Deposition of Leo A. Watermeier (Redacted)
Deposition
December 14, 1982
33 pages
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Major v. Treen Hardbacks. Deposition of Leo A. Watermeier (Redacted), 1982. 998394e4-cc6a-ef11-a670-00224832ce23. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/c3c40e51-0dea-4074-b44c-6e8577ec8360/deposition-of-leo-a-watermeier-redacted. Accessed November 05, 2025.
Copied!
AS LA IATED REPORTERS, I
iNGe
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
644 CAMP STREET TELEPHONE
(304) 528-3353
NEw ORLEANS, LA 70180
23 December 19582
re: MAJOR VS. TREFEN
NO. 82-1192
WATERMEIER
DEAR MR. WATERMEIER:
Enclosed find the original transc cript
deposition given in this matter
you read and sign the deposition
our office as soon as possible.
If you should find eces sary, to make any
Or corrections in t ; please do
the transcript but changes or
on the form which is ached and date and
the bottom,
Again, it 1s most important this be done promptly
returned to me at our address above. If you have
estions call us.
Thanking you for your prompt attention, we remain
Yours very truly,
ED REPORTERS, INC.
James Kellogg
TY 1
Martin L. C. Feldman
SS hb in Se sd
BARBARA
ET AL
VERSUS
DAVID C. TREEN,
ET A
vw I
LEO i
#1
L* 9
notice
offi
ge
14T
te
|
A P PEA an RAN : 10 E S
£0 He ge wry
S IEVE.
£4%
Or leax
vn a
& 5
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA
29-3355
sociated Reporters
CERTIEIED SHORTHAND REPORTE
A DDE A FST ad ld
& PE EARANCE 5
i 4
ur
LEPORTED BY:
BRAD
a an On ” 1 £ -r Se wb an 22 5 TT Te Certified Shorthand Reporter
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans. LA 70130 p 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
14.529.3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
Stipulation .
Examination by Mr. Quigley
Examination by Mr.
Signature of the Witness
Certificate
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA 70130
504-529-3355
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
a 110
it , stipulated and agreed by and
among all parties that this deposition is
being taken in accordance with the Federal
Rules of Civil
is further stipulated that,
the exception of the filing
transcript of the deposit:
and signing of the original transcript
deposition, all formalities are waived,
it is further stipulated that, with
the exception of all objections as to the form
of questions and the responsiveness of answers
all objections are reserved until the time
transcript of the deposition used or sought
to be used in evidence
ol
¥o
LEO A, WATERMEIER,
of
Louisiana, having been first duly sworn,
¢xémined and testified
QUIGLEY
Q Would you give your name, address, and
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318
Associated Reporters Ine.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
district that you represent for
record, please,
name is Leo Watermeier,
95th House Distri
¢h is part of the 3rd, 4th, and
2th Wards in New Orleans,
were you elected to this position?
@¢lected in December of 1979. My
term is from 1980 to 1984,
And what committees do you serve om in
the
I s the Civil Law Committee,
and Welfare Committee,
Municipal and
Won oun own Bf Be Se om
VOMIT CE]
employment.
wr on 9s Le 3 3n sua a work, though?
affirmatively.)
estate and real
development
Q JRE what 18 ¢ oy - A £ enera 1 wnat is
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
! 318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
By EB VE MTG
CCONOML ECE
of 3
Ls Fy
NG an ul 4 NW
om go
a
{4% @ wo
WEES Ye
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA 70130
504-529-3355
I voted, you know, on one plan or the
other, 1 wasn't involved in the
decision making processes, no.
You voted -- prior to your voting, did
you have any activities involved
in this? Were you contacted by
people, lobbied by groups, given
information, communicated with?
I think -~ let me think of what was going
on. I was aware of, you know,
sort of of the floor -- the floor
talk about the plans, you know.
I was not privy to any private
meetings at all, and I would not
say that I wae in any way involved
in the decisions that were being
made that led to one plan or another]
I personally was more involved with
the State House Reapportionment,
because I was concerned about making
changes in that plan and was not
very involved or very active in the
congressional plan,
Okay. Did you hear directly or indirectly
from any of the congresspeople about
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
their positions on the congressional
reapportionment?
The only one that 1 ever talked to
personally was Bob Livingston, who
called me to ask for his support
for the plan that sort of helped
save his district, which was, from
my understanding, from my remembrancg
the final plan that we voted on,
that we approved,
1 believe I also got a call
from him afterwards thanking me
for sort of sticking with him.
Okay. You say the plan to help save
his district. Did he explain to
you why he liked one plan more than
another, do you recall?
No, we didn't go into details. Again,
it was sort of the floor talk and
floor knowledge that there was a
plan that saved his district, and
we 2811 knew what we were talking
about when that came up. So when
he called, you know, it's -- a lot
has happened, you know, It was
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
quite a while ago to remember some
of the details, but basically I
remember getting a call from here
at my desk sometime before the
bill came up that we had to vote on,
and 1 was able at the beginning to
say, you know, "I am planning on
voting for, you know, the plan
you want," I don't remember him
soliciting, you know,
or soliciting support
plan, because we all knew
what that plan did, and 1 was able
to tell him I was going to support
that plan,
Okay. Another plan that was before the
Legislature was for the creation of
a Black majority district. Do you
recall that plan?
I don't remember the lines, no, I don't
remenber the map of it, but 1I
remember that being a factor.
Do you remember which people were
interested in that plan?
To
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
contacted specifically by anyone.
I mean, I knew that the Blacks
=~» that the Black representatives
were in support of that plan, you
know, after I voted against it,
You know, a couple of Black legis-
lators made some remarks about that's
going to be a factor in my own
reelection, and that it wasn't such
8 smart vote, because the new
district that I am going to be
representing has 4&4 majority of
Black voter registration, You know,
they made some comments about that,
but nobody called me == you know,
nobody specifically asked me to
vote for that plan, from what I
remember,
you contacted at all by anyone
from the Governor's Office or any
of his floor leaders about the plans]
Not directly from anybody from the
Governor's Office, from what I
remember. Now, I am trying to
think of the floor leaders. You
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
know, there is so much contact
back and forth, that I will be
honest with you, I don't remember
&@ couple of people from the =- you
know, from the administration, that
people said anything. I just don't
remember,
Okay.
Just part of the whole general picture.
Do you remember what the general goals
were for congressional reapportion-
ment during that session?
You know, in my opinion in general,
with all of the reapportionment,
there was a strong emphasis on
protecting incumbents. I mean,
whether it was in a House district
or whether it was in the congression-
al. You know, that was never ever
said, but that was the general
understanding that, you know, we
are -- you try to do things that
will help the incumbents, that
they would be in a distriet that
would allow them to get reelected,
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
In none of the speeches was that
ever said, you know, It was just
part of the premise, the basic
premise that we were using.
In addition to incumbency, were there
other goals of reapportionment that
you recall?
trying to think. There was another
plan that was going to create a
Jefferson district, if I remember,
and there was, you know, talk about
some people out in Jefferson, that
they preferred this plan, because
they wanted to see a district that
would allow someone from Jeffexson
Parish to get elected. Again, things
get a little bit hazy, but it seems
that was part of the proposal to
create a Black district, that was
going a basically Orleans dice
Parish District which would have
been a Black majority, and then a
Jefferson Parish =~ that was kind
of a coalition with the Jefferson
ma jority, That was one of the other
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
factors that was given considera-
tion,
Okay. You were not in favor of that plan
the Jefferson-Black majority dis-
trict?
Ne.
Do you remember why?
I didn't like splitting up the city on
racial grounds, 1 didn't think it
would be 8 good situation to have
8&8 heavily Black district versus
2 heavily white district.
And what reasoning did you use for that?
Personally 1 think Blacks, and I guess,
lower income people, would end up
getting a better ~~ having more of
a8 voice if they had a significant
voice in two districts, because 1
know how politics works, and I know
& representative would be trying to
reconcile his district to the fact
that we would have ~~ and partly
part of the vote im Orleans, that
the Orleans Parish vote could be
split among two congressional
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
glve Crleans Fa
greater representation in
I think it's a different
philosophy. I think it's a health~
than having one
predominantly Black district repre~
sented and then have one sort of
white, conservative district.
that is marke
congressional division of New Orleans
prior to reapportionment with a
to the right being
"
letter B is the way that Orleans
8 divided as a result of
18 the basis for cutting the
city up in this fashion?
- gr 1 y 1
» f # y ou Know N
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA
504-529-3355
70130
SWNB Building
102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
group
lines, so I can't tell you what
I think I
in general, sort
things that were
on, but, you know, I wasn't
part of the group that -- I could
tell you what was the reason the
people were drawing
resides
already told you.
All right. Now, in congressional
reapportionment, the various plans
what you call
vhatever it is
on on the bills, were the bills
described to you at all in terms
~c»d nl vee 1s " ny 4 rial makeup of
-
wr « . ¢ JOR oF on vy 4 or @ sn p ay 1
h Ou Nad Ow ® 2 LWeel i 1 4 a 4 ) «tL a A8 AL
ODViIOUs ly the considera-
L410 810C the JeiXey¥son Jarisn coa~
sideration, you know, because you
had the Jefferson people basically
2 wn FR a wr sh Yr n 4 - Fa % o ws 2a 2 4 " } - in favor of a plan that created a
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
district because they were
going to get their own district
you had that coalition, I would
1 -« v 11 it, that shared thet interest.
celling thet the
wae supporting
iR, FELDMAN:
v
herdy Black or white?
. It was an
interesting coalition of people,
coalition thet you don't usually
« on ov gn @ To 2 - 1 . together votes,
describe the district,
ecially in the Black majority
ribbing a Black
never heard
1B in those
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
-“
but wouldn
the floor.
I am not talking about the floor.
People are too smart to talk like
Did you
have a nigger mayor.
don't need a nigger congressman’?
opposition
the Governor's
Plan or Livingston's Plan?
Was I aware of it?
Yes,
Sure,
Who was leadin g that opposition in
addition to Chehardy?
I guess the Black legislative delega-
) Ye 7 n9 ' vein ta
the Black Caucus.
those people speak to
that,
ould think, yes, but
don't remember, I do remember
it sticks in my mind more after
vote. 1 seems to me
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA 70130
504-529-3355
SWNB Building
102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
given the makeup of that
strict. I seem to recall that,
a va #9 v & ‘ ry
and Livi: 8% 1
basically sort of a friendship
ir va Med
KNOW 9
2
m y min d
«
healthy situation splitting the
§ 4 os $d oq 4 2 ‘ 4 ® LA 4 » v 4 9 va do oA 2 cus Fd pnb w 7 . "uy
Le A 8 y 41% Q tL. » R./ LN Q Loe Ww la Ve ,
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
my own rnouse disc:
used to havi
*sonall y
kind of votes
We have three
neighborhood to heart, and they
us. We
based on that, I wanted to support
that plan,
know whether
opposed to
reasons?
the legislac
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
with you directly
thelr opposition to the Black
me jority plan -- thet it was basged
on racial reasons?
sure the:
voted
not say, you know, Legislator X
voted against this plan because
2 Black district,
I never talked to
about, you know, the reasons for
their voting, and any time you vote,
here's all kinds of issues, all
kinds of factors that are part of
So, no, I couldn't say
you know, "Legislator X voted
against it for racial reasons,
he
cther than
in peoples' opposi-
tion to the Black majority district,
I think one of the main factors was
protecting incumbents I said that
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
already, I don't think --
what ~- you know, if it's the =--
the real effect was a consideration
-=« 7 don't remember now how this
St. Tammany
1 don't remember
though, how those people up there =--
how they stood in line in all of
that, I don't remember, I don't
remember if that was another factor,
I guess people, as I told you =-
say that the factor that
me was my philosophy of try-
spread out the city vote, 1
thought it was a healthier situation.
«now ~~ again, you said ~~ you
say specifically
Jo you know whether
8 role at all in the Govern-
or’'s actions in reapportionment,
congressional reapportionment?
Absolutely not, no. I really don't think
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
28d,
You don't know?
I must that when I talked to
ce wads never an issue, aCe
“= you know, my ling
Governor was more interested in WF
protecting Livingston, you kmow,
MR, QUICLEY:
think that's all
I have.
ERY A ATT AY
NAY LON
BY MR. FELDMAN:
Q Let me just make a note,
and along with
Leo, my name
is Marty Feldmar
Bob Kutcher from my law firm,
‘e defendi the Governor and
questions to ask I believe,
Just so the record will be clear,
I believe we can agree that on the
%
fie J
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
House side, the llovuse Governmental
Affairs Committee was the committee
with overall jurisdiction for the
redistricting issue, and the sub-
committee on
specific responsibility
legislation, isn't that
Yes.
And you were not a member of
of those committees?
-~=- the factors that
into one's vote, are you aware
of any legislator who voted or who
told you that they had voted that
their goal was diluting the minority
voting strength in any congressional
district?
You asked
a factor,
fhether you are aware
whose goal was to dilute minority
voting strength in any of the
congressional aciLstLyices,
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
dy told
from what I know of
personality, their outlooks about
racial or minority voting strength,
factor in people’:
support of one plan or another,
That would be your opinion, is that
"We got to vote for this
7 don get a
{
1A oH dh AR i don't
8
remember ing told that,
In connection with the philosophy of
spreading the votes among more than
one district, as you characterized
Is it your view that gd jority Black
congressional district would have
isolated the Rlack vote
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
favor,
Can you recall in the time that you
been in the Legislature t!
there has
flition which you have
between the Black Caucus
-'s infrequent.
And it's correct, is it not, that this is
a coalition
iominated cor
Sure. There was
Nunez Plan.
That's correct,
SWNB Building
102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
Lafayette, LA 70501
318.232.2189
644 Camp Street
New Orleans, LA 70130
504-529-3355
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
%
Chehardy
ferson
LO%
Congress.
matter of fact, I believe
Mx. Nunez thought about running
for Congress one time, didn't
Yee, I believe
In addition to
-=- and consequently
coalition
Ys @ wre 3 z » ut 4 Fu on 4 n | ry Ala Ve ME oLL ADC U 2 many Will C es J
opposed to it, too, weren't they?
generally the surburban people.
#3 aware of any
Governor eve! ade or that
administration
made during the months of
the legislative process in connec-
tion with congressional redistrict-
ing?
Is . A
LLOVErneyr
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
bout reapportionment.
ivy to any of their meet
you know,. so I would say,
>, but, you know, there
noe reason to believe that
been 1 } #4
ems to me that that's sort of
questions. Vas race a factor
discussion?
was a factor, you know.
Whether that was the dominant
* on oe O° py pe pr on fe _— y of re Th. lctor or not, I certainly could:
minant factor
. B wag your political judgment th
Covernor wag concerned about
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Ine.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
And that was the street ~~ the loor
talk. The Chehardy and the Nunez
would create a Black
there is a plan that
rgston's district,
how things were
talked abo
1 believe you testified that Congressman
cr mentioned racial
that correct?
matter of fact, the second ~- the
registered vote in the Second
ressional District wes increased
Legislature
that correct?
a
to what you are
3aid 1 am sure race
you know, part of the
was that Livingston
r1lacted ~-- reelected
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
a predominantly
I keep saying that in protecting
incumbent, this kind of catch
y, nobody ever
as the foundation of protecting Ww
Livingston, or one founda-
Cions was o0DLY
intact as possible, but, also, not
putting him in a district that was
going
or Black majority registration.
Well, the district, as it was proposed
with the majority of Black voter
registration, would have been
rv $ y > t 33 ode oo , » 7 1 Lindy Bogg listriet, would
't remember, you
I believe
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
Tren T ee f R——
WIINESS — CERILFICATE
I, LEO WATERMEIER, do hereby
state that I have read the above and
foregoing dep
above transcript and accompanying
9
f any, constitute a corrections,
true and correct record of my testi-
mony, which was given under oath and
best of
tine
of the deposition,
ai. IEG WATERMEIER
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
CERIIEICAILIE
I, the undersigned reporter, do
hereby certify that the above and foregoing
is a true and correct transcription of the
stenographic (Stenotype) notes of the proceed-
ings herein, taken down by me and transeribed
under my supervision, at the time and place
hereinabove noted, in the above-entitled
and -numbered cause,
I further certify that the witness
was duly sworn by me in my capacity as
Certified Shorthand Reporter for the State of
Louisiana; that I am not of counsel or related
to any of the counsel or any of the parties,
or in the employ of any of them; and that I
have no interest in the outcome of this action
rR
i \
dinin”
Se
Xx my \ | /
A
7) A 3 3 3% A *
BRAD GULLY
Certified Shorthand Reporter
644 Camp Street SWNB Building
New Orleans, LA 70130 102 Versailles Blvd., Suite 304
504-529-3355 Lafayette, LA 70501
318-232-2189
Associated Reporters Inc.
CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTERS