Second Supplemental Memorandum on Behalf of Orleans Parish Board, Defendants
Public Court Documents
May 5, 1962
20 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Bush v. Orleans Parish School Board. Second Supplemental Memorandum on Behalf of Orleans Parish Board, Defendants, 1962. 2a26fd85-d2fd-f011-8406-7c1e526962fd. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/a69a6003-d511-45b1-aee2-477221c69fca/second-supplemental-memorandum-on-behalf-of-orleans-parish-board-defendants. Accessed February 21, 2026.
Copied!
Ey
A i a a ee EH HF
3
aE V A Ta m
SENET iy Sibi
a a a a TE a
a a
&
e
A i EE
misses
aad
a wr UL A A IIL ,
23 EE a ai
an
-
a A i,
BE & 8" 3 - 5 » =» &
» “® XX % 8 5 5 & % &
A Al LL
4 2 5 BB BF 2 hE EE Ee
» 5 5 9 CEE EE 2
2 2 i *
eg 5
%
v =
be 3 } v & Wl 8
¥ i 4 a To
{ t it 4h 5
- . # 8
ry, $3 y z
wa A 1 "
\ ¥ 2 4 *
“
a gs te a
wn ———
®
ad
WAR A
NE
i Ae a
#
ge 5
s 5
*
* 9 &
\
AN a a hE oh a ——
p : oe
: 4 AY % a?
ma das deste sibs
. &
%
. 8
LA
LB
$F ®
i
5 w
NS Sad
&
-
® = 5 ££ 8 8 = BR 5 0 8% 2 80 2 EF & » # 5
Ss Fa Py Ba & & & 2 BB 5 9 3 2 8 8 2 3
. . B= A F 5 3 . he H
h E : - : | ¥
i 3 5 y. F L 5 :
% » ¥ & E
yay DE % 4 TLE oF 5 4% 3 ¥ 4
& - to ae ES i EE ia
bh
: - , . én os 2 NEY ! :
4 & : # J pe A ’
Ny
a a - 4 i
ES
SN PAN RIA
= &
EN
> | {
A
B® 8% 8 3
a
52H »
5 > 5 9
SIN £% 4
§ oy i § 3
FM Fy
% 4%
NY eh
Pi 2
7 aa
wo win
Fai
wo.
~
N
a
opt
El RS ea ad
w
dn
h
e
§
A
E
a
r
d
w
e
® PRIA a
Se ]
Wired
§
¢
A
|
a
hc
o
X
R
e
3
.
e
w
¥
a
§
¥
»
sik
E
he
.
p
o
-
»
i
.
-
{
{
;
®
-
#
¢
,
"
5
D
n
3
hb
3
n
a
4
&
o
k
N
b
i
{
pe
3
»
d
-
a
.
5
¥
.
h
e
¥
:
St
R
t
Ad
4
e
e
pg
hb
d
o
s
>
’
%
.
R
O
gr
*
w
n
2
2
»
‘
¥
o
k
»
%
®
i
p
x
»
we
#
i
4
Re,
”
.
“
pe
+
X
8
a
foe
5
y
”,
-
i
:
-
\
6
o
n
a
v
i
g
ge
Re
~
.
.
a
:
&
g
u
d
a
3
%
b
v
Z
ay
F
d
e
d
%
=
&
h
i
a
YN
@&
Se
“
»
£
»
a
]
p
s
%
v
i
R
£
d
h
”
E
"
¢
h
i
a
2
2
-
.
a
-
%
»
"
hk.
"
*
e
d
h
x
»
L
o
.
'Y
g
5
P
o
r
,
-
3
.,
g
o
,
¥
=
-
Bw
¥
¥
n
i,
Wy
pe
»
prin
Jie
,
¢
#
M
Franek:
*
hy
»
#7
o]
§
pH
x
o%
J
:
a
1
»
|
.
»
n
®
#
a
:
2
a
%
;
pont
£
3
¥
.
in
id
”
-
p
o
d
y
.
-
%
#
£
2
£
5
»
#
4
%
ad
.
w
=
oS
§
¥
“
a
a
d
i
A
i.
R
R
5
i
a
:
:
Fl
:
)
.
n
"
g
p
d
#
E
N
S
:
h
o
:
p
a
:
P
g
.
1
of
L¥
LE
N
e
-
S
r
e
EE
:
§
-
"
as,
x
o
h
.
;
o
y
:
p!
~
.
=
a
v
nN
>
§
N
4
_
jo +0
w
3F
g
a
«
:
=
"
PE
5
%
$
d
.
a
”
fo
4
= »
a
g
o
t
e
d
|
ps
a
d
n
F
d
a
§
w
d
£
3
'
%
»
w
r
h
t
&
pov,
P
s
x,
pe
S
d
far
L
F
h
e
E
s
i
:
Es
:
"
{J
©
4
|
.
a
l
t
.
o
O
f
o
l
L
E
5
4
0
®
£
7
y
L
o
w
w
yr
{
a
a
l
:
%
i
d
H
e
’
N
w
v
)
3
oH
c
a
l
n
e
oe
n
N
gis
or
’
W
i
oo
E
i
Eh
Sid
W
e
or?
a
d
i
7
F
e
wi
pon
hia
Ee
rie
ok
“
&
>
¥
»
¥
a
-
—
A
D
e
oy
A
d
d
a
t
P
a
@&
E
n
PY
e
d
#
2
L
F
"
u
s
4s
ne
8
% ao
:
h
e
we
L
a
Lr
=
£
W
e
W
a
a
e
d
ry
,
p
p
ow
a
w
t
.
£
5
5
-
x -
v
“
4
Pup
-
%
{nad
”
sin
£
0
F
o
e
4
i
N
:
hata
we
ok
Q
F
.
i
=
3
©
:
£
£
£
£
5
o
u
aeiid
B
L
s
s
o
A
Eo
o
e
P
i
u
s
d
i
o
e
=
x
“
a
d
+h
3
A
¢
8
g
d
%
hi
Nt
1
4
3
3
a
’
.
=
8
="
}
4
&
£14
2
od
$
-
hs Bt
S
k
*
>
&
.
Sucd
S
e
"
ap
5
adr
1
9
;
$
¢
a
tar
~
F
F
o
g
E
O
; ok
Se
hot
a
~
wn
®
£
m
i
.
WW
pe
iid
iw
a
]
A
w
£
{
x
i
wa
a UL.
:
»
a) a gE
i Rr Yo
3 k an
5 : “ ENEY § Ena §
4 A
oe
: {s §
on &
cq on § & 33] 1! &
£5 v
we 9 IB oy 3 : i o
“i 3
£5 : f } §
1 ££ yi 5 En
Rn wo ;
A a Ee]
%
&% 5d A.
+
il # L &
$f 2 -_ Pe.
4 te $5 §
cy i §
i i
. .
FQ 4
! 1 £5 3
a
d
a
8 ‘
5 % ]
i £ :
» » eB
; : i £3 ba
§
= 5 5 & 4 ;
Ee I .
EY ¥ : Eh
3 y
3 § A E eg : 3
g $3 § 1 3 : } 8 © . » SRE
- . ¢ . y wy ¢ Yk J % 2 & #4 s 0% § 4
3 3 al \ Wit Fil 5
C8412 : Eat 4s 1 La i
k. i .
Ts a ry { $ 3
% & y . *
rm " i :
H 4 £2 Fil ¥ : Hy :
en Bo oF . 5 &
ex 3 3 ;
2 » {
EY 4 iY ¥
§
% = ns 4
“ @®
; > » £ % "
£5 9 3 in - 4 ™
Lo # 5 we Lad aX sn
a
‘ FF . ; £5
o i
y &
E¥ % : 3 A
* On
Po Ad TF i } H k IER J
We a bis € ; BEY iw
3 + _ bo 3 4
% i : » : :
. u Rs
. 3 : 4 “
# ” y 3 #4 §
“ nn $
*
¥ > wv ’
a : : wl
y ¥ we
aid 3 ¥ ¥ 1
§ Fo
4 TT 4 | &
a ul A a i a MIR. A
o ? » 5 i
¢ = { ] ® £
§f x 5 4 N \
1} po ’
i on § - ; §
det
a
: Ho pe * #% WY 4 3 f in wif y os : i a
YEE 3 With @ FLEE isle vi 1 2 y LJ Wal he is ly 114d d bd RR LTS
ANT RA IP I RE AIR Tie Dn - a a SH
5 % F
" i : i 5 3 § heh @% 5 4 Ls i 4 : 4 1% 4$ i £, \ a TeW 0, Ey £5 % H §
EB
a
i | . »
: | % 5 wi
Wy Ha § #8 -
if #1 i §
we 2 » , 3
7. 1 bis § ! i on
In 4 _ ¢ ; Gk Phe 3 ae oF an
£ n oy v " ~ a & » oy
{ ES § £81 i ¢ I 3 % 1 £3 TT ue
£3 8 4 5 ¥ a x g ¥ 4% 4 ¥ \
| ;
Sana SU ®
4 2 _2 A] 4 ©
§ R= y 3 £5 8 § " Fes 3 4
3 . x Ne fry A ¥ I k§ % % 4
! £14 § § 7 3 " *
5 pi Hg 4 i - Fad 2 ¥ § E o ] }
| i " p # w
» AS H end x i ; gh!
’ re 2 . 3 ! i 2 #
. 4 # ' . 4
3 3 i H gai § y } i" 4 :
te b % p, 8 Eanes " ¥ 3
ie
[4 a 4 % 9% # HE Ap 3 2 y *
We @ / ; % { 5 & EF 3 5
H 4
# 4 y % : bi 4 2% : 4 -
£4 #4 “ ¢ _ I . 5 & : i TL
Y ! i : EB 1
* = _ #
FF & : £
» " 3
J £3 § it 4 : Xt: } d a & fF 5
ojos Be 8 Sa F Tim & 4 as " i y - i Ww
_ RFR EET LF 4 ih § 3 & 3 k : 3 59 3 3 t
, 4 = ES ~ »
# ¥ $i ty
3
g F
SRO
Ey
R
E
i
-
a
4
R
a
d
™
Pore
rv
4
o
s
>
»
a
w
e
5
%
S
d
;
¥
wl
l
a
d
7
pa
on
&
od
Ls
:
Ee
1
#5,
P
n
E
™
3
u
4
V
a
S
i
4
£
.
a
un
ge
b
r
‘
Be
-
w
a
d
a
p
.
}
is
2
b
apf
n
e
5
po
{
o
y
n
y
w
i
L
M
*
-
h
g
:
&
i
apd
e
f
4
H
“>
i
pon
wii
v
&
A
H
wt
.
A
w
e
o
i
H
i
m
e
&
Ne.
h
e
!
.
>
W
i
de
hi
bor
:
.
»
P
i
§ 4
‘
oo
g
a
w
o
w
1
4
a
3
3
h
a
|
g
r
5
7
.
&
p
s
pe
i
.
*
pre
ada,
>
.
738
tor
ws
£
.
.
i
L
a
™
,
wi
a.
o
A
“
&
o
o
a
a
d
h
u
=
A
B
a
s
e
d
a
g
d
a
r
y
a
.
F
y
y
o
4
&
of
&
g
y
5
%
ER:
A
g
pa
w
o
#5
%
a
”
™
J
-
Re
‘
;
rom;
e
d
A
E
&
No
r
P
A
oA
9
Mi
L
3
5
wt
&
s
-
A
w
h
A
5
w
r
w
a
-~
3
£
9
Yad
[4
”
o
n
og
‘
0
P
o
»
§
=
®
A
N
}
a
n
&
_.
ey
¢}
§
-
ig
4
»
4
E
N
i
uy
_y
-
~
~
’
3
i
S
e
d
L
a
u
-
¥
4
<
-
py
i
aa
#
7
-
a
R
d
F
o
k
E
3
3
ts
-
"
o
k
&
ad
w
e
&
£
5
#4
%
¥
gr
&
Wd
Ls
f
r
=
id
yo
y
d
Fol
ayn
B
hs)
* a]
by
D
a
%
g pi
g
m
i
a
F
r
Wis
w
a
@
Cs
+ 3
&
#
22,
GrEUSOn Vig
this phase of the case, the Cours Be Bos
E7442
wy
JOE
Sa 3
bd sebion v at
&
vily upon Plesse
In
ans | 2 lie
L
P
9%
aliana
os refuse to
) 06
$
&
y
fal
»
do
Ww
4
Lar
§* E
d
ty pee
& gr
® poe
w
e
££. 3
a erisme for one t
on Involved an attack upon = 4
@r
wodations
oY
ren
¥¥
=
Care, 4 ad
: A
k 296 a
in rallro
oeeupy 1
#
¥
as bcm
i 3
pred
Sow
a
a
wu
£
p
o
m
Bh 4
“%
a
Feud
Fog
&
%
#5 OF ok >.
“x
[2
Li.
Er 4
S
S
S
r
ww
i
a
a
r
|
#
®
#
%
®
&
a
#
a
.
#
2
A
d
E
o
54
a
n
d
a
poh
%
3
&
if
a
”~
i
o
n
‘
1
w
G
o
d
£
i
e
WW
0
3
.
—
3
b
e
on
.
w
e
Ro,
a
5
%
wd
wk
od
fae
w
d
wid
h
a
B
o
_
&
psi
preg
#
=
»
ry Bn
7
Ee
EF
%:
"
We
al
R
a
d
%
a
Xi
ar
pow 4 Fa
a
”
”
aa
M
e
pate
o
t
*
8
h
o
X
.
n
e
p
n
F
k
&
%
id
M
y
w
w
o
w
Sad # fhe
-_ _ i 3
5 &
a
l
E
W
¥ L
E
P
R
8)
§ ond
4
ye
&
©
0s
h
»
i
P
e
CH
5
”
g
o
a
t
£5
he
3
b
4
3
:
g
a
‘
A
ne
po
EC
Sn
poo
{
‘
\
-~
od
.
-
»
+
=
w
s
£3
"
~~
nt
”
o
f
a
—
#
B
o
i
E
w
:
—
a
£
_
,
S
p
‘
donid
Rn.
e
r
E
k.
g
a
d
b
o
haf
.
Be
;
”
pe
"
o
e
oF
|
A
y
f
d
o
3
:
hd
gi
f
o
h
“
“
uf
-
£
5
p
o
#
»
F
s
4
v
a
-
e
d
a
eS
BF.
n
r
£
2
F
a
B
F
a
n
BR
p
w
*
%
h
e
gi
i
%
n
4
on
¥
$
4
5
4
.
.
3
236
Eo
+
do
#
P
Y
,
5
-
¢
-
pe
o
o
R
i
%
4
"y
.
%
r
s
3
Ss
5
w
i
f
goof
2
#
“
“
pi
h
d
ol
r
"
4
%
p
.
o
h
ihe
F
o
n
a
5
o
e
a
]
L
3
4
i
p
od
i
po
ne
o
y
od
a
d
i
4
y
d
"
A
r
3
i
p
o
a
'
w
a
»
.
W
e
:
#5
2
:
.
b
L
a
§
e
s
P
N
v
g
B
o
d
e
.
F
s
y
.
—
”
a
e
d
5
i
L
“
5
By
4
S
i
h
i
n
d
i
g
oy
m
"
1
’
L 2
4
on
BH
b
i
y
d
M
s
&
i
n
5
¥
Move
~~
B
a
d
kaa
.
Ee
w
e
#
y
PY.
’
¢
w
i
a
o
y
o
S
.
5
2
=
i
I
.
a
=
o
r
“
.
k
a
d
S
u
r
#
W
a
ole
4
he B
¥
-
a
g
nd
i.
r
e
2
$
i
d
_
jp
7
pat
"
F
w
a
ke
§
.
o
i
E
e
:
t
s
hy,
A
.
a
£
"
—
#
=
»
4
syosd
w
d
S
i
age
lt
_
{
i
by
#
&
"
H
&
ot
$53
P
g
X
Wy
r
e
A
Y
dol
.
h
e
pr /
5)
&
5
i
#74
%
d
a
ne
hs,
2
%
_-
i
b
™
ES)
S
i
P
l
hs
8
f
e
p
e
#
0
oe
is,
:
¥
¢
b
e
1
#
R
y
sind
EE
pi
{
.
B
n
$
o
g
=
1
~
pe
¢
V
a
i
"
.
»
.
Fo
%
5
>
1
“
®
gos
,
i.
~
a
pie:
-
wv.
—~
¥
wal
hi
hi
»
“%
»
a
ho:
"
W
o
-
3
5
2%
a
a
]
#
»
po
BY
P
o
p
r
&
.
e
y
po
m
.
i
R
O
W
=
L
=
%
%
&
w
y
pid
#;
"
3
y
a
o
e
wordt
¥
5
§
Bog
%
’
L
e
.
P
i
i
4
oud
8
#
¥
w
e
y
g
o
JEN
.
pons
w
i
d
"
8%.
.
a
#
3
»
8
.
.
Re
a
¥
host
W
Lal
g
g
o
H
o
o
e
#
w
v
4
”
w
k
i
3
i
”
3.
“
#
.
N
i
r
;
ped
pit
5
a
a
bose
:
w¥
d
7
=
3
ih
_
&
v
i
w
y
%
a
e
x
.
p
y
ion
3
oy
”
b
5
f
o
4
pt
“
.
os
.
3
w
i
a
e
:
o
f
p
u
s
a
o
3
-,
p
4
'
ew
5
¢
i
2
i
B
x
.
=
3
%
x
i
#
-
{
“
o
e
:
i
%
-
j
a
pis:
pe]
2
#
a
i
:
,
i
1
i
“%
h
w
a
L
;
;
%
%
:
pe
!
£4:
CE
£
pond
%
p
o
d
i
ji
:
W
i
£
fon,
S
v
p
o
i
pod
:
:
‘
5
to
i
/
:
.
)
*
ge
4
2
4
:
hay
.
3
%
-
A
=
»
i
5
a
b
e
"
“
hy
£
Fond
oe
b
‘
g
o
>
g
r
©
oe
_
ZINE
1
a
n
3
got
i.
”
5
¥
ae.
g
-
A
v
»
X
p
&
2
o
l
:
+
§
&
aid
wl
n
wl
F
ia
E
W
.
i
:
’
y
:
-
»
y
"
W
y
fs
#
5
@
oA
t
a
,
p
o
"
a
sod
¢
3
K
h
o
:
¥
pow
he
§
LF
§
&
-
-
&
3
%
a
;
3
8
.
AR
&
7
E:
:
3
ue
B
T
P
k
~
ue
:
Wha
3
-
N
J
a
a
5
anid
§
4
n
d
4
"
E
t
E
L
L
r
&
&
o
oF
’
3
HE
-
w
l
Rhos
:
proved
hs
w
d
a
b
#
Re
_
i
¢
i
2
3
»
&
e
d
¢
‘
!
”,
rn.
:
-
4
h
w
+
»
Wi
h
d
Ly
A
F
&
z
a
,
.
pe
0
F
G
a
“
w
w
add
:
%
Fonl
-_y
“
a
J
w
e
o
d
i
:
h
—
-
h
d
.
an,
4
h
o
:
F
o
7
A
;
pe
pio
4
£
#
:
5
Cd
V
d
¢
5
9%
-
pte
%
prt
w
n
ks
£
3
Kew
5
3
=
g
A
He
p
g
ke.
i
x,
#
fs
om
s
o
#
‘
X
“
C
E
J
py
paid
ye
a
RB,
"
!
*
Lt
i
»
o
n
;
“
p
o
d
$
-#
¥
p
e
d
’
a
A)
.
ke
Se
N
a
d
w
i
:
8
#
r
e
in
»
*
[owe
by
‘
h
e
i)
v
h
o
C
o
]
p
e
d
£
§
%
E
N
—
F
E
n
t
&§
A
We
of
;
®
Sg
#
W
w
i
£
1
3
fon
W
r
casi
#4
-~
£
7
e
»
“
ks
—
a
"
w
t
a
et
F
3
B
g
E
P
»
w
i
:
pe
LL"
b
y
3
}
a
ed
-
>
{
3
%
L
—
y
n
JP
a
e
S
r
~
~
&
3
2
;
d
m
=
A
pa »
y Z f : 3 :
EP i eve g ® 2
54 4 ¥ B. 3 3 : Xa > 5 43 $4 i 4 FB ots @ *
sad
: x ;
EP tad iE ¥
: # " “5
3 x x § i # 5 §
#F Bs Ne i « ]
N - doo B® a. a ws * 3 pd FL Ea Sa 3 ts r 3 a
. 5 # #%
" Po Pe B wh #5 i
£3: 2 i 15% WF = ‘®
EN su bart
Bau B® ’ ¥
Cy ah
4 J
3
- FE og
+ WY Ny y ¥% ¥% 3 ¥ £3 Te
A o . A EC rR » ® hd # * hd
# * - & 3
& ~ Bh Ty a . § #3 % 2 = 3 3 F Fog " & ¥ ok MS 0 bo re Bil ep : LER
aE Ea ; TIN Gre RN: SE IS AS am Re A AA RE TT Ee
Sh 5 2 ra. 1 EF) ed " . TRE cm fF ap wn 3
os 3 ‘ % E 3 | Le :
KR ra : k » i ead F
1:74 \ E03 [Ll & 2 i } CHCA )
1 £ og ud % ny 3
4 . ¥ % ¢ FJ ce Be $ H
! 2 ¥ # p = we
% "5 q % "
= 3
El
i 8 ¥i i F 3 i : 5 3
eo,
3 i
3 ® 4 % a : £4 ¥ 3 % § 1 5
minded - so " irs ee A ot ata ’ vd 4 §
Taal hE I : ; he ¥ # ¥ 7 s #
[
I EIS RI AEB
3 1 : HY : Ph Fog 1 \ % : p
* f iy L Pe i} © rs denle ! ls SOL
om &
5
, £1 ; & "ny
«Te IB ® vo . N en ih 3 o
oh OF 4 - . rs * d i p a
vo d a % : F | H iF © po Fo
~ # # y £ a
Sebald wo ® * a
7% . A i 5
L i ote
—. ———
@ * :
Pl ; oy
u ¥
Ee 8% CAs % i
sof
Fi, | h
o
/
t f y
2 on 3
p
e
EW
ad