Note from Grace to Hutson; Memorandum from Hutson to Guinier 1
Working File
January 1, 1984

Cite this item
-
Case Files, Thornburg v. Gingles Working Files - Guinier. Note from Grace to Hutson; Memorandum from Hutson to Guinier 1, 1984. 1c7b6dd4-e192-ee11-be37-6045bdeb8873. LDF Archives, Thurgood Marshall Institute. https://ldfrecollection.org/archives/archives-search/archives-item/b4bf59e8-7260-4e94-a5ea-cddc03323804/note-from-grace-to-hutson-memorandum-from-hutson-to-guinier-1. Accessed July 06, 2025.
Copied!
$NI$$N $N N a-tl\N\ $${N :t" 9 trRorl Re: 1//l q-lyto to ', Loti Gu t ,.1 1?-u '- Alsna:cq- Ht tsth Cpf l;.oU,Irt1 4, Lo-ttote-vil €sraypu( \rv\ Ld.^ ,stotn- v . Gt "l q PK rstNze-D Q/ -r-a^-f+t- /-!.4 ;4dt/ile) ,^-4"-* -J-1n#o"- ,bs.^;','{-, U^")r#- V./u,-/--tr{ ,,i, e) 4+ffiil e/rru--u-Srez-.,, w, ,fuo exnlat*-> alla- -4;-J ca,u) caA*a+aL q, -"r@# j/t*, at.tJ w rc:-*o:',o",1 ,q-trfu /L+"+ DAa/J /r-/-D1r, Lilr- /hhr-,,L q pl-U.tta.".1- zl-rlpp-U *; lL (l'flr- vo-t<-<-L *ry 'l-" I-e- prtoUdz-zc aytu4/f l/- t* Pa/ru)- 44 y'/Lr* uvyr'rAp-a ; ry ry*rc-l1 jh\ ljru*sr tu-l--p*r^;J- 4 rr- /a-Luo* d-t\?\-' Otej gJ. tt t,t-*.t Pz-ntt - fuf..,& Y4u- d*4J\r-^-D X @ *rerfr--L, **o#^-0, f-r,9u /L4t @ /-t T )v I i I FA ti@, U/af,-o*61 Mt ,u,4ur'"\,. U//-e q/j-r,r/-L1 /J;t aje:v- t; lL-<r- pr;/tr i -l- Clu o li (") I l (-)i P frrtr,fuu.^)attuiu 4t4t* *A Z,L h/rlrr 14 4*/a/,J ' W 4 ,4 atJ- 6J;W@ ry/,Ih,ra- ,,kva, /14ot pa].1/"--n>'g 4i /rr/z 42/*--< 6 ci u:-..t ) furnlzz, T3 a;uL filA fry ^y U-U-"*sz/o-L @ a e4rpnp*2/*- ','k'ffiT'p>/*bl+l*2,c, al*- fuz l-a-p* /1'z0 i arT )/ Tl-- re 04rt's /@f,uoc_o*t*<,trc & 4ruftL c.-d/&l/ ta-uu,L F Kx!/-o urdr*L /4e4 rq+ gLt(A T H^L 1ect,/<tz rr1* Tbf lr-*u^l;- (x 0 flrrL rup-+Utt A-Ul^- W Lat ".j--"-% 'f4--u gu-;fu-uua4 Uru12"L- uJ4J-^- -'P Z-fu1L1- a-- l+u-+*? , M /t-- ff "+rt&nru-r4 lzdyp,*. {lUr/" v. (hc_C-r-r*t c,1 , s.% f1,<- _ ___dt, + f //X-l/-t-t/4, /Ld+ .4"/4r'r^) v U-r.r-,* df>n a-Lgc-t4atc-a-L / udzt--t , V-l\-L /.4-tf J4wn rdry f* 4"7+ v/b ry *a {) c "JIYX,u-<-r--r,,*ta ffi) uo /r.rr-t li r4^L U ' l) n-r-t IJ I c^*a-t s2 <-.Lrt*ir or ^-/rn)- 5 e-<- - U f,"zr--<- ') : Ur urd-L-<J;zrv., Ff fro /*y u---0 {fu @ pr.r*,t-,.*tWf all f*tuf t r-W /u, M"*-V Y,,-* Tf*b Ma/za^'uzt C ufu+ur1) W,!/tr, fu utt*hn--e (z\ 4-v.-y> *xrt<p-q/L,a Brt-^ty v. Ttke-,r ttl '/4a. u, J /2 7 , 60 . €d- z,c ? L? (,z rr), ^42. Mu ry /-a c-e,wolt,<- {o b*, I or', *y /rr^-,t' "r*a O v'-a- fw/au,*I "t'/,9-uL.Lt!-L ,?" ^ lM (W 4LtA4 rytto,A;@*/s f P1r* /,1/aa laapt n 6,a/-t* l*M;(=) il. 'both l^t-la u4//euua-r\) Hr,r- Ja,ta A-tu//)- A @ ,' I ir ', A** &) 0 t4 %u-" L/vnrUl/M, Yl-r* Jazott- d7arJ^-t- q 2.n-t-t<.L( 1fl/ '-/4d/- uorY*,il\ ?/.,L v tu *.;, fi( Vl,U/v P rt,)&A) | I "Qfc% t37i t raTL </+b) fhtuh 7q F aa( t, , arrrh /-,|*Jopft- L aM /44. D c.t^- /)t-.<-- "d[II I li i'.<-^Ol* I i I w I i I I A *-u,l-*7a-r,twt err rU, */ l+p-Utury A/4 %,u-x) ^*/z,ruW /4 fM;n fu {D%l ' /-. i lll)+q1 0,J. ?0, L ell U-4"Lw b1-/-?tta4*/- olloypil,, d-x-LL a z-a<,t:t-* 4u ezL-{/a.L/,L d4') ld-1,-,q.) 4 fu ov /4rA *.: -t*s /-$Tt, v.tLa.r dr-u,z;.n) 4 f ru/u/,-ot, '^#-ry"1,"'D y H"L *^--- 0,n uo arr^* $" u"A-r//L,Jnvt /--a-u,Le, A-7 *-.1--.-tnJ c,utnJlz*' i ^ Pu+v {a.74-e- f,"wn a Vryryre l, ti V/u- L, €tza so 8) Lovil( ,/ rlt; o 1V'/D I i I i ry /fu-l' t-/o*U\) Y-/\.u/t- t- "CAr.+Jtfu - -/^* "r*L" P@p-L,n, @-u l4*bhL ,ly,ttue* YW. 7.# 1,,Tus. G. . \) ortu^ ,\z--l\ w/-!A, rt * /ry Ln r-u rtr## A* 4n t* /-4t &Ld-t-J,- mu-uz-t fuJ a H^L- z-a-ta*t> a-€ @dtav' A) VL.r*f/\/ L'+1 l-/ve' /r*t - Nul-t 42t 2, fi,up-y-- ry ,^*Vo<-tott-l Pii, tat-Z+tJ-t a-V fWxP* -/rr*- /ee-/\- a*/X* ?tu-/uL) ,4 ,.- //,t/Jt-/v a-aj- 6/ '//4/-L C"rt* I a-a* k) f-/r- dll-tou,^^."r*ri a*-* .-leo) M y-4 rur--d-*afrl!4,\/,. l@ u, .btixtn,,J.V.a , fu //r*n14-+ lr ', & l/ilr- fr t4t-z-u p)teut- . 0 i--\ i'aa*7+,tzzn fq @u^ *Lp+q,u-; / uvra?Pltcabl oi*1- l*t,lot*,)'?-|4ffi?q?w fr, ;7[1J; A*u- fry.,,*vw \ i', t?2o ). tL U,v. fu l-k4* qz& yrl</tt+),u .t f,ry /],r-dtD 1"^-ilaro -,A vu-t,% ll l"r( '0 | t d I il a-\ J- t z'?z Fu-ot- hn+:v b, , -s7e r.S^(p C r{(o y.4t,Ed a_ z-L- 1 \ ,- ,,[=TU *,?rea-ter ;t 6,&,ru /-44/"e/^, *v,-r d|'\rqL i, ( lr ',to,t oo b {lr- u-'/u* fnM -k ; i I I I \ I 'i\fta**vry@d ll p,ffi n (L *L /-(rr*^/) / *- lralr>e, See i; i , fqv tr.toL t)c/ @aCio i. ij', / ?, , aM,- 'cwfu,- b4r.rr,,J g r*ry lD /*) ^^r'-. WL *Idgsr.r) W f cr'//ajz/,L -O-</*h+-r-tl d,\t- @ a- /-t{oUt-+% Ze-Lk-a+r rt / / lr l$h &1144- ,* . Aa- V'L( b-eJ' q &+'41/z d/z'-t''-e ; l,;, t-.tr' t/4il- tQ >q aa,/,<, C-f2*e4, li ii I Iil li I lL ir i I I l , i I ll )'wk I i ( /-*r* 0 *L"VM:"- / 14,\-L-,-;-*L,.,'l "?r/ cn.f. d.a-a-.t-t-,- - : 2 1,' ltlf, @yby-*,-, tu^^.A ubt +4 4 D* U)rlU,,r^lt1 /-k-U Yt't* ba-' itry," ll'Fa*,A?r."tAVt Cg.zutt <_a* UA4* tu\.1 ?1MJA / ' Pl-\ ) ^Jtno )e* j4-t /t U I ll Jwtn*,t t* u 4l ).L I ) ,aa__;r_ r# / f<"L L4l4 Bar""(- v, cl fi tl) &/J-cW ezt\rL Wg /laA./J fr a- /q)o t prttz,-t--atL U^/t4Lt Y /ubUL Uxtqrgzrf eL %L c/fr-,,tzj ( Wt p^* f-- /,\L *7, * oz-;rr-. v F.Tc,Lor€2ot +q Y o-r ?ro e+.4# , G3 t_ €4.4 p-r-{ at s-. <- /_/Af/r4) y Y4j- ,fu,Lu-t-ul-41l t/, W- a-\)- 4-U_ *l-** * *,*Z *.*% a-/*<-tt., i Y4-.-La-4/-* lt Yl 4-4\ ll-t-r*l-), C W q YA-L \0 tl tur *r* u'/ U ,-). Arl*r-*r *t ru a*-d- fu ffr--flh %-w A/Af r,tu ),fu L^r*A u W,l n-- - tt /k{L I i I b*,44. . 2rua}< v , Ultl o- _ {4 l( it-/t\, trlt, l@@*&tuWf ry /urt Jr- /,--r- I I l l/V1,4/O+t I W<-r- t"4r,rt /Jz/r* f-/r.. f r*/t- fin d*nu ^A /* L *ie7UU ,a-L<//n,-q ea 4 4- urrYr- tr bK rl 6rl fu2 fpul-*t I I I ti I b- p,{l a-l<z. _r--l-*r/:ft* *'/"r* P*- */,,,- :l2<tfial- I li ii li 1 :zw-" f*%* ,*e *ry ,,r-4 a- ",*JJ; 'i'liltLm d-r/-La,r c/zt-r-^ f,- /4/,,,,-T E---,-,--- 5l i L/4.t^4 ^-P tl-Qzr az*4 ll<-"rn'al- )-t*- frr,r:r t p*t- tle/L Y-rf Ofl/t'L- ?7/L L ""//a't/ l ir\1 I t Ii At ^- / ry' vntd-t *'l-< (J d '/4a !44>n< '14< Fz* U vr-* K*k-a ,tlt- +eat+<zL- V/-qP,-* ry U>* ,-rh l4\4 AarL4l fu rL4-u fr,rft ?o+k*/*r'e, 4or, a,v (./ C o - v. A t' * 1-'r1qlL(aA-s-) froJ ( sY c/ L 6 1 q37 Us ra , Jrt, ftr t ;a at' 6ra | 5tr? (fi2+), /Ihve-n ^* -t L&(,LLr ue'0 /\-L/A-<.w el;r/N L/l/r4-<JIW I Sla-tez @' oe-J aad* fr<*u,r ,puL*t-& {t4- }ud,(;L"X-) i -I Ii ll -t4-4* W. //(fi-to-ll-c1* U L{-'14l6<4) 4 lo a ,t r/7, /53 ) d? t-, ttz4 el @, atf(tqn)i v' T'C"t', , 'c'frot'-J' HL@+ */':a* irufrrylrw.bulr-- Jr,- t ur>L/-t-r :/*rt*, Lobar".*o r (r-a v. . Luv,Lus,trt : ,'Luv,Lus,ty % J/liri,t F&a+,*. ) /e L)._r. J/31$--_ l\-_ , @r "?t L,€.{)a 7 eY (rzz t) , tt-,- h^-./ Q-./JJ-14- -7/L .Uun ^ ".,.n* eo * rlw M"- PrTo__^o )c,u? t'-o' 1 (,a1 f M ;r^ub @ //e-(/LL/-da) U- /d4-{//t zU ruj%^tqA, /f,qtfooJ */ d,e-z-zu-D .r--!*r, 14 /^-"2,r4- ,l 4; #*/-to"*h** /^,(Hb*L**Lr As Y4!- oLil*.)" L/h G t^t"** -t t ^ .r /ulzz-, t( /-/r-L ow4rt",@ ,oLra-o ou/-L,*.^iD0 yZ %{., )LLa4-1/h . A.%l- F a- '/1'na-Lo,///t ufiu-zl''-)' B Lcnd", .Tn4^ r, lo a L/, J. ^j Ja3,' & [ t. €zz.t a-t 7?L, (p^*i,-,^a |a-r*A v. &-Aaauo A-, 3x-7 tr)4 tt , //tq t7,l?/(t /s/ (,Q,[ c;. ,2n1,ru 3zt u,s, ?3(rzQ L,€d-Aa- a?8, 3/ iCt, ,33k (tflU), l"fubiL :r.*:?^ ''-'s/t* V*t d'*qr/d*eh U U 0 \ ffy,?<z ',^*r:Z /4zA:* pLbl*Ja V*WIL" ,''tfu!u*a)^e/7'',,,- a- ry f/7 0.{, a-/ ??, (,6 L €a)4,tsr3, -r42 y-tLa-t dJf4rll-tq O@- " p r*2,<-,-t-<.u21' A-/-<#,afr-Oa.n/L /^"* v- sY-lanr p t-* 7P, P"-" t O,ru, "/-/otr-en/ e-,, dal-LlALoU d-x*'-<,^-1J \ 43? U-5."j 3)7t 5-t L.t,Lz)-a-t-sLr. Yllr> vuaa-u^a u4 ry ryaJ*t,- tr *lW 7/2y ul@, tr*fr d ., %*r a/-UV 0/ y<L{ru.%-y I'Uur*, utrt >dd tg{/r*t, z,rfla W-"* fl,r-;q A ry fuP %,e,a-',t-z *o @ u,^ 9^^ fft 4, 1bh{/u,*flo i I lr ',1y\,{f nzr,rh-Pz ;i I W crL,**-J ,zkf( tt 5rt.-l2,%'. &f u,r\-21!,v * pab;^lr*rl z-.anyp4* -4.U *,fuXrrp ,b7 .rl-!""-ry -n4A//)<4 A-rrJW14 Ztrffi fur? % f-Ua-r,*aL Jz-*tp4z/- H?k W*f: d*"J-t*YZ^t' ?t il'u t%l"l-lt /F-t-<*^-t*6 a> L,.^) WLe-*4 YU, Vfu- /*P,L ry. 144- f* t , / a4A4/h lA q.,o,ift.,.t/ +/r:% ,tU .*iJ*/tt atc ft*,24-/. "1.1,L^o{Aun-e-rtt ' 431 l/05 J 32o,, sP L. €* z,t- o4-s{,(. M *4r-ozr-tt Lz nq M fr^ dn* {n fa^:p L*4 ^a **/)a'} g'YL L'ta-{tqzcu- J - tL If a defendant in the 6rst action is sued for small or nominal damages, he may have little incentive to de- fend vigorously, partieularly if fu- ture suits are not foreaeeable. The 929 (CAD; cf. Berner v gritilh Coillmo_nwealth pac. Airlines, gnO -Fii 532 (CAD (application "i "ri"".iilcouareral_estoppel denied where de.rendant did not appeal an adversejudgment awarding ltam*;; ;f '$-ei: 000 and defendant w* frtZr-.rJ-fll ov.gr $7 million). Alowing-otr;iJe collateral -estoppel may also be u.r_rql to a defendant if the judement religd upon as a basis f"; il;A;;pel is itself inconsistent with one Jr Ilore. p^relous judgments in fauor oiEne detendant.r, Still another situa_tion where it might be Fne*I unfair to apply offensivee{onpel is where the sec6nd ,;tir; affords the defendant procedu.ri-L* portunities unavailabll in the fiiit iiil"*"1*,ff:'%*:g,tY'"u'"' u l( lrrffi i*/^-.)-(> -Lt-{b(/wye--.r- "Jby'z-ar-,^* /r,t* % u=f,Lo;e.uaL!- t{t-tpp*(- FU-</U*dr-l r 6/a-r hlb h-*'l'W M6ry iotl-r,,t-rLL "/4,r*) 7r1 /ytLrt-/14-bJ tsur&< LLu Ld-,1^.1 /;/-A-,\-\24i ua,, alrrL d"#fu ,4*a4a/- ^re frrLrc^4r./\) zfu fn-tt:\il1A (. ry 4 -fe44-,k/-!) d-t 3LZ , 5 [ L, t'a- )"1- ^-/ -L/./-aJry W;r{/*fu4*-#1"/r41-)fi;fui:-4-'4 W-W" LrU a-f-uu-a-L j4*rppl-L , f f"tu M /f? 144- C-1"/rur44j- CM '7a */fuy /,-A ,ue/, "r,1" /h-+* r't-<J-n* /M,l LrL"a.o^6,8 yryprl- /*roct L (-r--- 64"-rr^"r\_ V 4s-G J j 4("/ t cl-/s- p^*4- Afu- k4!^^t fua gfufz p-u# /-u*+pty TA,W o{lltt-, k",-*L' I C*+a* t-|/L!-L ttn-* {-t (/Y\ f=l-L M C ov g*a*r- d-/2e-/a7 (r Mu, ,l a- P @,N \ f 't-r* 1\ t-11-L eut4\d-uv Af . U-S.e, ffl3Y, fu %-*{ Ja-ru-e- *,^j-L la,-l--t'- 4/(4 7-<t-alf y. *-lu-lr- //., M %-d-ta'a-.,1a- 4-/-rr/ /-t0 /)r, fta+u-t' &r-u /4rrt-fur . t +tG O.J at /32, 7) L. €a Ad- a* 2tr6 . J,- e..e\-' U-t;/z /?4t-Qt AAt y-/,\).- ar*fu-o-t- LAtt-A| -r.zoe*l,ol ^** - fl* F'L'z-/"-t'^- ry,-fr? ruXna1u-;J B Y4t'4- ),Y, l-rz */-l.kT\ ad -M, f* u c e--r\>*<-f . ra/. ,^ , ,y' ^, o,, - / - , ry +., W #U .k)e4? tL) H-a* t*tl;.k V? "f" /-o S4rtr-- lllP* , g/al (4 4.h+ tfutcA d Ln kyur*r- , W f*ta-L ps--u* 7* e-tflL<*pw"'-L a;tzVa*a- *f/w J4 4 th*<_ . VZVatRJ,> ryMD ./h J dz/e- ct r^+ )a4.,rr-z- /r) /-^/- ry 14"< ^u*,r-t- 4.;0a D fa- cAt ^ a/d- * A y4q- p-fur- o,o-r-.-( /J-,\-Q-,J r fQ'ul- y 'f-ll fu a-y,ol ct/z<L,t4k u* W- 1*1 3 /'-ur'*na'***Hitu - p/^J- uej t-fu AAl 4a4, (/ 4f /r/r';-?d*'/t\' *4 ^x4 a rt'k //,c'44+ / 7 /)44tu-'/'4l '2ah//-u!-'' ,, .. , c aa-,q-r 4p? *? v-/,.,- (*? ?!ffi^%;ffi'trrffi"^"Ctt / a),r' nf P*tuf? U ,LP,6a+r) ?r'/ ai ut/r4e-) a ;n Wa* qa-u/czz" clzL . y ru, qqq i),s y 15, n! , €1^LL.,+ TUW-.-"-,- u" U-"wl'"-'U Sta^f-<tt , '/cl o d' s oP t, 0 UJa4l ra,.tt-e/- -fl Y-h-!,4/ t/ l4 b f uoaaln *a d'*'-<Lf il*t- X""il-ti s*tLwue44ad,y fu* ( . 1, , fi,,uru;,-zg- IrL ()-y. '+ { Vt / li L. E4 24- a+ }8o' -- ,A //r-" ,313', ts3 7 l/ w4* /rr- D^Dt .1) *r V4)* 1 ll ll CI\q ?l-[-f /4,rL -T*e bcaK tN€_ OF coLLntfr-(dC (-54 fPec S##+ rJ t /lfr PpR.6 ?Z/t*T E A p *P/c/e/)'To J tt s'Tt c p D€ PA {r H€N7 He 4etilAJ {,tf tcL DLPApzrr e,uT ?RtcLe AaANcL PR Oceo<t{Lt r{ W-A-ig. Does D or P2- aur Dz rt € trOoL A/o D ttytK oPpO2=oNt-Tu.,l 'Tb LfrtAAfL -THe /tsoeC. L A. C<"\ Wa'vtLle ft Y flM@e -"lnf & a*<r4!12t71 ,'A< Jr'al-e-'fu fn a-4! , A ,1o "(Ut-< M & a,ifu-. fu <ry,n;"v.r: ^t-d- 1r- Seo t .' tS<-e, 2t *G4 't,g-/ O Iffiq /*X^.,dl /hn.t,u,. I /1a!4 u 0Ldq,\'-1.- tr"*ft */4- @ ^/ wLe- Jv c.F'? 9{t at*zu,n,*r-t ,_.X * f+"., ,Urjqr"ttrLt ute, /.tu) /)& ,aualt bazt* w **9 H, / .t^ /- / \-,/Tt* fn@ ua a.4 a-,2*urzn+Jq-*-^;-J /V,Lo4 ,lu a Ya*a- ,->-+z,ro-r^* */+ o?a/.L /*"*s, 0llo /r1tu4? * H-a-y. /4U- -"LO A@tv (? *o @tf ,/)rr.- r/vn u, /r- l-ar-,r,, @ 4 at ,t L , Y-/sa, f,l/6ueArL4, a-Su,u ';ffi 1ll **t*r,vr-L f&4J.+2-A -'fu,ru a4 av-aa U/^*a-tu/htt{ i^/ ?/,v- Jcrf r!4,rr-u A-u.-+ a @ Eutea4L Yh-l o ' Y+a''L4J) /-Ura- +* vyLn,.nrJ) ,*^? /" ry*,.r)', B 7tae 'a44: B N$&Lp l-zcnL Detr€rusL , eouc4'7-lbw L,tND u'r,4sE Nat A ?*ret1 T6 Tt+e ft?S.r PPaCeeDdq. A^"**- 0& *ff.tu 1* 4 {bU' y4-<r- aa-r- vo b* Plru* L'j^r" cnil.r,+,n ^-t ea+rypg,- c-a,..- h)- u"r,rryl,uz-t U /'l^",* *-/r-1- f *r*t a--7,a--,-asf arl-f>-t rvurt r,t-+ lar,L ilal.) o- f*tr Y4 t/-t- fu", a-<*-l* AU-q-r^v V'(,t-rrrrro, Vv, u,! ?;, ea L.€az43oE Y N*SCP N ,,^*/ f ,nf ^t '- ilo 5u brc/fiL D e-r{ Rr H €NT L{}- /-t--ry;tu4 %y- t/a-O H,J W qa,4-/-- ry /, .l ' L. €a L^ r-t L (tf T ), fi*- ,a,--/rri-r^,e- '/"-*r, 1:,,e-fu"u+ ry %,q- fr?"-4- au4tnz* c-,*.-,*fu 'i C|JA "Lr+ i--r,1- )4r/U2fl/'24-'t,vY b /\-o,lr"q-L; Vz"-r- 0.'v/y*^4 &t-,u-&rc4/t at*& uuuu) If ,)A g^ ttrt-ql Erqtu, ft,+ Wt rvn;, ".C/rM', (-, (l ,/ tt q3 > L/,5 q-t "@ h y -(o { , i3 L. (-t- z.r "+ i ft -1 .^ T/* d'-e*l-\/M L't/1 Y14r- 1-a4-L A d li i,,&1*'t-.u7,li*t-rrln (zt W. '11/.4 Lz*2r.*.*l*i,- i,, ,U y.s Mfr bx-r,tt -"-L ) a-!*i l>*utt-<-ii<rtnr 'l I --/ l, l*Jer*L /.0',^* rp./-Aa . (/* Ea C. Rzt/rLoo or Jus;-)ce )ZTt€ t-t tNrtr t d/tJ t uyLLala-ual Ur'oTZ/r/- e-A,+-Ja-C L@l- /-4- uA-{fCZ/-L .,^ {//r> g-r;la