Correspondence from Clerk to Chachkin
Public Court Documents
June 8, 1972

1 page
Cite this item
-
Case Files, Cromartie Hardbacks. Fax From Stein to Chachkin and Cox RE: Maps and voter registration, 1998. 052a82fa-d80e-f011-9989-002248226c06. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/e7beb558-b2ea-4503-ba96-6233e7e4c4ce/fax-from-stein-to-chachkin-and-cox-re-maps-and-voter-registration. Accessed August 19, 2025.
Copied!
12/11/98 FRI 16:51 FAX 919 967 FERGUSON STEIN doo1 ” ”® FERGUSON, STEIN, WALLAS, ADKINS, GRESHAM & SUMTER, P.A. 312 West Franklin Street = Chapel Hill, NC 27516 » Phone (919) 933-5300 = Fax (919) 967-4953 FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL Date: December 11, 1998 TIME:4:32 PM From: ADAM STEIN RE: PLEASE DELIVER TO: NAME: NORMAN CHACHKIN F 212 226-7592 TELEPHONE #: Topp Cox F202 682-1312 TELECOPIER #: 4 OF PAGES (INCLUDING COVER SHEET) Tf there are problems with this transmission, please contact at 919/933-5300. Documents Being Faxed: CROMARTIE INFO COMMENTS: Ter The information contained in this facsimile message is attorney privileged and confidential information intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited, If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify us by telephone and return the original message to us at the above address via the U.S. Postal Service. Thank you. Davidson County N I A L S N O S N O ¥ I A £G67v L96 6T6 YVd ¢ G : 9 T Idd [1] a m i r 141 Eh BAR? J nt pe nel Ls N P A p o resis r e p i g Y Re : | | | 1 i A l £ Ag’ f é { et en ar rar bei em rea i but I m h oh » DEER) Bann ay Ae od Ay F y 8 AI PowndAainh Danis BR £ 0 0 7 N I Z L S N O S N D I H A ¢e6y L96 6T6 YVd € 9 : 9 T IMd 8 6 / T T / T T i : | " | = o | po - : 5 | ' | | | | i Le i'n a d d s [4] = ! Ww i =] { D [" l s ] 3 | 1 Le | 8 4 { J 2 | 3 Ww 1 A | i 3 | : | } | eet 06 676 XV ¢¢:o7 Tad $6/TT/2T N I H L S N O S N D Y H A 12/11/98 FRI 16:54 FAX 919 96724953 FERGUSON STEIN [doo5 PRECING I NO./NAME Ye DEM. % DEM. % DEM. % DEM. CT. | RACES WON 8 | + REG. | SENATE LT.GOV, | OF APPEALS BY REP, ‘GUILFORD COUNT ¥ Precincts Bordering the GUILFORD COUNTY Portions ot District 12 : 1103 Tamestowne 39.64 16.48 27.11 25.80 3 0221 HP-21 45.10 38.35 38.51 35.36 3 0218 HP-18 47.98 27.16 32.20 32.84 3 0214 HP-14 55.73 27.53 37.56 40.38 3 0204 HP-04 45.74 33.96 40.55 32.26 3 0209 HP-09 55.29 38.87 46.81 45.30 3 0217 HP-17 53.03 47.42 46.88 43.61 3 0220 HP-20 | 41.43 39.12 36.06 29.73 3 an © Pwpaml owl unl” ve 32.07 3 0802 Friendship-2 51.13 31.34 38.64 33.55 a 3124 GB-24C | 32.86 | 56.56 47.92 43.58 gee 0122 VI GB-22! 52.08 55.40 48.58 43.22 2 0143 GB-43 | 51.76 56.42 | 47.04 43.81 2 0123# GB-23| 59.68| 50.59 51.95 51.38 0 ozs 0 GBAT| 6186] 6508 . 6168] 5819): 0 oftans GB14| S804 | 8691] | 6566[ 6392 0 o1ti#e iiGB11| 62.32 67.51 | (61.68 52.981 0 0 0112# GB-12 60.21 43.62 52.73 34.81 2 0128# ops] sem] sama] som 39.31 2 2135 (GB-35B 43.54 46.81 48.87 38.09 3 Nash... GRC] ee2n) 6640 49.01 38.13 2 1402# South Monroe 537.27 32.72 42.73 42.51 3 1602 South Sumner 47.99 19.18 33.33 28.64 3 12024 South Jefferson 63.29 45.76 53.37 52.26 1 0702 Fentress-2 51.94 27.77 37.41 32.14 3 1201# North Jefferson 55.17 31.19 45.19 45.51 3 # Precincts cited by court * Precincts cited in McGee's Affidavit FADATA\WWRSPLIT\DISTRICT\CROMARTNUSSCT\PRECDEMO.CHT 12/5/98 page | 12/11/98 FRI 16:55 FAX 919 967 FERGUSON STEIN [doos PRECINCT NO./NAME %DEM. | %DEM.| % DEM.CT. | RACES WON SENATE | LT. GOV. | OF APPEALS BY REP. FORSYTH COUNTY Precincts Bordering the FORSYTH COUNTY Portions of District 12 0303# Bethania #3 56.78 33.88 40.66 42.45 0401 Broadbay #1 5222 28.62 38.02 37.37 0603 Kernersville #3 40.94 33.21 33.76 31.19 0801# Middlefork #2 60.11 44.57 46.51 48.23 0802# Middlefork #3 55.84 36.76 39.94 42.98 1436# New HopeUnited 55.91 57.04 53.06 52.56 Methodist Church 1407 Brown/Douglas 61.60 78.27 64.07 62.39 Recreation 1403# Bethabara 55.06 52.12 53.14 50.21 Moravian Church 14226 Hanes [7. 76.) 175.77 71.68 | 69.18 Community Center |." ty 14084#* Brunson | 75.46 | 66.30 65.84 Elementary School | 1443 Reynolds High 58.15 54.42 50.51 School Gym 1411 Chnist 59.37 49.93 Moravian Church 1427%* Latham [|| 65. 5485 | 53.86 Elementary School |: 1 % 144 1# Philo 28.29 39.60 Middle School 1413 Covenant 31.07 43.05 Presbyterian Church 0102 Abbots Creek #2 22.38 29.84 1202 South Fork #2 27.63 34.24 0503 Clemimonsville #3 34.75 32.78 # Precincts cited by court * Precincts cited in McGee's Affidavit EADATA\WP\SPLIT\DISTRICT\CROMARTINUSSCT\PRECDEMO.CHT 12/9/98 98 FRI 16:55 FAX 919 #8744953 FERGUSON STEIN doo7 PRECINCT NO./NAME %DEM. | % DEM. | %DEM. | % DEM. CT. | RACES WON | "REG. | SENATE | LT.GOV. | OF APPEALS | BYREP. = MECKLENBURG COUNTY Precincts Bordering the MECKLENBURG COUNTY portions of District 12 0601 col| 5126] 49.43 42.26 37.13 3 01044 Ch.Pct.4| 54.50| 51.76 42.12 38.16 2 0195 Ch. Pet. 95 | 5046 | 60.77 48.04 43.44 7 0184 Ch Pct. 84 | 5344 | 6422 48.15 46.57 2 0145# Ch.Pct.45 | 59.10 | 47.60 45.30 42.05 3 0105 Ch.Pet.5| 57.03] 60.45 50.35 47.62 1 0133# Ch Pot. 33); 85721 S107 43.87 38.67 2 0134# Ch.Pct. 34 | 54.60 | 49.01 46.19 44.87 3 01074 hr? 477] asl’ se 49.08 1 0135 Ch, Pet. 35 53.14 59.88 49.41 38.19 2 [0147 Ch Pot.47) 49.57] 147.03 a070| OF 2787 3 0118 Chopet 181 4778] 4680 | 42.73 27.24 3 0101 Ch.Pct.1| 5130) 57.77 45.27 35.41 2 0108 Ch.Pct.8 | 49.01] - 50.28 42.54 28.55 2 0120 Ch. Pct. 20 55.02 56.40 49.69 38.10 2 01104 Ch. Pet. 10 | 63.45 | 73.01 | 62.66 5578 0% 0121+ Ch. Pet. 21°] 159.45 | 60.01] ~~ 5232 48,30) i an nit 0151 Ch.Pct.51| 5166] 54.90 43.68 38.14 2 0138+ Ch.Pct.38 | 5182 | 54.33] | 4495 40.67 | io 3a 0137 Ch. Pet. 37 53.37 47.81 41.89 37.79 3 0150 Ch.Pct.50 | 51.18 | 48.89 39.27 36.21 3 0159 Ch.Pct.59 | 50.65 | 50.57 38.01 34.23 2 0158 Ch. Pct. 58 | 49.09| 49.69 42.68 38.73 3 0176. ChPa.76) 3641] das 34.85 24.45 3 0192 Ch. Pct. 92 | 28.29 49.40 32.38 22.44 3 160 rT PvL | 4083 | 4838 34.25 28.40 3 # Precincts cited by court ¥ Precincts cited in McGee's Affidavit FADATA\WP\SPLIT\DISTRICT\CROMARTINUSSC \PRECDEMO.CHT 12/9/98 page 3 12/11/98 FRI 16:55 FAX 919 of) FERGUSON STEIN [doos PRECINCT NO./NAME 1 % DEM. | Y% DEM. % DEM. | % DEM. CT. | RACES WON er I REG. | SENATE | LT.GOv. | OF APPEALS | BYREP. MECKLENBURG COUNTY CONT'D 1801 SCa 51.87 47.50 48.91 36.66 3 0301# BER 58.82 42.90 45.58 42.97 3 01794 Ch.Pct. 79 56.46 42.25 42.96 40.49 3 0180 Ch. Pct. 80 52-37 47.40 42.18 39.11 3 0189# Ch. Pct. 89 54.2] 23.27 31.71 28.49 3 1401# OAK 59.14 30.23 26.56 34.42 3 1501 PC) 49.00 33.04 31.03 27.44 3 1001# L.C1- North 59.22 45.18 46.65 44.74 3 090% £0, LEM | 43.99 | 41.87 34.20 26.16 3 SUMMARY OF REP. WINS 3/3 2/3 1/3 0/3 Guilford County Precincts: 15 6 1 4 Forsyth County Precincts: 10 1 0 7 Mecklenburg County Precincts: 20 11 3 1 Total Number of Precincts 45 18 4 12 The total number of Republican victories in these precincts is 175. The total number of Democratic victories in these precincts is 62. # Precincts cited by court * Precincts cited in McGee's Affidavit FADATA\WP\SPLIT\DISTRICT\CROMARTIUSSCT\PRECDEMO.CHT 12/9/98 page 4 12/11/98 FRI 16:55 FAX 919 986 9 FERGUSON STEIN - PRECINCT NO./NAME % DEM. REG. % DEM. SENATE % DEM. LT. Gov. % DEM. CT. OF APPEALS | RACES WON BY REP, FORSYTH COUNTY Pre cincts Bordering DAVIDSON COUNTY Portion of District 12 0503 Clemmonsville #3 37.58 34.75 32.78 29.65 3 1202 South Fork #2 48.69 27.63 34.24 34.17 3 0102 Abbots Creek #2 38.27 22.38 29.84 29.00 3 PRECINCT NOJNAME | % DEM. | %DEM. | %DEm. | % DEM. CT. | RACES WON HRT “REG. | SENATE | LT. Gov, OF APPEALS | BY REP. GUILFORD COUNTY Precinct Bor dering DAVIDSON COUNTY Portion of District 12 | 0208 HP-08 44.79 36.44 39.19 33.16 3 PRECINCT No./NAME %DEM. | % DEM. | % DEM. | % DEM. CT. | RACES WON : 3 "REG. | SENATE | LT.GOV. | OF APPEALS || BY REP. RANDOLPH COUNTY Precinct Bordering DAVIDSON and GUILFORD COUNTIES Portions of District 12 | td | [Z1009 0414 Prospect|| 32.02 20.64 23.14 21,02 3 PRECINCT NO/NAME | %DEMm. | %DEM. | %DEM. | © % DEM. CT. | RACES WON Comes oo 7, 7 REG. | SENATE LT. GOV. | [OF APPEALS | BY REP. DAVIDSON COUNTY Precincts Bordering District 12 | 0601 Coton| 6271| 4632| 60.36 6060 | 1 1110 WadNos| 17] som | e03s 60.56 0 0502 Holly Grove | 49.27 | 28.96 37.97 37.96 3 1101 Lexington No.1 50.68 29.94 40.98 40.63 3 | 1102 Lexingion No.2 55.17 37.98 44.92 43 2 3 1111 Welcome | 48.85 | 27.03 37.15 35.49 3 1606 ThomasvilleNe.7:| 4123] . 20.56 33.19 29.74 3 1604 ThomasvilleNo4 | 52.39 | 32.71 43.27 28) 2 1605 ThomasvilleNo.5 | 5230 29.17 39.88 36.99 3 FADATA\WPASPLIT\DISTRICT\CROMARTINUSSCTYPRECDEM2.CHT December 10, 19928 page I 7/11/98 FRI 16:56 FAL 219 4 4953 FERGUSON STEIN se 4 do1o0 °% DEM. | LA : F APPEALS REG- : — a PE PREC INC No. NAME ii . ‘strict 12 a | ROW! AN COUT ON TY Precinct Bordering District = ae or pre) Trading FO oe ik a | 37.26 i 33.10 eT LL WE Cs SET Le on : Sy esp Fath 03 | 31.29 wera Riis wi g 07S 02 Sumner 1 1a West Ww 1d It pee Locke = eee ne Wilford bills [530 | a2 rae SS RIS— Le at | o% DEM. os, DEM. | % DEM. % DEM. CT. RACES WON PR) ¥ RG. | SENATE | LT.GOV. | OF APPEALS | BYREP. Se Turnersburg 6421 1136 30.19 Bh 56.46 | 1 3) 1101 oom] See | 2ue | 3430 135.10 3 oa Wen Helleny | Stas] mos] sem viaapm 3 1401 : Statesville #1 | 61.40 | 41.90 884 | 41.89 3 1402 Sttedvilles2z | 3590) 41.60 BH 39301 3.3 Tia Smedert ie] MIs B01] 46.41 3 1405 Susie #5 | 6206] 4030( 4088 i 43.46 3 1301 snich | 6107 | 51.83 37.14 41.77 3 0901 Fillsadwn | 38821 3823 BIZ Te 3 0701 | Davidson 46.05 36.45 32.07 29.96 3 FADAT VEA\WPSPLITDISTRICTC TH 5 ROMARTH SSCT\P, CHT % RECDEMNM? / | i ! Decempey 10 1908 page 2 doll 12/11/98 FRI 16:56 FAX 9i¢ 0g : FERGUSON STEIN b PRECINCT NO./NAME % DEM. | % DEM. | %DEM. | % DEM.CT. | RACES WON REG. | SENATE LT, Gov. | OF APPE ALS | BY REP, C ABARRUS C OUN I'Y Precincts Bordering District 12 a S— 0301 T pwiship 3 49.73 31.54 40.28 —— 0204 Tormey 2 37.80 33.20 36.84 Towbin: 2 41.68 32.48 36.75 Box 3 Towle 1 49.59 30.89 37.69 36.64 Box 3 Township 1 42.37 42.03 36.43 33.00 Box 1 _ S— SUMMARY OF REP. WINS Forsyth County Precincts: Guilford County Precincts: Randolph County Precincts: Davidson County Precincts: Rowan County Precincts: Iredell County Precincts: Cabarrus County Precincts: Total Number of Precincts 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 The total number of Republican victories in these precincts i is 116. The total number of Democratic victories in these precincts is 7, FADATA\WP\SPLIT\DISTRIC NCROMARTINUSSCT\PRECDEM?2,CHT December 10, 1998 o 9 EVERETT & EVERETT ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW SUITE 300 R.O. EVERETT (1878-1971) 301 W. MAIN STREET KATHERINE R. EVERETT (1893-1992) ; ROBINSON O. EVERETT P.O. BOX 536 DAWN T. BATTISTE DurHAM, NORTH CAROLINA 27702 TEL: (919) 682-5691 SANDRA G. HERRING FAX: (919) 682-5469 OF COUNSEL ROBERT D. HOLLEMAN December 8, 1998 The Honorable William K. Suter United States Supreme Court One First Street, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20540 RE: Hunt v. Cromartie, No. 98-85 Oral Argument: January 20, 1998 Dear General Suter: In conjunction with the delivery of Appellees’ Brief, there also is being delivered herewith 20 sets of copies of four maps that were attached to the Affidavit of Martin B. McGee. This affidavit is located in the Joint Appendix on pages 253 through 276. These maps are identified as Exhibit M, Exhibit N, Exhibit O and Exhibit P. J.A. 255-56. Ten copies of these same maps were previously lodged with the Court when the appellees filed their Motion to Dismiss or in the Alternative to Affirm on or about August 28, 1998, but were identified respectively as Map 1, Map 2, Map 3, and Map 4. To avoid confusion, and to allow the Court to more easily follow citations of these maps in the district court’s opinion, please accept these maps for lodging in acconjanee with Supreme Court Rule 32. Sincerely, Kober 5 Hf pn obinson O. Everett cc: ~~ Mr. Edwin M. Speas Mr. Todd Cox Mr. Seth P. Waxman Mr. Laughlin McDonald Mr. Matthew J. Zinn Mr. Paul M. Smith Mr. Burt Neuborne Precincts by Percent of Population Black with Congressional District Line Overlay March 17, 1998 gp u 8p - 2 SEE eB 73: 368143 | rry County Stokes County Rockingham County LEGEND County Boundary | VTD Boundary Dist. Boundary (C004) adkin Coty 0 — 35 Percent Black 39 — 40 Percent Black 40 — 100 Percent Black Alamance Co¥inty County Alexander County Davie County Chatham Coa Montgomery County Stanly County Moore County N.C. General Assembly jon County Legislative Services Ofc. Redistricting System Bentine Software Copyright 1990 Public Systems Associates Exhbit M 4 & Guilford Precincts by Percent of Population Black with Democratic Registration Values March 18, 1998 88:888938 is, } 78:338738 W 79.£98 7.944 457 LEGEND County Boundary VID Boundary Dist. Boundary (C004) 0 — 35 Percent Black 35 — 40 Percent Black 40 — 100 Percent Black VTD N.C. General Assembly Legislative Services Ofc. Redistricting System Software Copyright 1990 Public Systems Associates Exhibit N a a a a Forsyth Precincts by Percent of Population Black 4 with Democratic Registration Values March 18, 1998 X o & Ee 3 LEGEND 260% ode00Y >] & 5 53.908 County Boundary @, OOO) eee OOOO KAN 0,9.9, RK od 350585 XR XX ll es : ST ETH KK BO 02050.9, CL 307 or oteotetetost I RK VID Boundary A : 3 . Dist. Boundary (C004) OO) 3 OOOO) ®, J *.0.¢, C J {XX XO) 8 OOK) OX) 9,.0,.0.0.0, d QRRXRN RRR GRR RIES 0% 0 — 35 Percent Black 5 QS 0.9.0.0 9, 0.0.0.0.9 9 0, @, 90. & $2 QQ 0.0.0. 0.0.0 9.0.0.0 9.0.0.0.0.0.0.9. ee? od oe CORR SRK 55058 SRHAIXARXY ote de’e 5 IKK XK 0. CK 9.0.9, OO 4 9.0. ¢ REIRREERR oo sll 4 RC ICICI 3 ooo 35 — 40 Percent Black AT ATATATATATATAIATATAT ANAT ANA | EX x XR CS KL 9 9.0.0 5 : 9.9.9.9-99, ®, (X80 @ 0, $) 0.0 OQ 2.0.0.9.0. 0.0, — 9% X CRRHS QRRRERARHXHRIRRS SRK GRR CRT Co al VTD . ', RX IX PXXRANK 0202020020028 020, 02020038 0202020 % 0 0% 5 5 5 29.3 OR 0! re 000200000 0% 0% KK SKS SRS LOCKERS SB QRRRLIRIIKIEIL RIAN pen RRSRRRIARRS QRH RARIKERRIRS RRL RAK QUIRKE QORAXK, , & ERRORS = R ARK CRIAER: 4 000000058, K 5 IRS RRL ole 20% 20% LRRRRRKS 5 ERKS ES RR X 355 Velo SIRILS COIR SS 0.0.9 4 0.0. KXSRELIRS CSS BOON XK y XXII X REPRKS 002020507 0% 2% % GRIAHAKIRRS 0. CRHRKRRS GRRIILRR GRRIHRKAK SRR RHIRI XA 024 LISTS PRANKS RK SRAIRXHKN 13 0 XK eg SERRA RRKRIRIKRS a! RRIRRAIIRALIS os SRRSAERKL XO a *-S 46.051 sO 0T090 0000008090 RRL 58.669 5 0.202077 %% 2% % x o% 0900076%0%% 2%. XRG REHXS ; RRIIIRILRL SKK & 3 QO) O RES RS 00000500 0% % 20% 20% 2% a0 0% % 2% 2% OOO Ar, IRRKRKS ARE 020% SRR ®, 59.656 KRHA ESLe XX Soles ot te totetototel RIN GRIER GRIER SS 2 5% ER SRS sss CXRRHAALIN GR 0QOS0S0sas0 0% KHXHKX SKS 90%6%6%6 20% 2026 2 2% 0% Welele%e% ma? 4020020 0 vv 0020007076" Wodelededede O DOOR 6 OOO %° OOOO SOIR KRRRRRKN X RRS 18, RKS 99 2S 88 SRILA 3 8 QRIHRHKS 0003000207000. 03070, CRRA ot D ORR N.C. General Assembly Legislative Services Ofc. Redistricting System Software Copyright 1990 Public Systems Associates E_xhlb tf 0 35.633 Precincts by Percent of Population Blac | i with Democratic Registration Values March 18, 1998 rr i ude : = i | i LEGEND 59.225 01.676 County Boundary 59.382 VID Boundary 50.835 STROSS x . SERRA | Dist. Boundary (C004) & ote %e 0s \ ACR OO) 3% ™N OC) Pe’e 0% e% 200005 & 9,9, / @, hi QE Wok | 0 — 35 Percent Black | 35 — 40 Percent Black 40 — 100 Percent Black 0.0.9.9. VTD 42.371 ~ KS % %0%% 5 RECON a 026005 % 0002020025 ORS 58 8 CO) WAXY () ote 35 ® RRR RSET Soe X RETR IAEERETHRRRNKS 54.334 53.091 XX RS XXX CRIARIERKN deteetelele: . 2 2 S QERIIHKR f ERR AIERRIIRNRS , 23030300 by QQ S 2) HX RIT YL 0% 20% 0% ) SAS OAHCIALIRKS 000%0%6% 1%%%, 0200765426207 20% SHXHRK 2008.4. otel00008 ed feted b E59 & ; RXR 020 te %e 6%% RRR OC 000500008 202 8 Va%a82%a% 2g § 3 S0T0%8 Q) XX 67.598 36.464 54.498 5 02000 P00 % 2% 020% 0%? 10626509 62600220222 % 2% ERLRARARAC NES 2X28 > 51.258 9, 67.532 63.528 (J ND Pav & GUAR . ®, LX KAR XC . 5 XS RIESE EE RLHAD > > 2 + OOOOOTRARRAD 02 OOOO * 5 0,070.0. 070.0. 6.0,0.0.8 00000, , 07070.6.0 0. 0.0.0.0°020.670 25¢¢ : ERX 2 RAHI RRN ROBE RAKK 50.464 4 QSAR IRAERH IRR x KK OCKO SIX 4% SO ole & 53.43% 58.818 43.888 ERS 2S ole o0le ele ete te tele 51.744 RRL RXRHARKRKK %% S005’ X 42.233 (KY ahndmtanlamianiantony 00000, 20% 070% 2% 000%. 06% : 90%%¢ 3 9 * 0202076%5%4%0% 020%, % delete tele’ EIERTARHIHRRRK & 3 ORS XR 3S 61.165 51.866 38.894 6.603 34.211 np SR fi N.C. General Assembly Zs Legislative Services Ofc. tas Redistricting System fn " Software Copyright 1990 Public Systems Associates Exhibit iP » JEWRY 1