Knopf Draft of Insufficiency of Evidence Claim 3

    ir.-lJ"-

, I 
t]^ ""tytrrouiled opy*tur;\ t flqt,"t^-.jt

tettp\-*u

1tI lr

.,^\\ , rr |.',l o 1 
t ,.toior-rf tr.c U e. [[ ofs , f.^ ,.

n1 6,
(t4,r^\ \e,rsun r.uLssr pou^e [e <-6,"[l ^,rt ,a,*lt [ -Uca. u) o,a

ka\ce pLa.
est. t, 0..L,C

i't iS iun?osib\gdB [*,ow t,,k.t "[ tl,* co[te,^,0 @ +]ct

lLe n otrozrrT.* 
X tro.r^L il to\,-e g \r'ct oql" ; L t " f4eserrLc

{t,)<' st^afe. o\\ene 6 r.ro cu. de,$.e o.tlnno 
f 

orrut n tt,rt1 r.,t tt e

Crwx . t ,E Ldre . C.. ;.r\1 pt;h.r\e4s rhe^c paeser{e ;1 k\e-

. ctl* v ^lt +1., wurrtJ vt^ 
Y!40urP

!-
wwo \ S,^t1

oItt'..,rters.

;t *uf rh

{, Iow\ o I P:t

^i 
+lq &*t

'^r*.Irau +'
rr,.. \ $l- p

Or*-r-ny) W, fxe votc^s

"-^- 
" l ont rtt-c (

l,*Uj,[, l,- [ lr- ) B- / 5 t, I I ;s - 1[ .",*r^] t pn 
^,,r"tt

*re ("r c(err"nrut o( o.".,whzt

C,\N l-xe ),." N .^ ..q-ll,

\Y-T,\l{y,,i: tt, :er\4 (0" rr66[trr i ;r A.ds\

Oarr-r{- ) 6 olfu flaestr,ct

,L

i-' t.i r.j. tlh-f'/

(it^t
th(

],\

g i n^p\1 us e-u i {eNcQ of $-e d bq,"".I U^rf rt\,"t.J c[ou( St t[1

[s oToa t-ar.]

"r- .) ,r* t( - r.rkrr <q - tritl c3

8.,.t euo,-t .[\ cor*\ & be

tlte [*f X".Jr tt

prt pnesest J ^*,d f}'e I

s-l(r"cr{^.t t^ 1^r* le tuw.e

@ en; dtr.. "\ c-,*lv"A
r-,- 'r [.."..1f ,!o ,.rr,*/ ,,

L

c-l .l eu

tor,-",

, LJ o. ro[p rr.r corra4p\ttr

eirNce " [ 1X" vutPzr t -1X, fg.(t,o.f "/, (c., J*_ny',,,^
fe-If r,ra.r,y rf lt'.^. r?tl/..; /
9t; t^, *^' ptquY* rolg

p 6tasrt-.r.rq\
i,^If-Prup.[ 6

A7(Ttt

,depct



I

rb
'

i \O- <rrN her hrelie 7n.r,,*. f the tootort:.r{ 5"sh

1t,(*o azt^o neala Otencfi .

f*p.,t auCc.^ A\aLr.,rr-.,, [,^.^,.

,i ,

i 1 f c c^r,p of tu sen.J" <c',..*c ',f,. ,) t.e 
Peti ir6nor'(

li
il
ig". Sr,,, c. *t \ug poTarll rr l dt t. ur tr.., the ruarrou,r g><ccpft u*
iJ
I

i+" -h.e -.,^[e n-.r rn^e,^€ (-tesev1e, Lo wr*[|.*-t- tt, (,^afc'.-^

$c. p"l [.1sr.r[2..o. ,

toor,-^r-L-, (,"L.[G{- T-,., orJ* G J, (o i+r^,.tA L,,,* A t€rl

$.^^^, tL.$ FflC.€^ r^Joa pa<-seut ipte,.d,-ltr ,"J ip fLe
I

;li

,1i.,,.-*, ,\tr, 6bx,,ste< 5,,\\*s ]L'n yL (^r,*,1 , tt*,atl*r'-lr{
rli
.ll

,1 
<rtU..^ \^(r .Ep 

1rlesuJt' I+h>o FNr{^^) " I flrhtt.xrrr 's Ct^lp}rl,<
ii1
li

,,1v^.rsr-O sFa-bt , 1fr* wai ,*bs"1th4 N o e lF t

1 rrtr,,.- rl^*,4 e.v.'J, e ;,- c € prrtc^ i *,, 
1 
t O+'h+,**f rcla:t'rtruA'ya

,il

lii fi.." " I r-(.r.rr";rrtrtn r 1f*o[^ 
)e.)op 

i ( it w o. 1:,T-.r.,g^,-flfr f]-p

iil

iil "O \,*,rFa F Wd,J q ff tLp s,"+o,'-y"l t t^-o
ril
til
rll

:ll

., 
o; +\ *l* otl* uo,rtrJ pregr,sf-:f +/" rvofo5lz,,uq ) Qr\ce/ S.

I,l

lil 
'fu.'.to.f,,..."*1 ,f ^ra,ut"l Wy*ffi

ijl

',1i1 "l u,^t Lrl;r6er <n tL {,-. t"lur*1L fue.,-6 [{-^ pate'rt(, urlewrpf



,*f,,-\ lr.rs u*{^trs .[ \\1-B-l,th*u ilr,tuiAs\,c(

, 

^ - t..-lt. \ \oao A caxfiIr^ {)*J +k^lw?^( 
^-,r..,. 

o I

] g, t"-b. .r- yfil64'te,,."'5 [,J\ o.&',*N. crr,**'* ,l
I

lh- qrf
ilt
t'l

ttf""", As P *at,,r^.e,^-l *r** r tk

t-ttvo t^rr-[h-lrJ| uilr$ €r rrrllerfu

o- (,rd rpt o \ t*A ipten TT ur-rJea tL f ,Ar1t,-,[ ol aeves,)

pa:rzr J", b1 Jyrtqt^, SJo W*f*'"fL )(-l J [rtou, .



I

,Tln st,^t" q-U"r! \eo t csLut,q,h *r.* tl" (,..1e(e,'e,JT.

i't
I 
,{o u"..,r*yloa \,"Li\,t1- 

".t^^Q aro,r,abr^rc( i*r -tLa (rm.4.A,oqrr\

il
rl

j.] 
o[t" ,\hl,,.-" - w\tk tk t.rt^,^-^1 o[ [t,t. R.llirrs.

,l
rll

)t{ '1iNs\^reyer Co" t}.- 
f 
*.1(,f I it L u,-vme& art urn,d. o Jt"t

:

I

.l{.." St^te's er,,iJerece (po,s s((i.i"lT to conuirsce q re{Aso'..^.bl€
il
j;

;i,
i,i )*rt roeg,rn-J a r<,rcut'".ht< dr,^t,t. ?A.-h fe4f h,rr..c,r a;J{ ;P
lI
Irili -)

f l c.^r^r^1 tlc r..,otQrttdh6., \ occt*-, ,wt a[ fl.e p^et€,..,c( "/ fhe
ii
rl
lrl
lr

llivde-s . (;pJ.^ f . r ot\ t^,1t- *^J p-"o( Lo lf e

f *"s(eme^tf ol ,**".7L4 t*&\i*ct^o-? "-d Mtaf.'.*7

sat,s6re I ,ut p (,,t b, (,ty ,^rde,, f t 2 -23- l,li

f"oo(f".:Istog.or,..d<,Su((rctc^,teu.Jtpc-€ui..,dlrb

" I +!^,e r-,.e^,fo--0 cwl poL u tr,rl rr6re,r,,rc J fo-- a6aat^pl,wg ll abrtt\

:,"*l.le L+rr.
te,.rJe.. $,r-)3-l - L-tLe.\l.tuurl<r^"rt

,[ T^.L r,"". tl^J {U \.*1r",- Coulrt "hor*r*r=oa-a.-*glg

i^, fctr*,cc6 tn,-. Vort;<, (,rA, t qltrn^..tc (*1. 
l.tr,r,3 

u,5. clT

j\q. 
) 6 | L'€l-2d *t q'13 4 Tt uul,u-,.n t:^< re/eua^,y



(uest,oo L w\-.ths\ arn". t\ €

porr.rl^ fu^f Cosbl l^d cr,*^ff"[ ')t-brn4. f,r". tL<- SS:,,Sa

L*t,craarrun<d \-{r") +lotletittdrrea c.' Jg.( r^-/ .Y fle

Nolu,^rng,1 /fil " p\ore. 6s15,le , [il. tf ft.!1rvce "Itt,

y6ficsS , E-* pe+;f,o^er. po.a c^.lt,rt -{ uith i.,v-fe^Jtt

6i.A iu w[.J- s[.e k]ren^rG\, ^p a{[,-tt cleprur( otl<u o(Wa

,,--T-!'*z pt^-rbh* -o^.,^,i+ ,*ppq hr* (mJ Lry l^or-"*J"/,
[t ^o*,G (t.., J hq/,l..,! a-^!+-t.^-0td,\ t "tJ ( .ne**ztn-a}l. la^Lt " t

T[u e\euruth c\rouit hetd neceut(1 i,..J fh e ia"<-e*c c,(

r ,rr{e.,r1 'uttt,,..,ts 
Lrr-n (-*., [u*1.1 *rA, ,"nJro , l"Ina

o() ."-t'ta-*rofu.r,. -LJ trfu" sAo.f , ( +^e T4"^ ,.,, (t (t +

f e,.xf wLe", tl.a ,^rJr:pJ"J @ lry< \"J t*f par.fG

I p c<rnr, stert t at{ere*tc- .l /Co, b. ,. I^n- 68 7 F, Z J t31i )

ljB]*.)[ CtltnC,' . kB]Y, f1^^the rturtr. l u,oleyc,f].e

C os [ur J,le^Jo*t tu.o f,^.e. d *rnu u '.1 eoy' o / b '-,ri (*^,-r . TZ e

-?th:"\,4,tl/
ft"Te nJ,r.t$J"",lvx* oo<,e*rt,.1 Corbrrvts P"tio*rl o/

ftil*,,.- fnl-, # ft* d? b\1,'\a,rd T. ,*yru"; 1,r^

It ": 
J it-"l lkq ev r Je,r*c, 1o* " ey.,^.0 tq p,^t To a,, q(ur € * c<

o ( t.^^1t"^n c^-d. ./V *(U*t^"* '+/- Crslll wa (oroctrt 1 Eur")

i.|. ca r.r b<- ttcrsrn^.c.\,f,a i*fe.,.,".J



1'
4

!o ('T V
 6

.c
C

\. 
o

!t ,IY 
A

.

IL
:

lA
 --

{-
l9

r
) .C

I t:
t;/

q
?\

.
x 

s'
\-

) F
T

-+
B

\/) ct
/ 
I

\r
x t r ( 2- I -f 6



%{-a uJrJ-& eui \e",gq

': ta"tg

f ^e0 
owdea.rttz i N fi^urn , I ti, r"(e"r"*2,. snf P^-F.+x t\e

d ,, q.r-",*-,t [t \*1 t^{p.)l- ,t"rnlrOarrrj,l ho ho.bor <x

',rQ-u-c.r,-ott, Aoubt W aul +u.v[uv u^rdc,^.
I

J....[".* t\, crr,,vr <,t,,on luJ"ot

---

/"fl . IJ.)A l)83- f * s;,^y,11 ca,^,Iii-

illli
Itl,
,be s.,d +X;t^ MteTt-ru<
i

t:

I 'l-hg |.ofozrrZtWq{G c<r,t.,\ fve,o h&<s''\4. s,,11ortf c^^, i*,fezte*rce G(,ll
I

, jC-*t pc.L,\r\ +I""#" i*ftrc^z( o{ ir,*,16 €,u.( . Fu- s,J cp i*rf<,a,er.,cA

I 
"rr^t).,o

i 
restrs - 

1' lalez.o1 u I rr*(ue;l.< vf \ v\+,re*ce OacA o | *kJ.,
ir

:ll
I

Iit sarpe<,{-ur'rdca il, }gE*.'',.u1€ oIz,er,--,'aLler',enzl , fi"trt
li

ti;,Efu1,t@J {^,,n^ lte tec,tt*ra "( thnoe uohrr4 / 6m ,(u
i,
l'

i,; p,-eVote,*rr{estulot,rt 7c^",clo"f, ,( f,{
lr

iir

, trl*",^ 4hrtotee b,,'[t ots wer<.ust / fu c-Ao

3Q v ole,-, (ow

4artt (iel
*A.U n 1^,7

i

iii 
HA l,I p$uufed b1 abce^rtes b..\\ff, f n*d be o^lu.,ed +t"t

lji 
u"t--.@ 5..*.-1, ;f r^^'4* Le ,r^6r-, d f"t,*1b

rti

ti

i,i 
,or" a +^^,:r tl^e n\earrs o( urtctn tzt.tt! ta.toa 7a* " lT/-

5ul'ere T Je?at*<! t Tt".^J , ,/ rr*"* Lu tr"(e/'rq/ f n^
I

got;trc>^,etn *e/e pl."o^,p c-o,l( to ylfr,. POll,*r9. 11^af rA< nturl< J



a \'D\e i p aor,,*,41 fL" r.,,ofc\^^.zru1 f, fake p\*<

or^t , \ tt" pece-ce o\ t\.e voters. [i',-,tt ';l hlJ L{ 
^(r^t)

f^,r,* \}J a.o\t +U.*-t yetrtrgxrn s^.rr{ o-ctr.J{ t.,tx tL n.-tol

:i c""\5.-.Q-rI, *,tc-0.a.6s^1[^ *.-/r- t*U,U\ . A+ b q,tuv\y*r(rrl,((

te'k<- '+*,\^rgg,l( a^,d t ,tr*,).r^*^no {^rt**-Q Sv.Fr;-T (^^r ,teatgil

,\ b*e af^ ur["( to p i le

r e*A burlal au^r>okl<

{t"c Pht, {l\.Jr, tu(t< cr-<-f,*1 t , ftl

ii fu r,xc,oha! *11.*J-1r\ ,f a,^, 6..,*it*ra, C^^.-Lte^tt vof #q - The
t L ,'

w[t,terce , ( fi,e,'td

t.v the- Stz.tu" fouo^

f\Jrth.r.n y oYL< ev€v'\

ul/ Aatlr^r1 lnn(e;reectb ',f 'o*r be sfo-ft' J

p e4i tta6€a k ^o t e u^ tl' prf,c;-' -t-rw 
{ l+, vt d-r)

*r?.L

ii 
l^e,^,,,' t\^ op Dyportu^rity 6 c-<.f, Lr,r'tVr {e'atcJt-

,8,-Ju|"^rt v atr"r1 ; SA e. <zrt^-|. d

(hc{,11o"!/6i2f,Ld
c"-^t cle,' ,*r) t tq t O.S .

lLoway v .

tnBo I

'(

i ,r.rfta e "rc C

d,r,^bt fk?

L w c*u+e.tl it-e

6 05 ) 6Lt I (t.r^
totZ C ttar )

Ovec-



,[ o11o*tuuit5 b .,^.*iF -.oriwre ; r*^.il-,
i*tt"..*^a &rw,r-cf> (e. J'*pl ,. St us?) (l ) fui; )1
\t{ . q\\\ C A\* . Inq\\' Lt o"^J v St^t<, IBI S"2t'/tJTl',/l!, I l- r -t I - I L/ 

' 
\r w v \ I l- | l',/ q Ll v - -, v - tv, s r 0 n

t'/LJT-, l:
tsS, b\'tO C A,L^ -; 'Af n - \"t13); Ls-v^.,pt6.,

l_(t"f" , ztl S. Lr )l\;1qo Cnr" olff

-/ 

.'l I

11 6 I ) ', Sv\4^e'cr-Q .,,, St^tp > to 5 fu. aJ ZiiO,

{B t;: 3tz Cll" nir-rir}) fl,.%5 lu
o( C-,y.*Se kr-c^.r-r .l-+o& by *)..e )pl,o-.e^.,-t- i-s." (tyq
o('*, Ja.,c-., [ "T p;l!.{'t zof"t-l^J- lt*|"^ff\. Silorl*ly

Sg--^"^-a ) L,--.\tfg",,o-,d L!$trs)-f.9l- I 
vf

1rl



i t.o..rQ'a "\ ,"tc,r,r2r!,1 *'[L.*r\e*.t *1;I- !f o,A i*, t\.( }n;S-

v ut,-\ o \ \" Uc.\\r,ts tp"u,,ll. (--.1 . ]J olle^ Qplnurfuuwr

'l

, . e c1r^o\ plr^r""/"t"\ e Li'. . S).e lcrt, er,.r fh" [L[ ( ,.r s (^ lt
trl

1t'1,-.,-.tcaLlr *nrQowF.u1.r^, ll(y SSI q,,J *r-, pla<(

ill

,,i " 
(. r..,uto,^.rzrra,ho^ cr ^lr} t*^.e l*y*cLu p bt%l b[ fL<

:

i

,,11**.*r". rrFc,r^vcnrt(.rJc€ "l hr.,..rj,rl t* ruulcrrt, fa o l( o I tlt
li

:rlri

ibt u ot* .) (:,ue*t +r- (.'nt tkJ tle."-, "u^, Cc,.. , / A, sf u\d
i

rl

,il .a.-r-d rtn" sqpt rl r.ro €rr, dt^,cc o( pe{''i*,o>-.vro -rlrr,.b,[,41 ,lt,enl

irl
i

iii 
r *otl^l-^? fo n^.aEt tl-o st'at.,l v^p-,,tnce rnsv p(rur*.Vt<.

rl

iil-
lii L*r-; tts 

fl,,"(.u^o r[% st-r.tets c-a,2.-D ,*tJ1; ,y"^J bilr,-f t"Q

iir

!,i

lil Sa,,,'d 6 (*.,-- lL ^(* eNc4 +I*-A potit,^.,^ t+t,.')^,t
lt
it:

ili^*rn dpc.t (a . At o,.*, ,*nte,c\ reo4,,nbl< ,-(ue*c-e.
l,l

ili c<rrotr"t \* Vrr*) q. ',^-e. Lun1e.fuzrq a,r, L surp(ct^aru. /l
tii

l;l "'s'v 
Ft= Lu,-j.6jz e>_d LLt6) qz\cg'*G-,..

liil\
iil soo J (oppt,1,n-1 T-_t r.] . ?,t;t,,,*J ro\<
iii \

\ *, lr* ,il*,.,^r\J ,u*- . 
l*, Va,[,'.'.raa) to Lo.,e *.!

ht^, put-cr,^,,nr',t lo o.aq-.\ or^f, o[ lLo p..oS<rtC€ Altxe uo*,/

d o eo nr6t frc^m* a nt r-..,*oht. )- yI. { 6-"*,



t'
U

/o
\-

.-
J r\
E

F
> P
t

o)
e

c$ )oI
d

9, oe s hq
-

LC 4F 6f c+ 4+ F( ft9 c<
-\

P
r-

P E
 

),
L. tA

 
-l-

/o
q

+
-o >
(

.C "s
s

\: to
f

i F

H o I 6 t 7

,- s o

Lr
-\

C
f,r

tr r)

c2
-

q t c- + -+
oF

r*
-o

tr
E

-L
P

o?

=
16\./
t

S
 

),
 

,l
-r

,C
,Z

?o
l

}.
/ ca
\

,t1 o-
1

: (_
,

J-
 

-+

&
o-

9 -t o O

sr
o

?-
f ao

L
?o

-
t J-

{
c-

+ aO
G

<
\

J
.-

?)
 

2

X
qc

t./
<

)
./\

%
d

c 
)-

' 
:}

--
, 

=
 

7
S

*J
L

i e ) o

-:
\ ,{ ) C

\ q c-
l

;

-<
3.b

6 tr t 
..: 7 \

a=
 

6
6F >

P
G

j, 
t

lb
( \_

 
E

-
_-

J-
l

(T
(e

--
-C

 
-=

-
J> F
\

a )-
-

_t
i t>

<
--

>
n

e5
Y

<
/

rs
n

9-
:l*

\_ 1J
I

-+
E

c-
 

t- I

=
I

til /s I />