Correspondence from Alfred to Lynn

Document text

The following text has been generated automatically during the document scanning process. It may contain errors, omissions, or incorrect formatting. Please refer to the PDF document if this text is not usable.

Download

By downloading, publishing, or reusing the Materials outside of the Website, you hereby confirm and attest that you have read and agree to the LDF Archival Collection Terms of Use linked below. We draw your attention to the following:

For those Materials owned by LDF, your use of the Material outside the Site is solely for one or more of the following (the “Permitted Purposes”):

Non-commercial research and private study;
Teaching, scholarship and instruction (including distance learning);
Non-commercial print and non-commercial online use;
Criticism, comment or news reporting; or
For people with visual disabilities (See Section 121 of the Copyright Act).
For those Materials not owned by LDF you understand that:
- It is your responsibility to determine whether the way you plan to use the materials falls within the copyright exception of Fair Use.
- For any use outside of Fair Use, it is your responsibility to seek and obtain all required permissions from any existing rights holders.

LDF hereby grants you the right to use LDF owned Materials for the Permitted Purposes without seeking further permission from LDF.

If you publish or redistribute any Materials (including excerpts and quotes), you must include a credit line and/or proper citation to the source of the Material. However, you may not use the name of LDF in any manner which creates any false association between you and LDF or that incorrectly implies any sponsorship or endorsement of you by LDF.

NOTICE: Uses that do not comply with these Terms or that do not fall under Fair Use (or another exception) may make you liable for copyright infringement.

Read the full LDF Archival Collection Terms of Use Here.

I agree to the terms and conditions for use of this content.

If you would like to use this content in other ways, contact us at

LDF Attorneys
Cooperating Attorney
- Leslie J. Winner
Organization
- NAACP Legal and Educational Defense Fund, Inc.
Matter
- Gingles
Case
- Thornburg v. Gingles
U.S. state
- North Carolina
Collection
- Case Files
Taxonomy
Identifier
- c7428233-d892-ee11-be37-6045bddb811f

Cite this item

Case Files, Thornburg v. Gingles Hardbacks, Briefs, and Trial Transcript. Correspondence from Alfred to Lynn, 1981. c7428233-d892-ee11-be37-6045bddb811f. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/9719bb93-02ee-4975-a5d2-32fd58f0aa2a/correspondence-from-alfred-to-lynn. Accessed July 17, 2025.

Copied!

    s
1

f.,,

Nrrrilr Crrr,rlirr;r (lirrr,.'rir[ ]srt'rnt,trr
t\,'rr:r I t U lrlrlrrIr,'r

>Strrt,' ?!cqi:,trr tir,c ].lrri [trirrq

lirrlriql; 'li ti I I

August 5, l9B1

l,.il, i r ''r tt' t ti 'ill

I

,r a{Aroil (.AuY O. Al.t-r.l.u
| (J rrr a)r5 rIrCl
lr. 2. 8ox 32O
;uaLrNGToN. N. C. 27215

COM M ITTEES:

ECoNoT4Y
FINAI{cE
HTGHEF EoucATroN
HUM^N REsouRCEE
.rl,It,:t IY I

ltrutsr rrcTtNc. tfHArc
SENrla CrrtzEN9 AFFAtns
SM ar t. BUs tNEss

lvis. Theresa Lynn
De.'pantrrrent of Justice
Civil Ri3hts; Division
TcrrIir u Perrrrsylv.lrti.r AVt'.., i.i .vr.
\\'ashington, D. C. 20530

Dc,'rr^ l,as. [-yrrn:

It is my opinion that the Congressional Rec.l istr icting Plan for N':,.16
Carolinn nntifi<.<l lrv tl-rc'lotzt scssiorr of thc Cenc:ral Assembly of tlonth
(l.rrolirr,r l,ril'. lo torrrlrly v.ritlr'.('v('r',rl r'r.rlirrrl:, oI tlrt'1irrl,r'c,rrrt,(]r.rr.r r't oI
Llrr. Llrritcd 5t,ltcs .rrr<l is tlrc:rcforo urtconstitutiorlal.

ln t[-rr' f,ttlrrlrrrr' Cotrr^[ (],1':,(, rt{ \'./r.';lrt'rry v... !,;rrrrlt.r-:, tltc r-(-rtrr-t tr, lcl tlritt
tlrt'l)tri)trl.rti,rr ol c(,r)r1'(.ss:,iorr.r'i--it i:.-li-, ct=, [' tt--," -r,,,c stutc rrrusl lrc

f.>atricl< vt;. ilrcislcr, thr-' court r<:jc:ctccl tlrc su!'lqcstion tlrat tlrcr. ir 
- 

r

,r lroirr[ ;rt rr'lrir l] l)(,1 ,ttl,rliort <li[[r.rt.nr:t'., iltr(lr-rr; rJistri<-t:, lrr..ccrtrr<:s "rlr-.
rrritlirr,iS." 'llrc courI lrclcl tt-r.rt a stilte rrrLlsI cither sfto\y tlr;rt nt(,ihcnlatical 

:

equality vitriarrccs are unavoidable or specific.llly justify the vi,ni6nces. 
r

Tlrc r;rtif iccl Cot-tcj r-cssiortal rcdisl.ricl.in! I)l.ln of 19Bl fc-tr lrlorth C rrolina
(loes not rncct tl'rc rulings above. The ratified plan splits one (,)unty
(l,',oor^c) arr,crng tr^,ro cj istnicts. lf counties had beerr split in cacl- of
Il-rt.' L]on(ir('s5i<rnir I cl istnic.ts, tl'rc <listricts corrl<l h;tvc l.>c:en <jnatwn nlonc
r'tc.trl,' equ;ll in l)()l)(Jl;rli<lrr .rnc.l lnor(t ()(:o.lrer;tlricllly c<-rrrrpact. J lre
vil ri,.)trccs irt cr-irr,'rlit;, ctf f)()l)ul;rtir>rr rif tlrt: r^ittif ic'cJ pl.rn itre thg,,:forc
r-rnjrr:-tifirr[.rlt.,rnti <:orrl<l lrc ;rvoitlr,<1.

ln City of I'rol,lilr.'vs. [.)olrlr.r'r, Jr.rstir-c Stevens stirtcci th.it the cor r,;titution-
al test of ..r r^ecjistrictinq plan is wl'rr:ther it is: (l) 'runcouth," i.e.,
Ur"rLrS(rcll arrcJ I'nrilnifestly not Lhc. pro.jrrct ()f ;t rorrlinr: ot^ traditic,ral poli-
tic.rl tlt.t.i:,ir,rr;" ('t-) lr.r.,'r,r :;i,.; rriIi<..rrit.rttvr,r-:,t.,irrr1->ir<-t orr.: rrrin,:r.ity
';r'oll1r;",rrrrj (j) isrrrtn!tr1,ltrrur'[c'q iry Lrrr rrc'tltr'.:rl justific.-rtiolr" c1 r-r ..i tltcrc-
ic.r"t i:; t:itlrc:r irrittiorr;rl ()r' tlrr: frrorlrrc-t o[ ;r rliscrinrin;rtory rrroti, c. ..,

Trrc. ratiriccr rJ. c. pt..rrr .[ rebl is irr..rrion<.rr in ,,-,:;o/7C!r*P;I (o|/.d-,
coLrnt)/.rnd tlrc scconci district is al qnoup of count'ies strunq out in I
tr fislrool<-lil<c shape to av<.:id inclutJinq Durharrr Coulty, which l.,rs a /l
lrcirvy Conc(.ntrati<>n of 11 1161. vol3rs . // ^\' ' 

/'A,'I ' .,., IA^ /\ 
[ 

/' ,-'-' l,:)\' ' 
(

\i_l ) 
\) 

1 I AUG 19Bl /.i:3 r, ;, , t

-" 'r .. - i'; 
" 

-- " '/

) ot -) \

i:i)ii -{-l rllr



llrt' tir 'tr'ict:' ,l tlrr. r',rtiIit.tl l)lcrr] dr(: c('rtctinly ,'uncoutlr" bcc.iusc thcy
c.rrC rl()t crs !i c'()!r^ili-:l"iicir lly c()rnpact ds l)ossiblc. Alarrrancc count)/ deci-
:,ions tvr.rultl nr>[ l-.lc routint, ly linl<ec] r,.,iti'r tlrose of E<.J r-leconrbc County.'l-l,r' rl{'(,([',rirlrit rorrli,lr]r'.rli()rr r,I llrt' lrr,t-r)r'r(J District of tltc r;rtiIicrl tJlc]n
i:,'.,UCir tlrirt,r Con(lr'{.'s:,rrLlrr ctn)r-r()[ irci,.r;r-rirtcly rc'l)r(].icnt it. Durlranr
County is cl<-rrninatccj by tol-.>arcco irrteri,:,ts Lls drt: rno:it oi thc othcn coun_
tie.s in tl-rr: scconcJ cJ istrict oxcci)t A. Ii,rri,rnce.

llre r'.rtilretr lrltrl o[ lgol ir..r:, .r :,i,1rrilic.rlt cruv(:r-Sc
vo[crs lry diltrtin<; thcir lrolitical strc,rrrlth t-retw,ccn
l")istricts. l-lrc: Votinrl Rirllrts; Act ()f ll)(;5 Dro[rilrits

Tlre r-atificr.l ;rlirrr rninirrizt,:., tlrc,
r\ I irrr,, I r ,r-c. frlr r n t y I )('C.t (J':,r, t I tr'rc

t,y f>liir:inct Allrrr;tnco irr'lrr.l^'1 ltr,-l p) c()lnti\)ii irr tlre Sr,CCrrrrJ {-tiStriCt irnrl
lr1'1r.r:.:'lrrr1 I)tlr'lr.trrr c.oLrrrt\/, tlrt. l.rlirclr volt.r.:; r,, I []urlt.rnr curtrrt/ Ccutr-leI
cort[;ine tl-rcir volin! str(:r'l(]th witlr othcn Sccorrcj Distr^icl. countics ltaving
hearvy [.rlocli vot(-'r rt:cj i5tr;rtiorr to have ir qreater. influcnce on cle,:tions
for Con,,rcs-. ln tlrr.cir:;(. ()[ v.'iiite \/r; . llsr;r,sIr'r, a l(_,!lislative c.l ,str^ict-
irr(t ;rl,rrr v\',r'. lr.lrl irrv,rlirl 1.,,.,-,iJr,-iliT.rit.,t",lJ-nc votirr<.; strc:ngtl, of
, r ct i :,cr-r.' I t. ( :r(rLl I-) . 

tt

lrr lri,- c()rtcrrrr-irr(l ()l)irr ion irr Cil'Z of l,{rtl ril(.v.i. I}rrlrl<.rr, Jtrstic<.S_,tcv<,rrs
.,r'(,tr('(l tlr.rl. tlrc' L(,r):j,titutiurr.,ll;;;t, i-,ir,-is- 

"-fTi ,rst in"irj ious cl isc! inrina-
tion arr'(-' "i-r;>ir licut:lc, not rrrc'rr:ly to .c.tc.nr\/nr.rn<lers cl ircctc.c.l againsl racial
rrrinoriticl;, Irrrl to tlro:.t:.rirrrt'rl ,1 t rcliryir;us, t.tlrnic, c'con<>rnic, ilr.r ,r p<.;li-
tir..,rl (1,'(rr.Jl.)li rr.: ryt,l 1."

irrrlr.ret ort bl.rci<
tlre Second ;rrrrJ Four^ih
<liscrirrrination ci thcr

llrr. L(ri)(.. ()l (-ity

irrflut.rrcc of tltc [-icp..,ul>licirn Plrty. in
(rr'c n(.) r'f Ir:r.: t ivr. llclrtrlr li<.;rrr ()r(J(_rn i..:ir t iclns

tlrr,'1,c,c<.,rr<.J District oI tlrt: ratificir planlll til(l:,I rtl
o{ 19til.

Ilrl otlrt'r' cottlrlit.:: <tl

Tlrc' nlr)st cf frrctivr: e6:lnr..]rr,:.sion;rl rc_,[)r(,:,(_.nt;rtior-r riill cc)r]r(., f rom thI n]ost
(: r)rrrl),!(t tl('()()r-(rlrlri(-,..t I rli:,tlir-t:; lrt.rssilrl<,. -[lrc n,rtificcj pl;r rr docs rrot
cr cltit'tzr' tlris. l'lr<' G,ri[rr,5, vs. Crrnrnrirr,:;:-', olriniorr stated that cJist,.icts
rnay [.ro ccluirl ;rrrcJ siff f,.'-t,"f",e."t 1..

t t) A/ 1r,. r

lclr lr-r[ (rrr .rtt()rrrrjy, uLJt lirupc, lirovc..livt:rr
tlrc Cori,jrcs:;ic>rritl Redistrictin<; plan a<loptecJ by
ra I Assr:.,nil> l;, r:f I98'l slrorr tcl l-rc rcjec tctJ lty t[re

Sincr,r'c:ly,

t-l i r r-y Allrccl

(.rucqu<rle redSons why
the i'lor^th Carolir.l Gene-

Justicc Department

'it?'J '1, .t'r .:., ;, , rl r--i 'r !.-]r '-t /; !-( l, 'l- 
':.E ?t l- .;i- rl-_- t.

Copyright notice

This collection and the tools to navigate it (the “Collection”) are available to the public for general educational and research purposes, as well as to preserve and contextualize the history of the content and materials it contains (the “Materials”). Like other archival collections, such as those found in libraries, LDF owns the physical source Materials that have been digitized for the Collection; however, LDF does not own the underlying copyright or other rights in all items and there are limits on how you can use the Materials. By accessing and using the Material, you acknowledge your agreement to the Terms. If you do not agree, please do not use the Materials.

Additional info

To the extent that LDF includes information about the Materials’ origins or ownership or provides summaries or transcripts of original source Materials, LDF does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of such information, transcripts or summaries, and shall not be responsible for any inaccuracies.

Correspondence from Alfred to Lynn

LDF Attorneys

Cooperating Attorney

Organization

Matter

Case

U.S. state

Collection

Taxonomy

Identifier

Cite this item

Copyright notice

Additional info

You may also be interested in