4th Circuit Opinion and Application for Extension of Time

    p., Richmond, Va. 23208 

  

HEN TAT LS OURT 0 Ee APPE AY Q 
ED STAT Eo COl Ki Uk APPEALS 

  

  

No. 10,792. 

- Charles C. Green, Carroll A. Green and Robert C. Green, 

infants, by Calvin C. Green and Mary O. Green, 

their father and mother and next friends, 

and all others of the plaintiffs, 

Appellants, 

versus 

County School Loard of New Kent County, Virginia, et al, 

Appellees. 

  

APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DisTrRicT COURT FOR 

THE EASTERN DistricT OF VIRGINIA, AT RICHMOND. 

Journ D. BuTzNER, JR., DISTRICT JUDGE. 
  

(Argued January 9, 1967. Decided June 12, 1967.) 
  

Before HaynsworTH, Chief Judge, and SoBELoFF, BORE- 

MAN, Bryan, J. Spencer BeLL,¥ WINTER and CRAVEN, 

Circuit Judges, sitting en banc. : 
  

S. W. Tucker (Henry L. Marsh, III, Willard H. Douglas, 

Jr., Jack Greenberg and James M. Nabrit, III, on brief) 

for Appellants, and Frederick T. Gray (Williams, Mullen 

& Christian on brief) for Appellees. 
  

    

* Judge Bell sat as a member of the Court when the case was heard but died 

before it was decided.



PER CURIAM 

The questions presented in this case are substantially the 
same as those we have considered and decided today in 
Bowman v. County School Bd. of Charles City County.’ 
For the reasons stated there, the rulings of the District 
Court merit our substantial approval, but the case is neces- 
sarily remanded for further proceedings in accordance with 
the District Court’s order and our opinion in Bowman. 

Remanded. 

2a Or, ooo F.2d (Decided this day). The special concurring opinion of Judge Sobeloff, in which Judge Winter joins, in Bowman is applicable to this 
case also.  



  

&u 

s 

~ 

§ 

¢ 

| 4 

& fa 

"3 
Vs 
§ 
» “ 

4 

  

., Richmond, Va. 23208 

  

ha & fa 

i A TES CO UR wr OF AF p PEAL ¥ 

WV; i A ES 1 1 RT i 31 

FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT LR. RAN 

  

No 10,792. 
  

Charles C. Green, Carrolb A. Green and Robert C. Green, 

infants, by Calvin C. Green and Mary O. Green, 

their father and mother and next friends, 

and all others of the plaintiffs, 

Appellants, 

versus 

County School Eoard of New Kent County, Virginia, et al., 
Appellees. 

  

ArPEAL FROM THE UNItep StATES District COURT FOR 

THE EASTERN DisTrICT OF VIRGINIA, AT RICHMOND. 

JouN D. BUuTzZNER, JR., DISTRICT JUDGE 
  

(Argued January 9, 1967. Decided June 12, 1967.) 
  

Before HaynsworTH, Chief Judge, and SoBeLoFF, BORE- 

MAN, BryaN, J. SPENceErR BeLrL,* WINTER “and CRAVEN, 

Circuit Judges, sitting en banc. | 
  

S. W. Tucker (Henry L. Marsh, III, Willard H. Douglas, 

Jr., Jack Greenberg and James M. Nabrit, I1I, on brief) 
for Appellants, and Frederick T. Gray (Williams, Mullen 

& Christian on brief) for Appellees. 
  

* Judge Bell sat as a member of the Court when the case was heard but died 

before it was decided. 

fa 
- 

 



PER CURIAM : 

The questions presented in this case are substantially the 
same as those we have considered and decided today in 
Bowman v. County School Bd. of Charles City County.’ 
For the reasons stated there, the rulings of the District 
Court merit our substantial approval, but the case is neces- 
sarily remanded for further proceedings in accordance with 
the District Court’s order and our opinion in Bowman. 

Remanded. 

14. Cir, (Decided this day). The special concurring opinion of 
hich Judge Winter joins, in Bowman is applicable to this 

case also.  



  

  

.» Richmond, Va. 23208 

NIT TATES COIIRT OF APPEAYC UNITED § Si TES COURT OF APPEALS 
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT 

  

No. 10,792. 
  

Charles C. Green, Carroll A. Green 2 id Robert C. Green, 

infants, by Calvin C. ir and Mary O. Green, 

their father and mother and next friends, 

and all others of the plaintiffs, 

Appellants, 

VETSUS 

County School Loard of New Kent County, Virginia, et al,, 

Appellees. 

  

AprPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DisTrRiIcT COURT FOR 

THE EASTERN DisTricT oF VIRGINIA, AT RICHMOND. 

JouN D. BUTZNER, JRr., DISTRICT JUDGE. 
  

(Argued January 9, 1967. Decided June 12, 1967.) 
  

Before HaynswortH, Chief Judge, and SOBELOFF¥, BORE- 

MAN, Bryan, J. SpExcer BeLr,* WINTER and CRAVEN, 

Circuit Judges, sitting en banc. : 
  

S. W. Tucker (Henry L. Marsh, III, Willard H. Douglas, 

Jr., Jack Greenberg and James M. Nabrit, 111, on brief) 

for Appellants, and Frederick T. Gray (Williams, Mullen 

& Christian on brief) for Appellees. 
  

* Tudee Bell sat as 2a member of the Court when the case was heard but died 
oo 

before it was decided. 

& 
or 

 



  

PER CURIAM : 

The questions presented in this case are substantially the 
same as those we have considered and decided today in 
Bowman v. County School Bd. of Charles City County.’ 
For the reasons stated there, the rulings of the District 
Court merit our substantial approval, but the case is neces- 
sarily remanded for further proceedings in accordance with 
the District Court’s order and our opinion in Bowman. 

Remanded. 

  

24 Cir. Fad... (Decided this day). The special concurring opinion of Judge Sobeloff, in which Judge Winter joins, in Bowman is applicable to this 
case also. 

EL 

i
 

Ba
il
ie
 

 



i
m
 

t
—
—
—
—
—
—
 
 
 

  
    

  
 
  
 

  
    

 
 

 
 
 
  
 

 
       

  
 
 

 
 

  
 
 
 
 

   
 

 
 

 
 
 

  

 
 

 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

  

 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
  
 

 
 

 
 

  
  

  
 
 

 
 

  

 
 

 
 

        

r
i
t
e
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
e
s
 

ee 
e———— 

A —
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

r
n
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

s
e
 
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
a
 

m
e
n
 
—
—
 

; 
ae 

3 

5 
= 

: 
a 

£ 
i 

: 
- 

pe 

a
 

pe 
f 

T
i
 

A 
hy 

wed 
* 

ke 
i 

% 
8 

4 
grt 

/ 
4 

a“ 
ay 

h 

¥ 
x 

2 
W 

3 
8 

d 
3 

: 
pe 

& 
¢ 

¥ 
% 

i 
w x 

& 
{ 

; 
» 

’ 
» 

@ 
k 

F
e
.
 

4 
i
t
 

" 
4 

pe 
ow 

4 
” 

. 
. 

. 
bof 

§ 
4 

# 
5
5
 

3 
Ey 

n
 

fond 
i 

i 
| 

3 
ho 

3 
& 

] 
y 

" 

t 
& 

2 
Y 

4 
: 

* 

» 
H 

¥ 
: 

&
 

i 
{ 

- 
hs 

¥ 

- 
¥ 

} 
2 

n 

» 
3 

i 
= 

) 
% 

| 
pi 

§ 
3 

¥ 
EE 

» 
3 

: 
4 

3 
g 

bi 
® 

$ 
¥ 

7 
£ 

y
a
l
 

he 

1 
i 

& 
i 

i 
v 

A 
8 

» 
i 

ity. 
3 

iy 
EN 

{ 
: 

Hd 
# 

. 
i 

' 
i 

lg 
\ 

; 
: 

! 
] 

L 
£ 

Ee 

ib E 
i 

- 
i 

3 
¥ 

wd 
x 

5 
; 

] 
3 

Hl 
’ 

3 
3 

¥ 
i 

§ 
; 

i 
: 

H 
oy 

3 
gos 

x 
# 

: 
C
i
 

" 
y 

fo 

3 
fi 

; 
We 

LG 
. 

F 
'
 

bl 

Es 
r
o
 

a
d
 

5 

¢ 
py 

yb 
4 

pe 

: 
: | 

he 
a
 

& 
" 

% 
—
 

E 
» 

o 
F 

% 

# 
: 

" 
v 

wv 
at’) 

3 
G 

wr 
. 

g 5 
* 

ov 

er 
— 

— 
a
 

= 
—
 

—
—
 

_
 

—— 
a
 

A 
AE 
R
A
 
E
T
 

ul 
rh 

- 
— 

— 
x 

t
s
 

pe 
—
 

» 
i —
 

—
—
—
 
L
S
 

A 
a
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

P
—
 

— 
—
—
—
—
—
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

—
 

- 
—
—
—
—
—
—
r
—
—
 

- 
—
—
 

- 
— 

—
—
—
—
—
—
 

  
 
 

 



 
 

 
 

 
 

  
 
 

 
  
 

  
 
  
 

  
    

  

 
 
 

 
 

 
 
 

   
 
 
 

    

 
 
 

  
  

 
 

  
 
 

  
 
 
 
 

 
  
   

   
    
 

 
   

 
 

  

 
 
 

  
 
 

  
 
 

  

 
 
 

 
   

     
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 
 

 
 

  

 
  
 
 

  
   

 
  
   

 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 
 

  

 
 

  

 
 

 
 
 

 
 
 

 
 
  

 
 
 

  
 
 

 
 

    
 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

  

 
 

 
 

    
 
 
 
     

    

 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

¥ 
# 

: 
3 

i 
4 

4 
§ 

an 
a 

: 
¥ 

4 
v 

Ei 
A 

ol 
" 

bia 
fi 

& 
{ik 

# 
“ 

; 
§ 

y 
4 

“ 
y 

ov 
V 

‘ 
« 

fy 
™ 

Th 
ol 

- 
3 

i 
— 

pd 
» 

bf 
l 

oq 
i 

. 
3 

pe 
b 

i 
3 

4 
; 

; 
S.3 

Sd 

_ 
: 

; 
wi 

i
s
 

§ 
we 

» 
RH 

" 
” 

@ 
& 

i 
» 

# 
i 

oe 
; 

‘ 
’ 

n 
» 

4 
¥ 

del 
¥ 

J 
2. 

& 
Sa 

7 
? 

¥ 

E 
; 

od 
. 

i 
i 

5% 
y 

# 
% 

£ 
4 

> 
4 

P 
“ 

5 
i
 

3 
l 

A 

= 
& 

Re 
- 

a 
# 

J 
3 

a
 

“ 

4 
W 

: 
oo 

# 
4 

Y 
wd 

¥ 
: 

- 
y
 

di 
i» 

p 
a 

3 
3 

3 
4 

3 
3 

bir 
. 

h 
; 

: 
: 

; 
us 

) 
’ 

Fuh 
i 

ind 
hc 

4 
% 

y 
8 

§ 
; 

5 
oN 

2 
prog! 

i 
” 

3 
andl 

Mh 
| 

fo 
» 

& 
a 

aula 

8 
3 

4 
$ 

pr 
4 

% 
; 

‘ 
i 

all 
: 

f 
p 

. 
i 

cu 
en 

y 
4 

3 
- 

; 
t 

X 
o
P
 

3 
Gs 

4 
4 

: 
: 

: 
- 

; 
1 

% 
ry 

wo 
1 

4 
— 

po 
:! 

ly 
% 

1’ 
J 

et 
i 

a
d
 

¥ 
N 

b 
# 

i 
i 

i 
# 

ia 
) 

: 
A 

3 
4 

) 
: 

" 
» 

: 
© 

% 
ha 

n 
RO 

§ 

: 
3 

ye 
a” 

8 
$ 

oh 
: 

: 
7 

kX 
: 

¥ 
i 

> 
& 

4 
df 

A 

¢ 
oll 

ig 
2 

BF 
i 

2 
i 

i
 

2 

i 
: 

é. 
# 

§ 
¢ 

», 
% 

. 
1 

i 
i 

a 

Vo» 
’ 

v 
d 

on, 
i 

4 
} 

§ 
# 

ii 
i 

§ 
’ 

hic 
i 

¢ 

wl 
Ri 

® 
i 

% 
3 

{ 
r 

s
y
 

il 
h 

k 
i 

a 
i 

w
d
 

% 
o 

i 
% 

i
h
 

. 
m
y
 

Ki 
Toy 

1 

; 
y 

£ 
£2 

« 
ra 

5 
k 

a
]
 

god 
Fr 

=F 
Rr 

ia 
w 

id 
k 

. 
& 

#%, 
A 

y 
0% 

' 
] 

-~ 
£ 

FE 
y 

. 
= 

a 
¢ 

R 
i 

C 
. 

is 
# 

3 
; 

p 
£3 

iJ 
ow 

) 

WV 
* 

wo 
po 

<3 
%d 

- 
ad 

} 
Fh 

wed 
. 

i 
Bs 

Ry 
oi 

oS 
. 

¢ 
- 

) 
: 

Foi 
5 

" 
% 

‘ 
# 

& 
& 

g 
{ 

3 
id 

Fed 
" 

4 
- 

at 
. 

P 
4 

” 
& 

3 
% 

{ 
£ 

: 
: 

3 
ahi 

3 
i: 

#1 

y 
y 

3 
# 

* 
» 

é 
¥ 

7d 
4 

4 
3 

i 
3 

4 
. 

3 
¥ 

~ 
i 

¥ 

’ 
{ 

£3 
5 

y 
nl 

’ 

. 
. 

$ 
¥ 

Ly 
. 

t 
i; 

we 
: 

fs 
y 

. 
bad 

- 
Sp 

Wi 
4 

p 
§ 

a 
¥ 

w 
hy 

. 
5 

A 
% 

x 
{ 

PR 
i 

wa 

L
A
R
 

hr AE 
R
A
 

Se, 
S
R
 

3 
et 
B
E
 

e
t
i
a
m
 
h
a
 

a 
- 

> 
e
e
e
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

. 
- 

- 
h
e
:
 

. 
. 

oe 
ce 

t
n
 

se 
- 

r
e
t
i
n
 

p
s
s
 

— 
i
 

———— 
—
 

e
T
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

~- 
E
—
—
 

—
—
 

E
E
E
 

—
 

  

 
 

  
 
 

  

- 

 



 
 

 
  
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

  
 
 
 
 

 
     

  
 
 

 
 

 
 

   
 

  
       
 

 
   

 
 
 
 

  
 
  
 
 

 
 
 

  

 
 

  

 
 
 

 
 

    
  

 
 

    
  

  
  

    
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 
  

  
  

    

 
 
 

  
    

 
 

 
 

 
 

      
  

 
  
 

  
  
 
 

 
 

 
 

& 
EN 

3 
3 

h 
’ 

5 
- 

h 
ind 

. 
3 

i 
& 

sid 
# 

a 
id 

d 
Yi 

# 
“ 

! 

} 
4 

t 
of 

; 
% 

P 
7 

: 
: 

- 
a] 

¥ 
\ 

% 
. 

k 
i 

4 

i 
§ 

ull 
dae 

o 
£ 

2 
p 

: 
y 

z 
a3 

Fh 
£ 

f 
x 

h
l
 

b 
hate 

# 
3 

v 
# 

g 
] 

1 
’ 

1 
. 

i 
‘ 

“th 
% 

; 
; 

% 
id 

w
k
 

. 
4 

. 
3 

. 
” 

b 
5 

Pi 
5 

- 
% 

id 
hg 

y 
X 

4 
& 

i, 
£5 

% 
ig 

. 
PS 

E 
—
 

. 
# 

h, 
d
e
 

r 
Wr 

3 

! 
- 

wd 
4 

3 
, 

4 
¥ 

: 
fy 

oh 
S
b
 

§ 

: 
: 

* 
i 

3 
. 

wn 
Rik 

‘ 
# 

g 
1 

Sil 
i 

i 

% 
a
 

§ 
» 

a
 

Yo 
§ 

y 

J 
: 

, 
; 

1 
o 

| 
i 

hy 
3 

oh 
; 

“ 
DO 

we 
3 

rT 
f
a
 

g 
" 

he 

h, 
: 

§ 
‘ 

ud 
! 

3 
4 

4 
"
9
 

w 
¥ 

Y 
i 

i
 

i 
3 

iow 
: 

oR 
3 

uk 
d 

§ 
4 

i 
i 

: 
jos 

: 
» 

4 
¥ 

¥ 
1 

# 
1 

wl 
i 

» 
i 

- 
s 

ba 

E 
; 

¥ 
ad 

¥ 
¢ 

Ko 

3 
z 

A 
& 

2 
ful 

FevE 
] 

y 

Ne 
i 

Li 
P 

FS: 
¢ 

4 
3 

fv 
od 

» 
ard 

ual 
¥ 

2 
a
p
.
 

5
 

y 
3 

oe 
u
p
 

i 
# 

" 
» 

3 
% 

i 
3
 

F 
$i 

% 
Vw 

n
i
e
 

. 
» 

Q 
% 

*
 

pe 
¥ 

; 
§ 

3 
/ 

: 
® 

j 
wr 

% 
| 

og 
k
d
 

e
d
 

¥ 
k 

fd 
w 

WE 
as 

i 

S 
i 

2 
po 

% 
y 

ga 
i 

% 
par; 

J 

i 
: 

i 
¥ 

i 
In 

bak 
gr 

4 
¥
 

2 

o 
; 

om 
¢ 

- 
Ey 

od 
¥ 

" 
P
a
 

bj 
. 

aot 
wd 

: 

4 
fia 

i 
L$ 

3 
: 

Wo 
3 

- 

n
e
 

We 
i 

x 
5 

N
t
 

kd 
. 

* 
g
o
 

’ 
m 

1 
hd 

. 
oh 

& 
& 

" 
¥ 

nd 
" 

Bird 

wi, 
#5 

1 
i 

ps 
" 

a” 
wh 

¢ 
[3 

; 

i 
&
 

w¥ 
P
i
 

4 
#4 

" 
. 

{ 
a
 

§ 
iW 

wi 
" 

: 
3 

¥ 
3 

wi 
# 

: 
* 

» 
a 

& 
id 

J 
ag 

1 
= 

k
e
]
 

4 
H 

9 
» 

ow 
% 

d 

# 
[3 

§ 
#7 

: J 
7% 

a
]
 

Td 
3 

* 
A 

ih 
: 

: 
ol 

£ 
i 

2) 
¥ 

: 
i 

; 
# 

# 
Ted 

l 
ns 

pe 
and 

bs, 
ke 

if 
i 

Bes 

" 
a
 

# 
§ 

ge 
 ] 

8 
» 

v 
¥ 

’ 
: 

; 
w 

  
 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 



o
e
 

r
e
r
 
—
—
—
—
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

| £3 ? 

 
 

 
 

 
 

  

 
 

 
 

  

 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

: 
3 

i 

~ 
4 

u 

* 
3 

a 

idl 

ud 
i
 

wi 
3 

« 

Ww 

 
 

 
 
 
 

 



 
 

 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 

  

 
 
 
 

 
 

 



 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 
 

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

- 
= 

—
—
 

- 
er 
—
—
—
—
—
—
 

— 
. 

—
 

E
S
 
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
r