Motion to Dismiss Appeals
Public Court Documents
March 27, 1970
3 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Hardbacks. Motion to Dismiss Appeals, 1970. b4309710-2e34-f111-88b4-0022482cdbbc. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/bbbd077c-ab15-4eb1-ba13-5c14723bdf5a/motion-to-dismiss-appeals. Accessed June 02, 2026.
Copied!
[||0eedb9ed-9137-44c4-8130-521d750eb663||] a
re
t
n
Se
e
e
A
A
A
e
n
ta
m
e
Y
e
Ny
0
i
A
5
P
l
ST
S
m
A
E
.
tn
E
A
A
P
O
A
O
E
r
r
At,
p
o
o
A
G
A
A
B
A
I
SN
A
5.
|
ro
~
-
Se
RY
ed
"
|
~
a.
"
Py
=
rm
~~’
®
i
wt
-
N
‘
ig
we
-
}
h
|
~
~
—~
A
—f
i
~
rs
oN
4
9)
fo
ef
Cy
wn
"rd
Nd
T+
oe
sind
4)
ls
ee
»)
:
3
O
Y
[RV]
wii
~
’
3)
2
-
-
C
x
&
be
Et)
3
Pt
~~
A
A
(3)
po
oi
}
reid
4
;
rt
geet
r
o
o
(
i
i
a
-
<
>
{
y
-
3
Moa
f
e
y
Cop
y-
r
y
tnd
~
She
-
fume]
re)
is!
-
—
&
-
:
Pd
T
£47
free
~
;
~~
\&
i
p
e
~
y
Lad
WW
o
C
l
Fore
Ne
I
po
t
d
Y
48)
=
m
ny
=i
3
a
feed
~s
Tea)
ft
99]
od
av]
0
=
Nd
Us
.
—
i
t
a
:
0)
)
:
—
po
—
Co
it
-
y
~
i
{
(
Ww
hr
\
=
Y
p
l
>
Fo
on)
a
ho
_
o
n
2
J
mt
>
&
<
oO
hore
AV}
I's)
* pd
. gn
=
5
oN
oO
¢
fod
oN
:
-
[gy
LD
vile.
nN
2
N
I
¢
ri
lay
ve
—
—
~
N
D
i
a
~
n
d
crm
C
i
in
|
4)
bv
=
oP.
~
(
J
d
“
—
N
d
p
y
\.
O
o
=
c
o
i
is
X
—
=
—_—
al
~
-
rr
Pe!
I.
~
-
~~
¢
3
”
4
¢
oo
OO
po
iy
eb;
+
3
ei
.
~
3
—
@
W/
t
1)
{
-
C
i
»
:
OO
QG
rr
ud
—
i
~~
_
pac
4)
hy
~
”
~
f-
2
poord
~~
Q)
L
J
yds
a
oo
~
-
CO
~
—
—
~
C
pr
-~
i
—~
=
int
-
7
lf!
QO
¢
i
L
y
=
L
N
No
J
oO
o
t
~
~
™
y
P
o
E
—
r
e
.
-
i
:
pr
;
,
gud
[iY
({
Tm
A
w\
GN]
9
ol
L
S
~
hl
+
{
;
id
pd
Fn
.
a
~/
©
Go
ry
a
O
r=
J
A
a
3
r
r
°
7
I
s
v
o
pn
=
Gr
’
—
W
R
Cid
Ul
oO
ot
~~
¢
69)
oO
%
~~
¢.
)
ri
~
hi
at
-
pe
—
i
-
:
¢
x
Ci
Q
oO
—
wn
~/
=
wiped
'
a
~~
:
pe
y
‘
PR
bh
[)
bat
wy
%
~~
~
~
<
.
“!
~
Pe
i
ori
{
C
r
49
di
ged
ant
r
t
«
f
e
Q
a
ox
r
y
t
i
ct
ey
"
[®’
J
~
e
WN
-
a
)
—
F
S
S
|
r
t
j
m
phe)
md
i
¢
.
ei
ae}
Frey
1
§
\
r
jp
3
Re
pp
r
ry
.
—
a3
45,
jy
:
~~
i
¥
pid
N
{
—
ener]
I
Ns
e
s
_
5
vv
So
~—
"
~
|
7
w
a
of
e
t
4
=o.
J
-
S
d
:
-
=
f
P
r
i
“
wo
a
}
-
ie
o pu
£)
PS
1
Jd
-
—
G
=
4
1
Ci
rt
{
pi
Pe
EP
w
d
(
i
x
Co
OF
STE '
ei
\
AP
ont
J
ci LY
D al
1S ¢
1
i
L
S pul
wt ‘wy
CULO
£53
£2
1
Loz
ak
= 2
Py 1
i
, {1
jk |
P
N
S
N
A
N
P
N
P
S
~
~
}
\
fo
r
i
i
Ss!
0
OQ
i
S
®
;
C
(
ad
b
d
N
~
il
y
4d
Ud
OJ
E
E
or
&
Q
et
=
C
v
:
o
-
¥
i
{
hav
F
d
=
¢.,
ry
44]
(
0
o
—
-~
5
F
o
form
i
i
(
Qe)
ine
|
J
p
—
~
~
~~
=
|
¢
L
{
H
’
LJ
a
d
.
—
n
C.D)
p=
peared
4
te
oe]
i
H
\
p
t
rt
i
=
~~
-
~3
a
M
A
pe
:
—~
3
~~
i
|
ce
CO
3
i
;
~
l
}
Sr
3
—
C
1
{x
r
}
|
2
3
ot
i
A
42
I)
a
"3
>
A
in
~
=
{
i
nt
feet
QJ
ee
>
Pp
wpe
;
Wh
ul
iw
4
we.
Th
™
one}
fer
:
=
3)
.
¥
{
{
ud
<
N
-
iE,
ri
-
0
|
=
;
=
=
Je
~
3
s
N
=
§
3
HI
I
r
~
~
i
~
'
®
)
2
oO
—
~
~—
i
t
(
A
J
y
I)
™
)
§
i
‘
4
h
u
i
a
J
.
p
t
w
e
\
/
_
—
~
\\
:
!
.
;
!
C7
PN
y
:
i
ba
3%
i
n
7
rn
So
ra
ny
~~
{C
5
A
C)
CS
C
O
hd
bd
-
Na
Za
}
re
\~/
va
NN
=
pour
N
‘v
<
ho
gd
Je
=
-
J
-
i
(69,
~~
id
i
or
es
©
E
os
C
a
het |
p
d
bt
3
Fern
0)
A
~~
{
pt
.
53!
—~t
Fs)
>
oN
C
»
wre
.
(3)
re
f
r
]
”
R
e
k
a
N
S
bode
a
i
a
[89]
Q
O
—
~
A
O
-
r
a
~
—
7
4
"
A
Q
voy
3!
#
whed
ct
Po
“
r
~~
2
J
;
re
»)
oo
2)
—
’
"
ro
.
o
d
Sq
——
xy
-
O
2
.
od
p
:
an
{
i
MN
°
a
i
a
i
i
gp,
Po
re
5d
at. ii.
Ta
fa
A
Ie
¢
fi
J,
py
e
s
QL
A
re
0
—
€9;
=
“
i
~
C
R
A
3
:
_
a
e.
No’
~
~
/
~-
7
I)
[3
’
gs
x
Q
=
0
oli
IO
-
;
0
5
o
O
i
a
hu
on
sf
@
~
—
oy
3
OC
i
el
on
¢)
et
bg
ec
£
0)
i
~~
Fed
-
r
S
—
¢
—
i
1
/
rs
rd
4D)
J
i
a
n
yf
r
i
pf
WW
a
:
r
i
-
I
~
!
1
0
4
~~
Von
¢
-
C
E
Po
—
id
}
p
l
bs
sud
o
i
d
{
{
"
5
>
4
be
ri
oO
‘ts
QQ
$
v
r
|
or
i
iin)
“A
\o’
|
lh
nN
Ij
AE
¢)
ri
-
whe
~
")
i
on
A
a
d
<
<
hs
<
G
{
—{
g
.
\./
o
>
~~
c
o
wn
oy
—
$9)
feed
Ud
he
po,
>
)
KA
i
|
I~
=
rt
oO
~~
Ci
.
i
—
i
—
-
-
a
|
v
=
}
O
i
av}
o
oN
>
a”
ct
-
-
-
—
}
<
i
-
-d
po
-
W
N
o
}
r
—
;
iy
~
~
}
L
J
Se!
e
e
d
A
so
r
=
a
~
rn
y
=
Co
i
r
{
)
°
F
—
}
i
go.
2
5
a
el
4%
4%
ro
I
\/
23
;
i
e
_
ay
=
¢
v
~
.
oe
~
i
:
=
ed
ar
et
J
|
bg
r
N
i
et
}
~
i
WO
—
AS
Ww
.
$
(@)]
>
J
ri
t
Y
:
fod
)
{
rt
or
CY
C
Pas
.
4
9,
ol
~
yen
F
oud
Jem
=
J
OO
i
i
-
-
{
=
f
i
fr
I
N
a
}
~
~
!
o
~
\/
c.
i
pd
a
f
tP]
ry
pret
-
~
(4D)
Runa’,
freee
{
L
O
ct
a
ct
ad
Se
7
Ro
i
.
=
i
‘J
~
=
z
rd
~—
C
~y
—
oy
CX
~
A
i
F
r
fed
‘
a
N
(
pi
i
a
!
wt
w
-
By
—
A
/
v
r
|
>
)
L
o
i
d
a
—
C
e
l
* pe]
~
Tod
4
=
-
~
P
—
i
Lo)
«
T
{
—
Swen]
J
[5]
ted
—
3
C
r
J
T
d
~~
=
1"
~
<<
=
~
~~
i
”
f
-~
—
’
i
r
f
c
a
ro)
jor
~
GU
4
~
~
Q
Q
.
od
L
y
wi
Ul
~
Ss
Foe
fend
7
\
HM
C
e
a
“
Ps
H
E
i
n
_
-
C
Y
0
i
f
-
r
/
t
—
.
J
fi
be.
TT
‘
1
os
7
|
o
y
hn,
d
d
-
P
=
qv]
”
mje?
o
D
~
~
—
_
—
~
~~
{
al
=
t
©
(4!
J
oO
—
Q
Q
:
Ww
[®]
i
~
RR
!
J
Q
:
a
he!
-
ei
~~
A
er
|
<|
frown).
om
{
3
of
3,
~-
O
=
5
-
Co
-
rr
|
—
y
§
09)
r=
fui
oO
re
r
t
p
d
-
—
()
|
I»
CT)
r=
i
Sy
¢
~
{
Oo
qv;
n
KS
i
5
{
=
4
rm
{
~
,
a
p=
e,
fo
—
2
—
CS
[=]
©
i
29)
R
E
rd
Q
4
a
Ci
Ee
i
4
3
~
=
fovme
Mp
2
i
-
1
os
VL
~
)
*r™
-
pd
{
i
.
4)
§
r
e
I~
{
rr
of
o
r
box
Oo
£,
id
te
os
re
Li
OQ
§
—]
pied
[+,
-
~
~
~
49)
-
~~]
0)
=
LD]
Fe
y
|
.
:
{
ri
i
pe
Sy
a3
rd
GO)
fll
§2
:
ay
CD
{
—
—
C
M
c
»)
or
L
c
pricy
:
i
L
\
/
NF
p
—
3
as
r
o
d
‘
i
d
C
.
Sd
a
i
i
oi
T
S
Fan
/
i
d
hi
ed
ri
i
(1)
i
i
a
i
(
r
~~
r=
:
CJ
|
i
hn
i
-
C
$.
rt
-
2)
ord
~n
{
rN
rr
r™\
r
i
ord
Ie}
c
s
of
Mi
[a]
hd
r
—
!
bn”
|
Jd
prone
|
\
*
i
~
~
—~
Qo
a)
pn
Ca
—
A
|
ng
a
|
~~
<
~
~
&
Oo
-
poet
J
~
N
.
|
fv
1}
)
—
|
Sal
ae
i
1
ie
~
>
=i
Te
5
—
3
_
—
h
i
PRY
n
d
find
rome
fu
oY
Ly)
49)
rt
i
|
~oy
~
Q
>
e
d
wy
—
—
f
pind
—~
-
{
—
—
et
H
A
nN
«
¢
S
)
;
cS
“
J
~,
ry
|
=
A
{
~~
sei
<
<
~~
3
/
fas]
6!
o
~
)
7
{
i
jdt
LJ
i
45
W
o
r
CN
[5]
eo)
bo?
o
-
.
i
<
<
e
T
i
49]
hg
Cid
~
:
&)
~~
p
g
Sy
El,
kt
i
rn
=
——
HH
{r)
~
7
~'v
fp
os
i,
|
pr
vo
ol
|
4
—
oC
a
&
prt
a
d
r
i
o
i
(4)
J . LeVONNE CHAMBERS
ADAM STEIN
Chambers, Stei
216 West Tenth
Charlotte, North Carolina
JACK GREENBERG
JAMES M., NABRIT, 111
NORMAN CHACHKIN
10 Columbus Circle
New York, New York
ha
pa
Sr
A
—
—
—
A
Y
t
f
ot
A
n
H
A
—
-
|
H ¥
1}
1 ri XA rT T hi I I J y {7
( FG 1 RR 1 \ Tel SS £) > sInvV i
i, oa JEL len , ] ) 1 L i.
dersigned hereby certifies that he h J
Loe 27n I= A 1 1 \ Tt iy 47 NS Ct VV OFC NX amr TS
11) Wiotion to Dismiss ADDeasupon (
& 3 i
tS nN LL 1 I] 3 Cl ry -
Co P £ oO a8 ne in i Uni Od Stato:
a Cle
3 C's i 1 J
th Carolina
x oe A Y o or
Gaston H. Gage, Esq.
1014 Law Building
Attorney General
of North Carolina )
Raleigh, North Carolina
James H., Carson, Jr., Esc
Law Building
Charlotte, North Carolina
Benjamin S. Horack, Esq.
606 East Trade Street
in Nes 5 Td ve hh Carolina
Whiteford 5S. Blakeney, Esq.
North Carolina National Ba
Charlotte, North Carolina
William H. Booe, Esq.
Law Building
Charlotte, North Carolina
y of March, 1970,
WAT nals! 2
1/ - ad
Attorn
\
Te PP
Lis
i Pa
WEE we
12131
LCL 3
urge
/
/
yi
v fo
Building [||0eedb9ed-9137-44c4-8130-521d750eb663||]