n^* 
%y,^



,bu,*r\- W #. (; (,t-d b-eoL6-l

y Pttrh G"W ir^ Yuo' ^Tl^' 
4w,"*L^,

V rr c/rr^r- .,

%. 1., 14-k /'taolJl*. " Sul'r*^ '-

413A.c. d 34,

;* .yrv*Sl bL ?.ov4r^ 't4*k IL.

ft\( . l,O,U,u- fuo-, Cqu:r*A -{V;t^*;,
g n- ?fuil rt y* Lk g h-;dd^^^^ Pt 15 / ,JJ

W;b i put^.-+ f*l
t 

htLa Pu' \ tt nt t,u$"o v o k t rwl $,1Q t(,t^

or fupur,ll, ,rrr,- T^a,A oAa- b4!/5+

lnr fu0- sa,** W o-, -4; u*-
'A,* Ur^ l).-o-<f*qt or la',,-'*.fu
q{<,^fb h vo&'ur)*-' 4'- ; A.+

!*',14il + bo^so1 rLffi,\w1
k ,A I ,utl.r*Q or ]^at,it,Ja*T
**T\, *tf 

6.' %wrlt!L^' L'<-

y."WL-"^'J h -Ki- P^tL4+;"1 \o'
U-- 4(* 1,^/t )tutt .atLo,-.- fu^ b
W, d,, fr* dLo'rj)-oc,- 7 la
Y1 '

{nr e Ot^rr}tnn t b. obhu*',-^9 urr,4a

g t1- 0.J-l 
z

frrLLLUr'-g o^,"fu@ fa*r) { /o# ttttult- (/'-*''



G

AnU. W:uLs,,^ v. e{il* /€ 2 +h, )4q/ ?o Z

L tt 1t ) ', l/rl fu^ /. g 1*1c, ct6 I gu u
/

/
/sl , LLc> (frlo h;- ftfr,.) , o*t

t ' 'l-

4bt fo ,d lbs aru, (%r), ul / -i ,

L drrfu* cr#t h16*;;, s,uq^*tt4

C^rUdr^L Ar) X 
ff,*

&rJ

I"/.6-"/ h Vo, qu |\ns-

Wfu*Q*z--

fr,@ at*oun* q t^Jo^r--
,+1"* hutt^+- tplt-' Cr-e

lh [^,* rvW'vvto- q^ Wt* (rt" fu"'rr-/

ffimwYLwbff*
prd*l wp rgwrwau-t I4N;-A^L./
b,"..{.o1.' l,tu* + fuL iw).n(
hYLuq Vok-.hx&- ?*'yfl\LtgJ,rb, rr pl,* l"*l 'a;* h )Mr*1
a frl'L b4,*<, 0^,-,1 aL u-h L V=-t
hrrq +Lre i. u 'l'la; t Q^tl.^r t"
Vrr.' ,hA a^;-J.9 fr fi-tL4 co,^L-l

lWaDM^,Flz flil t-rfu^l'6
fu^a-a.',."+'d o\uJi U|* uil/t-
rr^ tl "1"* [i,Ll /^ (/^- buJkh
.l^!^?,).{ wl tu+ YLtuW^ lL ,^l+



0tl
w,y a)dlrwflry dtl Wb

$*,-^l*p h^i: +fu)w4 n"{ WTTnV

ffi Trnf fi"*fo W qt

a@vg fvww ry Vf,*fd u*,)nY W ffi
yy-drfi*a mr *p r-f V.*nil o

.t\1+su?-) L-r* jw) ,f+ y n-rry| Amvfux \.L

)yl'"rl ,,ri4 =trd'rwv hq Wry t"**'1'r1 {4
?q ?t*,.*"7vt 4-*f,^,r+ty ut f{ryu(J ry

) lw W u,etrrcp tf*--)* f-,,qO \ l*\?
%ropdl % dr,avr 

ri"'r"r,f \^""oa,1';, M
0
b ,yenry ywfl ^fl- ua fniy ?N\d t ''n")lT

*-efd +ry

o'[?)|-flln x

m
f:'t?P aL 'b

]a+W a'ry'*?rr'}1l tf 'PT-

y*r1/ -)t \.Pnrnyt n

a_ fli+ ryv 4Y8 J^d
'J h s l ttlh *r.,f vvoto wn,)

,e"q @)i -tTqul



@

U4^AL ?rfr.lL^ta AnA wa) TJ,4 U-fu-ac-t- +1,.4

lqiL Lil^;) h^ Uil/tt)-,^ tn t4^ p"tr{*,ntu\

a^l ,",1* fr,- ,W*lb^k c*in ; fr&,

'v1a*g,,, tls f Sr*fp . kZ Cs-t)

l@ 1L &-Fr* ,^,^+ kp* c-o,tr.q

0,,,*9 \!.5{r\1& +;[+L*^e) clir";

dr^r**r) -W fu,1o^J.n^l- t'+\ k"l- a Ar-i\rL**"0

Wr*, \W-1, ci^^1 7L<t- pr( lilL
t trt-,r,*ff W (rr4J Mf,nar*f

lr),*, + uJ-il**.1"'w TL& ()/6-

lid**u- +. y+'h a,n$,^*J

&u^ q,wfw ew
W"",L a A).-o<o,n-lrls- dt:urtrT. 

tt

5 tI- f.s4 r of 16+- lb< ck r1.o<qo* Ar*#



CD

tra,- ${^ 3odrf

qM W @**,,^

to to,n1 t^r,V^ .lL C"-t*, M-I,A

Wd- y 3o d*{ +1""-^{. l^^

f/f

f,Suff, o* lU r .

Ll,la,l il^* "-l)-.b+ t r,.*p a,u-l w & -Ur"t-,9

LWL h t4t), \,h" Wt fl^,Q- lufu)-t

&-} t^ Lb,nrtdu..1 urlqfl^^ fr M ttu,^r"1

d^/ 
qfr,,# i,^ b,,, ( fi, MlPo-lt* b{ A4,'i<^o

@ur fr* at*,L'^,,.; Ut^ /0f& L hJ ["u^
r-"

Lbwr,>k) s, h fi-6?^ir 6juu- il"e W

apmarl

tld-k'

-1, fh**
J4

d $u d"ur"**= .' 44* s//^k 'ff"t * a,n/3

&rr^ ; /^j<* uT* f.{,{|u 
a / fl-

ru-*iua 
^ 

d,r,^-; n*./ fr4/'- 'r ,u-V--rf-L

muf,'bm. .,V' , ,o , 66 z E e/ zJZz.



@

dA / ' /W @ /-o6r-f ccya.t /zore/ fu-

\U/ru^*J b1 -f^;! Orq{.JL* A}r*l 1af4'

tulAil l^ h"t Q*U u->4r-*t a b,Tl,. Nl;';

W {-- tli,"A'|I hil hr^{lt}+u^,o o' t)occ,-,au*.
(J ut v I

w fu4 Wr ["a{.na Y,* d;li-* 6*r| (

u. C',/r* ,b6?€il

at rr (. , 
t, pfrl;,^ ,fu tu,*4

I

h)lh^ but 'L Wt, k;"* A*4 t' (*, ),L-! 4 aztq*t*/

t M,q gnltua tlrt t-4- "vrr4"/4/ r/a,*t'u-/ a{'

fr^L &ak A(lrj. Oqr\+l s*tanor!1 UJ

Ca*&rdil flqf 'ilu- qn'/e,^ct- le rv'"1 r' ffi
ful'rJl*,l^ tvtl N [4,,ru'AA y /l^ /1.0-*-u.//-

1-,1 p ul/ti f l,ut 4u Lr*rt-L 4hfr, t( f;d4e,^ {^-

W CA)n+/ /LilrJ t(ti,a, d^>Gr* b*,+



6

H'+

rafu--wu laira fi*-Jr*livr-y uL&'-

W ttac.tttrch;{*1 etn'ltnc'L (D d4

arl ({1,TU-+b/ Y4 tu'u* tH* oa ( a(ro .

,t-ta *,^t 1qtu:;:; ;, i-;.fu / ii r,--+- 
-

ryr & a (l4u,L;^,-ti W d*(r:,k rn*rl s

/t{,lrtyu4+ ,e!. N @ azr,'l /D/4,,11<4 +

\dlr+-- U*P* frf++*^ a,l.lrg

{ pq- wfu,-cz, X A e+ g8? - (r't.
1

klt),Y^/ry tuN, +I'n] *L u,*

t 1u* T,,* u,-t krLlP,^Rl 
d a>ust

Y^ru-Ar.u!- W tlr,llrrrfu ,\{s- b";\lA) ch;
\)

frrr^ W /1r-!^L1 a^-a-{--.- lau-.*, ,}-d4
D

t^ r,-6Vr.r;-,



9q ,c, th1 U^d Wt,t,aJtnl"t-
h,'!,'4r")r#- f "d* X {l* {c+;^.,*,

Atr ffi"rh&,W;W;!r' ,
Wlt^"L f,u*"-W a W Xt 

t*f*"

W,^A 4d** n.,,1 + W dgla€rr>,^a-1L

-.f.1W-r,+4* +<,+i"r^- X
p..$,'errro, t^il"o g^4- U^+ L

*H'{^"r$ ks fi*+ fl,g 
b.4.^,}. 

n-, og L

+

.!yuJ* 'lAil {*l Wu: }rJ d ",,^'-;^",1"1

)rtn)t',,Lrr-o4itl W F;*4" Vr-*' n/u'<4

{, b d'u"r+. l"tt- UJld'h, +;,1 \nl
da^ cr"hl b.&, Pl"* tta& 6,a!^ P.H:,rrn\
Ai^ff<-6 fuA^ry F-xrYv-^,.-!*^

arv,A 'l-t-*+ A,L<- l-.9 cLAa/r,k^g

b Nbv \ hw+ /'1^

.W WbJrv,, t>r"r*uT)r*-, W-rl aJ

[-Luv- UJ { l't'18 %- Al,ro c,on ca-LA W

Arl,a -l-A pru),-J "-ft dla.,'lza- boJJ^+s +

wd'rry
fr,ad- )^^r*

U

qY*
w@



t\* pn'cl.!,,. .,- T!4b"Vra ^J il,Lr. fu\/tr^'t (n:'J-

,lrlXt^/d- W y 1ot*Dv'L'

t\A^M y* wl,tust b*l,ul-r Ur4^L tu/1L6,^fl

aJrrl )v* *< 1"""^.,^1 t o-, lr*\ Le^

b
Ms,

h,ryt A4-tr-i

Ltn--l*-
ltar. /41* Oluat

Urwd [hr, h/,a1 [-;nes.Vol So.Ud]lel-/ez'

'JloOfuY
q 1Ur* o..l.{^0"

Cp',"l AA; o'

e-,'tfun-u{ . frl* rkt< "fldirJ*

l,Uv b"+t^ b"Ntu\ il'!,-l b^lMy,
A*1, eqwh,r'q a" lnh o t,'L t*o')*a
W!r^" ilA).4.+;+'wwo\ wu 4uroJ,u '

-l L,o til. "1,'- fvt^st-uLL trW b".
dt-Vfu ,',|il)a il,a/r!- A- upr,t{'*ov



t"^
'4fu"^^

fr^r^

T"fue. A; g,.r^* rgrLu ,/rr+/ d;t ;h^P"l

{ .kL hr 6r6t, fiJ*- ftlsw/ Da,1^r- (

4.4 +1Q l I q!.---tt)Jr* url,*-@ h - -

W;$"'dd- W tuAb,t a* tt^* pttlt,

*!* At!, Ue aJ,)'t'r)<& hoJ/"u+'-

lhillr- l* /,*rri$ t l,*t^uY-

a* fi!- %ru*.hJlr^y
0v-^r6 b(/t rr 01,* We^^n) l^-L- t1**

ar) CiLu,> il)*L 1'(qtl^.'cua+^
0

+BW
6n*
A,l,'\Ud 7

ffi Now

L MJa^^Gl ( Utl<-, lln,,,,'t- tfLs*+l*A {Ja,
0

Offii^fu ry u- ,"1 +@ W
a^l a)t al.L, Ml /llr/J ,aVU,,nh*Ju-, ,n,'.lL

Irruh o//-tu.

T1". W tt)b',ar*/ c;"j bu '{,"*
t

CAri-\ h,,;,*0 A'?Tu"Lt 41/,rlf*1 il[..^'f



q>UAk\ yrvt dlr^a Ah Lo,nl*'j'^-*t"'-" f-o ?rVL(.

t

W rlfuA\ Cl,ar^;r, 'U*rl- {tY. a-Aa !-'t*t*o'^l X TL'*

% Uf W l,-l t.,u^ b,^,*-p^+/X^*f

nia4't u)^ ae|lyt st^^,^*A uc,".*

tA^76.,,tjn."f.t: lqz, W WCqil@

& ; p"; | *Ll.*\ sld-,,0 'et lrr- wLlu

&;,& ,,,*+ W {ak l.; [ruk LT*
Ft,u M tfurtfr^t', erfr,h, fu fYl'n (tmn'u1L'*

0 !*a ,ur. t*tl.L, U*l /; a-.u,rtr^{
Jr,f,bLJ nW 0L lA D,,.. /^a4^,4-4 on )

0

fl,,
dq

b-llct uLl* r:v-sl 4"* 4-''N'-

U ith'",r t,r,,^@ a^* -t/to- htuf , T, l7(,

/f'-1 . . t - l r , fu
11,"^ Cctv^ l^-r^tq ; d,wdap ff orr;-Ar"^,o

+l,r^4 Al"s. Ur,l"fu4u€+CLll i{r:. 0rn^,--,dna^'t uk,

tn 4w ard* ft,f frl*n"il sk(I
t-

lU,rT^4,- a

t fr;"^f frt*wo'il Sk(r- *'ll
{ilr^\ w;,*1",r",1 y,,,,; io^ .

Copyright notice

© NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.

This collection and the tools to navigate it (the “Collection”) are available to the public for general educational and research purposes, as well as to preserve and contextualize the history of the content and materials it contains (the “Materials”). Like other archival collections, such as those found in libraries, LDF owns the physical source Materials that have been digitized for the Collection; however, LDF does not own the underlying copyright or other rights in all items and there are limits on how you can use the Materials. By accessing and using the Material, you acknowledge your agreement to the Terms. If you do not agree, please do not use the Materials.


Additional info

To the extent that LDF includes information about the Materials’ origins or ownership or provides summaries or transcripts of original source Materials, LDF does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of such information, transcripts or summaries, and shall not be responsible for any inaccuracies.

Return to top