Correspondence from Guinier to Winner; Legal Research on Summary Vote Dilution Caselaw

    Lesa,U&renseH" NAACP LEGAL DEFENSE AND EDUCATIONAL FUND' INC.

99 Hudson Street, New York, N.Y. 10013o(212) 219,1900

September 9, 1985

1,1s. Kathleen Heenan McGuan
Suite I020
900 Seventeenth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005

Re: Thornburq v. Ginqles

Dear Kathleen

As we disbussed at your 'of f i"ce on"September 4 , and conf irmed
by telephone September 6, appellants' designate the follow-
ing exhibits for the Appendix:

Px 4, (attached) (Pugh Plaintiff,s)
Px II, app. 3 and app. 5 (attached)
Px I3-I8, the summary sheet for all 53 elections

(attached) to put in context the 82 elections you deslgnat,ed
Px L9, (bottom half only; at least put on two separate

pages )

Px 20, Px 25,41, 52 (3 pages) and 53(c)
Px 56-70

We also believe that if porti.ons of the Stipulations
are designated, that aII Stj"pulations dhould be included.

With regard eo Px 25.and 53 (c) , the aCs shoulC
be photo offset and not reprinted. As I mentioned, Px 52
refers t,o 3 pages: a letter addressed "Dear FeIIow Democrat,"
and a two page attachment that begins "Dear Registered Voter"
and is signed "Tim Valentine." You do not need to include
t,he letter addressed: "Dear Neighbor. "

I enclose a list of transcript pages t,hat we are
designat,ing for the Appendix. Leslie will send you directly
the color maps that should also be bound with the Appendix.

Fina1ly, I will plan to come by your office Thursday
afternoon, September L2, to see the page proofs of the Appendix.

Contributiona are ded,uctible lor U.S. income tat purposes

The NAAcp LEGAL OEFENSE & EoUCATIONAL FUNo is not part ol thc National Association tor the Advancement ot colore.d People although it

;;i;uid;d biliinJ srriras its commitmcntlo oquat righti. LDF has had f or over 25 years a separate Board, program, statl, ollice and budget.



Ms. Kathleen Heenan McGuan -2-

Thank you for Your cooPeratLon-

LG/ t
Enclosure

cc: Leslie Winner, Esq.

September 9, 1985



PUGH PI*AINTIFFS I EXHIBTT NO. 4

Table l-A

Comparison of Black Population and Black
i n the North Ca rol i na Leg i s I ature

Representation
l9l{o- l 982

Population

I of Total Popu- Z

Blacks lation Black

NC Senate

lof Z
Blacks Black

gBl,2g8 3,571,623

q,05l,92g

I , I 55,870 \,556,155

1,126,\78 5,082 ,059

I ,316,050 5,87\,\29

NC House

tof Z
Blacks BlackYea r

r 940
1g\2
l9l{l{
l9l{5
I gq8

1 950
t95z
I 954
1956
I 958

I 960
1962
I 964
I 966
I 968

1970
1972
197t'
1976
I 978

I 980
r g82

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
2
/.
1

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
Il
l{

2

2

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
1

2

3
q

\
3

?

l1,t

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0

.8

1.5
2.5
3.3
3.3
?(

?.5
o1

Sources: Thad Eure.North Cirol ina Legislative Directory 198'l-1982, 1983-1984

Thad Eure. North Carol ina l,tanua l. Ra le i9h: prUf icat ions Di vis ion,
rgrrr-197-

u.S. Bureau of Census, l9l{0, 1951, 1960, 1970, 1980

"Six of these were elected from rna-i ority black districts tha'. the General
Assembl), was forced to draw by the Federal Courts.



I r,
-'/

Name, Party and candldate # of each Black Candldate

Candldate #'s and Party of tllnning Candldates

# of Black Candldates

lL3;',| '{-o

Number of
Vo tes for
Candldate
# I (0. '18)
#

Proportlon of Black
vote f or candl da Le 't

(p. ny 
t'Bc, 

(p.21-22)
reqress'ion extreme casa
esilmate est'1male

Proportlon of l.lhl te
vote for candldate 1

Dr

(p. 4) *Ll (p. 21-22)
regresslon exlreme case
estimate estlmate-

_,3 7
,/3
,20
,)1
,lll

7

I

,?o
,13 , s:d , t?

10

,2? ,47

,so ,sl

,f3

I

IIa
{I

PIAINTIFPS
DfiIBIT
13 (a)

Ciaq le s

,l/

,1 /
, CP

,fb

,l?-cA: t?to/
^c^qt9.t(7
_cAst4sJ /

CA.
o

I

,t
U

*
Y

Candl date #
1, Party

2 ./1 h./

3DLr'

40w
s0d

SUMMARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

Iype of Electlon

and Race (0.'l )



Coun Ly

0a ie of

llumler of
Vctes for
Candidate
* I (0. '13)

- cAt3Tasv

- cAz 3(," o D

cAo : o gs,
cA-

I

tA
ô

CAo

Cand 1 da ie #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l )

1bv)
2 rvJ

,t

3t2 uJ

LDU
5 Rt,'/

,6JW

,

8

9

sutlilARY Sllt t'i

BP.SIC RU}I I. GENERAL ELSCTIi]iI

Type of Elecl'ion

Propor Iion of llhi ta
vole for cantllCate 1

6tr t.tc
(p. 4) '"1 (p. ?1-22)

i'egression extreme casa
esr,irnate- estlmate

1{
s'7
)J

=DfJrJ

.44 ,27 ,Lt o , Y/

a

I
F
A

T

PIAINNFPS
D(HIBIT
13(b)

-

G!ngles

Electlon

llame, Par tY and Candi Cai.e li of eacn Black CandldaF.e

Candldate #'s' and Party of 'riinninq Candirlates /,' ^l ,'? 1 - 0

# of Black Candidates

Proportion of Black
vote ior candi da Ie 1

(p. 4) ''u'', (p.21-22)
regres5ion extreme casa
es'uimal.e es'.imale

,so ,v4 ,s7
,f1 , tli ,fip
,sa q7 ,fr

- 
O . ,f - ,31CA.^,^^^

) ) l'lt) a



County TYPe

Proportlon of l,ahl te
vote for candldate 1

or
(p.4) Hct (p.21-221

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

o-?-JS )-,
r ,\tbLt

J-rY i

-

-I "l ,J

-

, fr:

", :,f,. _' ,,

, V4

i3
tr'i)

I

/,n kL"/' f-'tr

SU}II,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTIOII

of E.lect,r on ,.,4.r-* ,!n.,.*-., -ft'-'r-
(./

gate of Etectt on fr,1,-, /q? ,P # of Btack Candldates
U

Name, Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate
: -' ,, Jr5'i,.. ,i(..ir.*ra't, -/^, f ),D

,l/

Candldate #ts and.Party of l{lnnlng Candldates

l{umber of
Votes for
Candl date

cA3 ,r,. S.?

cA+ '?.r-?:

CA5 q.1, u r
cAo

cAz

cAe

cAg

Candldate #
l, Party
and Race ( o. 1 )

10/3
2 Ott)

-a.a *
1 0 tt,,'

t,r"
6

Proportlon of Elack
vote for candldate 1

ol
(p. +) ' BC1 (p.21-22)

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

-.2. z'5
-t. Y,.

f.i
.32
,v a

'l (0. 18

( cfr )ar : r::
cA, i,j,: r'

I

9

-



.\
a, .# {4-/ rA,*D

SUI{I{ARY SHEET

EASIC RUI{ I - 6E}IERAL ELECTIOE

ttod ,/" + - 
/' 4uJlounrrl (/ ' rYPeofElec

llnf 13 #of BlactcCandldates

Candldate # of each 8lack Candldate

o

Ilate of Electlon

llame, PartY and

Number of
Votes for
Candl date

CandldatE'#
1, Party
and. Race (o.l )

candldate #,s and party of nnntng candtdates /''),3; ? ''' I

,3P
.fa

-

. Y/

;YLl
.Y0
."7

9ltorcr r oB
- c[z PZLz
.zCA, f,qt Z

-cA+1a9P'. + W

cA6 97Pg
cA-

I

-'

cAa

z v' 
,

I tl/

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for candldate I

(p. 4) 
P Bcr 

( e.zt-2zl

o

Proportlon of l{hlte
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1t'tt.t (p.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate. estlmate

37
,s?_
.yq_
,YJ
,31 --

a2
.bg-
,[2
,cb

rW
aW
1

8'

e+

P[AINTFPS
D(HIBIT
r3(d)

Gingle s

cAg



r---'I.!

SUHIIIARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

county klt- - ( u TYPe of Electlon

Oate of Electlon

Name, PartY and

# of Black Candldates

CandlAite # of each Black Candldate

/0,7 o #)

Proportlon of Hh1 te
vote for candldate 1

(p. + 1P'wc', (p. 21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

, cl
eC
Ir Ll

.b3
. -r:,

.v1
,.fb
,A3
,cl
,c3

,11

,91
,lb
,lq
,23
. lb

and Race ( P. I )

10&
20N

cAs r I /c{
CA,

o

eA?

cAe

CAo

i PI.AINTIFPS
D(HIBIT

l3(e)
Gin gles

candldate #'s .and Party of !{1nnlng candldales I , ), , 3 U - D

Number of
Votes for
Candl date

cAe rl ssJ
cAq2alt I

Candldate #
1, Party

au)
*J
sod

1

I

9

Proportlon of Elack
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) BCt (p.2'l-22)
regresslon extreme case
es tlmate es t lmate

, ?0

,/3

;23



SU!4HARY SHEET

: 
BASIc RuN I -'GEI.ERRL ELECTIoN

counry 11* - t n rype or E'rect ,"^ ./, ..f, ;41 ..r..J
oate of Etectl on ,lL^r 7 P # of B'lack Candldates

Hame, Party and Candldate # of each B.lack Candldate

' ..',r-' l:,:,- 
- ',,' ,, .dy'*..,1,,,b..-. 0 # /

Jt

.j ':!. bi:

.- a

:

Candl da te #'s and Party of i'llnnlng Candldates L)_D

Number of
Votes fot'

'Candldate

_ cAz qsoL3

cA: f,l I9.9

: c\sl:is
' 'CA- ? 1o ?n
. )a)r,.. u-/

tlil.r 16

cA-
I

%
cAg'

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l )

rrd
2 |t'"t

Iurv'

5A tt)

-rll6: 'r't

1

8

I

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldat,e 1

' 0r

(p.4) BCt (p.2'l -221
regresslon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate-

,qq ,r7
, el- , L/-3..---
S- ) u'7

Proportlon of Hhi te
vote for candldate I

(p. 4)''*'t (p. 21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

Ltl
,Vf

,s4 ,.rr
cd uo ,.C:l .;d

0{ a-,
r .t I ,:./

n , oe. ,7') ..?.7

.t I
,?2

I

I
t

PtAlIimFPS
.. a(HBr
iI3!E) *:

6ingles

*q usrq



SUI,II,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ I - GENERAL ELECTiON

i6lt^,lt cid,l"1. 
"tr l L.Q'&
/nnc )

Typc of Electl on 4/ 
*o 2 , - 

=
# of Black candldates 

- 
fCounty

0ate of E'lectlon

Name, Party and Candlda of each Black Candldate

.t3

Propor tl on of l{h t te
vote for candldate 1

0r

(p.4) HCt (p.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

),

,C/
ura
zf uJ

3n U./

IDtr/#

s nu/

-

c\ tt P€

-td

.t V

.2 I

,21
,/n

-

clz23 r2
2l

,2{
, Sq

-a1-
,n?
, s_7

-7/
+

.L?

Candldate #'s and Party of t{1nn1ng Candldates 2, 3, q, -f - D

!{umber of
Votes for
Candl date

cAq a?6s7
cAs 2t2 Lt..'

CA-
o

CA.
I

-

cAg

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (o.i)

6

-

1

8

-

9

-

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 't

o.
(p. 4) 8cr (p.21-22)

regressl'on extreme case
estlmate estlmate

.79

24
,0?_

cAg

t
Ii
tI
E

PIAINTIFPS
DffiIBIT
l3 (e)

Gieg le s



SUHMARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTIOI{

County 
-/o 

f, r,r' ,S Type of Electl on 'Cnoi' Dr"-"t

oaf e of Eleci rcn S,/ 9O # of B'lack Candldates 
t

Name, Party and Candldate # of each 8'lack Candldate

R D -A l,'o-.1' C L

Hhl te
ldate I

(p. 21-22\
xi,reme case

r3
.)1

estlmaLe estlmate

, al-

. ,sL

1?

,57
,L/7_
,?n-

,/8 _

,Ll7

, Lly

,q7

a

t
?I
tt

P[AINTIFF'5
DffiIBIT
/3(h)

Gine le s

Cand,tda,.te #,s and Party of Hlnnlng Candldates W0'a)7 VrdL Y0dY7 tll 'f

Number of
Votes Fcr
Candl da.le
4 1 (o- '18)

cAr sao:
'lAz C stS
c{t Sr! sf
cAq ca aJ.
CA. ,-r t ,a) 3 E?2(J

Candldate #
1, Party

LCJ :WO
3a3 u/D

a 2u1 VD

5 r-i wD

1

8

9_

Pr opor t 1on of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

Pt o^
(p. 4) o''l (p.2'l-22)

reEresslon extreme case
estimate estlmat-e.

,lt, Bll]r ?l-tS
1?

.30
?1r -L.(

Proportlon of
vote ior cand

(p. +1P"''lc,
regresslon e

and Race (0.'l )



counry /ri F- C. ,'y TvPe

0ate of E'lect ton 
'/4 "'-''''? 

:1 # of
V

i,lame, Pai'ty and Candidate # of each B'lack

SUMI4ARY SHE ET

EASIC RUN I - GEIIERAL ELECTION

Propor tl on of B'lack
vote for candldate I

. P,^-
(p.4) ut1 (p.21-22\

regression extreme casa
estimate esllmate

/ -+ it
of E'l ec t 1On ,4t - *.J ?- t "'-'tn-r-'t<a

Black Candl dates 
Y

Candldate

Candldate /f 's and Party of l'linning Candidates ? ,2', l,S---C-

Number of
Votes for
Candldaie

cAzJrlt1i
CAa - .,. :.r.i-.),

-#c'Aq.f -i :': ?

c\ :, :.trr.
CA,

0

CA:

cA
Û

%

,l p
,lP
,al
r P.f,

.t1

Candl date #
i, Party
anC Race (o.l)

1 08
) t\q)

3 C1Lr,/ "

q ,-, vv

1

a

o

Proporllon of '/hiLe
vote for candlda"e 1

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-2?)
regresslon extreme case
est'irnate e-stima'te

,23
a"i),S d

: . &s

,*
rl

IJJ

r9J

r .\ -J-.

*1 7
. ,r,
Lb

: PIAINflFPS
i D(HIBIT
f 1?1i\
a !J \ 5/
!l 

-

O -. .i ir-ng.Les



SIJ:rl:.,lRY Si{E t f

AASIC RUI.I i . GEIIERAL ELECTIOII

Coun ty ,U -r..r/-2 ,,, ,,^...,- Type of E'lec t 1on

t,a/ , .L/'
-t t?

-ti"' ,...... t-L !:_j!_tL'r. l.r*

(/

'1 lro{a

,*

_,.f3
,\ -rr* A

cAg

I

I
.I

iI

PTAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT
13(i)

Cinsles

gate of Etcct ton 0.",^-9 9 1. # of B'lack candldates
V

Candldate # of gach B'lack CandlCate

C//.,1 .,!'-
I A4 te 2./ t' -:.__

Name, Par tY and

Candldate #'s and Party of l'l1nn1ng Candldates 2 . 3, "{-i-: D-

llumber of
Votes for
Cand'ldate
# 1 (0. '18)

cAt I 9 t'l
- c[z t to ttn

cA+ ? /.r q

-Sg.sr-
-CA. )a,c,,o; )t /.2

CA,

cAg

Cand'tdate #
1, Party
and Race I P. I )

1 0w
2 t?ut

a

,3c"v

/t .t
5l-' t.{

6O tv

7

I
9

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. ny ''Bc'' (p.2r-22)
regression extreme case
estlmate est lmate

,J/
,el
,/3,
,83

,r0

,2n

Pr opor t 'l on of l,lh 'l t e
vote for candldate 1

(p.nyt'n'', (p. 21-z?)
regress 1 on extreme case
es tlmate estlmate

i -,r
. o'/ G'(

, r(,
./ r)t Lrtj

,ta
?-I -: .-5

JP

.t{.1.

f')

"!)

,DLl ,0 q



SUI'1MARY SHT E T

RUN I. GEIITRAL ELiCTIONBASIC

of E'lectlon /r/ ,^.' 
j 
i2 # of B'lack Candldates

. r 1/

Date

l{ame, Party and Cand\daie # orrrr}rn Black CandlCate

/r{'l' a *! =

Candl date #' s and Par tY of iJl nnt rrg Candl dates q-n.' ;i',!:

Proportlon of [Jhlte
vote f or cancil date 1

0r
(p. 4) HCr (p. 21-zz)

regresslon extreme case
estlmate .esttrnate

u" ?.,,4
, -(^,i^ , .f j

4:

I'lumber of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (o. '18)
l#

cA.ls.;- i0 ,1,

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (o.l)

1 .O e/
zO v'
3at4'
qOtt/

5 t? t.'-t

OR url

7 *r r'.2

I

9

Proportlon of B tack
vote for candldate 1

0r

(p.4) BCt (p.21-22)
regresslon extreme casa
estlmate estlmate

2u?ts) !

-

. ?-ru-

,, 'l Ll ' ,t cl'

a- ?-.,I J S t --l

0 . na
,\0 ,.J \-

nhtl . t t

,32
,.3 1- cA2 q t/:' i i'

cA3 a'rt't "/
CAq u r: ?.1

CA. .r ' , ,'. e,
fd

"*,t""
cAr ; 3.:
cA^

u

cAg

I

I
!-A
TI

PIAINTIFPS
P(HIBIT

13 (k)
Gingles



4.-)

County

0ate of E'l ec t 1 on

ilame, PartY and

*'t (0. l8)
CA.l / -r3.>-

SUI{I,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

Type of Electlon

# of Black Candldates

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

or
(p.4) BCt 

ie.21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

Pr opor t 1on of lih 1 te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-22)
regress'lon extreme, case
estlmate estlmate

, .r-7

,l?
,3C
,tlt/

I,lv
:

r.\ ,)

,3/

1

/ !..t-Vt 'uuy

Candldate # of each B'lact< Cand'ldate

/'1 , o-

Cand'ldate #'s and Party of l{lnn1ng Candldates 2'" 1;''- C

Number of
Votes for Candldate #
Candldate 1, PartY

cA2 il l':'
CAs Vf-i?
CA. Li -) .r'rq ,; /4

@/..,:il
-9-:-..:-dcA'l

cAg

cAg

and Race (0.'l )

1 DW

20rv
3Cnt

+a'u
so13

aOat
1

8

-1 n., I

.bu
,2 D,

-

t-J
lJ j

-

'ta,7 )

-

lrl

r 75



,ffi /.*/ r*'b

SUI,IIIARY SHEET

BASIC RUII I . GENERAL ELECTIOil

/'&-o
county i '' 'n TYPeof Electlon y'' '
Date of E'lectlon

Name, PartY and

ilrrr L*-L
Candldate # of each

t

# of Black Candldates L
Elack Candldate' fu-,{ o *.

Candldate#.sandPartyofltlnntngCandldates

7b

lt 4'

Proportlon of t{hl te
vots for candldate 1

(R. +1P'rc.t (p.21-22)
regress'lon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

, ?9 .J-7
, t17 ,VP

,37
,'l{ ,tlb-

K
(.

.l
Y'

20h/
tO B
+6v
sR w
6RV/
7JW

llurnber of
Votes for
Candl date
# I (0. 18)

CA.

CA^

@nr
C'

f

*
D

r^il
cAg

cAg -

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 'l

(p. 4) 
t't'.r 

(p.21-22)
reqresslon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

Cand'tdate #
1, Party
and Race (o.l )

l nv

8

,f e ,15-
,01 ,09

.,Pf
,PP

,41
,3{
,03
; tN-|

,, ,0\

-

,?{ , -Y t:-

i

i
!

iI

PTAINIIFFS
O(HIBIT
13 (m)

Giaeles



SUI{I{ARY SI{EET

EASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

counry hg-a+
Oate of E1ectl on 

,!.u-,.^o- 
A a

D

Name, PartY and Candldate # of each

Type of Electl "^ /."--fi. /",'^1-n
# of Black Candldates d
B'lack Candldate

/-ai o #r

Candldate #'s and Party of l{lnnlng Candldates 2 ,3, {, L -4_

llumber of
Votes for
Candl date
# I (0. 18)

cAtCtt?

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race ( o. I )

lJD W

2 0w

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

0r

(p.4) 'BC1 (p.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
es tlmate es tlmate

,0'f
,al
,ll
,/3
.13
.21

Proportlon of I'lh'lie
vote for candldate I

(p. e1P'wc1 (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extrene case
es tlmate es tlmate

.2b 2- I

4"u/
5D B

6pw

.01
.an ,-fY ,'Y
,2' .b0
,01 Ll7

.73 ,3 b

,24 ,61

,?b
,YP
.34
,b0

-
cA^

Y

-

7

: PTAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT

l3 (n)

-

Gingles

- cAz ft17 {
'c(t t7z't7 30W

- cAo t 7sa2
cA'l

cAa



)

county ./11-. ' C. '-
DaLe or E]ectlon l,rn- I e

SUY,I.IARY SHE ET

BASIC RUN i. GENEPAL ELECTiON

Type of E'lec t i on

# of Black Candidates

//., ./, J )\l' ., 7/

/- I'

Propor tlon of l'lh1te
vote for candldaie'l

(p. +1P'wc1 (p. z1-22)
regression exiierne case
est-inate estlmate

:'' ,-l
I

-^rY 
-)

-r<t'r 9.,

Name. Party and Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate

, il / ctl='

Candldate #'s and Party of tnllnning CanCldaies 1

# 1 {o. l8)

- CA. .,, .t ,^l-'.": /Jil.' 4,J ' \ 
"2-t

1 car.i: 
" 
/i-(\-rr-

- 
'oo 

t t, a,o

CAr.J tl :l ,.1 (:

- CA^':'\c?l
U--

and Race (0.'l )

1 .t1 uJ

o r) nt
=j---

*) t3''

4 0 \)./

sR'il
6 .11 '.r'l'

1 z \.t''

8

A ,)f

-L A at {

Number of
Votes for Cand'lda'.e #

Cand'lCate 'l , PartY

Pr opor t 1 on of B'laci<
vote for canCioaLe 1

P,^^
(p. 4) uti (p.2'l-2?)

regress lon extreme :ase
astimai,e e$1OAlS-

'r;Jl a Irrr 

-L-,34 ,?.? 
-,q4 ,.f i,

,\0
r J:' Jr

o , LJi

'f,? . (:r

cA7l., /

cAg

cAg

.aa

; PLAINnFPS
EffiIBIT
13(o)

.3ilg Ie s



SUI'I[.{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GEIIERAL TLECTIOil

llumber of
Votes for
Candl date
{ t (0.'18)

-sCA, tbf? O

cAz 3 6ob

-- CAZ tq 407

cAtrrfD
.? CAS l? ,, O

- c(t'l) I8\
.- c\2'4 C88

carqol{

county fll.fur-/'*r Tvpe of Electlon , L
,ate of E.lectl "^ + 

# of glack Candldates /

ilame,. Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

Candtdate #,s and Party of l{1nnlng Candldatesl 
,7 , 

{r' 6r'7, tC ' t) ' i?-D

Proport'lon of t{hlte
vote for candldate 1

(p. +yP'rcl 1p. 2'l-22)
regresslon extreme case
esi'tmate estlmate

.3?t?
ar .l l .]D
,q s- 1 !--)

,01 ,lb ,)b_
.lt ,qq , Y}

, Y}

,e? _ ,ba
0Ll .D 7

Candldate #
I ,- Party

Proport'lon of Black
vote for cand'ldate' 1

(p. n1 
t'tt, 

(p.21-22)
regresslon ertreme case
esilmate estlmate

.a )

,08
,13

. D,

,13

'10
,al
a{

, oa

and Race (o.I)

lDw
zD tv

3DW

4nw
5n rg

6?*
LDW
g O'al

sOuU

,v7
,be
,0q
, Y1,'

: PIAINIIFPS
EffiIBIT

14 (a)
!insles

CAg r-f ?32 .)D , ,13_



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUil I - GEI{ERAL ELECTIOTI

County

0ate of E'lectlon

Type

#of
Black

c{zlozso
cA+rPlaf

clsza3?.

cAa L o ool

c[a C,|ll1

sO v{

2 nv)
3DV/
+Oul

oO'A)

tOB
a0 u)

8t/

.-r/
, rl/

U'\I t4

,*

, q+

,31
,? J,

,3?

Proport'lon of llhl te
vote for candldate 1

or
(p.4) HC't (p.21-zz)

regresslon ertreme case
estlmate estlmate

,\l
,?7
.3P
.3J
, +b
,Y7

l3
,'ll
,'1 I

'31
,Ll 3

, q3

,e3
. ?U

, L)L/

i t*t*n*
qHIBIT
l4(b)

-,-_

Gingles

Name, Party and Candidate # of each

Cand'ldate #'s and Party of rtnnlng Candldates 2.1,4 ; C, C , l-D j /6-<

of Electlon /4-r* -LU
Black Candldates

Candl date

Number of
Yotes for Candldate #
Candldate 1, Party
# 1 (0. '18) and Race (0.1)

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

o.
(p.+) 8cr (e.21-2zl

regresslon ertreme case
estlmate estlmate

.,1 b

,3 -r
.'? -{
,-?3

,Ya
.32
.r 4

,3r

clz Ioltr

2-
cAgSrti3o ,a3 ,qq



SUI{IIARY SHEET

BASIC RUII I . GENERAL ELECTION

county ,/Vl ' / t * rvpe of ETectl o^ ,/7& /*'

,atE of Erectl ,^@ # of Brack candldates - * d

ilamq, Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

Cand,tdate#,s and Party of t{lnnlngCandldates IJ' ?. '(- (' l 'i)'9

B-e.--, o ;t t
rt,:r&-u-*^ o lt ''

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 'l

(p.n1 ''Bcl (p.21-22)
reqresslon ertreme case
es itmate es t lrna te

llumber of
Votes for
Candldate

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (P.1)

tfB
ZOW

3D t^/

t.t) rJ

5DW
60 rel

7DW
aD 'il
sCI&

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for cand'ldate 'l

(r. +1P'rc, (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

..la _ , s-3
-;t---.--- __cJ

.b J

,L<

,1q 9A
,e1
, 0 D/

,0&
,001

_, llo
'le

-t.6->

,1 I

.2b-

0 (o- ,23
,b/

, fJ_
.2{ . uq_

,1 n

CA-,r.Tr
- 

J/< J-a\

cA+ ra gf

- 
CAS t 20Q)
cAo /lQy'

-- CAZt,r23t,

- cA8 l?2ro

@

, 11_ - 
ot(l*(

i

-, 
t-7

, /s.-

,ltt

i

Ir
I

PIAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT

14 (c)
3iac Ie s

',t30b

1t_ aa
oJl



a

Coun ty

# 1 (0. '18)

cAr g rf 40
cAz'+ q, z
CA3 I )z-: -<.-

cA+ 3qi t q
cAs 

3 rq, 't

cAo I Eq3t1

cA? q 3j-?,1

CAg ar-:r?
CAg I .1,', ;:

and Race ( o. I )

4r./\\/\
2 0 /a,v

3A\^J

lolJ

sDv'J

6y6/

7 c 'd,t

80i-i

---).\. (5 . ).1.

.3).
^olla /

,? i
,4;

SUI{I.IARY SHEET

BASIC RUT{ I . GENERAL ELECTLON

Propor tl on of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

o.
(p.4) BCt 

1e.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
es t tmate. es t'lma t e

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1t'*'', (p. 21-zz\
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

,:/3
, V,,

, '17

,i'7

+L
,!Q .tl 2

u-
'1 a

r 5J

OF,J l

-

/)
---..L-

.Yl.
, tLl

^-a

lar
a ,a

-

^.-,/\r->J

- i PutNnrrs
E(HIBIT

t4 (d)
=Gingles

Type of E]ectl on /-/' '--' '--'-k''-'''-'" /

oate of Electl on ,,1 .l ^'-utg ''? L # of Black Candldates a

ilame, Party and candldate # of each B'lack candldate

4-r.... o{!
.r

rt , ,eLi^-L-,'.. rl * C

Cand'ldate #' s and Party of lilnnlng Can(ldates / ,, ) , a, '1 , -f; t^,1- O: / {-R

Number of
Votes for Candldate #
Candldate l, PartY

7.r,-.;/--L,Lu -



0ate of Electlon

Name, PartY and

SUMMARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

Type

#of
Black Cand I da te

4
county i,r.-*t

// ,, ,

of Election &<a.,a-> / -tt-t*,ct1

Btack candidates 3 d

Candldate

CandldaLe #'s and Party of Hlnning CandidaLes l3,,t g,?-0

Number of
Vo Les for
CandidaLe
t i (0. l8)

- cAt Lt,6
c[z ,ino A

- c\ ftq2
Wuj

- @rt,, ( cD

-

c^oYL4/

Candl date #
I , Par ly
and Race (0.'i )

111 q/

Lov
30d
4r) w
w-
60w
108
808
9aw

Proporlion of Black
vote for candidale i

(p. 41 
P'Bc', 

6.21-zz\
regression extreme case
estlmale estimate

,lA .r{

Propor'.ion of l,'lhi te
vote For candi da ie i

0r

(p. 4) *Li (p. 21-2?)
regression extreme case
estimate estimate

, /).

,4j
3d\

. /5 ,bn
,t1 ,51
13 . &F

'\cl
,61

,08
#

tr1
tt I

,3J ,1 L_ ,1 5-

,g
4-,J5

-,({ ,fB
, a8

/A
,/)

, /1
.1L

,tf
,2?
,f/

,31,12

,47
.c3

-,/P

'08,/9

/
,r
i
E

PI.AINTIFPS
flHIBIT
I5 (a)

-

.--rng Ie s

of each



BAS IC

SUI{IIARY SHEET

RUNT.CENERALELECTION

County ftrtS\ rt/ Type or Electl on /i'USt 6A'UAPflC

# of B'lack Candl dates A-
0ate of Eiect'ton

Name, PartY and Cand'tdate # of each Black Candldate

Karu,vaD'/ . I ,,4
S(, t€R.,',?

Candldate #'s and.Party of l{1nn1ng Candldates t ' Dr/a D,/ 7 rl:, l, K

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
# I (0. '18)

'^r2WJwtuw
cen la ofj
cAs Ail2l
c^6 n 56q

@
4 

^.-t 
/

c^BAd lt b

@

Candldate #
l, Party
and Race (0.'l )

1 ILR,

8 NR

,(K

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1 
t'BC, 

(p.2r-22)
regresston extreme case
es tlmate es tlmatr

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p. c1P'|Jc, (p. z\-22)
regresslon ertreme case
estlmate estlmate

ttCt <,1,'1 | + J'J

, qb ,'i G

,qLl
t4

,76

-

r.1 I_.-
-t,>l

-

,4L t-i I

r ll

() .- l-7,5d ,5'l
-r 1 'l^,)) .)-/

,-(/.1 ,A
rrJ U

-

AX
, r.-l U

,6'>
, oa,

1Q.
,4

c
.n ,')

tUf

nA.lJ/ J

q7 ,81 ,2*
,-4\

/ \rl

i

I
a
at
!

PlAINNFPS
offitBtT
t5(b);;.

u Lrl9Ie S

s lrD

, AJ ,dA



cAl lv tf -'

cAz I tll'l
-$d'A- ,., . ,,1Jll )t-.,

- CAg, r l]/J

-cAli h ;'' bi
cAg

cAg

Number of
Votes for Candldate #
Candldate 1, PartY
# t (0. '18) and Race (b.l)

/
County t .-'+-'T it TYPe

oate of E]ecttoi 1l'l '. . ': f # ofT
Name, Party and Candldate # of each B'lack

l,/K-- '-:--.. D

SUHI{ARY SHEET

EASIC RUN I - GENERAL ELECTION

of E'lec t 1on

81ack Candl dates

Candl date

Propor t1 on of B'lack
vote for candldate I

(p. 4) 
t't'', 

(p.2r-22)
regression extreme case
estlmate estlmate

-/t I
//

\- / |:',2'.-/.'

Proportlon of tlhl ie
vote for candldate I

0r

(p. 4) HCr (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
es t lmate es ! 1ma te

,L,r1 br

)

c.l

rt .tA,*' ' /" li I

Candldate #'s and Party of l{1nn1ng Candldates /-'- ,l t -7-r)

1 111, r

2 a,,t,

3{1 t.tt

4LJ />

62'.rl .

TOrtt

8

.t'-i
i/ o,

,t2
,J. /

, \^b
,3,b
. t1

_,_3L

,lq
57
1"52t , br1

,,]o

ls
tQ/19 I

(l ,qe

, J,
,t'? , L6

"1 b

PIAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT

l5(c)
Gingles



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENTRAL ELECTION

-r/ 
,lZ ,--.-,_r,T I Type of Electlon '-.1 ':. g*< - -+

F.rcrirnn ,/'-.--- i ..'; .1 /\ # of Black Candldates J

Name, Party and candldate # of each Black candldate

O #3

Candldate #'s and Party of l{1nn1ng Candldates / I y','

,ll
Coun ty

Oate of

Number of
Votes for
Candldate
{'t (0. 18)

cA', ?it,-':

CA-D-;

Candldate #
'l , Par ty
and Race ( p.1 )

10'a)

2 j '";l

3u43

4 0'1,.j

5 ) i'L't

6'.rr fr

7lu d

I '.t.' xi

qi/,{

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

or

(p.4) BCt (e.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
es tlmate es tlmate

,') ?

;i
47

-t ?
,,!/

o

' ,ai^

Proportl on of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

0r

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-?21
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,1'1

tl ?.

ui

,90
, P0

, '/ i,:

,i, I

ult
rt t.

?-1, Jr{

?-t
-Lji.-

, tr1
G

ttJl

-.r# ,r -r !.\,

J -:-..

14
D2

, 't ,l'U

, c 1_ . rJf
-- /-'

. :'-1

i

at
tt

PTAINTIFPS
EXHIBIT

15(d)
6sTa;

n t4t'.1 'L'a



,1 l

t-

'.o

County

0ate of E]ectlon

t{am1, PartY and

Candl date

Type of Electlon
l!

^

/l'-z---,^-t;',. O G

#'s and Party of l{lnnlng Candldates
:,

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (p.1 I

1Dt,,

-

Ltt r*t

g D',il

1n-A

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 'l

(p. d) ''t', 19.21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

-t)

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for candldate I

(p. +1P'utc,t (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

v3 'l I ,,,1E-

,3a -) - Z'l+,lJ , (x t

,0{ ,J1
\n

t* I

,Ab ,7d
,7 ll ,40

0{ _ 3y

.:

tlumber of
Votes for
Candl date
e t (0.'18)

"--r ?5

3b€
,01

/4 1, YL,

,n ,1
, 'y?

1t-,6\

-

,a{
,aI

-

-l, J@

3+
,3 o

. g:o

rn

cA, t/ V .f7

s0 u)

60 4
10w
yjw 

,

sl w'

,01
.01
,01

. (13

,03
,3)
,a9

-c\qqrl
"c[z;4 2?

cAs 3 v'^'-tu
cA, s-:-l d

W

' !. - :- i' ? # of Black candldates

Candldate # of each Black Candldate

/L.,,.^,- O 4

SUI{}IARY SHEET

BASIC RUII I . GEI{ERAL ELECTION

9!r'q / o t

I

I
I

PtAINNFPS
. E(HIBIT

15(e)
Gingles



SUI,iI{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

0ate of'Electlon

llame , Par ty and

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
{ 1 (0. 18)

c\3a t i:

cAolr c tl
cAr: t l, 3'7

cAe-:::L/

cAg

# of B'lack Candldates

,s?
, P-7

,'l'J
, v3
r'l ll

c
J-

I

-ifJ

.| .\

.'/\

-

J,rt/

-

rl,\

-)g-

uj
. (,, -.

.f/
, v3

ra
ti

30/3
4,1uJ

S0 '^/

aL'.t!

.'ll
_!t e€

rJJ

-

, Y'P

A
;JQ

,.n

a:
.0-\ -ir .) ,./

, .f?,

t
i
!
cI:

PTAINTIFPS
EXHIBIT
t5(f)

-

3ineLes

02

4 ,,1

County I r.o-'i a TYPe of E1ectlon

y'.' -- i'e)
Cand'ldate # of each B'lack Candldate

tlflo't'u' o *A
rf2r .*,-cr,; i) * 2'

v

Candldate #,s and Party of l{1nnlng Candldates /, 2 ,7 ,4 '.f - D

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race ( o.'l )

t hv.l

-

2DB

1,(, a-)

8/? w

Proport'lon of 8lack
vote for candldate 1

(p. +y 
P'ac', 

g.21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
es tlmate est'1mate

,9b
.,,rj
12

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HC't (p. 21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate



SU!{I{ARY SHEET

EASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

of Electlon

Electlon t 7f) Black Candldates

Name, PartY and Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate

b{t

,P
Y1 ,/

Coun ty

Date of

Number of
Votes for '

Candl date
s 1 (0. 18)

W.
c\riOri
cAl

cAs

/,

Type

#of

Candl date #'s and Party of bll nnl ng Candl dates a 
'3 - 

D

Candldate #
' 1, PartY

and Race (0.'l )

tD ti,
L!) v/
q !1 , t/
=
4

5

1

I
9

Proportlon of Black Proport'lon of I'lhlte
votl for candldate 1 vote forocandldate 1

. (p. n1 
t'tt, (p.2r-22) (p. 41''xc', (p. zt-z-?l

r.it.titon exireme case regresslon extreme case

eiiimiie estrmate estlmate estlmate 

-, L I .Srl , ia _.!_: --,. ./f,;,t ,&J ,17 
-,.. "r) /tr,

cAo

cA-

br-
-9--cAq

-,-

i pt lNnrPs
I EXHlElr

I rs rHl
I cing le s

I



J-

SUMHARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

.04
, 31

Propor l l on of r,{h 1 te
vote for candldate 1

0r

(p. 4) Hcr (p. 21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estimate estlmate

-

, /0

0b

-Pb
.0 I ,Y{ ,?3
.0b , b{ ,6:
,ol .fr ,s-b

,02 ,b3

'qa ,P7 'lb ,02

. /32 0B
,0J
,01

o

o b/

104

PIAINTIFPS
O(HIBIT

l5 (a t

Gineles

county 
-P,rl* 

Tvpe of E'lect ..on k"'o /^'-'""^'

-/

oate of E'lect ton 4.L/ 7P # of B'lack Candldates

Name, Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

Candldate #'s and Party of l{1nn1ng Candldates q, L , I D

Number of
Vo tes For
cand 1 da te
# 1 (0. '18)

cAr trgf

-

grua
cA: I 3:z
cA+?3ga

cAs-7 221
c|a ?62I

( cA) Psl z
\r-:
cA

6̂

C,li^
Y

Candl date #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l )

1 O ur./

3Ov./

4Ot^/

S0 t^)

a 0 ttr./

8

9

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

(p. ny 
t'B', 

g.21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

.D I



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I - GENERAL ELECTIOI{

# of Black Candldates /

,t:-,/

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p.n1''*t'' (p. 21-22)
regress'lon extreme case
estlmate 'estlmate

,!.i -

Candldate # of each Black Candldate

-2n ',i,.'- a53

Candtdate #,s and Party of lilnnlng Cand'ldates ; ) 3 - D

Proportlon of B'lack
vote f or cand'ldate 1

(p. n1 ''Bc, 1p.2'l-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

.1q , v? s'*
)P ,35- ,-J-:

,j) . 'l i,la
2 nt.v

308

Candldate #
1, Party

5

6

7

I
9

CA,, /?> r!'
J tY 

-,

cAq

CA-
f

CA.
o€

cAa

cA :̂

County D*jr.*, TYPe of Electlon

0ate of Electlon

Name, PartY and

Number of
Votes for
Cand't date
# 1 (0. 18)

cAt lq'c t /
cAZ trl 4 i2

and Race ( o.'l )

I

tI
a

,
I

PIAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT

t5(b)
Gingle s



(-
:

Coun ty
Dr-,,e H A rvl

SUI,TTTARY SHEET

EASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

Type of Electlon HouS€ 6€ttg?Pt-

oare or Electl on lt- I 180 # of Black candldates #

Name, PartY and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

SPn ucDrNO,i; F3

Candldate #,s and Party of l{1nn1ng Candldates rf': r 2D' 3 0i

Proport'lon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. 4) ''t'1 (p.21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

t2la\r

Number of
Votes for Candldate #
Candldate 1, PartY
# 1 (0. 18) and Race (0.'l)

cAr fi Ai) r r,t, O
c^z }?:ei:

5

5

1

I
9

Lltt D

LJID ,82

Proport'lon of l{h1 te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p.4) HCt (p.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

<, <-

,.SS
,fdca'. A36aJ

ton 
,

cAs

cAo

cAr

cA^
o

cAg

,{},

,S)
,q?

, As

i

iI
iI

PTAINTIFF's
E(HIBIT

15(c)
Cing le s



SUIII,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUil I - GEilERAL ELECTION

Cand'ldate #'s and Party of lllnnlng Cand'ldates 1 ? U-D

Proportlon of l{h1tE
vote for candldate 1

(p. 4)P rc1 (p.21-22)
reqresslon erireme case
esilmate estlmate

.3 V -,2b ,21
61 L!_
0 b. ;L 6

.71

,Lb
,L?
,37

Candldate #
1, PartY
and Race (0.'l)

5

!
1

ry
cAo

cA7

cAa

-

cAg

PTAINIIFPS
D(HIBIT

l5(d)

i

I
5
A

T

county P, , , Type of ErecLlon J+-+ e*,
,ate of E.lecrl ,^W # of Bracr< cand,ro.,., a d
!{ame, Party and Cindl(ate # of each Black Candldate

il?u -t,o *

Number of
Votes for
Candl date

c^zt3Cs7 zO W
c[zt ?Eab 3o V

+OA

I

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate I

(p. n1 ''t', (p.2'l-22)
reqresslon extreme case
esi'lmate est'imate



*-#

SUI{I,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GE}IERAL ELECTION

Proportlon of Black
vote. for candldate 1

(p. n1 
t'Bc, 

(p.21-22)
regress'lon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

,t3 trJ , Sa ,9/
c[z tut,t ?2 Lp W .ll ,13 ,cq ,57

@rrruz ,P? ,q3 , v7_
cAr I ? LZ .00{ ,Dq , 0,{_

,lq
,00 L/

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p. +yP'tlc', (p. zi-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,a9
r.fu)
-i.G-

i

II
{ttIr

County y'* , TYPe of gtectton

oate of Etectl on /u r.r 9? # of Blact< candldates . /

llame , Par tY and Candldate # of each Black Cand'tdate

o

Candl date #'s and Parti of lllnnlng Candldates /,' 2 ,3 ' D

t{umber of
Votes for
Candl date

cAs

cAt

cAr

cAa

cAg

Candldate #
t, Party
and Race (o.l)

P tr/

5

6

1

I

#'t (0. 18)

c\ rqs?

PTAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT
lrrot

-.-r#Gingle s



SUI,II{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

county DUF*q14 TypeorE1ectlonSEpgT{ 6<ntr1
gate of Etectlon I I I ?A # of B'lack Candldates

Name, Party and candldate # of each Black Candldate

I n,? n,,? 1 ,t, , 3

Number of
Votes for
Cand'ldate
* 1 (0. '18)

c\ ttbl3
caz tit77
cAg 38 99
cAr31q?
cA.l

cAo

cA-
I

cAg

4L

Candldate #'s and Party of l{1nnlng Candldates

'8 o#
afa,v

t6
,l/

-

-

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (o.l )

r UJD

LruD
r8(
+ /r rR

6

1

9

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p.n1 ''Bc, (p.21-22)
regresslon extrene case
est'lmate estlmate

,8i
'A l'

t'ulb
,OE

/)-a

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1''*t', (p. 21-zzl
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,,5/ ,S?

'(0 ,{3 ,r7
,11 ,17
,JO ,lK

: PTAINTIFPS
D(HIBIT
'16 (f )

G:lng le s



t,
't

SUI{IIARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ I - GE}IERAL. ELECTIOI{

r O , . .) ? | '

county UrJ* Tvpe of Electl on i/- /-
oate of Electl on ApA' - ? # of B'lack candldates

llame, Party and Candldate # of each B'lact Candldate

(/ " a i ^

Candldate #'s and Party of l{tnn'lng candldates '/ ,' 'l t C, P , ?, l? - 0

llumber of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (0. '18)

cAt rol ba
CA:, tllo{

Candloite f
t, Party
and Race (0.1)

uFw
Z0tV

30 4
4D,t )

Proportlon of Blact<'
vote for candldate 1

or
(p. 4) BCt (p.21-22)

regresslon extreme case'
estlmate estlmate

Proportlon of l{hlte
votE for candldate 1

o,l

(p. 4) HC'r (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,'2
,02
,1(o

,)1
,0 b

,/0
,0 h _

, OP

,lb

cAs sa, ? so LU

.t7 ',Va

'01 ,/). )4.

,il ,2P
.2q .-il fa
.03 rl
, a? .3)
,Oa ,14

cA6 tql tb
ciltLo?b
ua/o?32

6Dt./

t9u
8D \J
9D \Y

,3 2
.tb
, Yb

,90
tb .ro

cilgnql/ ,l{

u+)o'lo/

i
j
,
A

I
I

P[AINNFPS
D(HIBIT

17(a)
SingLes



_--

County /,-) *.

SUI{IIARY SHEET

EASIC RUII I - GENERAL ELECTION

Type of Electlon

/,,i .,-. Black Candldates
{

Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate
n4

,

,L-..-, ,...- /.1, ,. *.;

Propor t 1on of trJh 1 te
vote for candldate 1

(p. +yP'tlc', (p. zt-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate

'-)
0

.c;a i # of

/*1..-r- d F.l

Candldate #'s and'Party of l{lnnlng Candldates

0ate of E'lectlon

l{ame, PartY and

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (0. 181

CA' r uc, 
^lJ\ I l't<r-

[cAa: ) s-s:
\-
CA^ e'r F, ,\

Jl l->o,

cA5 ? lu ''-
3o .'i q lu

cAt t't i i:
cAa?ti)4

.t4 L:/

20 13

-

.8 t ,31

Candldate #
'l , Par ty
and Race (0.'l )

1iu)

3OyV

-

4i)tv,

5 t) t,,'

6r) '. t

t , ) 'r.i:-L,+-

8r.):r'
q -.. 

'! r r.r'j.L#

Proportlon of 8'lack
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1 
t'Bc,l 

g.21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

J.'t

.i a

-

. a-7

,lu
D

-

,3 /

, ')t?

,43
V/

-l-J-J-1 t^
I .) tlJ

-

,AS
] -i (.'

,y?-

aa -<- A

,14 tLl

/.\ uf]

, /e

-

i, i

t.l u

: PTAINTIFF'S
EXHIBITt7(b)..*trrgtes

cAgJ338,]



lk-,A

SUI.:I,iARY SIIEET

. BASIC RUII I -, GENEP.AL ELECTION

county :!J.!., Type of Erectl on ,./-L-,,;-u ..--<'(l , ,-. .'l

Date of Electl on A.! f ' I V # of B'lack Candldates

Name,Partyar:dCandldate#ofeachB.IackCand,ldate

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
d I (0. l8l
CA.l rS u gl
ffi o-.,, 4,- .;t-*-*:
v-_,,.,*)'-

cAq c:.t ls
cAst37 d.l

CA6rrJr-f/

cAl s r:::.
CAg,t-tr:

c\.:.'rt.t''

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. o1 
P'8c', 

(p.21-22)
regression extreme case
estlmarue e.st'imate

,TJ) ,1 ?

Propor t 1 on of 'dh I te
vote for candidate 1

(p. 4)t'*t', (p. 21-22t
regresslon extreme case
estimate est'lmate

' 'l ," o #t-',

Candldate #,s and Party'of l'llnnlng Candldates 
- 

I 
=b 

fi,

Candldate #
'l , Par ty

1D"ll
zD8,
3DUy'
q.D vJ

5 '/1 't)

6 /l ttt

I ( '"'.'

g,{tv

9 
^: 

'r,

, ?0 ,

,r q

Iq_
. vi'
.V I'

.\ t\)'f ,r

-l -l
a).
,i?

. -7 f ,-7J
-i) 1l

,i',r1' 0i

_.04,
c

tl

: PTAINTIFF'S
D(HIBIT .
17 (q) 

?

Gingles :

. ''-' U

,rly
. ?r

-1 il'lJt

.36

.,: ..,

il



t.J-'

SU}IIIARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I - GENERAL ELECTIOT

tlumber of
Votes for
Candl date
#'t (0. '18)

cAt . o 3t2
gs',=

cA:2 aL t b

-

cA+gbto

cls I t' t{
cAa tPt,8)
c\Q3eq

,Pa
,2P
.0t,

J2a
,12
,OP
,A Ll

,dP

, A.I
,?5
.3?_
,O L

aLl

,l)
ron

,01

Proportton of l{h1te
vote for candldate 'l

(p- 4)t'*t', (p. z1-22)
regresslon exlreme case
estlrnate estlmate

,qr_ ''

,'/l
,51

,10

.vF
,37
,9D
,2?
,20

\,1 
,/

,11

,/3

,al
11,o\ J

P[AINTIFF'S
DfiIBIT
17 (d) 

"Gingle s

County TYPe of E'lectlon

0ate of Electl on /., 
eZ # of Blactc Candldates' I

llame, PartY and Candldate # of each B'lact< Candldate

Candldate #,s and Party of l{lnning Candldates /' 1,? 
) 

( ) /Qj /)-D

H:I::':.:l''lli!*''
cand'ldate # (p. o1 ''Bc, (P"21-22)

i, Party' regresston extreme case

:Ic oacl rc. t r esilmate estlmate

1?d
2n B
lp Y"/

1DV

50 t'v

6 D ,a./

7o ^/
8D u/

''l I

9 Du/ _,01



..1

County Type of Electlon

SU}II{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ I . GENERAL ELECTiON

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

or
(p.4) BCr (p.21-22)

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,81

0ate of Electlon

l{ame, PartY and

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
f 1 (0. '18)
4

cAr 3qgql
cA:. q os3t

It I f X # or Black candldates+
Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate

F tt'6 n a-

Cand,ldate #,s and Party of t{lnn1ng Candldates' 1,, 2 ,3, \ , C; C-D

CJ.3'4a i2
c^+ 3qo{t
cAs qoogb

cA6 ?9,t3 ?

c\ 7o ?tt>
cAs i t598
c*, )0331

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race ( p. I )

t (J)D

4N0
5 l,u0

a LUt)

7 UU{

8ilR
s ,UIt

.tr4
a.i,Jl

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) Hcr (p. 21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

30

,9,?
rCltOl

zb). "?l ,10 'Q,T q1

tUD .f5 ,'r5 'LJY
<A

,( I ,\4 , '15 , Lt'\

. g_i ,6T '/,95
,fr I ,qY

Ll7
tlJ

G
I l!zt lJ

:
, t()

-

ar

---l.5

,10

,83

-

0

-

\J

,Ol

,Dl

I

aI

PLAINTIFF'S
D(HIBIT
l7 (e)
Gine Ie s

ftoo 1€



\+
a--

SUt,t!,tARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ i . GENERAL ELECTIOII

County EDG€CoAa Type of Electl on /]Cv1€ ]4,- ..1,1 1,t
Fl(. ,' i, . /''! ;:-.'t

0ate of E'lect'lon .44-Yf # of Black candldates

llame, Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

cA.r 5al ? 1 bJ ?
c^2 ,791 2 !.uD

-

,0, 
' 
tV . i:" ,o?

Qqoqewfr
c[s,)f?7
cA6 gr(oo

CA- < j.x f
I J:r4 )

cAg

6? ,c'){
7)t 'l(r, ai t3.A

,la ;l 0
,!1 C

:4. ,aJJF-

J+ ;.d)
,2q

, {-,,#

-f:;-)
'icO

4tlt o\- tiQ

I
9

PTAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT

l8 (a)
GingLes

Candldate #'s and Party of l{lnnlng Cand'tdates I \ ' io - - D

llumber of
Votes for Candldate #
Candl da t e 'l , Par tY
# 1 (0. '18) - and Race (o.l)

Proportl on of B'lack
vote for candldate 1

(p. 4) 
P BCr 

( p.z\-zzl
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

Proportlon of t{h1te
vote for cand'ldate 1

or

(p. 4) Hc't (p. 21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmare estlmate

,01

cAg



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

county W lL 5C A), Type or E1ectlon #Ot-'':5 Pt tm 'ftL\

gate of E'lectl ,^ ,, / Yl # of a'lack Cand'tdates /

Cand'ldate # of each Black Candldate

c4,(T€A n 3
Name, PartY and

Cand'tdate #'1and Par ty of lil nnl ng Candl dates l,L) ,1, 1-D

l{umber of
Votes for
Candl date
s 1 (0. 18)

c\ {xt4
cez tbbL

.G8,3,
cA4 E^13
CA.;;1 1 !
-le:->.w
c\ qicS

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l )

t 1il0

z Jj}
sAC

6 t,.r l)

I

Proportlon of Blacf
vote for candldate I

(p. n1 
P'Bc,t 

(p.2'l-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

' i5 'dd e(o\.o\

Proportlon of t{hlte
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-22)
regresslon ertreme case
est'lmate es tlmate

,A

,ba

, 5'1
,16

,ft

,ob ,os ,11
a/

i. -t I'J

,lA
, q+

14
e<

,06
,ia

lb
,n2

-l, )/

,23
*

z r../ L,

-

,51, l] Jbb
CA^

6

CA^,

: PLAINTIFF'S
DffiIBIT
18(b)

Gingles



,.a i ' 'l
/?,1-o (t.'e'5- ltst-t '''e'r

SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECT]ON

Black Cand'tdates I

.., 
t

,-t
Type

#of
county 

u' 
u/ 

,

t/ J,
of Elect1on b<c.,4 ;'-,-t,t,-,1

(1,,.-.c- tq,?eOaie or Electlon

Name, Party and Candldate # of each B.lack Candldate

( p. 4 ) t'\ tr. r',
regresslon

,SJ
,n

-

,SP€
,3a€

Proportlon of l{hlte
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-22)
reqresslon extreme case
estlmate eetlmate

^eq
,tf , t1
.a 3 ,a-f

--

,Y ? . s.(-

P'a\ 
(p.2r

on e\treme
-22\
case

A

cand,tdate #,s and Party of l{lnnlng candldates ' 07 q 0 , ( r7 ; n

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (0. '18'l

c\ Gq€t

cAn s3?t
CAS : f.: /
c^a Ci2 i
cAt t c,,
cAe

cAg

Candldate #
1, Party '

and Race (0.'ll

10 w
20 w

3t^B
40 tv

50 w

6 0 ',,',,t

Low
I
9

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 'l

-

,30 \ 'ltl 'b/
,J/ ,f', ,f7

\

Ginqles



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUII I . GENERAL ELECTIOII

*)usf Pn irn-€
county lJ 12 -E f>'U,l t Type or Erectl on fr)i)\? /R irr'-

gare of E.lectr ,n '6 I YL # of B'lack candldates

Type of Electlotl fTL/'/ -)t- I t.' t tt " -

Itlame, Party and Candldate # of each Black Candldate

(eF:aR,7,D

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
* I (0. '18)

-

ca., i / c:'o
Ft t|-.tava) 1> o>
--c\ ? 11;
e.\ t 1536
cA. " *-i

) , J-/

@3w

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l )

I

9

l{lnnlng candldates t, q , L 1- O

Proportlon of B'lack Proport'lon of l{hl te
votl for candldate 1 vote for candldate 1

,0s. .tj ,lb, ,t4=
/r' f) ,01 ,dtt[i'a '-l 

-

ol

(p. n1 
P'Br,' 

19.21-2?r (p. +1P'ttc'' (p. 21-zz)
.iir.siton extreme case regresslon extrene case

esiimaie esttmate estlmate estlmate,

t4_- ,3o , [5 ,61

,)0 '- , Zl 
"+ 

q 
'di?

,lD ,2i, ,e5 .A+
4-ALL/1,A, .J[ ,0n 'b)FTT@

CA^
6

%

: PIAINTIFF's
EXHIBIT

18(d)
Gingles

Candl date #'s and PartY of

l./,t0
z lrtO
, ED
4 L\,'D

s htl
o ltt{)
7 lt,D



SUI.II$RY SHEET

EASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

county g 0 Type of Elect1 onlsr US 0a)6{255 ri' i'}rt'€'i
I

# of Black Candldates

Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate

M lC it A,:ti . ), -z i
:'!

Party of Ufnnfng Candldates

[late of Electlon

l{ame, PartY and

Candtdate #'s and
/, a

n-
(v t1,7 t\

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

(p.+1P'ttc, (p. z1-zz)
regresslon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (0. '18)

cA.r srr /
c^z h57w
cA+

cA-l

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (o.l )

rgD

5

6

1

I

9

Proport'lon of Black
vote for candldate 1

( p. n 1 '' Bc', ( p.21 -22 )
regresslon extreme case
estlrnate est'lmate

, tro
,0>

, 8q

,'(3
., O4 ,OT

,07

lv t

i

It
eIa

PIAINTIFF'S
D(HIBIT
l8(e)

Gingles

cA-
I

%
cA

Ŷ



./-a--

SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ t . GEI{ERAL ELECTiON

County <t) Type of Electl on A",l U1 ?cnLresS Pri ,nk r f

Candldate #
'l , Par ty
and Race ( o. 'l )

'6D
3

4

(+
6

7

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

or

(p.4) BCt 
1p.21-22)

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,?1
,0/

,?7
,0C*

Proport'lon of f{h'lte
vote for candldate I

ol
(p.4) HC't (p.21-z2l

regresslon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

,0s
1gcAz 571i; 2 kJD

cA-
J

cAc

cA.l

cA.
o

cA'l

cAg

CAo cr

- : PTAINTIFF'S
D(HIBIT

I

oate of E'lect1 * 1 I rL # of B'lack candldates

-

Name, Party and Candldate # of each 8lack Candldate

D

Candtdate #'s and Party of l{lnning Candlda}.es /D

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (p. '18)

c\ 5ii:7



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

counry W I t- 5O ,t/ Type of Electl on t',r ! )S Aa,NA,t$ f?rffiA?'l

0are of E.tectl ,^ b I Q a. # of B'lack cand'tdates

l{ame, Party and Candldate # of each B.lact Candldate

lA lct44 u(,, i\,, I

,t5 t 01
,1 )

a

tIta
St
E

P[AINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT

18 (e)
Gingles

candldate #,s and party of t{1nnlng candldates 
"-' 

D 
,

llumber of
Votes for
Candl date
F.1 (0.'18)

c^1_3gqq

cxi t1.11

cA3 s3s1
cA+

cAs

cAs

CA-
I

cAg

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (P.'l )

r BD

Lwo
3 LUD

4

5

6

7

8

9

Proport'lon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. n1 
t'BC, 

g.2t-22)
' regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,1s

,01

,01

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-22)
regressl on extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

,06 ,ii ?

cAg



SU}II,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

4 
US ( vt aresS

( t ) i L1) A)- Tvpe of E'l ec t 1 on !!!!t
Data of E'lect1 on 7l 8 * Black Candtdates

County

Candl date

)

?P tnA RY

; .' :.^.1 nl-

l{ame, Par ty and Candldate # of each

rvl tci:,4v K

#of
B'lack

,,\,

a \rI I

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
{ 1 (0. '18)w

Candldate #'s and Party of hllnnlng Candldates

,qy
,01

-

-

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race ( P. I )

,Proport'lon of Blacf
vote for candldate 't

or

(p.4) BCt (p.21-22)
regresslon ertreme case
estlmate estlmate

,11

Proportlon of l{hl te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4) HC't (p. 21-22l
regresslon extreme case
estlmate ' estlmate

,ll
,7'-lcAz ?lL) z t,O n_- -

3

4

5

6

1,

I
9

cAl

cA+

cAs

cAs

cA'l

cAa

cAg

,e1
,70

-

-

i

II
a

TI

PTAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
18 (h)

Gingles



, al l.-l

SUITI,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

J) ,
County 

' /l t *- /t

0ate of Electl on 'l'" '--l. /f I a

Name, PartY and Candldate # of each

Type

#of
B'lack

of Electl on A..",--'* iJ 
'4t'v' 

'..+?

Black Candldates

Candl date

cA: tcfr
cAr

cAs

cAo

Candldate #
l, Party
and Race (0.'l )

10 6
20 n./

3aV
4

5

6

1

8

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. +; 
P'8c', 

g.2r-22\
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'1mate

Proportlon of t{hl te
vote for candtdate 1

(p.4)''*'', (p. 21-zz)
regresslon ertreme case
es t 1ma te es t'lma te

,0 It

-

AlatV'e

-

01
t_f

: PIAINTIFF'S
offilBlr
18(i)

-

Gingles

cAz

cAa

cAg

/lrl )^/. ,, - {F/ D

Candldate #,s and Party of l{1nn1ng Candtdates Ir3-,8Ul,tt *UU"f I vfiln Nqtt'

l{umber of
Votes for
Candl date
* 1 (0. '18)

(fi',)'.'3.-:-

-

CA, ij <rrt

-*



a'

l--
.t

.&,11 ,/ r-ur'-"h

SUI{i{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUI{ I . GEilERAL ELECTION

County

Date of E'lectlon

Name, Party and

Type of Elect'lon

# of B'lack Candldates

Candldate # of each B'lack Candldate

, ",'i''l^"', / /,

Candl date #'s and Party of l{lnnlng Candldates 1o

l{umber of
Votes for
Candl date
# I {o. 18)

-

cAt 
'l ol q

cAz ?ct z

cAg

cA+

cAs

cAo

cAr

cAg

cAg

Cand'tdate #
l, Party
and Race ( o. I )

10 a
2D t/
3

4

c

6

1

I
o

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

ot
(p.4) 'Pcr g.21-?21

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,31

Proportl on of t{h1 te
vote for candldate t

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-zz)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

,0q
d.\

.? (

,/Ll

PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT

18(i)
Gingles



BASIC

SUI{I{ARY SHEET

RUNI.GENERALELECTION

County €D Type or Electlon CoUntr! OOnen P€ir;'iAEY

oate of E'lect1 on b f ? *'
- tl

# of B'lack Cindldates 1

llame,PartyandCand,ldate#ofeachB.lackCandldate

{.,Pa€N 1,4
lY\c [LArrrr 'il, f
albn ur D, ?

I^JALk€P-,,y ,tA
Cand,tdate #'s and party of l{lnnlng Candldates A, p, t D - D

t{umber of
Votes for
Candl date
{ 1 (0. '18)

cet3428
c^ziifr
ca'" %71
cAq i o ?r)
,.l ' ()a.4t^5 ! (,5u-w
c\ 3t?8w
ca, ,t i-)l

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race ( o. I )

r /,UO

Proportlon of Black
vote for cand'ldate 1

( p . n y '' B'l (p.21 -22 )

regresslon extreme case
est'lmqte es tlmate

,0S 'A 3,Lt ,/a

,0?
,1 0

Proportlon of l{hl te
vote for cand'ldate 1

(p. n1t'*', (p. 21-221
regresslon extreme case
est'lmate estlmate

-.1 
I
^t'7t 6/

-e a,1 {
i \)-)

-

,0b
--

'/J
,04

z ltJD

s LUO

n 6D
s8D
o \-.U 0

1 j)D
s-6 D

9 i-UD

^Atsl 
^,t t ,

,ib_

.Ar)J
,fL

a,e,\r./)€
()

-->g-

,q?€
\qi

r <v/

. i J

.r\aLi t

---- ru/
a,r .r i

,il))

A-

, !)
,Oi

, a[
l l'\,)

,01

i

I
I
d
I
E

P[AINTIFF'S
O(HIBIT
t8 (k\
G:'.ngles

,cq



SUI{I{ARY SHEET

RUNI.GENERALELECTIOilBASIC

County
9L,--/r'.\'F'-''l Type of Electlon

0ate of E]ectlon ,L-n:t l f ;'- # of Black Candldates

t{ame, Party an.d. candldate # of each Black Candldate

r ) r/
h-,! a,(.i-t* O fi{ Z

i
A

/4,

Candldate #
1 , Party
and Race ( o.'l )

1 r) t,.t

2DB
3DA
48W
5

6

7

I

Proportlon of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. +1 
P'Bc'' 

(p.2'r-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

, )q

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

o.
(p.4) HCt ('p.21-22)

regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

, 9?
,3f,
,J I

: ,14

,'//
--

,2{
d)L_

,q4
.10

,Li€ 13

cAg

cAg

PTAINTIFPS
O(HIBIT .

l8(1)
Gingles

Candldate #'s and Party of l{lnntng Candldates 'r'2 ,3 - fi

Number of
Votes for
Candl date
* I (0. 18)

?\7'! i c

@j.,
gy-r3l'

CA4 ;-:i:i,;
CA.l-
cA-

o

cA7



I 
- '/') ,iJ

SUI{I{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GEI{ERAL ELECTION

/ )'l a-- -!?r^-rr-r /-- -/ .'-/ ' 'i)'
County /' /, .'; t--t Type of Electl on C'''/.. /( J l''t''n'*'L

6'

Date of Electl on la--.2 i'z -i ? # of Black Candldates 
' / 7/ '

llame, Party ano candtdate # of each 8lack Candldate

I n.LAt

-
Candldate #,s and Party of l{'lnnlng Cand'ldates I ,i 't. '" . iC ' ;2 ' "' - D

..-. . . u!
1'Z *a)I

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 1

or

(p, 4) HCt (p. 21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

t A r-f

,2 :I.

-D 1iS
,- r_.>J

,34 _

f-.-Lae-t;-:/ )'-. t',
r\J

t{umber of
Votes for
cand'l date
# I (0. 18)

c\ ina r

cAz ! r',?
CA, q; .r,,

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (P.'l)

1 Olt)

2 Ov\i

3 fi t,./

5.'') ''t-

6 *) j'.

'l D :t.i

etC
*t

9't) L:

Proport'1on of Black
vote for candldate 1

(p. +y 
P'Bc,t 

fi.21-2zr
regresslon r,extreme case
estlmate estlmate

.tt
,l{

,01
, l'{
,)3
,t?
,l/

. -iD

' .-> 'i

,2 t



,
a.. r

SU}iI{ARY SHEET

BASIC RUN I . GENERAL ELECTION

County 'l/l*./l TYPe of Elictlon
dgate of E'lect1 s1 /,r.- -t /:t ))- # of Black Candldates 7

Candldate # of each Black Candldate
/

,l/rr.^.',.-..^,,.-, o E (

Candldate #,s aiO party of l{lnnlng Candldates 7, U. : - 4

Proportlon of B'lack Proportlon of l{h1te
votl for candldate I vote for candldate 1

(p. 4) 
t'rr,, (p.2r-22) (p. +1P'ttc,' (p. zr-zz)

reiresiton extreme case regresslon extreme case

eiitmate esttmate est'lmate estlmate
\ :) 2z

\,40- ,vf ,2))

-T--

,2h ,v'? ''?l
a /. u2 -A
-^ \ 'Y' 'q'l
s-1 \ , [':? t -,1

Name, PartY and

tlunber of
Votes for
Candl date
# 1 (0. '18)

cAt tazl
cAz q tu,

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (0.'ll

1{)tu
t t) t.t+

3 t)tt!

4Cttt

50irt
6il B
1

8

9

PTAINTIFF'5
O(HIBIT

-18(n)GinsIe s

cAg



't

County lll|'A D-l/-) I Tvpe of Electlon

SUI{I,IARY SHEET

EASIC RUII I . GENERAL ELECTIOil

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for candldate 't

(p. n1''8c'' (p.2'r-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlma!e

Date of E'lect'lon

tlumber of
Votes for
Candl date
# I (0. 18)

-

Candldate #
'1, Party
and Race (o.i)

, ,3D

5

5

1

I
9

# of Black Candldates t_
Name, Party and candldate # of each Black candldate

[Y\tLPA't't ' I , i\

Candldate #'s and Par ty of l{1nn1ng Candl dates

Proportlon of l{hlte
vote for candldate 1

or

(p. 4 ) Hc't (p. 21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

c\tR)25
c^z iA13

%
cAo

cA-

cAa

cAg

2 lt) /\
3 hln

,94 , t 3 ,02 , OZ

,07 , c) ,oq ,c /
, 0'c ,01 ,'O laA

,/*

-

i P[AtNTtFF',S
DffiIBIT
18(o)

-t-

ut-ngIes



SUI{I,IARY SHEET

BASIC RUII I . GENERAL ELECTION

?*,,rfr e"l

,q7 , O.f ,o?

,(1 b ,Ol ,?t ,tb
CAo

cA+

cA-)

CA.
o

c\
cAg

cAg

: PTA|NTtFF'S

i ExHtBtT ,

i+s#h

County ,\ /A: €O- rr r I Type of E'lect1 on M
oate of Etectl on ,? lK? # of B'lack Candldates

-

t_
Name, PartY and Candldate # of each 8lack Candldate

Mr(,ry4i'-vi A t

Candldate #'s and Party of l{'lnnlng Candldates AD

Number of
Votes for
Cand'tdate
# I (p. '18)

c.qr r9g7/
cA^ a aaiq

Candldate #
1, Party
and Race (0.'l)

tBD

3

4

5

6

7

I
9

Proportlon of B'lack
vote for cand'ldate 1

(p.n1 
P'Bc'' 

(p.21-22)
regresslon extreme case
estlmate estlmate

Proportlon of l{h1te
vote for candldate 'l

or

(p. 4) HCt (p. 21-221
regresslon extreme case
estlmate est'lmate