Response in Opposition to Renewal of Defendants' Application for Stay and Motion to Strike Exhibits
Public Court Documents
March 26, 1970
11 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Hardbacks. Response in Opposition to Renewal of Defendants' Application for Stay and Motion to Strike Exhibits, 1970. 02f08904-2e34-f111-88b4-0022482cdbbc. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/ba2f78ae-5363-4924-8289-1518e8110960/response-in-opposition-to-renewal-of-defendants-application-for-stay-and-motion-to-strike-exhibits. Accessed June 02, 2026.
Copied!
[||89d5dfbc-e365-44a7-91d2-029c5cd5b028||] \
a
-
Cogan,
BE
aie
BE
a
e
TO
a
n
B
l
a
n
e
SN
c
e
W
e
n
a7 k,
CrTVT A
1 hy
~ w=
DOYNT CQ
TIN,
NQF
43) RE
—
—
move 1 y
—
r
owing.
I!
tH
1
i! |
| |
| i
| r y ‘ , ; 1 §. { 1 C i
! U. JR 19 and C C Tic 1 \ o W¢ » L el ll 3 10 P: T1550 ly yO J Bo "0 ein) 9 re i
I — RE —— RE. a - - - - - - a - ——— - - i
{
i
| |
| . TE < "Jd 2 4 i. a > oo; oh, Ri 5 ‘ Es 3 +1}
| quire that implementation of the District Court's plan proceed as scheduled. |
| i
|
| 1. Onn March 5, 1970, this Court, upon-a ication by defendants, |
| §
i
{ a 1 ~~ tod . i 3 pe 0 Boh Lh - .- i 1 - 1 107% i
| directed the District Court to make additional findings with respect to he |
|
|
general issue of bussing and the effect of its order [of February 5, 1970] |
{
| with respect to the number of pupils transported, the number of buses re-
: a crey 11 + 1 - ale Na + ~ FY 2 3 oy 3 + <n 3 ~~ I quired and available, and the additional capital operating costs of
ia rated 1 my ) as LRA RR a - 1 ih A is ak i
transportation’. The Court stayed the provisions of the District Court {
}
i
1 A ~1 3 ~ 3 AC TOT ON TYNI OF 1 [a 1 3 yO an 8 1 1 3173 171% >) NC » Order requiring reassignments and transportatic arising out of the pair-
ET MERI, Fer, TENE AALS IS rT Ep RL hr St . kameinon, WEWERMRC, PLO PTY on vir a rs wg Beret ! ing and clustering of schools with resulting cross bussing . 'I'ne remaining
ot pci £ Lia To, RA TS JRL . WRI ‘ TE RR er or Te TIE cite ian 7d pean reads br Le dh t portions of the District Court's Order were left in tact, and, except as to
{ s ’ i
1. he ae EA ET ere nl Cava oy py di] phen SURRY oh ls Ck Pa i SE erie A ra vy dnl Si
the cross bus Sing, the appli cation for s tay was denied. Implementa tion of
| H
|
= a | ig 1 i 3 verte 3 pal + ny arr ZK NTN YT i}
the X einaining |S, YX E10NSs OF the Ox ger was Glirecieg at ne times ang in the
!
« 1 1 £7 A 13341 Arn] 3 TT a] 3 4 NA ! x7 N + 4 } 4+ 3 14 7 manner specified. Additionally, the District Court was directed to modify
; . 1 1
| its Order if necessitated by the partial stay so as to "achieve a cohesive :
4 i
3
and efficient system of pu TS A We Re blic education .
ey
of counsel, voted to renew its application for stay. Xach member of the
Board prepared letters in support of this application. We move below that
[ these letters and the letter from the staff which are attached to defendants
application as Exhibits 1 - 11 be stricken. These letters were prepared and | {
| dated on Friday and Saturday, March 20 and 21. In the evening of March 21, |
|
1970, District Judge James B. McMillan completed and mailed Supplemental |
I | |
| Findings of Fact and a Supplemental Memorandum. The Supplemental |
|
|
Tid inoa ov \ NY ATArliIITy avs atta alo ACD a Wy TI Findings and Memorandum are attached hereto as Exnil
qo J
| Ts 3 rev ples 3nd Yoni vray vy ird vies tN AR 2S nS OS A TTT TVS TY Cl YY Sry OY ot wrli ty
| 2. I'he deiendants nave advanced No ary gumeni SNOOTY Yeasonns wihicn
!
| were not previously presented to this Court why the Order should be stayed. |
! 1
| |
|
| We would assume that this Court in requiring implementation of the Dis-
Los ds Wg PREETI SPE 17 0 ruven ani pd etn ae prep) ely pe ey 4 | trict Court Order of February 5, 1970, considered and rejected these claims] | 3 J
| |
|
{
—
| &d
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
a
—_——.
A
Z
A
—
—
—
—
—
—
-
—
-
AA
ES
™
a)
)
rr
:
sg
2
-’
-
hal
o
r
-
~
writ
~~
o
n
=
oo
~
r
5
“
A
v
ot
p)
~
oy
Vi
re
i
=
CA)
=
{
.
30)
ec,
y
oud
Jd
3
y
A
et
in.
i
i
=
i
i
p
-—
e
l
€))]
S
e
J
~
~
o
r
(
V
C
"
r™N\
~
”~
3
y
s
~
~
ps
i
pry
\
yl
-
wy
ne,
4
(
J
h
i
~
Ua
—
Oo
a
d
~
po
rey
fet
.-
ne
~~
7
"
y
e
OD)
LY
~~
If
—~
i
i
ood
PR
ry
bf
\
p
d
Poi
A
Pe
%
|
~~
»
O
c
=
=
red
,
~
a
go
0
:
-
Ld
ri
~~
J
oN
(
/
r
n
d
re
i
~~
-
.
A”
e
Vv
®
-a
Q
G)
ool
A
a
(
/
—
/
il
rd
3
»
i
A
—~i
hd
=
7
3
Q
an]
:
py
0)
oe
he
L
J
0
-
hn
ou
£,
=)
2!
Sut
Fone
or
h
e
hd
i
~~
rn
ou
Ud
a
]
ih
w
—
g
J
Qe)
p—
~
—
av
Ul
[ve
4
~
od
qs
j
d
pu
hut)
-"’
rt
-
{
a
ed
"ri
Cy
~
~
y
CU
S
g
~
-
id
~~
—
od
-)
a
t
-
~
\
~
/
~
J
3
{
:
pred
4
-
[ro
Ww
.
Sy
~
U
£3
J
N
E
D
J
@
1
f
m
<
3
®
3
a
QO
5
st
£
Pi
—
~~
)
oO
~~
rt
r
=
i
U
E
—
—
|
~
»
pet
—
,
r
ent
i
i
~
-
+
>
g
e
Jd
em
—
—
n
uf
a
~
pd
od
r
—
I
C
=
1
;
fre
i
fo
QO
C
(
ag
)
a
rt
v
~
jo
~~
k
(9)
~
fae]
po?
C
y
Yer!
™
hie
-
.
=
ve
~/
hi
—
—
—
+
B
L
if,
(
P
S
oot
~~
—
—
C
)
~
y
.
p
t
>
ws
~
~
Y
—
L
r
~
~
~
—
—
—
_
—
J
\\/
oN
c
‘
3
r
Ged
=
¢
.
oO
'
-
>
pt
¢
~
of
—
t
—
)
‘
5
Sy
Hy
a”)
—
q
o
tod
y
n
ped
/
r
-
4
U
~
oO
~
~
~
3
=
SE
m
n
i
-
f
d
-
—
i
169
WJ
)
ent
et
oN
3
a
—
i
Ul
/
N,
»
pnd
in
=
pis
git
of
i
U
Nad
v
>
A
C
Y
o
—
—
|
~
ro
©
oe
=
i
g
fi
god
p
=
0)
CS
~i
!
.
™
A
Ud
-/
QO
>
¢
=
ns
/
,
~
‘LV
pe
3
~
$
C
n
r
=
/
Bh
Oo
o
17
SE
3
(Lo
—
—
Uli
aa
~
-
i
.
7
~~
¢
x
(
G
rt
Cc
Ud
~
r
=
f
rr
>
~~
~
~
(
4p
es
—
g
s
a)
rr
~~
Q
p
a
dg
CO
r
oO)
rt
7
—
®,
jaa
w
h
i
Ud
¢
a0
,
-
!
y
r
N
o
~
{i
/
A
)
r
w
h
y
phi
r
149]
~
A
—y
ped
>
)
Vd
0)
t
l
.
¢
~~
(
\
~~
ne
~
J
\/
ned
wed
(\
c
ki
r
l
a
]
C
S
'®)
(
-
PEN
-
j
r
-
—~
Pi
~~
/
,
So
5
3
;
.
A
en
:
i
©
B
S
wn
cb
C
ay
T
l
R
y
k
eb)
—
—
|
T
I
O
f
d
S
i
go
—
h
Pel
<
@
,
N
pred
NS
“AL
¥
r
=
(
bdo
T
E
e
d
2
.
~
yp
3
atl
—
pf
~~
>
tet
Sd
Pr
~
rn
ype
a
~
~
>)
¢
f
a
a)
oO
”
c
—
-
hat
°
oS
~
re
O
C
=
~~
-
4
r=
.
[
)
¢
Welle
/
P
y
Ca
|
~~
~~
o
d
~
P
i
d
L
J
a
A
i
~~
~~
Y
A
~
y
pod
-r
i
{
pe
~
\.
v
l
Tr
—~
-
3
.
-
e
t
pn
roi
bv
~~’
~-
hi
oud
~
J
r
ed
apf
i
«
-
~
.
"
he
nd
{™
“t
By
4
~
ks
—-
ye
pe
~
4
/
™
hs
-
ey
—
)
"
)
—
~
po
———d
{GC
ri
1
~
R
F
)
\/
ow
O
~
®
r
wed
.
:
re
Ne
ii
Cr
*ved
os
L
Y
&
i
BN
wr
)
y
o
\
{
/
~~
~
—
-
yo’
~
~
?
{
{
0
)
Eh
—
C
d
~
J
u
®.
. pe
oi
’
i
-
J
by
ol
\/
”
0
=
G
y
-s
b.
y
bs
-
Pet!
-
{
b
’
-
—
~
~
*
(
hung
.
A
J
B
d
-
.
)
piel
wl
e
d
~
Co
L
o
P
E
L
\
o
r
i
-
\
/
j
d
p
e
€5
&¥
N
p
]
ay
-,
-
—
py
p
e
L
a
g
¢
-
|
.
r7
~
{
i
7
—
P
a
“
)
’
J
A
p
m
~~
-
Ta)
.
J
-
ind
So
~~
(al
r
ud
CC)
po
|
rd
p
e
—
—
_
/
o
S
9
re
hd
\
—
-
—
4
~
~
~
~
~
—
_
—
r
t
y
i
id
=
b
i
d
)
-’
JY
U
l
re
/
:
r
n
$
5
u
[i
BEY
=
i
ye
~
~
~
U
=
=
OQ
:
_-
rr
“rj
Ct
[49]
«
A
@]
a
d
ake
I
-
boc
ri
r
i
{
pA
[{
}
po
|
PA
)
]
W
W
;
~
~
yo
p
r
g
.
/
i
ee
.r—i
(@8)
=
o/
hy
(=
C
i
o
r
r
t
~~
p
z
C
~
ha
an
-
—~
g
~~
~~
:
(
re
.
TM
eri
C)
x
»
-~
&
i
~
he
y
(
‘Ww
S
t
a”
~
~
jl
i
£
2
ce
Ul
}
/
C
Y
.
{
>
~
/
esd
-
-
\
:
sel
$C
R
E
mt
Mf
R
H
E
~~
Jd
i
l
wean
Vid
o
s
J
oi
~~
(
"
ik
—
—
=
-
j
d
yo
rt
a
]
'
£3
¢
3
bt gn |
~
3
1D
~~
AS
—f
V4
ND)
|
J
&
.
=
-
—
pie
V4
phd
i
SB
-
opi
>
C
i
4}
ae
wy
(C
C
~
*
J
pli
-
oN
v
be
U
~
—
—
¢
~~
Fs
-
t
v
u
“
9]
Q
n
i
m
ir
Gc
U
:
p
f
i
"
—t
—.
wt
awl
(
-
~~
-
f
~
~
\
A
N
i
U
L
I'S)
Vv
S
p
y
a
=
Si
0
3
—
o
+
A
So
-
1
0
xy
i
2
a
-
r-
C
~
i
0
~~
~~
UN
H
u
A
W
U
4
2
.
-
M
i
e
hol
~
;
p
d
0
a)
Ul
4
Ty
-
A
r
y
a
fe
—
goed
f
4,
¢
had
-/
C
a
~
O
W
es
Jad
—
Na
r
a
-
\
/
-
-—
~
1
)
pol
\
L
/
{Lv
i
e
y
r
Ne
for
rise
T
e
-
'
¢
ce
a
n
»—
/
:
=t
“uy
f
o
\
3
A
. r=
~
N
$
pm
i
J
me?
i
a4
-
»
C
“=
J
r
t
pit
.
.
Ra
‘es.
Ad
{
r
r
er
0
Uli
(or
S)
ry
re
ri
E
=
~
-
<<
(0
>
CC
3)
pa
wl
—
<r
Pe
ou
Rd
a
|
-
r~—
ho
-—
Ld
g
S
k
J
~
=
"yo
4
L
>
=
J
p
~
<
T
R
|
y
eS
=
Nout
J
-
~
i
3
»
-
y
y
~
i
s
3
o
i
S
f
ALS
C
)
o
O
O
)
1)
n
h
m
y
hg
%
—
dl
;
n
y—
do
1
C
j
e
#
D
a
S
y
|
-
-
C
~=
5
i
=
Rae
~
~
455%
os
S
@
A)
ee
=
pie
=
=
¢
-
pnd
~
‘al
A
Ie
—]
y
3
O
N
pm
3
C
|]
~~
-
Lr
0)
5
QO
~
~
.
GC
r
i
~—
dei
rp
Pa
TIE
JE
bpd
all
"
.
<
4
—
—
~~
¥
A
g
n
~
al?
A
=
Lu
~
{
od
U
—~
Ee
.
3
<A
«
yi
r
!
»
U/
pos
bd
¢
fot
i
i
s
yi
:
Sojour}
A
Q
u
yl
{
ia
.
O
l
oo!
-
Q
:
;
yis
iL 8
-
)
a
rd
“py
A
~
"3
U
p
i
.
—_—
.\
’
ed
pa
4D)
co
Cd
if.
r:
Nr!
@
Lu
r
TA
R
E
1
R
f
A
ko
CG
-
#8
I
G
-
r
A
—
r
-
"x
~~
—
~
—
l
l
-
~~
¢
—-—
£4
:
J
pei
|
(
oe
.
cy
r
r
A
L
~~
{
=
-
Pi
wey
&)
od
C
=
ad
J
=
p——
or
os
res
0
w
reins
Pi
LW
J
j
a
—
fe
No
hi
=
o
es
* ped
C
V
o
i
.
p=
>
y
a
~
~
ered
-
o
p
Jd
d
a
d
~
~
S
e
J
R
Ln)
(
a
i
Re
a
)
_
~
~
~
U
U
-
hd
_
—
—
»
a
od
al
Jn
—-—
.
~
.
-
5
|
I
r
d
3
\
’
ed
~
dt
a?
-
QO
¢
jc
a
0)
mg
:
rd
wpe?
Oo
~
—
l
e
y
et
=
1
Y
os
3
®
-
i
CH
G
a
s
J
i
rn
~/
AY
pm—
C
=
y
—
—
C
"
-
-
8
i
Cri
fo
I
—
-
W
E
~
4B
ft
w
d
)
0
«pom
;
(
Ce
—
2)
{
¥
¢
Q
r
r
~
A
a
t
—
re
—
~
—
r
Ud
.
m
y
Frm.
ny
.
~
A
.
a
>
)
oo
OQ.
)
F
A
O
o-
on
Ca
~
J
2
c
~~
QO
¢
Cry
J
2
\
)
=
QO
oO
nf
r.
hd
{
;
5
a
L
0
Ql)
+
NN
-
)
"
-4
y
et
pei
}
A
—
o/
r=
ph
5
®
-
AY]
v
el
r
t
yf
p—-
rot
Se
o/
-
=
a
C
—
=
-
4
3
I
-
20
N
S
C
o
r
y
C
or
y
an
J
abs
dh
~
“
\
/
J
—y
{
-
~
~
P
F
—
{
.
—
U
l
.
or
~
~
I
™
{
ha.
.
p
o
-
Pp
Ul
-
pe
-
a
1
d
e
d
4
%
o>
La
—-
[T,
Coed
Nr’
o
p
-
A
Ay
_
C
3
pn
V
s
~~
[@)]
>
-
-r
LG,
>
OJ
a
0)
r
~~
a
/
Ns
—
r
(
rt
(Eg
od
p
p
d
oO
C
rN
~
wd
oJ
/
pd
, =
J
0
.
3
pod
p
—
—
¥
i
~~
T
y
i
i
|
O
O
[d
dl
a
d
F
S
A
PJ
Syert
—
¢
!
het
o
n
a
.
QO
Nr
ry
po
N
o
~~
i
rt
r
r
OJ
rs
QO
¢
>
>
r
&
got
P
i
r—
A
3
C
rs
>
—~
i
/
(49;
¢
$
4
~
yo)
-
Lid
(
r
t
e
'
\
Vv
)
“
Y
{
AN
o
d
t
p
]
-
$C)
.
b
d
-~
-
er
Y
c=
Set
Lil
A
a
p
i
7
RE
G)
I
.
(=
ye
hye
*
3
or
~
~
e
d
_
—
W
font
on,
SOR W
L
i
™
ro)
~
®
rt
~~
ho
lh
J
~~
¥
—
S
nl
—
_
>
oi
~
Cri
—~
=
3
iy
=
A
bon
0
re
193]
~
Jd
Ss
¢.:
—
—
u
O
ee
Sed
eg
o
~
~
ot
0
Bs
~
~
(
Stent
~
>
-
.
r
t
*
poe
Prt
¢
—y
:
}
1
)
e
t
(
Q
sd
r
9
)
\W/
(9)
:
~
,
i
v
—
—
¢
-
©
]
pr
~
i
ba!
Q
3
A
Q
A
R
~
~
\
/
J
r
t
hat
¢
by
» J
led
{
O
¢
E
re
\
)
v
i
hi
)
P
a
—
:
Cond
2
r
r
~
U
L
pt
—
nN
Fn
s
r
n
d
H
L
i
/
~~
¢
o
r
.
et
Py
}
4%
ND
r
r
—
r=
-
t
t
Ud
f
r
o
o
r
!
en
$
rn
ld
L
r
bod
[
-
fo)
O)
ped
son
U
l
b
d
T
T
{
a)
P
ec,
~
~
Vd
rn
o
g
OO
0
nn
Fn
8)
[
cd
b
t
—
4p
C
o
OO
r
-
F
o
i
ed
pi
i
lJ
¥)
od
*
2
+
Re
y
d
a
S
ry
p
d
ot
C
i
Ln
-
rt
po
4)
0)
-
/
u
i
0)
n
C.
rf
~
%
Set
~.
oh
BN
a
JE
Sq
v
7
0
fed
-—
UI
IVI
RN
i
i
¥
i.
———-]
*
po
5
=
P
i
J
l
A
L
N
ny
p
«
pad
/
—
~
p
o
P
l
-
i
)
e
S
o
d
a
)
Pa
Th
c
s
—
-
+
A
>
\
ye
fd
C
~
LJ
Ql)
p
e
pi
-
:
5
3
©
ed
rd
Co
0h
negle
0)
Q
io)
=
a
A
om a.
J
2d
4
{
i
,
Jl
)
¢
.
of
Sud
Ul
|
a
\
-
n
g
p
o
d
C
d
it
rind
.
~
~
~
~
1S)
rt
gy
e
s
is
(49
.
-/
«pe
N
U
%
A
(SV)
£
-
(4)
(CG
9p)
hd
ee]
pl]
GY)
ori
OO
—~
0
res
R
m
r
NY
—
£4
Q
~
po
5%
(Lo
~
r
*
-
c
3
(
ori
A
=
J
{
—’
od
nN
J
pe]
(OY
oN
r
pi
J
-
g
d
A
i
>
Cid
Ly
Ne
T
-
—
~
Ui
¢
A
-
a
&
Ea
g
l
a
n
—
=
Po
“=
c
y
B
D
S
:
y
p
e
—
~
A
A
-
~
3
-
-{
;
—
r™)
w
——-
£.
SL
or
(x,
=
C
i
a
n
I
3)
i
-
#
-
o
ot
QO
0
J
~
r
~
r=
w
“J
f
a
ay
‘2
~~
,
rr
”
r
e
]
:
OJ
WW
N
a
r
”
-
C
r
¢
h
o
L
4D]
~F
PP
5)
.
-
~
a
)
m
d
M
J
o
y
i
3
p
f
r
n
N
~
—
A
c
’
wd
=
®
{0
ac
ao!
ry
0
=
ep
arf
ra
1)
.
sha}
q
—
—
a
i
Sad
~~
peed
-
mt
Q
¢
)
$9)
pt
3
9)
ad
C
OU
~
~
x
f
i
\
/
poet
”
y
.
HE
~~
°
\
G
Y
ES
6)
jad
A
¢
>
ot
Cid
.
~
~~
9)
r
e
lt
Cy
—
p
b
rr
~
y
Nn
{
)
69)
o
P
t
i
»
et
A
»]
LL)
.
o
e
0
Ud
y
i
f
r
/
Ul
e
4
2%
pt
©)
he
as
v
=
p
pi
P
a
J
—~t
)
Ud
1
>
—
i
¢
[49]
Q
y
S
e
O
ye
#
(No
it
—
’
a
i
IN
~
J
-
2%
3
A
~
3
-
t
l
a
CJ
[ot
-
ye
~
pod
x
Si
r
a
[4V]
GJ
y
d
)
-
(4
oud
Oo
m
m
e
t
A
v
”
}
+
S
—)
y
AN
S
pl
rt
C
9
wid
—-
~~
~t
nt
oO
Q
jd
v
Feed
A
ri
.
/
—
ri
‘
3
5
{
(>
a
ST)
7m
J
ori
i
—
hyp
r-d
o
e
ps
-
pret
{
Jd
EL)
©
2
~
(
O
O
ao
o
“fod
;
Jd
—
~
wna]
—
C
®
(
a
i
.
\
s
~
p
i
If
a
.
/
i
1
3
LY
)
"/
2
a
4
-
od
p
e
40
5
we
>
425,
—
ed
e
d
p
o
d
¥
hor
ap
+
rt
~
et
J
oo
Sod
a0
~
=
7
+
|
on
a
)
-
Y
\
(
~
J
—
{
{
Ko
{
—
-
©
et
~
St
=
oe
—
a
-
a”
a
~/
~
00
)
ro
oS
Ls
hy and
———
w
d
~~
bn
|
jad
—
40]
—
7
quok
~
4
*w
OJ
$<
KA
p
i
Q
a)
QO
ro
"pe
y
e
To)
dd
Ie)
Pi
hed
;
i
“1
:
i
f
pa
O
id
Q
S
nN
bow
.
2
fu
®)
fir
C
t
r=
Ul
(
A
~~
'
ae
/
i
ot
~~
-
wd
»
ped
Q
O
r
ot
>
Ql
ot
-
=
o
Lo
+
~
oO
=
ro
}
¢
LT
r—i
EY
f
r
~
~
=
v
GO
8
PR
0
ci
~/
Yeuing
~~
~~
uf
~~
~~
its.
3
(SP
J
uf
frost
~
~~
ec
o/
Lo
pei
=
0)
—
jrhd
ed
0)
4)
Ih
=
pa
Ra.
~
a
~~
U
“
0
J
A
p
i
d
cc
5
[&
—
1%)
Si
{
as
Ly
~
-
ped
ged
ct
=
F
e
4
-
Ted
o
bo.
-
N
a
p
—
~
~
o-—
e
r
m
{LU
m
e
=
(4V]
j
e
~/
ny
(
U0 ~
pe
o
d
C
6D)
V
i
drevioy 1
y ic it J
i
| 1 " hana { 1 a - er y
| gesegregalion of ne oCnNior Lig] Cr( 11]
i 0) hb) 111 + r { oa ' 4
| all P irticliiargs except nat 1ne on Sod calls
1}
! for the assignment 10 Indep ends nce riigll
t INN 1 1 } on I i ¥ py
School of 300 black children. (Findings,
| -
} Pe
S
d
3
S
o
n
d
pe
d
(
S
e
}
| The Court found that the plan would require additional public transportation |
| |
| » accomplished with 20 buses. (Findings, |
i
| }
| 35, p. 19.) The same cost analysis applies for ¢ High Schools as it
|
| does for elementary schools. The Court thus found that the additional
|
| sts for integrating Segrior High Schools would be $60, 000. 00.
(Findings, 40, p. 21.) |
I
i
| {
| The Court analyzed at some length the bussing requirements for |
|
I Junior High School students. He noted the options available to the Board :
li
" 1 ii vy " ~ TA - 3 r - 2% 37% : v I) EF 1.3m
: under the District Court Order of February 5, and determined that their
|
|
choice of the Finger plan was educationally and financially sound.
! 3 .
1
1 : 3 ry imrd
| In summary, as to junior high schools, the
ih 1 : | Vo adr Dans dd Court finds that the plan chosen by the Board
! oy I!
and approved by the Court ple ces no greater
! i J &
logistic or personal burden upon poy, ents
| or administrators than the plan proposed by |
! the school board; that the transportation
{
~ 7 - - ~ <7 ~ 7 ~ + I .. oe 3c - 1 | called for by the approved plan is not sub- |
{
| a peng rw 11. i a nL ~ stantially greater than the transportation
: b LS
called for by the board plan; that the ap-
< y fF A ¥ Ln) x7 2S YY) To 2 Te Tr Ine £ | proved plan will be more economic Wr ef-
| ee : :
| ficient and cohesive and easier to administer
| and will fit in more nearly with the i ans -
portation problems involved in desegregating
B SR ENT Ae hn LA, R Ry Sw 5 IRE A
elementary and senior high schools, and that
the board made a correct administrative and
educational ahelce in choosing this plan in-
OD
3 SL hilo Wa hn A oi i wre re ives ry es 11
stead of one of the other three methods.
| ©
(Findings, p. 13-14.)
|
! 4.1 3: M i % : 3.3 i 1-4 f+ 1 of |
Moreover, the bussing involved is essentially the kind of one-way bussing |
| of black inner city children which the Board proposed in its plan of July 29,
1969, the Court accepted in its Order of August 15, 1969 and which the |
Board is presently carrying on. (Memorandum, pp 5-6.)
|] r + 3 Ban nA inn sim. 13 ah Cray vi1ird Arpiie | I'he Court found that &y 500 additional Junior ign >cno )] students
|
|
: 1 " itivy= i J > ! } a , TO +3 x} 1 - * - -
sould require public transportation, that this could be accomplished by using
3
| §
1 |
! ] 3:1 | ‘ ! ‘ 3 ct 4 f SX ONLY) nN 3 1 re Qf 3}. ( { 28 buses at an annual cost of $100, 000.00. (Findings, 35, pp 19; 40, | 553
}
© |)
{ :
|
= {
or
{1
i]
il
A
S
a
S
t
a
r
S
e
t
a
n
y
u
p
e
n
r
e
mem
n
s
rca
pe
tem
ps
nm
a
a
a
m
a
t
E
A
E
N
E
p
A
Q
{
tn
1}
pet
i
T
i
C
L
ph
5
i
:
;
~~
(
{
a
a
.
i
t
d
e
Q
)
Pt
~
pi
r~
C)
oh
* pi
a)
/
J
.
[4%]
~
~
C
o
r
t
l
a
d
W
w
i
—~
r
wt
O
—
y
t
oy
¢
fy
o
ri
0
4
©
.
=
0
H
@
C
m
~
a]
Q
—~
'S
r
r
[49]
>
PE
I
r~4
a
—
™
a
.
re
0
oO
—
—
J
~
—
=i
~N
!
oe
¢.
¢)
6D)
oJ
1)
¢
+3
“a
Crd
-
a
“uv
-
4)
i
/
al
“=
A
J
ot
i
Rr
3
i
i
d
-
Q
o
)
~~
~
C
o
m
p
=
]
p—
D
)
i
1
r
r
‘VV
—
(49)
p
a
~
~
X
fee
7
3
i
-
£
J
V
i
~
~
—
~
i
d
i
r
~
—
be
aod
of
pe
p—~,
—
;
"
-
;
\
Sh
veri
rv
~~
Ct
C
5
#
.;
a
~,
~
~
~§
Q
>
O
Po
7.
i
»
—
\
i
f
f
e
:
¥
V
e
—
wd
rd
\
2
wr
. pi
AS
W
/
i
o
o
>’
/
*
pe
~
Set
(ae
=
ng
a
e
d
43]
A
)
pi
r
r
=
ri
~
~
——
L
c
Se
-™
\/
~
yea
¥
at
P
h
S
N
v
Yo
-
-
ped
~
Q
r=
r—i
—
~~
)
{
I
.
x
—~
:
pot
:
c
t
~
\
-
14
L
R
Id
8)
i
(
a
m
e
|
"
C
N
r
e
)
or
0
—
a
“ej
~/
=
\/
l
OO
*
~
0
Va
rr
Oo
oie
|
Ee
$s
i
i
p
n
4%
-~
i?
q
~~
~
as
.
j
o
UA
ty
Pas
Ia
y
(T
'
[©
MN
Ct
p
C
36
O
2
oD
Sy
<2
ol
~
-
hed
[4s
£
oO
(LV
e
Ps
pW
i
)
4
~
(L
C
r
i
yl
ee)
Hy
{
-—
—
a
C
S
[&)
he
R
C
nes,
Sa
wood
i
r
e
,
1)
i.
C
d
—
.
r=]
I
a
5!
\
>
»
~
—
Rone
[48
pe
-
iN
Ne
O
D
~
NA
r
=
\/
be
3
M+
as
~~
~~
oie
tn
by
i
wn
—
4
p
d
a)
oO
—
H
o
=
4D]
—~
ir
R
l
Te
a
At
LU
Is
:
Pr
r
i
~~
$/
—
of
nn
.
OJ
K
~
i
4)
fo
po,
~-
et
ry
-
Lo
2
~~
ie
a
¢
[ot
~,
0
el
ho
/
~
ye
=
—
;
r
ml
.
po
y
r
re
-
(@)
~
=
r
<
Pl
Eh
—
rm
—
—
A
y
—
t
—
G)
e
®
-~c
Ul
ot
3
Ped
~~
re
5
ry
~
x
yo
joy
oy
5,
45
Lies
host
oO
ci
a
C
or—i
OJ
\/
a
es
1
-
/
i
J
—
-
(
o
r
i
—
J
pul
a
r
r
es
~
hi
=X
.
he
er
oO
~~
f=
~=
.
[6
£3
fo!
4 5
Cm
Q
(TC
di
~
Soe
—t
JS
—
CS)
6p)
—
oo
Q
&
PIN
c
-
~~
¢
\
y
-
Seni
—-
i
"
e
’
La
%
od
\~
(
4
ee
-
AN
~
~
C
y
a
ad
/
No
ho
on
+
hy!
Si
©
2
OQ
ot
oes
d)
ety
n
O
a
y
,
el
~
Ee
Ct
®
n
f
0
~
fs
pe
=~
rn
>
~~
—
—
i
J
\
Cid
—
Ud
O
~~
i
-
- ped
~
p)
)
Sy
3
~
;
0
an
IS
~~
C
2
,
eed
=
C,
oi
OO
a
oF
oT
—
[4%
oD
b
o
a
~
3
~
P=]
ce
:
Fe
p
=
~~
ar)
A
T
.
—
{
ab
pu
~
=
wn}
—_
CC
.
pd
wn
A
Y
e
n
f
~
and
:
wid
-
¢]
~
P
u
at
“ged
aa
—
i
a
oi
1
rr
on
%
A
—
a
:
pg
pe
A
i
n
Jl
*n
~
-
AY
=i
~~
C
r
r
r=
)
rr
fa
-
40)
R
d
A
pl
9
V
S
—
.
~
~
CD)
—
et
1
\./
J
\
Ji
ba
Ph
jt
O
a
2
¥
—t
-
=
-
L
W
rr
4
» pe
{
A
ALERT
3
a
yo
bh
_—
b
-
~
)
n
t
Cp
1A
r
o
io
’
~~
—
&
hy
a
-
ct
(CG
PR
Fs,
da
¢
wat
ro)
i
\
/
N
1
s
J
@
ied
{
-
§
“/
peed
-
L
p
o
rn
\
on
i
4
i
—-
hy
3
od
prs
{
-
A
49]
~
6p.
Ay
oJ
)
Q
fy
uJ
¢
(0
#
hd
J
i
g
49
1
9)
nl?
Ww
x
3
J
b
l
\
—
-
<
K
1)
po]
;
:
-
.
js
>
~
5
a
Qo
a0
J)
2
.
“=
M
o
E
T
H
;
on
~
Q
0)
Pend
Py
(3)
:
Py
w
pe
paved
*
™
J
(u
QO
»
w/
SA
9)
pt
o
hr
St
~
N
e
pea
Jon
4
>
poe
I'S)
~~
pu
~~
=
Ny
J
r
—
1)
b
d
:
any)
ot
—
rr
C
Q
u
i
f
i
oe
i
(0
-
—
—
per]
A
$3
=
>
LL
Cc
'®
~~
a0)
~~
LU
op
m
n
\o’
sig
P
i
N
a
Hy
Ps
Q
Q
i
™
y
s
d
r
t
h
t
J
Nor
pd
-
)
Sold
©)
-
~
A
a
by
aod
o
“nN
r
mjd
¢
:
“
-
V
A
(
—
Ny
oF!
“
¥
iE
ral
(
.
i
o
~
-
n
Vv
Os.
Jo
REE
or
EEG
HRY
]
C
f
~~
0)
\
iy
po
OJ
ie
vl
rr
0)
"
r=
4
gE,
Pd
—
‘
-
—
—
-
a
rd
Q
on
~~
i
)
~
a
)
/
Q
™
Q
MN
20)
149
\
Q
Lo
O
“/
=
(
i
80}
~~
n
—
™
,
a
a
"
(
\/
v
i
d
{
S
h
i
)
~
J
l
:
]
>
-~
IN.
H
i
—
C
y
~
BP
~
—
—
a
«
“
i
ent
i
d
r—~
0)
PP
e
r
1
i’
ny
£
3
,
% i
i
i
g
'®)
$—
!
o
~~
a
~~
oy
c
-—
QF
i
~
a
“
J
r
—
“
=
x
+
ri
a8
Lv
i
ad
~
r
r
I)
)
)
re
ts
pe
(AV)
~~
r
r
CC
pt
li
nN
Ay
eS
~
~
rt
u
Ul
4
<H
oO
—
ud
28
od
o
oo
°
:
-—
od
S
d
»
~
4
bi
i
3
C
O
J
P
E
na,
"
—
—
t
e
oe
ep!
A
—{
weed
ol
N
n
(
a)
\
r
r
Fo——y
J
k=
p——]
fd
iy
fo}!
CO
Q
e)
7
+
=
!
4)
ot
pa
—
a
(©
=
ry
(-)
ee
$
hd
-
A
-
;
bs
om
i
t
r=
=
a
—
sig
AN
,
~
N
”
—
Pe
i
.
~~
sx
L/
ord
r-
ad
r
l
ER
hd
Kner?
nd
p
l
®
a)
~
~
o
r
BY
Q
(ou
Cimet
pus
Hy
~
4}
gg
J
O
=
.
a
)
per]
o
s
H
as
rr
fussed
~
(0
yo
Sr’
}
C
i
~—
<
J
3
1)
Xe
hs
»
y
od
a)
rf
i
port
2
{
I
p=
rn
—
bend
R
e
td
Jd
er
~
*
Sri
1
48
i
p=]
O
ail
Q
on
i
e
0
a
4
av
oJ
A
pot
cS
hel
-/
~
45)
ci
~
a
Ls
¢
Lo
bo
—
rn
po
-
1
frond
"
—~§—
~
0
a
-
{
s
a
A
~
~
NE
a
J
i
rN
CS)
-
~~
I
¥
a)
n
ro)
9]
AA
ec)
r
Suton]
—
J
7
«pum
9
I
~
=
4D]
Q
j
e
—
y
e
Nl
QO
9)
/
>)
—
~
—
"
~
~
r
r
r
~
~
3
r
a
y
t
p
a
Cid
.
a
o
o
A
N
C
oy
©
[x
C
i
(
.
~
r=
i
J
©
=
cl
Lo,
E
C
gn
3
pr
B
o
,
C
™
y
:
f
o
g
m
r
i
~
a
)
)
a
s
og
a
e
e
t
4D]
~
~
V
d
4
pe
>
C
e
;
f
pe
N
is
id
PY,
Q
&
Ud
48}
;
nd
+
¢
5
p
r
N
a
’
-
—v
.
'®)
:
v3
AN
1
p
—
—
nn
i
p
r
t
~~
bent
Cy
~
~
pi
(
U
-
-
4D)
™
J
7
nN
ot
A
e
r
—~
“
a
P=
'
had
~
A
p
r
-
~
a
=
=
Wi
wedi
Q)
r
s
J
N
t
P
o
i"
/
L
n
N
\
/
'S
V
a
N
d
fret
a
)
W
/
0
Pod
r
t
il
pra
rs
wn
a
-
:
mind
U
J
—
:
~
Pr
-
5
-
.
Ay
e
C
”
~
~
a
y
3
.
®
)
[od
=
,
e
i
o
N
N
o
49]
(4)
i
—
~
=
i
U
J
N
A
u
e
J
~
W
J
rt
r
—
~
»
ky
E
Y
”
A
Q
Pas
=
1937)
p
e
d
PRY
p-
®)
i
o
pod
» pd
A
N
l
/
RN
—
—
—
bday
ay
wn
n
y
p
d
=
1
\
fel
i
y
A
r
a
Joi
—
v
po
r
m
A
:
=
N
14D)
4
nd
=
in.
Nr
A
o
i
b
i
$Y
i
=~
P
o
p
i
-
w
e
A
4
ple
b,j
oi
&/
a
n
{
“
C
y
et
—
{
1
A
y
|
pa
|
~
Pan
.
i
>
Cri
het
)
cl
ct
“a
(S
a
e
rs
fo]
(9
49,
®
w
i
S
Y
a)
f
o
fo
~
wei
—
~
Ul
®,
a.
Z
H
py
cr
~
o
20
oO
—
-
4
—
Ww
Ul
Q
c
td
Sy
pe
O
—
ARR
ey
-
l
m
hind
¢
~~
r
(
C
E
fees
e
p
i,
C
t
y
4)
~’
et
-
Q
~~
—
—
-
-
"
+
A
~
N
~
~
~
~
y
Q
Nn
4
A
|
a
|
—
h
s
fo)
—
A
.
whee}
p
e
[a
o
r
d
4
A
LT
—t
AA
w
d
w
d
ast
OO
~
~
r
A
Ly
ry
nd
Ji
\
oe
;
1
.
-
~~
—
Q
°
i
o
a)
Ye
nN
Y
“
o
o
N02
Q
oi
N
~
or
oo!
L
Q
n.
orierS
/
-
.
ve
wn
Jl
r
Ul
Ul
"
ye
.
C=}
RS.
r—3
i
“i
fy
~
3
—
*
5
-
rs
—
~
~
re
|
3
)
AL
Ul
Ct
a
)
a
ie?
{
"
a
4
0)
y
r
gi
(6)
~/
S
©
3
=
a
Cir
i
A
N
&
©
A
ed
rr
cd
T
E
0
wn
o
d
-
Cc
-/
he
«
A
hg
f
r
)
eet
QQ
pd
My
ro
Q
a
Ul
.
(4)
{
on
ity
()
\
et
J
L
O
~
i
{
¢
ue!
\
4)
r
E
r=}
(]
,
~
{
)
4)
3
m
.
{
~
So
ee
.
a
}
Oo)
$
e
nN
be
ad
(9
¥
»
i
/
=
o
n
d
\S
(>
§
—
!
ad!
<
“Wo
Q
l
peed
4
/
~
—
i
r
=
.
b
~
8
)
~
C
s
>
jin,
~
—
0)
pene)
2,
&
oo
1)
Oo
re
OC
>
—~
i
i=
:
0
/
{
-
N
A
¢
0)
Qa
bo
ct
—
oO
i.
w
—
“r=
O
CO)
©
Q
—
Ci
-
U
gi}
©
fas
~
ao
a
!
Ag
~~
j
d
ht
®)
¢
one
~
~
a
pt
—
~
)
Q
O
a)
p
r
J
i
o
r
~~]
-/
~l
<
fi
/
OJ
poet
o
y
~
J
bi
d
{
—-
CY
Bs.
pt
=i
“
r{
"
.
=
S
v
D
-
y
z
W
Eb
=
9
S
y
CO
“~
50
S
r~
ba
~~
d
=
-
CD)
Yn
7%
~r
7
Q
Pa!
i
—
Oo
a
;
0!
(
)
4
&
Q
—
~
A
n
be
=
.
-l
~
Q
Q
l
~
~
4
\
/
Lam]
—
=
”
{ee
—
Phd
=
oO
-
ped
5
a
i
—
—
=
i
0
wn
oped
-
tl}
Id
rr
¥
~
a
0
{
,
#
H
=
¢
:
)
5
A
c
0)
<>
ds
di
CL
0
-
a
%
a
ov]
nN
\/
~
PR
i
J
&
~
ie!
J
J
i
ri
Pi
¢
:
w
x
-
2
ro
oO
Q
es
=
<
©
a
=
C
2
o)
*
~
0)
ol
Q
—
P
r
—
p=
ct
Q
ye
.
=}
Lo
o
—
J,
Joe
¢
J
-
ri
A
<
J
i
a)
—
—
o
-
P
Y
C
y
P
o
o
d
:
3
~
~
1)
ne]
A
)
yoomamnd
;
Oo
ns
A
3
r~
be
nt
Cod
o
'
Pi
~~
(
~
-
ct
hi
Ci
oO
A
C
s
~~
Gry
a1,
i
i
>
—
¢
OY)
O
i
°
i
Ud
wn
—
re
«©
hit
=
A
y
os
»
ci
v4
y
e
Ul
p
—
r=
he’
—
—
[+
—
—
7
WE
—
re
n
d
CS
—
pee]
/
—f
=
—
rt
O)
J
(Qn)
J
E
.
7
F
w
~
Jd
el
\/
~
~~
-
0)
J
bord
DE
C
Ul
—
9)
. pol
rd
C
(
¥
QO
pr
rn
J
~
~
"
:
3
~-
J
r
a
pd
et
“
Ul
i
=
i
y
d
ay
>
=o
ed
—
or
&
io
¢
a
weer
ot
e
:
—
<3
4)
rs
Fn
poi
i
rn
~
=
nN
C
(
~~
O
O
?
ol
id
ei
~~
(
a)
Lo,
-
Jd
3
(05)
i
FL
~~
=
<i
i
a
ed
©
s
Ra
oy
ir
Po
oo.
en
:
o
LH
r-
‘V
pe
Q
ope
=
(LQ
~
~
:
[48]
. pt
®
O
red
i
je?
r
\/
-—
J
—
ay
us
oO
(-
foe]
¢
Kh
Ny
~
—
i
-
)
a.
rN
Pa
&
)
(
Pat
M
—
i
i
re
~
Set
\N%
ce
¢
C
o
~~
~~
r
o
—
—
(
40)
Lo
.
~
r
U
~
J
—]
D
ad
qb}
>
O
*
a
)
~\
4
pi
C
f
d
4
z
(
HIE
ee
ed
\
O
o
=X
OQ
}
(
©
fd
—
¢
(
:
vy
>
—
—
¢)
c
so,
Si
i
od
oO
Cy
NS
by
a
i
o
a
(ae)
»
od
“3
Cy
~~
@©
n
oO
i
oO
Lu
C)
ped
'®
had
:
49)
~~
ny
oN)
~
ho
ro
PRY
Ud
a
—
-
\
—~
(V
(C
1S
~~
Q
9)
wid
J
~
'®.
gi
e
r
—
—
—
—
—
im
r—
t
o
r
t
a
:
mn
-
t
t
-
A
C
C
y
J
bf
j
o
r
—
o
a
a
I
—
—
—
—
—
—
q
n
C
i
w
ry
~
OO)
QO
Ud
~
r
r
r
p
e
e
’
p
*
(
\
/
e
l
t
—
—
—
—
—
—
>
~
>
NP
pei
a
=
/
bd
I
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
pa
a
t
e
ee
pe
p
e
eee
—
—
—
—
}
r
d
~~
p
r
/
i
~
A)
yr
/
hv
~
~
FRETTRES:
|
I)
SR
T
E
rt
3
—
\/
)
p
-
®
J
3
A
x
\
-
-t
-
wl
Ne
a
4»
4
~
ipl
—
v}
V
d
)
—
WJ
¥
—-
jo
@
)
»
~/
~~
f
e
©
~
~
}
re
?
Vd
a
as
—
A)
feed
\/ , VY
OX7
,
<
“
£3
3118 C J
p
—
rr!
/
me
p
g
S
g
50
0
s
t
A
A
N
S
pe
S
A
i
i
P
e
t
H
SI
Se
N
E
O
e
A
I
—
—
—
~
_
_
—
o
r
—
“/
i
~
or
Q
>
V
i
-
~
—
y
t
i
y
¥
f
e
>
«
-
=
~
~
ht
$9
}
=z
2
~
;
“r=
.
5
0)
\/
—
-
i
~
s
=~
n
t
.
—t
t
n
C
L
e
e
o
e
~
~
—
\
s
49
outed
/
r~!
o
d
=
}
-
:
3
C
-
iw
O
o
oo
=
0
£3
oe
-
©
2
—
~N
+
—
:
f
i
0
O
~~
.
~
&
—
i
C
O
~
enn
CO)
-
\/
;
a
d
.
~
~
3
f
;
-
—
—
h
N
/
~~
y
-
rd
-
-
rs
JJ
“
J
-
»
i
IN
:
y
p
d
=
e
vy
hed
(9,
.-
7
dts)
ht
proses
Ul
—
\
-—
e
d
{
a
re
JA
c,
:
p
wn
c
~
!
T
=
>
~
ri
\
)
fed
-
=~
-
:
C
w
oO
-
To
/
iy
0
Cm
“
e
r
t
ks
peu
o
t
‘
:
-
L
p+
—
¥
%
{
J
a
d
J
~
—_
—
J
y
-
—
Q
~
/
C
e
t
3
J
--
—
ee
3
os
:
@
~
~
~
~
—~
3
©
;
a
“h
«<
&
-
=
J
4
~~
;
St
ro)
5
ed
"
y
d
m
a
oo’
3
C
5
»
po
U
d
=
h
r
y
so]
ou
i
4
p-
J
Fé
o
g
3
=~
3
7
J
Put
fred}
—
-
il
~
Ww
.
>
b
r
v
d
y
4
°
C
5
=
J
p
o
N
e
:
-
8
T
.
2
p
i
.
r
t
=
Sd
—
—
3
-
(i
.
C
d
2
‘r=
(u
=
::
a
»
~
-
Tod
o
L
‘
\
;
Ly
3
Co.
-!
C
—
—
o
m
(49
5
C
o
w
x
—
—
-
r
i
W
h
y
~
/
%
~
y
-
a
NS
r
=
C
f
PN
;
=
~
c
QO
i
Q
i
re
pt
-
a
]
Bi
”
)
>
5
ad
—
—
))
R
wud
;
vr
.
-
-
X=
—
—
~
—
$<)
J
*
po
r
m
=~
N
e
fi
i;
4
oO
|
J
-
$
on
E
e
-
~
N
w
E
Y
Hon
SD
5
f
e
¢)
‘
GC
i.
=
—
—
~
~~
of
FA
A
aud
1
-
i
<
V
4
-
-
=
=
=
Sim
Ch
r
—
L
a
~
-
:
py
I
~~
AJ)
—
.
hg
i
~
ct
O
2
~~
>
+
Kw
An
eo
ar
"
—t
-
i
oy
.
”
’
~—
P
e
“/
i
U.
y
r
Vo
p
e
e
r
WH
R
E
R
e
t
e
i
TLS
SR
T
E
e
a
n
C
l
l
A
S
T
a8
o
O
R
a
l
he
0
Re
SS
e
n
t
te
i
D
a
i
J
A
C
E
E
,
G
S
O
M
A
tS
a
T
R
A
TON
at,
0
l
l
T
I
R
E
,
T
E
R
E
R
R
R
I
Tiel
JRE
S
E
RE
LL
e
e
l
Baer 3
oo.
~
=
e
d
"A
’
O
o
u
d
’
wed
a
greed
<0
-
Po
4
mt
-
r
\/
ee
(LV
youd
-
An
A
.
—
C
~
3
~
-
i
oo
-
J
3]
k
e
a
~
7
G)
C
Y
-
r
—
L
J
;
~
&
r
o
y
'
e
\)
r
r
0)
=
~
C
~
C
m
J
6p)
-—
.
3
=
i
~
ed
,
que}
p
n
D
o
.
{
{
pa
-
-
LA
W
f
.
—
2
——)
y
.
—
Pl
©
w,
Jud
T
~
“ee
res
Ih
ad
r-
9,
4
4d
ist
Va
ry
-
.
’
~
bd
sa
|
r
e
e
d
=
u
ri
0
A
u
fod
O
A
-
ois
.
FY
)
>
4
%
—
)
r
e
;
ry
rd
~
U
¢
Q
p
Do
—
No!
i
S
§
4
2
—
Q
+
in
>
;
~
>
(VF
od
r~i
i
Prt
—
J
—
a
TE.
C
L
*
p
o
~~
~
C
{
wn
:
ri
r
-
:
JA
(iA
=
-
C
-’
168
~
a
.
i
i
—
(
,
ho
a
i
one?
—
~
~
J
py
-
end
-t
-
eh)
A
>
Jd
(RY
~—
e
y
\/
¢
r
—t
0)
~
~~
™
—
(
9]
[-
i
po
~~
)
=
~
0
—
~
/
3
a
t
—
~
-
ann
=
L
y
o
r
S
—
{
a
d
i
p
t
=
(
(BY
™~
R
i
ee
A
S
C
t
i
A
N
t
e
A
t
e
A
R
E
S
~y
1)
rt
i
S
L
i
-
7
=~
p
d
Cc
4D,
¢
(NO
i
.
.
cS
Cl
r=
~
’
i
dud
LJ
w
d
r
—
ut
—
i
=
t
|
-
P-
<
R
E
—
J!
i
‘
p=
J
e
C
=
Oo
(O
—
~~
ay
i
as
{
pe
.
(
i
-~
~
.
—~—
7
—)
p=
-/
"
.
ES
ad
4
—
p
e
——
is
id
~~
Dp
~~
”
a
jun
~
~~
Pu
Sh
oo
S—
«
’
Su’
~.
"i
70s
~
(Lu
Pe
(
>
Pus
a)
C
(+
>
¢
p
y
[9]
Jd
=
“or
~
~
so,
JU
o
e
K
Z
-—
oJ
}
e
-
nN
&
Te
—
(
c
re
QU
i
Oo
oi
ol
nN
Sy
i
—
=.
{
Jd
Ry
C
S
—
8
Lu
yt
-
ts
od
~
!
O
:
8
—
a
_—
-
ie
P-
A
-
[as
ht
C
T
jd
=i
yd
———
<
P
x
hey
Q
~
~
A
—
H
4
—
~
)
r
rd
v
y
)
$)
~-
p
a)
{
—
!
Oo
—
t
d
~
y
o
S
re
@)
:
hod
ye
!
ed
~
S
t
n
g
—
deh
N
o
¢
3
hd
L
o
f
r
—
—
-
\
4
|
N
J
re
Sy
r=
Gey
\
ps
t
=~
a
]
@
Phen
|
3
Se’
Ud
(
|
/
a
I
/
—
"
;
6
-
a
a
.
C
-/
5
®
pect
r—i
®
—
a
C
ol
-
J
-
LV
vt
-
or
&
®
£)
hat
ry
yo—
_——
St
re
po
tf
)
-’
i
~—l
—
"
i
Ud
~~
J
’
(LU
[)
.
pe
U
~
3
5
T
—
2
C
r
t
unl
4
»
<
\
-
c
&
Q
hod
C
?
¢)
=
)
.
ge
-
ot
C
p
-
Sy
QO
n
a
fo
/
opi
r=
®
9
—
&
Sy
ot
(9
a
1
os
\
/
~~
~
OJ
)
e
m
=>
-
-
J
i,
”
od
gC)
pe
GJ
-t
h
o
o
a
r
rn
EP
O
P
a
Pe
(0
HY
ps
id
g
4
A
°
oO
oe
Ul
Ul
Q
Oo
4
6)
yond
Q
Jl
(0
—
nd
~
adi
5
(
ne
p:
CC
t
d
’
i
ped
—
[SQ
—
Pi
m
j
rth
Oo
Cri
—
—~
et
~
a)
Q
(©)
3
nN
a
LT}
a
“r=
nN
ny
A
—
ri
.
i
Q
”
~~
at
5%
Ul
el
~
(QC
Her
Ck
Q
3
Se
_—
~
»
pg
o~
byes
.-
=
—
(
a
t
—~
ay
—-
™
Q
Phd
od
[OV8
—_—
rt
-
r=
wheal
Ie
ws
heest
a)
og)
9
2)
UW
r~
a)
Be
¢
>
_
“
—
o
r
G
3
™~
A
O
"
:
J
Sh]
-
~
b
—
i
49.
a.
ft
v
iss
~/
Mi
4
—
Sy
Ps
QQ
—
~
—
Pt
o
d
3D
-
~
or)
fu
=
0)
¢
A
et
3
~
45;
—
a
3
le)
\
{®
-
hed
ik
2
Be
Ul
(9)
~
]
Nr
os
Is
nl
"i,
OD)
oe
;
re
=
r
~
;
Ie
C
DE
—
3
d
a
C
<n
—
A
R
¥
Cl
if
res
~
~
3
{
pend
)
*
r=]
r
O
—
i
Q
.
=
J
i
o
r
rn
9
=
¢
an
bh
an
fey
</
av
Ud
pr
~
~~
pro
vi
—]
-
~y
vd
r
w
v
—
C
p
d
2)
Hl
.
J
i
et
\
5
Jl
-
\-/
U8
Ul
>
Ce
J
&J
L
y
b~
r
—
ind
s
$
A
~~
wilt
Fri
Q
,
x
i
jong
Bg
Ne
nc
=
a
e
d
i
:
>
[i
Pg
@
(9)
-
Ln
3
-—
~
7
on
3
v
—
=
-
]
ed
io
a
-
75
=}
TC
“
Us
:
sp,
be
O
a
;
-
pd
~~
»
<
a
y
o
y
-
‘
nt
ry
~
~
:
.
y
;
.
id
'
pi
4
Li
de
wd
had
ads
AN
\“/
.
i
™
of
~~
>
fo
‘
£5
SE
5
“uJ
i
y-
it
J
)
p—
Re
4%
Yi
os
‘
—
» out
od
rr
ic
7
-
{
pd
=
ge}
GC
od
wd
Eo
¢
-
4
C
(
—
2
_
¢
oO
v
i
rr
—
}
{
-
-
C
t.a
\/
¢
-{
~~
—
y
;
4
—
re
-
~
Sn]
poet
.
“
.
)
oO
=
pei
2
€9)
™
§
~
o/
rr
a)
a
ad
7
a
A
{
PEN
-
£
9,
a
So
J
(4p
No
T
D
0)
vi
\
—_—
va
—
od
raed
[48]
=
<
“
.
b
s
{
>
§
}
=
n
o
=
8
i
:
Jd
—
ed
™
“/
Li
ND
2
Yomi
=
-
Sy
QO
\
“
Aa
:
jd
a)
—
rT
j
g
Cg
ig
.
~
Ia
r
AA
y
o
L
:
by
ba
/
ht
1%,
-
~~
+
Oo
2
hd
>
~~
7
A
a,
-
3
-
:
-
Te
7
oo
c
ot
©)
~,
OJ
~
ry
§
ol
2
A
(
5%,
:
it
~
0)
=i
J
Q
=
!
ol
+
SIE
B
R
E
SET
i
I
)
dod
we
~
h-
\o’/
—
—
3)
os
F
d
>
be
i
wi
$=
dun
[5
a
)
-
Gc
/
o
r
;
0
—
r
~
i
—
{
2
:
C
163
r
/
)
>
:
(
-
tly
4
-
ck
—
—
-
-
-)
4)
rn
—
.
>,
:
—
—
|
7
(J
by
(
Dy
{
t
—~
~~
MN
4
a.
-
(
y
—
r—
pa
“/
we
yee]
or—i
o/
—
C
y
tis
u
J
G
y
0D
N
A
Try
r—-
’
O
T
@
—
Bs
¢
Gs
rl
-—
*™
hie
7
pre
Sr
et
S
i
La J
R
E
}
-
jy
J
5
r
)
OO
"
U
mn
he
Sf
fe
—
—
-
)
Cg
¢
gy!
fed
[4
+
\/
~
~
4
=
‘)
02
C
r
Ty
—
Nj
Vo
jn,
oud
Oo
he
$1
r
i
Yd
opi
i
e
t
—
—
S
w
r
IR
AE
=i
y
)
ri
i
8,
r
\
\
—
oi
h
—_-
[
)
po
wd
>
)
a
)
|
{
l
e
)
(
t
J
'
gh
—-—
Vv
1&9]
~
~
QO
\/
¢
A
V
o
n
C
Neos
"
—
¢
AN
-
-
ol
3
Y
wel
ne
!
;
f)
-
w
i
i
~
rit
rd
<
Yee
}
ford
Se
Ou
O
ag
A
=
-
—
—
J
x
i
1)
p
e
0
~
O
o
4%)
w
d
—
=
~
~
:
re
r
p
d
Y
e
~
r
N
r-
:
e
n
e
d
,
~~
«rf
HOE
\
CO
—
—
\/
r
e
r
J
o
e.,
=
ort
ID)
[40]
(op
on
N
F
O
—
pr
-
rr
tf
y
e
o
p
y
od
£
iC
”
oon
AS
a
{i}
or’
J
=
:
be
Lu
:
i
3
O
i
:
i
0
=
:
C
f
r
)
(
rr
un,
|
~
—
p
t
i
=
p
t
le
Jd
a
x
\
/
i
U
i
t
u
t
F-
Ey
/
—
o
r
:
:
~
hp
i
rr
PD]
i
(
4
—
—
=
ph
v
<
<
pr
-~
1
—
Jd
J
nid
—
UJ
"ny
wn
f
Fa!
-
oO
nw
O
>
ve
ot
I
0
«=
~
"
—
3
Nn
ty
4:
+
-—
ie
ri
r=
~
=
~~
$a
at
~~
O
Ma
9
—
40)
d
u
ba
~
—
8
~y
p
=
C
m
e
A)
5
ori
AL
gos
O
ed
—
oe
Q
-
Cho
vi
-
-
he pun
)
-
i
ud
~
¢
y
a
-
vy
S
JL
{
h
-
3
/
Q
i
o
r
“
-
i
(
ad
i
dd
"
+=
.
J
re
ik
N
eu
a
(CG
r—
ho
WJ
O
C
,
—t
0)
~
1
a)
A
yout
*,
iy
i
LD,
~
ol
ye:
(
S%)
OD
or
y
Nh
~~
»
>
~~
~!
o
d
Wa
wn
Ie
)
pu
\
cine
U
d
=
i
a
p
e
e
d
f
i
h
d
Ld
a
A
-
ed
)
pith
Fa
e
»
~’
I.
=~
-
-
i
”
—
~~
i
'
pd
i
a
)
ig,
®
~
—
-
.
(qe
wn
))
J
or]
’
=
4
J
Lu
Q
A
R
NY
Q
.
oe
2
r-
os
r=
Se
rr
rel
ge,
"pd
.
-
4
CJ
rn
°o
rt
{Ul
J
i
emend
{0
oO
-
i
4
~
P
be
6D]
9
—
\./
P
Sef
pao
ori
pid
ne
-t
-
J
C
or
by
+
e
S
a
)
j=
o
l
-
:
p
“Pluk
of
~~
[a
¢
Y
of
ou
i
I
r
ry
“/
(0
—
pig
-
e
d
/
r
s
:
~~
il
Ud
Pl
J
-
pe
~~
~~
.
QO
0
-
~
[
—
()
oy
A
QQ
id
-
)
-
~
~—
~~
Ne
ht
.
-
n
T
i
r
-
)
~
~
~
.“
ot
>
»
x
0
a
ra
)
i
i
Joi
~
dt
7
»
0
\
~
1
i
J
i
’
r
S-
-
Ie!
.
r=
f
e
Pe
J
h
a
d
rn
-
-
)
i
{
r
e
{
Jl
-
WE
“
49
ne
=
)
J
)
J
J
OJ
3
A
et
r=
&
U
)
f
.
=
=
c
~
i
es
~~
r
we!
i
>
U
”
3
U
0)
Oo
od
ed
—
ny
>i
Oo
£
23
po
*
r
T
3
h
o
¢
4,
ostsal
ny
hg
we
—
Cy,
r
r
a
\’/
‘5
”
\
o
/
-
“
|
~~
@
or
J
a
of
Sk
P]
N
.
/
LA
ron
~
~
{
r
r~
gs
~~
|
A
#
or
rid
oh
[=
et
~
+
oO
ri
—-—
ned
/
1
Bert
a}
-
{
{
v
:
¢
)
y
p
—
—
.
E
Y
A
i
y
P
a
q
l
d
¢
,
ai
I"
ey
i
_-
“AJ
h
e
Nr!
{oid
ded
F
L
f
—
OJ
rn
1
od
v
Co)
~~
x
“=
8
¢
re
:
c
a)
pi
jo
Nn
=
O
Ss
-
~
-
~
bet
Pp
pt
=
—
AN
@
opi
-
—
—
a
:
oO
;
—
{/
i
fi
~
id
N
J
od
(©
~~
r
=
~
~
hot
Po
-
—_—
-
-
pe
—
£
I
)
T
\
oy
-
—
oe
—-
my
~
res
ke
hart
~~
-
—
-
r
i
=
10
~
LA
Lo
—
Te
eS
U
—
—
—
rs
re
C
i
-
-
-4
e
t
~
yneed
(
L
D
ue
(RV
§
Ne
~
~
Ia
j
e
T
i
T
N
-
et
ajend
en)
-
-
VU
1
U
f
—
Cpe
~
w=
9;
-f
~~
=
i
—
—
.
-
vd
n
-
)
»
——
u
.
~,
w
p
rn
—y
~—i
w
¢D)
ot
~/
>
C
quand
oJ
98)
~
>
.
Ul
j
t
:
i
Pet
<
vl
-
,
pt
=
pt
r
i
o
S
i
i
Ud
I~
co
.
oF
pate]
Pe
J,
L
p
—
f
o
-
i
Y
a
T
g
e
—
a
|
p
o
w
hg
~
~
~
)
a
‘
-
“/
na
p
r
169
J
y
—
pl
A
y
o
~
CX
Gry
LU
M
p
~~
~~
oo
~
Ud
¢
pet
O
—
el
lal)
“\
pd
be
or~{
C
a
vid
i
Pf
hd
0
a
ct
i
—
—
-
i
3
ge
Co
Cm
pee]
-
\
2
-
oi
Pe
x
O
—
wd
re
-
rr
ged
O
D
~
%
of
0
r
F
y
pd
9)
Ie
OJ
~
—
169
‘U
-
¢
=
(4
T
.
3
w\
4
(o
~~
a
~/
.
~~
bia
r
=
$J
a]
eS
.
“
-
~
re
prot
QW
L
y
r
=
(@)
:
r
s
Cri
eh}
'
S
Q
ot
z
—
ro
&
rl
r=
=
i.
SU
a
Q
QO
JH
oo
C
{
i
fd
I»
—
P
A
{
r
i
-
”
(
Q
T
C
re
©
he
.
2
Q
bd
a
QO
QO
C
3
;
—
i
o
p
i
-
U
d
F
t
G
U
of
G
J
yopet
-
o
r
—
i
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
I~
.
p-
aN
QO
d
S
J
PRY
C
f
C
nN
r
i
—~
rn
~
Q
~
>
QO
58,
@
je
-
Be
9)
.
-
x
3
Ul
PF
4
J
opel}
pt
[¢
—
oh
cl
(
~~
(©)
—
QL
QQ
f
t
Q
(on!
Pred
.
-
-
—
—
~
N
w——
pred
~
~
>
h
r
e
$
"
r
g
be
i
4
p
A
0)
>
~
~
/
pnt
Ul
y
e
/
J
r~{
~
~
()
|
)
<
r
o
"
F
i
—
—
()
9%]
AR
ee
ns
ee
fae—re—r————————————r——
a—
—————EeT
rr
ot
—
—
—
—
—
—
e
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
A
A
A
A
N
A
A
R
A
N
R
S
A
0
R
E
E
i —
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
E
E
a
a
n
E
E
a
a
a
m
a
a
.
.
h
i
t
B
i
i
i
I
>
E
E
a
n
E
E
a
m
—
P
a
er [
rf
pani
rood
J
py
pee
ad
*
¢
pe
3
-
5
A
4
—
pe
/
y
Al
|
rt
—
|
R
E
£
—
~/
uo
!
C
d
—
i
;
Jd
atone
”
i
v
e
}
-
;
@
Ph.
?
.
pt
&
-
s
i
woud
/
-
a
i
{
i
—
»
&
W
R
—
’
~
~
=
)
D
a
\
© [||89d5dfbc-e365-44a7-91d2-029c5cd5b028||]